Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse to pay NDN £1000?

63 replies

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:14

We live in an area with clay soil with a well known subsidence issue, exacerbated currently by weird weather of the last few years. Our house is one of many in area currently being investigated for subsidence issues, via insurance company. We have bushes/trees on our boundaries at the front and certainly, the roots are clearly causing some problems although exactly how much or what they will do to sort is still unclear.

Ndn is also having some minor signs of subsidence and has started similar investigation via his insurance company. They have come round today and confirmed that on his side, yes, the trees/bushes' roots are causing some issues with pipes etc underground. This is first step in process and a report will be prepared.

NDN has suggested that as the reason he has problems is our bushes, we are personally liable for his insurance excess of £1000.

I say, 1) it's entirely not clear that our bushes are responsible at this v early stage in investigations, and its very unlikely they are solely responsible 2) even if they are, this is not something we have personal liability for. The bushes have been there for years- long before we moved in. But even if he has a case, it's for our insurance and his to fight it out. If it is decided that somehow we are liable, our insurance may agree to pay out. But we are not personally required to pay his excess?

I mean, isn't that what insurance is for?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 00:32

If both houses (and others) it's hardly the fault of your bushes however if your bushes have caused problems it'll be down to your insurance to pay up. If he claims on his own and there's a £1000 excess (which is typical) he could in theory make a civil claim against you for the difference.

2bazookas · 02/07/2023 00:27

Your own insurers will be very unhappy if you admit any blame or fault by paying compensation.

Tell neighbour he needs to wait for results of his insurers investigation; then tne insurers  can discuss any  distrubution of losses.
FarmGirl78 · 02/07/2023 00:01

parietal · 01/07/2023 17:28

he chose to have insurance with a £1000 excess. so he gets to pay the excess. that is how insurance works.

I think it's quite normal for policies to have a higher access in the small print if the claim is for subsidence. My buildings insurance excess is £50 for anything else but £1000 for subsidence. Its all I've ever known, but I'm a geek who always reads the small print!

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 21:23

LadyTemperance · 01/07/2023 19:17

I don’t understand this unless it only applies to subsidence. If someone crashed their car into my house they would be liable despite me not predicting that they might do that.

I think if my bushes are to blame, a better analogy would be if I parked my car, legally, on the street and then there was an insane storm and as a result my car was actually lifted and smashed into their house. I don't think they could argue that because it was my car, I am to blame.

Ranks @honhoneylulu I don't know that we do have liability insurance. But at the end of the day, it seems clear that no matter what, we don't just fork over £1000!

OP posts:
honeylulu · 01/07/2023 20:40

Do you have liability insurance OP? If not then your insurers will have nothing to do with it anyway.

topnoddy · 01/07/2023 19:57

It's HIS excess on HIS insurance policy , nowt to do with you .

mrstea301 · 01/07/2023 19:55

If your insurers assume full responsibility and deal with all costs, he won't need to pay his excess - he would only pay that if his insurer deals with the costs.

I wouldn't pay his excess - it can be taken as an admission of liability.

Raindancer411 · 01/07/2023 19:55

Just out of interest but how long have you lived there, and when you moved in and had a survey done, was anything said about them possibly causing an issue in the future?

Kennykenkencat · 01/07/2023 19:28

We had something similar. Our neighbours property had a huge double extension put on the back by a builder and of course being an older property the foundations of the new extension didn’t match the much shallower foundations of the original part of the house.

My neighbours insurance company told me that it was my trees that were the problem but as they all had TPOs on them then I had to apply to the local council in order to remove them.

I knew it wasn’t my trees otherwise my house would have been affected

I had a word with my neighbour and because I had watched them build the extension I knew the problem was how they had “tied” in the brickwork of the extension.

No one believed me. So I obtained permission to remove the trees and neighbour was still experiencing cracking in her house.

It took them 3 years to finally admit that the problem was not actually the trees but how they had “tied” the extension to the original house.

honeylulu · 01/07/2023 19:25

Sorry Lady Temperance, re reading your post. The victim does not need to be on notice, only the tortfeasor (defendant).

honeylulu · 01/07/2023 19:24

LadyTemperance · 01/07/2023 19:17

I don’t understand this unless it only applies to subsidence. If someone crashed their car into my house they would be liable despite me not predicting that they might do that.

If you crashed your car into someone's house that would be negligence (I assume). The negligent act would be in that moment so prior notice of the risk is irrelevant because all drivers are on notice that negligent driving presents a risk of damage and injury. If your bushes encroached onto your neighbours land that would be nuisance (a tort similar to negligence) but you wouldn't be at fault until you had been "negligent" by being aware of the specific risk and failed to take reasonable steps within a reasonable time.

IsThisReallyPC · 01/07/2023 19:19

RudsyFarmer · 01/07/2023 19:12

Our tree was there first👍

Interesting.
Naughty neighbour, bad builder and crap structural engineer ( bet they didn’t even consult one )
They should have put in a barrier. If they haven’t they should now!
Save your tree!

Ask them what mitigation measures their structural engineer proposed to stop your existing tree affecting their new extension. Ask to see the engineers drawings. There won’t be any, but I think you’ll have made your point.

LadyTemperance · 01/07/2023 19:17

honeylulu · 01/07/2023 19:11

Insurance lawyer here. NDN is talking bullshit. The insurance is "first party" ie between him and his insurer, including excess. He and insurer pay in first instance. IF there is a reasonable case that you are liable the insurer can seek a recovery from you (third party claim). Also known as subrogation. But they won't have a case simply because your bushes are the cause of damage. To be liable they also have to show you were "on notice" of the risk BEFORE the damage occurred AND failed to abate the nuisance in a reasonable time. It doesn't sound like that can be proven so he can go whistle. N.B. if the bushes are the cause suggest you reduce or remove them promptly to avoid allegations of post-notice further damage.

I don’t understand this unless it only applies to subsidence. If someone crashed their car into my house they would be liable despite me not predicting that they might do that.

LH93 · 01/07/2023 19:16

Home insurance manager here.

You are not personally liable for the £1000. Subsidence excesses are nearly always £1000 + due to the time & costs involved in these claims (often 10's of £1000s and 12-18 months).

Given both your homes are built on clay and the warm weather we've had the last few summers it's much more likely this is the cause than your trees/bushes (500% increase in subsidence claims 2022/23).
Even if you are to 'blame', you still won't pay this. Ndn insurance company (IC) will pursue your IC for what is known as a 'recovery', where they'll chase the cost of the claim from your IC. If successful, ndn IC will then decide if they want to give their customer the £1000 back. They often do for good will purposes, however don't have to as it's within each insurance contract that the owner must pay an excess.

It's unlikely the 'blame' will be placed on you unless there's proven negligence, i.e. they have an audit trail of letters to you informing you that your trees/bushes may cause damage to their home (and proof you did nothing about it). Either way, you wont be flipping the bill. But you will have to pay your own £1000 (or more) excess of your own claim goes forward. Do not engage in any liability conversations with your NDN, if they bring this up, inform them they will need their IC to speak to your IC.

I hope this helps

honeylulu · 01/07/2023 19:15

Also your house insurer is unlikely to be involved even at subrogation stage unless you also have liability cover. Most building policies cover damage to your own property only, not liability for damage to other people's property.

Hibiscrubbed · 01/07/2023 19:14

Your husband is a dope. Don’t let him anywhere near this. 🙄

RudsyFarmer · 01/07/2023 19:12

IsThisReallyPC · 01/07/2023 18:03

@RudsyFarmer if it’s a new extension they should have taken into account your tree when they put up the extension assuming your tree was their first.
If your tree was already there and they put up a new extension in spite of your tree and obviously too close then it’s down to the neighbours and their structural engineer.

They should have constructed a barrier underground to prevent the roots of your pre existing tree damaging the property.
Obviously if it’s an old extension and a new tree, just ignore me🤣

Our tree was there first👍

honeylulu · 01/07/2023 19:11

Insurance lawyer here. NDN is talking bullshit. The insurance is "first party" ie between him and his insurer, including excess. He and insurer pay in first instance. IF there is a reasonable case that you are liable the insurer can seek a recovery from you (third party claim). Also known as subrogation. But they won't have a case simply because your bushes are the cause of damage. To be liable they also have to show you were "on notice" of the risk BEFORE the damage occurred AND failed to abate the nuisance in a reasonable time. It doesn't sound like that can be proven so he can go whistle. N.B. if the bushes are the cause suggest you reduce or remove them promptly to avoid allegations of post-notice further damage.

FOJN · 01/07/2023 18:52

You're a long way off from a claim being settled.

I had subsidence problems at a house years ago. Similar to you it was due to maturing shrubs in clay soil combined with low rain fall. First they established the cause of the problem, removed the shrubs, then they monitored for a year to see if there was any further movement in the house, then came to repair work followed by a further year of monitoring to make sure I didn't end up with heave after the soil rehydrated.

Your insurance companies will sort it out between them. I would not get involved in any discussion about it and you need to make sure your husband sticks to the same script.

3dogsandarabbit · 01/07/2023 18:50

I had a car accident once which was the other driver's fault. I paid the excess to my insurance company and then was reimbursed the excess by the other person's insurance company. The other driver did not have to pay for my excess out of his own pocket.

Do not pay your neighbour any money. Leave it for the insurance companies to sort out. It may well be the case that his excess is reimbursed, but it will be via the insurance company and not you. This is why we have insurance, for them to sort it.

WingingItEveryDay7 · 01/07/2023 18:45

I work in liability claims for a well known insurer....... Do not under any circumstances pay anything to your NDN. If down the line you are found legally liable for the cause of his subsidence then your insurance company will correspond with his insurer about who pays what. If he has had to pay his XS during that time then he may be able to claim it back from your insurance company, depending upon the liability outcome. It's how insurance works.

CheeseandTrees · 01/07/2023 18:39

If you were liable, his insurers would be contacting your insurers. His excess is his problem.

Georgyporky · 01/07/2023 18:36

NDN is wrong, but I can also see his POV. I'd be annoyed if I was expected to pay if there was no fault on my part.
Stay strong, let the companies sort it out.
I had subsidence at my last property, & had to pay the £1000 excess; as others have said, this is standard.

LadyTemperance · 01/07/2023 18:35

SavBlancTonight · 01/07/2023 17:55

Yup, £1000 seems to be standard. Its what we will be paying on our side.

I have no idea whether in subsidence claims if its considered our fault our insurance would pay his £1000 - seems unlikely- but I am 100% certain that we do not have to pay it out of our pocket.

If your insurers accept responsibility then ndn will claim off your insurance not his so won’t have to pay an excess.

Skodacool · 01/07/2023 18:24

parietal · 01/07/2023 17:28

he chose to have insurance with a £1000 excess. so he gets to pay the excess. that is how insurance works.

This.

Swipe left for the next trending thread