Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex is getting angry at My suggestions

54 replies

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 06:17

So im currently 32 weeks pregnant with my first baby, the father is my ex who I split with in April of 2022 but we continued to meet up on a casual basis for the next 7 months or so until I found out I was pregnant. He hasn't been involved during the pregnancy as continues to say he doesn't even know whether it's his or not so I've said he can do a dna test if he so wishes. He's been dating this girl I believe for the last few months although he says it's none of my business. I've said im not comfortable with her being around my baby until they've been in a longterm secure relationship. He has flipped out calling me all sorts and says I can't control this. Do anyone of you have any advice on what you would do in this situation?? The only advice I've seen online are for kids that are older and not newborn/babies.

OP posts:
Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 01/07/2023 08:25

I don't think it's on you to call the shots of his relationship.

The baby is hardly going to be off with them both anyway when so little.
Are you going to be breastfeeding? Because if so the baby will either be clamped to you cluster feeding 24/7 or needing a feed every couple of hours.
If you do want to BF and your ex says it's not fair or what then tough shit. Your baby, your choice.

I can't imagine the new gf will want to play happy families just yet either.

Strictly1 · 01/07/2023 08:24

Hibiscrubbed · 01/07/2023 07:06

Sever all contact with him, don’t put him on the birth certificate, claim CMS as soon as you can.

His behaviour is going to annihilate you, you’re particularly vulnerable at the moment and the last thing you need is him trying to control you and your baby when it’s born.

Don’t give him any rights but take his money. No wonder society is at it is!

Would you be happy for him to dictate who you see? Do you have any real concerns about her other than it doesn’t suit?

Please think carefully about what you really want. I work with children and watch how parents are so busy fighting they lose sight of the feelings of the children they say they are fighting for. It’s not about you but what’s right for the child you two have created. I’m sure he has done lots wrong too but you both need to put all of that aside and be the grown ups.

BadgerFacedCoo · 01/07/2023 08:24

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 07:45

Thanks for your replies.
Still in contact with him because I didn't want him to miss out and being his first child as well I stupidly thought (even though it wasn't planned) he would want to be involved but I think im just hurting myself or my expectations are too high.

I dont think badly of her as I don't know her (yes think it's a bit odd to start a relationship with guy with a baby on the way but that's my own personal belief) I guess I'm worried he is going to prioritise other bits in his life.

I was doing okay emotionally until the last week and now I can't stop crying that this is not how I thought pregnancy and having a baby would be like

But odd to have a baby with an ex but you keep your personal beliefs.

He's not even acknowledging he's the father- wanting DNA tests etc. You really need to start being realistic here. You've tied yourself to this man for life with non of the benefits of a relationship. You can't choose his partners.

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 08:22

electriclight- I was on the coil when I got pregnant and I went through with the pregnancy because I had a previous termination the year before (he had lost his father a few days before i found out I was pregnant and didn't want the baby) and I mentally couldn't go through that again. I also continued seeing him as I still had feelings and he admitted he still did but didn't have the same kind of love for me as before.

OP posts:
Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 08:18

I have good family support just not local. I'm almost 2 hours from either of my parents.

I am feeling pretty lonely and I'm working my backside off to prepare for the baby and working overtime etc.

He lost his father 2 years ago who wasn't around for majority of his childhood till he was in his teens and I didn't want history to repeat itself by him not being around which is maybe why I've kept wanting him to be involved

OP posts:
AuntMarch · 01/07/2023 08:16

I split from my child's father before I gave birth. I did put him on the birth certificate. He is the father, and as entitled to be a parent to our child as I am.

But in your situation OP, when he is questioning paternity, I absolutely wouldn't. I would agree to it later if he did a paternity test to satisfy his own doubts and then wanted to be added, but I wouldn't give him those rights until he's proven he actually wants to he a father.

If he isn't involved in the pregnancy you don't need to be having contact with him at present. I'd send him a photo of scan images or a summary of appointments perhaps so he can never claim you stopped him being involved, and answer any pregnancy related questions if he were to show interest, but no need for conversations otherwise.

But no, if he steps up as a parent, you cannot dictate who he has around when it is his time with the child. But he isn't going to be having overnights for a long time, it'll start with frequent but short visits, with you there.

electriclight · 01/07/2023 08:15

He probably thinks you got pregnant on purpose. Weird that neither of you used contraception when you were just casual, didn't want a baby and didn't even like each other very much.

He's single so he's allowed a new relationship. He's probably told her you did it on purpose and made you sound mad. You can't interfere with who he introduces the baby to on his time any more than he can control who you introduce the baby to on your time. You are trying to control him and make him behave as if he's in a relationship with you and care what you think.

I'd stop contacting him and plan to be a single parent. If he wants a relationship with the baby let him do all the running, and if he doesn't well that's great. Claim cs as soon as you can.

Daisydu · 01/07/2023 08:09

Just seen your second post. I feel for you. I was left pregnant and the dad was in a new relationship within a month. He was involved though and was good to me to be fair. But as your ex is saying he isn’t sure if he’s the dad, I think no contact for now, wait for him to do a dna test. Also people suggesting don’t put him on birth certificate, if you know he’s the father then you shouldn’t not do that in my opinion.
but still, you can’t dictate who he has around the baby, so let that go.

Daisydu · 01/07/2023 08:05

He’s right, you can’t control that. If he has the child on his own he can have who he likes around that baby.

Hibiscrubbed · 01/07/2023 08:04

I was doing okay emotionally until the last week and now I can't stop crying that this is not how I thought pregnancy and having a baby would be like

And this is why you need to cut him off. Stop trying to include him. He’s horrible. He doesn’t care about you or the baby. He denies it’s even his child.

Why are you doing it to yourself? Be honest about your reasoning - is it to try to win him back? Take him back from her? You feel you have a claim to him? Because you’re lonely? Worried about doing it alone?

Whatever it is, he’s only bringing negativity and pain. You do not need that.

Sever contact.
Do not invite him to your birth.
Do no put him on the birth certificate.
Claim CMS.

If he wants to be involved at any point, it’s on your terms and he needs to earn any right.

Cheetahmum · 01/07/2023 08:04

He has to come with you to register the birth if he wants to be on the birth certificate and given he's disputing being the father it doesn't sound like he'll do that anyway.

Ywudu · 01/07/2023 07:58

Do not put him on the birth certificate, just don't. You don't want to end up in a situation where you are applying for an emergency court order because he has taken the child and won't give it back.
I would stop contacting him, he just isn't that interested and no father is better than a useless one.

Velvian · 01/07/2023 07:57

Honestly, I would cut contact for now. No question that the baby has your last name anything else would be madness. Continuing contact with this man is not sounding good for you at this stage of the pregnancy. He doesn't sound interested.

The last thing you would want is time away from your newborn with another couple playing mummies and daddies.

Do you have family support?

UndercoverCop · 01/07/2023 07:50

I'm not sure it is that odd to start a relationship with a man with a baby on the way, you'd been separated for seven months at the point of conception, so nearly 16 months now?
He may well also have not told her about the ongoing physical relationship, maybe just that it was a one off or similar.

Either way your focus is on the wrong person.

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 07:45

Thanks for your replies.
Still in contact with him because I didn't want him to miss out and being his first child as well I stupidly thought (even though it wasn't planned) he would want to be involved but I think im just hurting myself or my expectations are too high.

I dont think badly of her as I don't know her (yes think it's a bit odd to start a relationship with guy with a baby on the way but that's my own personal belief) I guess I'm worried he is going to prioritise other bits in his life.

I was doing okay emotionally until the last week and now I can't stop crying that this is not how I thought pregnancy and having a baby would be like

OP posts:
veryfluffyfluff · 01/07/2023 07:39

You can be uncomfortable with it but you can't stop it. Not unless you refuse him any contact.

Gettingfleeced · 01/07/2023 07:38

Do you want your DC to have a relationship with this man? What might that look like? (Eg. Shared custody, eow, once a week for an hour in a contact centre?)

Do you think he would be a steady and reliable person in your child's life, always prioritising your child's needs or that he would be unreliable and let you/DC down at the last minute?

If you want him in your child's life you have to accept he will introduce people to your child that you might not know or like. If not, cut ties now.

Search old threads on Mumsnet for "birth certificate" as there may be some issues you haven't considered relating to whether his name is on the birth certificate.

Hibiscrubbed · 01/07/2023 07:29

Do not put him in the BC. Just don’t. Especially not in a misguided hope it’ll have an emotional effect. It’ll give him power you don’t want him to have.

You need to protect yourself and your baby. He needs to earn any kind of right to see this child, something he has so far failed to do spectacularly.

I’m surprised you’re even in contact with him.

Having him at the birth is a truly appalling idea, too. You need someone who can advocate for you and care for you. You will be at your most vulnerable.

Tinythumbelina · 01/07/2023 07:24

Don't put him on the BC

strawberry2017 · 01/07/2023 07:18

Don't judge the women, she might be the best thing that happens to your child if the father decides he wants contact.
Don't look at it as a negative look at it as extra support and to look after the baby.

She will never replace you, no women can but she's not the bad guy here.
It's him that's behaving poorly.

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 07:07

He has said he doesn't want to be at the birth as we are no longer together and baby is taking my surname. I haven't made a decision about the BC yet as I thought we'd be able to make reasonable decisions together but he's making me doubt things after his serious lack of effort

OP posts:
Hibiscrubbed · 01/07/2023 07:06

Sever all contact with him, don’t put him on the birth certificate, claim CMS as soon as you can.

His behaviour is going to annihilate you, you’re particularly vulnerable at the moment and the last thing you need is him trying to control you and your baby when it’s born.

Reugny · 01/07/2023 06:46

Forgot to add it is expected if he is the father, wants to be added to the birth certificate at any time and takes steps to be added, he's added. The birth certificate is a legal record for your child as an individual not you.

So while you can not take him to register the birth so he doesn't have PR then, if he bothers to do it later then you will be advised to agree by your lawyer.

However to claim child maintenance from him via the CMS he doesn't have to be on the birth certificate.

heldinadream · 01/07/2023 06:44

Well he's unlikely to have the baby on his own for some time - maybe nearly a year after baby is born. So it's not an issue yet.
Are you even putting him on the birth certificate? Questions like this are of much more immediate importance.

Reugny · 01/07/2023 06:41

Oh and PPs are right it is none of your business who is around your child when the child is with him unless that person is a known danger to children.

In fact your child can even stay over at that person's house.

If you cause issues e.g. harass someone related to him, then you won't be told that is happening and the address of the person regardless of whether the person is a grandparent, partner of the father or family friend.