Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse to pay NDN £1000?

63 replies

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:14

We live in an area with clay soil with a well known subsidence issue, exacerbated currently by weird weather of the last few years. Our house is one of many in area currently being investigated for subsidence issues, via insurance company. We have bushes/trees on our boundaries at the front and certainly, the roots are clearly causing some problems although exactly how much or what they will do to sort is still unclear.

Ndn is also having some minor signs of subsidence and has started similar investigation via his insurance company. They have come round today and confirmed that on his side, yes, the trees/bushes' roots are causing some issues with pipes etc underground. This is first step in process and a report will be prepared.

NDN has suggested that as the reason he has problems is our bushes, we are personally liable for his insurance excess of £1000.

I say, 1) it's entirely not clear that our bushes are responsible at this v early stage in investigations, and its very unlikely they are solely responsible 2) even if they are, this is not something we have personal liability for. The bushes have been there for years- long before we moved in. But even if he has a case, it's for our insurance and his to fight it out. If it is decided that somehow we are liable, our insurance may agree to pay out. But we are not personally required to pay his excess?

I mean, isn't that what insurance is for?

OP posts:
Pushmepullu · 01/07/2023 18:22

We also live in an area with clay soil.
We received a letter from our NDN insurance company telling us that the likely cause of their subsidence was our trees. We very much doubted this but paid to have them cut down. Many months later it was discovered that the cause was likely to have been trees on council land. NDN didn’t ask us to pay his excess and we wouldn’t have done if he did. We didn’t ask them to cover the cost of us cutting down the trees. That’s one of the responsibilities you take on as a home owner.

Pearlsaminga · 01/07/2023 18:22

LoopyLoo1991 · 01/07/2023 18:20

He's being a cheeky bastard. Plans to guilt you into paying by gaslighting etc.

I agree, watch him going forwards and keep any comms to written forms if possible

LoopyLoo1991 · 01/07/2023 18:20

He's being a cheeky bastard. Plans to guilt you into paying by gaslighting etc.

Dotandtime · 01/07/2023 18:20

If the insurers judge it's your fault, your company will have to pay his whole claim, including the excess.

I don't know if the bushes are the cause, obviously, but if they are, the fact that you didn't plant them won't mean you aren't liable, if they're on your land.

But yes, leave it all in the hands of the insurers.

Gateappreciation · 01/07/2023 18:18

LadyBird1973 · 01/07/2023 18:17

Mostly you need to make sure your dh doesn't just give him £1000 and tell you afterwards!

This!

LadyBird1973 · 01/07/2023 18:17

Mostly you need to make sure your dh doesn't just give him £1000 and tell you afterwards!

Quiverer · 01/07/2023 18:15

There are circumstances in which you could be liable, but you would be very silly just to take the NDN's word for it. This is exactly what you pay insurance premiums for.

Comeonbarbiebrianharvey · 01/07/2023 18:09

His excess is his responsibility, and, as you've said, the bushes aren't the only problem.

I'd strongly advise mentioning to your insurer that he is asking you to pay his excess, they will give you solid advice and reassurance, and, if he were to pursue it, in my experience they would have your back legally, e.g. respond to any formal requests via their legal department.

Tell him politely but firmly, you've spoken to your insurers and they've advised you have to leave everything with them. If you want to, as you have to live next to him and don't want to get nasty, you could say it could invalidate your insurance were you to do so, so you're under strict instructions to leave it to them. If he's in doubt he can speak to his insurers.

He's a CF.

IsThisReallyPC · 01/07/2023 18:03

RudsyFarmer · 01/07/2023 17:35

You need to get your insurance company involved. If you pay him a thousand pounds you may be admitting liability.

Our neighbour has come at us via a subcontracted company her insurance company has hired to tell us our tree is making her extension crack. We have instructed our legal cover through our house insurance to sort it out. Which they are (very slowly) doing. We are happy to take the vegetation down but the assumption is they will pay for it and the subsequent costs of replanting with suitable plants. I have no idea if that is what will happen but I believe that’s what we’ve put forward.

@RudsyFarmer if it’s a new extension they should have taken into account your tree when they put up the extension assuming your tree was their first.
If your tree was already there and they put up a new extension in spite of your tree and obviously too close then it’s down to the neighbours and their structural engineer.

They should have constructed a barrier underground to prevent the roots of your pre existing tree damaging the property.
Obviously if it’s an old extension and a new tree, just ignore me🤣

Lemonyfuckit · 01/07/2023 18:00

Crazy to suggest you're liable for his excess. Even if (and it's a huge if) his insurance company decided it was caused by your property and your insurance company agreed and agreed to pay his insurance company, that's entirely between them, and he'd still need to pay his own insurance excess, absolutely nothing to do with you. That's how insurance works. Don't give him a penny whatever you do!

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 18:00

legalseagull · 01/07/2023 17:56

Tell him (and DP) the insurance companies will sort it out and obviously you won't personally be paying anything to him - that's what insurance is for.

This is what I said to dh.

I feel bad as I was a bit snappy. I came in, in a huge rush as me and dd had to go out again in 5 minutes, and dh accosted me with a face of doom and the hushed voice of concern that we would now have to pay this £1000.

But while I could have been more polite, I am pleased to see that I was overall right. Its ot our problem. Ndn must instruct his insurance company and we will instruct ours.

I am going to tell dh not to speak to ndn about it again and just to say that if his insurance company wants to talk to our insurance company we are happy to.provide details.

OP posts:
IsThisReallyPC · 01/07/2023 17:58

Leave it for the insurance companies to fight it out.
Just make sure your insurance company doesn’t take NDNs insurance company information as true. Your insurance company must investigate, on site with experienced and qualified building surveyors.

You are not required to pay his excess, under any circumstances. How much excess he chooses to have is his problem.

BooneyBeautiful · 01/07/2023 17:56

parietal · 01/07/2023 17:28

he chose to have insurance with a £1000 excess. so he gets to pay the excess. that is how insurance works.

As far as I am aware all insurance companies have a subsidence excess of £1000. I have never seen any cheaper.

legalseagull · 01/07/2023 17:56

Tell him (and DP) the insurance companies will sort it out and obviously you won't personally be paying anything to him - that's what insurance is for.

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:55

Yup, £1000 seems to be standard. Its what we will be paying on our side.

I have no idea whether in subsidence claims if its considered our fault our insurance would pay his £1000 - seems unlikely- but I am 100% certain that we do not have to pay it out of our pocket.

OP posts:
fuckmyuteruslining · 01/07/2023 17:55

Absolutely hilarious to read everybody claiming this is a high excess. It isn't. It's standard. Look at your own policies.
But he's been a CFalright. Ignore op. And tell dh to keep his do gooding mouth tight shut 😬

Gateappreciation · 01/07/2023 17:51

You are not responsible for his insurance. The reason he a high excess is to reduce his yearly premiums. He’s trying it on.

FOJN · 01/07/2023 17:48

LadyTemperance · 01/07/2023 17:17

YANBU and if you paid it I suspect your ndn would then say you had taken responsibility for the subsidence. They may then come after you for more. Having such a high excess was their choice when they took the policy out.

£1000 is the standard excess for subsidence issues. I've yet to take out a policy where that was not the case. You can reduce premiums for other items by increasing your excess but the subsidence excess seems to be fixed.

MRex · 01/07/2023 17:46
  1. Speak to your insurer, they will tell you to stop debating it with him
  2. Terribly sorry NDN, insurer says we must not speak with you about this and let them handle any conversations [repeat]
  3. If you put up a fence and have receipts, then it is still your fence. NDN can add his own fence to maintain the boundary if he wants, or ask you to take it down if it's encroached on his land. Most people avoid responsibility to avoid taking on maintenance, nobody can nick a fence someone paid for.
gamerchick · 01/07/2023 17:44

It doesnt sound as if the neighbour is your most pressing problem. It's your bloke you need to have a stern word with so he doesn't do anything stupid.

HollyBookBlue · 01/07/2023 17:42

I don't my insurance company will say, "yes, because the trees were part of the problem we will now pay for your entire subsidence issue"

Your absolutely right. His insurance company will cough up for any work that needs to be done on his house because of the subsidence. It doesn't matter what the cause of his subsidence was. He has to pay his excess, because that's the terms of his insurance.

Don't pay him any money!

FictionalCharacter · 01/07/2023 17:40

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:26

On plus side, I don't think he would expect it upfront. More like he'd laying the groundwork... "we have subsidence, it's your fault, so once we make the claim you will have to oat us £1000".

Dh seems to think he has a case. But dh is a total People pleaser and it infuriates me as he gets taken advantage of as a result. Often to the detriment of the rest of us.

My dh is the same and it drives me round the bend. I try to make sure I deal with tradesmen instead of him. He thinks I’m terribly harsh on said tradesmen (for making them do the job they are meant to do, because DH would do half the job for them / let them get away with poor work).

No you are not liable for NDN’s policy excess. Cheeky bugger. Don’t enter into any conversations with ndn, tell him it’s all for the insurance companies to sort between them, which it is. Tell DH he MUST NOT talk to ndn about it. The last thing you need is him making sympathetic or conciliatory noises which will make ndn think he’s got a foot in the door. NDN might also start saying DH admits liability and has agreed to pay.

RudsyFarmer · 01/07/2023 17:39

I honestly would stop conversing with him about it and let your insurance company liaise with his. It’s what they are for!

QforCucumber · 01/07/2023 17:39

@LadyTemperance @parietal most insurance policies have a £1000 excess for subsidence, it is completely separate to other claim excesses and not usually a choice to be able to reduce.

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:38

Pressed send too soon.

I can see our insurance company being responsible for the trees and taking them all down. But either his damage is minor and that's fine or he has additional issues and his insurance company will have yo sort. I don't my insurance company will say, "yes, because the trees were part of the problem we will now pay for your entire subsidence issue".

We paid for fences at the back. He told us they were our fences. We were dumb and trying to be helpful and we paid. I don't think he was purposefully trying yo screw us, but I do wonder sometimes if he did actually know they weren't.

OP posts: