Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex is getting angry at My suggestions

54 replies

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 06:17

So im currently 32 weeks pregnant with my first baby, the father is my ex who I split with in April of 2022 but we continued to meet up on a casual basis for the next 7 months or so until I found out I was pregnant. He hasn't been involved during the pregnancy as continues to say he doesn't even know whether it's his or not so I've said he can do a dna test if he so wishes. He's been dating this girl I believe for the last few months although he says it's none of my business. I've said im not comfortable with her being around my baby until they've been in a longterm secure relationship. He has flipped out calling me all sorts and says I can't control this. Do anyone of you have any advice on what you would do in this situation?? The only advice I've seen online are for kids that are older and not newborn/babies.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RicherThanYews · 01/07/2023 13:15

@electriclight there are posts on this thread telling the OP that she should mind her own business about her ex and his new girlfriend possibly being involved in the baby's life from birth. That's why I said there is a double standard.

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 12:22

Hoardasurass · 01/07/2023 12:13

@Cotswoldlife90
Some of the advice you've got is just wrong.
1st, You can't just put him on the birth certificate he can only go on it if he agrees to come and sign it when you register the birth as you aren't married. Or he can petition the court when the dna is done.

2nd, he should not be taking a new born out of the house and away from you (mum) for contact. A judge would only give a hour or so every other day with you in the same house (not nesscarilly same room) this would be the same for breast or bottle feed.

3rd he should slowly build up the time that he spends with dc over 6 months to a year until he can take dc out for the day (no overnight access before 1-2 years) after this overnight access can be built up to 50/50 (though usually not till after 5). However most nrp have every other weekend and 1 night in the week so 70/30 split.

As for his girlfriend if you don't want her in your home she doesn't come in therefore she can't meet dc. Also contact should be dc and dad only until a bond is created between dc and dad. However once dad starts to take dc out alone (around 6 months) he can introduce dc to anyone he chooses and unless there's valid safeguarding issues there's nothing you can do to stop it.
In reality if he wants a dna test then he won't be on the birth certificate so will have to apply to the court to get his parental rights, which will be granted with the dna then he will be granted access. You need to be reasonable about access before the court order otherwise it looks bad on you. However you need to remember that any contract that you allow will set a president so don't allow him to bully you into more than you're comfortable with, I'd only offer the court standard that I've listed above and if he demands more tell him to take you to court because he won't get more and may get less because the judge can see that you are putting your child 1st by offering reasonable contact and he is refusing/demanding unreasonable contact and not putting dc's needs 1st.
Basically forget him until after dc is born and ignore his new gf, who may not even know about you and your pregnancy and if she does may not want any contact. Also I'd recommend putting as cm claim as soon as dc is born. Good luck

Thank you for this, some great advice

OP posts:
Hoardasurass · 01/07/2023 12:13

@Cotswoldlife90
Some of the advice you've got is just wrong.
1st, You can't just put him on the birth certificate he can only go on it if he agrees to come and sign it when you register the birth as you aren't married. Or he can petition the court when the dna is done.

2nd, he should not be taking a new born out of the house and away from you (mum) for contact. A judge would only give a hour or so every other day with you in the same house (not nesscarilly same room) this would be the same for breast or bottle feed.

3rd he should slowly build up the time that he spends with dc over 6 months to a year until he can take dc out for the day (no overnight access before 1-2 years) after this overnight access can be built up to 50/50 (though usually not till after 5). However most nrp have every other weekend and 1 night in the week so 70/30 split.

As for his girlfriend if you don't want her in your home she doesn't come in therefore she can't meet dc. Also contact should be dc and dad only until a bond is created between dc and dad. However once dad starts to take dc out alone (around 6 months) he can introduce dc to anyone he chooses and unless there's valid safeguarding issues there's nothing you can do to stop it.
In reality if he wants a dna test then he won't be on the birth certificate so will have to apply to the court to get his parental rights, which will be granted with the dna then he will be granted access. You need to be reasonable about access before the court order otherwise it looks bad on you. However you need to remember that any contract that you allow will set a president so don't allow him to bully you into more than you're comfortable with, I'd only offer the court standard that I've listed above and if he demands more tell him to take you to court because he won't get more and may get less because the judge can see that you are putting your child 1st by offering reasonable contact and he is refusing/demanding unreasonable contact and not putting dc's needs 1st.
Basically forget him until after dc is born and ignore his new gf, who may not even know about you and your pregnancy and if she does may not want any contact. Also I'd recommend putting as cm claim as soon as dc is born. Good luck

IThinkItsCalledAButt · 01/07/2023 11:05

RicherThanYews · 01/07/2023 09:40

I'm dumbfounded by the double standards on here. Other threads where a mother posts that she has children and a new boyfriend results in her head being ripped off for introducing the new boyfriend too soon and she is always advised to wait until the relationship is on solid ground before introducing the new boyfriend to the children. When a deadbeat dad does the same thing its perfectly OK and the mother should mind her own business? The op is being sensible, she just wants to be sure that the deadbeat dad is in a serious and committed relationship (when baby is born) before the child meets the new girlfriend. Only on fucking Mumsnet.

I don't think anyone is saying they think it's an ideal scenario. Just that in reality what can OP actually do about it? She can't prevent her child from seeing their dad because she doesn't agree with his length of relationship.

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 10:40

So just read everyone's replies and I agree not to contact him further as emotions are getting involved and I'm probably not thinking very straight
Appreciate everyone's points of views

OP posts:
electriclight · 01/07/2023 10:40

OP, you are hurting yourself because you like him and on some level want all of this to end up with the two of you together.

Look after yourself and your baby. Put him on the bc because he's the dad. Claim cm because your baby deserves financial security. Plan to be a great single mum and negotiate contact that works for both of you. Keep contact to essential communications about the baby only. If he isn't interested, and doesn't want to be a dad, consider moving closer to your family so all the people who love you and your baby are on hand to help.

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 10:36

CurlewKate · 01/07/2023 09:53

And for the love of God, sort out some contraception.

I was on the coil!

OP posts:
electriclight · 01/07/2023 10:36

RicherThanYews · 01/07/2023 09:40

I'm dumbfounded by the double standards on here. Other threads where a mother posts that she has children and a new boyfriend results in her head being ripped off for introducing the new boyfriend too soon and she is always advised to wait until the relationship is on solid ground before introducing the new boyfriend to the children. When a deadbeat dad does the same thing its perfectly OK and the mother should mind her own business? The op is being sensible, she just wants to be sure that the deadbeat dad is in a serious and committed relationship (when baby is born) before the child meets the new girlfriend. Only on fucking Mumsnet.

Of course it's not sensible to introduce a child to a casual partner until you know it's serious.

Of course that's going to be the advice for anyone, male or female, who is thinking about doing that.

So no one is saying he is right to do that. It's just that op can't stop him or do anything about it, so needs to be realistic and manage her expectations.

bumblebee2235 · 01/07/2023 10:12

Cotswoldlife90 · 01/07/2023 07:45

Thanks for your replies.
Still in contact with him because I didn't want him to miss out and being his first child as well I stupidly thought (even though it wasn't planned) he would want to be involved but I think im just hurting myself or my expectations are too high.

I dont think badly of her as I don't know her (yes think it's a bit odd to start a relationship with guy with a baby on the way but that's my own personal belief) I guess I'm worried he is going to prioritise other bits in his life.

I was doing okay emotionally until the last week and now I can't stop crying that this is not how I thought pregnancy and having a baby would be like

If he is denying it's his at points... is his new GF even aware? I wouldn't touch someone with a barge pole whose ex is pregnant, I'd feel like a rebound!

RicherThanYews · 01/07/2023 10:08

@HundredMilesAnHour he told her to abort her first baby, he has had zero interest in this baby for the entire pregnancy and has called the OP a myriad of names whilst saying the baby isn't his. Rather than focusing on the baby who could be his, he is concentrating on a new girlfriend. Yeah, he sounds like the Mary Poppins of dad's doesn't he .

RicherThanYews · 01/07/2023 10:08

@HundredMilesAnHour he told her to abort her first baby, he has had zero interest in this baby for the entire pregnancy and has called the OP a myriad of names whilst saying the baby isn't his. Rather than focusing on the baby who could be his, he is concentrating on a new girlfriend. Yeah, he sounds like the Mary Poppins of dad's doesn't he .

PrueRamsay · 01/07/2023 10:02

Quite a lot to unpick here.

It sounds like you are still in love with him, I am very sorry, that must be hard.

Given his doubts about being the baby’s father, I agree with PPs that you should sever contact until you have the DNA results. Get these as soon as you can. If he is the baby’s father then yes, I think he should be on the birth certificate.

Moving forward (assuming he is the father) you will need to come to an agreement around contact and around child maintenance.

Unless any women he is involved with are a danger to your child, you have no grounds whatsoever to dictate who he spends time with when he has the baby.

Finally, don’t sleep with him again, and review your contraception before embarking on any new relationship.

Starlightstarbright2 · 01/07/2023 10:01

so you aren’t due for 2 months - when baby is born contact will be with you for the first few months … so this is not a heat and now problem- if they last they will have been together over 6 months so not a short term relationship so put that on the back burner for now .

He sounds very disinterested in the baby for now - he isn’t interested in the pregnancy - leave him be for now . Let him come to you .

once baby is born let him know . The recommendation is little and often .he may: may not be interested- one thing I learnt the hard way you can’t make the ex be interested.

I wouldn’t rush to put him on the bc and despite what others think you can claim cms without him been on the bc . If he disputes paternity he can be made to do a dna test… which may resolve everything in his mind

focus on you for now .

safly you can’t determine whether or not he will be a good dad and that really hard to get over the idea it’s something you can control

HundredMilesAnHour · 01/07/2023 10:00

RicherThanYews · 01/07/2023 09:40

I'm dumbfounded by the double standards on here. Other threads where a mother posts that she has children and a new boyfriend results in her head being ripped off for introducing the new boyfriend too soon and she is always advised to wait until the relationship is on solid ground before introducing the new boyfriend to the children. When a deadbeat dad does the same thing its perfectly OK and the mother should mind her own business? The op is being sensible, she just wants to be sure that the deadbeat dad is in a serious and committed relationship (when baby is born) before the child meets the new girlfriend. Only on fucking Mumsnet.

Why are you assuming he's a deadbeat dad? The baby hasn't even been born yet. He was no longer in a relationship with the OP when the baby was conceived. It's understandable that he's not exactly jumping for joy.

Conkersinautumn · 01/07/2023 09:58

A caring parent isn't going to introduce someone into their child's life who is more than likely temporarily around.

But you're both persisting with an informal dynamic when obviously there wasn't a future.

He's not attached, holding off emotionally probably until dna test so he has more investment in his current gf and he's right. Going forward you have no business about his private life. He might not be putting it kindly but if you do coparent you cannot be dictating these things. You need to keep your focus on your child.

CurlewKate · 01/07/2023 09:53

And for the love of God, sort out some contraception.

CurlewKate · 01/07/2023 09:53

Don't put him on the birth certificate. Don't give the baby his name.

RicherThanYews · 01/07/2023 09:40

I'm dumbfounded by the double standards on here. Other threads where a mother posts that she has children and a new boyfriend results in her head being ripped off for introducing the new boyfriend too soon and she is always advised to wait until the relationship is on solid ground before introducing the new boyfriend to the children. When a deadbeat dad does the same thing its perfectly OK and the mother should mind her own business? The op is being sensible, she just wants to be sure that the deadbeat dad is in a serious and committed relationship (when baby is born) before the child meets the new girlfriend. Only on fucking Mumsnet.

IThinkItsCalledAButt · 01/07/2023 09:38

I don't know what to suggest in terms of the BC. Can you even request CMS if you don't put him on the BC as PPs have suggested?

I think if this man is the child's father and he wants a relationship with the baby then you would be wrong to prevent that because you don't like the fact his girlfriend might be around. Really, if you accept he's the father and he wants a relationship with the child you also accept his time is his time.

If you get the impression he wants nothing to do with the child then by all means leave him off the BC but I'm not sure where that then leaves you in terms of what he would be responsible for financially.

JudgeRudy · 01/07/2023 09:37

Loverofoxbowlakes · 01/07/2023 06:28

If he is the dad, and he does step up once the baby is born then there is literally nothing you can do to stop him introducing her to your baby once born. Unless she is a massive safety risk it really is out of your control who he introduces the baby to. Sorry that's not what you wanted to hear.

This

missmollygreen · 01/07/2023 09:35

Reugny · 01/07/2023 06:31

Stop contact with him now and inform your midwife that you are no longer with the father.

Sort out another person to be your birthing partner

Tell the hospital/maternity unit that you don't want him as a visit.

A few days after giving birth tell him you have by text. Make sure you have someone with you and don't let him in to visit until you are ready if at all.

You are basically a single parent so don't give the child just his last name when registering the birth.

If he does go to Court for contact and to be put on the birth certificate the Court won't be interested in giving him solo contact over night until after the child is one. Before then it will be little and often e.g. 30 to 45 minutes with you present at first.

Weaponise the child early. classy

Quitelikeit · 01/07/2023 09:32

Sadly you need to accept this is what happens when you have a child outwith a relationship

Your child will have half siblings and be doing and seeing things beyond your control

You are in control now but once she is born you won’t be if you allow contact

And unless you are going to be spiteful about it then there’s no reason why this child shouldn’t see their father

Surely you realised she’d have a step mother in the future?

electriclight · 01/07/2023 09:25

After one unwanted pregnancy and a termination, I'm surprised there was a second unwanted pregnancy. He's an idiot for not using a condom.

What is he currently saying about his level of involvement, assuming he accepts the baby is his? If you are discussing his gf meeting the baby I assume he expects some level of contact?

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 01/07/2023 08:34

Look, you chose to continue your pregnancy with this man. This is how it is. The sooner you accept he doesn't care for you or the baby the easier all of this will become. Dont beg him for scraps, especially if he is with someone else. Raise your head high and crack on. Let him know when baby is born and get a claim in via CMS.
In answer to your question, once/if paternity is established and he has contact, he can introduce the baby to whoever he wants. You cannot demand to meet her first, she owes you nothing. She just needs to be kind to your child. That is all.

ladykale · 01/07/2023 08:26

Reugny · 01/07/2023 06:31

Stop contact with him now and inform your midwife that you are no longer with the father.

Sort out another person to be your birthing partner

Tell the hospital/maternity unit that you don't want him as a visit.

A few days after giving birth tell him you have by text. Make sure you have someone with you and don't let him in to visit until you are ready if at all.

You are basically a single parent so don't give the child just his last name when registering the birth.

If he does go to Court for contact and to be put on the birth certificate the Court won't be interested in giving him solo contact over night until after the child is one. Before then it will be little and often e.g. 30 to 45 minutes with you present at first.

He isn't abusive though, what right does she have to deprive her child of their father?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread