Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse to pay NDN £1000?

63 replies

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:14

We live in an area with clay soil with a well known subsidence issue, exacerbated currently by weird weather of the last few years. Our house is one of many in area currently being investigated for subsidence issues, via insurance company. We have bushes/trees on our boundaries at the front and certainly, the roots are clearly causing some problems although exactly how much or what they will do to sort is still unclear.

Ndn is also having some minor signs of subsidence and has started similar investigation via his insurance company. They have come round today and confirmed that on his side, yes, the trees/bushes' roots are causing some issues with pipes etc underground. This is first step in process and a report will be prepared.

NDN has suggested that as the reason he has problems is our bushes, we are personally liable for his insurance excess of £1000.

I say, 1) it's entirely not clear that our bushes are responsible at this v early stage in investigations, and its very unlikely they are solely responsible 2) even if they are, this is not something we have personal liability for. The bushes have been there for years- long before we moved in. But even if he has a case, it's for our insurance and his to fight it out. If it is decided that somehow we are liable, our insurance may agree to pay out. But we are not personally required to pay his excess?

I mean, isn't that what insurance is for?

OP posts:
SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:35

Yes, I said to dh I imagine that either his insurance company or ours is probably going to have to take the trees down and we would have to give permission, which we absolutely would. I also pointed out that the chances are that our insurance company is already planning to remove them as part of our subsidence claim so it's silly to be getting worked up.

But either way, if ndn has to have any additional work done, and make a claim on his insurance, dh and ndn think we have to pay. I also told dh that it's entirely up to our insurance company to duke it out with him...

Realistically, based on progress on our claim, the trees ate likely to be a contributing factor but not the only factor.

OP posts:
RudsyFarmer · 01/07/2023 17:35

You need to get your insurance company involved. If you pay him a thousand pounds you may be admitting liability.

Our neighbour has come at us via a subcontracted company her insurance company has hired to tell us our tree is making her extension crack. We have instructed our legal cover through our house insurance to sort it out. Which they are (very slowly) doing. We are happy to take the vegetation down but the assumption is they will pay for it and the subsequent costs of replanting with suitable plants. I have no idea if that is what will happen but I believe that’s what we’ve put forward.

HollyBookBlue · 01/07/2023 17:33

Also his insurance company will contact you directly to let you know what NDN's report says if you need to be involved. Wait for that to happen. Don't speak about it with NDN.

Em308 · 01/07/2023 17:32

Subsidence excess is usually around £1000 - you all might want to check your own home insurance policies.

HollyBookBlue · 01/07/2023 17:30

I've been through this, no you're not liable for paying his excess. That's crazy! If NDN's insurance company's report says that your trees/bushes are responsible for his subsidence, then you are responsible for removing them (organising for it to be done, the cost involved). However you could claim on your insurance for this if you wanted.

Our neighbour refused to cut down their tree and our insurance company ended up taking them to court to make them.

WhatADrabCarpet · 01/07/2023 17:29

And even then, your insurers will deal with payments.

EastCoastRye · 01/07/2023 17:29

Don't give him any money or say anything to him, whatever the report says. Just pass everything onto your own insurance company. As PP says, giving him money may be taken as an admission of responsibility and in the worst case scenario could potentially affect whether your own insurance pays out.

WhatADrabCarpet · 01/07/2023 17:28

It's up to your own insurers to decide if you have caused their problems.
Leave them to decide. Don't pay them anything until it's been resolved.

parietal · 01/07/2023 17:28

he chose to have insurance with a £1000 excess. so he gets to pay the excess. that is how insurance works.

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:26

On plus side, I don't think he would expect it upfront. More like he'd laying the groundwork... "we have subsidence, it's your fault, so once we make the claim you will have to oat us £1000".

Dh seems to think he has a case. But dh is a total People pleaser and it infuriates me as he gets taken advantage of as a result. Often to the detriment of the rest of us.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 01/07/2023 17:25

He's trying it on. Tbh shy bairns get nowt, but still trying it on. Tell him no...sorry. these types of people just look for a foot in the door to rinse you imo.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 01/07/2023 17:20

Tell him you'll wait for the insurance report. Don't pay up, he's chancing his luck and will come after you for more.

LadyTemperance · 01/07/2023 17:17

YANBU and if you paid it I suspect your ndn would then say you had taken responsibility for the subsidence. They may then come after you for more. Having such a high excess was their choice when they took the policy out.