Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband lacks empathy for toddler

57 replies

DassDio · 01/07/2023 01:56

Recently our DS has had the dreaded chicken pox. He’s only 18 months old and has been managing pretty well during the day with it, but it’s really shaken his night routine. He has never been the best sleeper, only going through the night from around 15 months, but this has seen 1-2 hour stints of crying out/wanting cuddles/etc. and a number of settles beforehand. My husband and I both work full time and are lucky enough to be able to work remotely, but it’s been pretty exhausting.

My husband has never been pleasant on limited sleep so I have always defaulted to handling the bulk of night time duties since DS was born. He helps out, but he’s often grumpy about it and it definitely affects him more than me. I think I’ve been trained to have limited sleep these days.

Anyway, since the chickenpox started (7 days ago) it’s felt like he lacks any empathy for our toddler. He seems to think our 18 month old is trying to manipulate us to get what he wants all the time. I’ve tried to explain that they don’t have the brain development to consciously try to manipulate so young, but he won’t hear it. At night, when DS is upset and hard to console, my husband will say “No!” In his face and “Back to sleep. now!” Which probably doesn’t sound that bad on paper but it comes across quite aggressive in person. This never has the results he’s hoping for and often just escalates the crying. Husband will often storm out of the room and declare “leave him to cry”. If I try to go in to calm DS down, husband gets very annoyed at me and it will lead to an argument. DS doesn’t always go back to sleep for me quickly, but he doesn’t scream and cry. He typically asks for cuddles, water, or a bum change. In truth I get the feeling he’s uncomfortable from the chickenpox and he just wants reassurance that we’re there.

I think our parenting styles are ultimately very different, he’s a bit old fashioned and strict, I’m more emotionally driven, which means clashes are guaranteed. But am I being unreasonable to think that husband is lacking in empathy here? Any ideas on how to help him look at the situation differently? I feel like I’ve done all the research into baby development and modern parenting recommendations, but husband still thinks he knows better. Is that me being arrogant or him being dismissive?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MissMarplesGoddaughter · 01/07/2023 18:14

Your poor little boy having a foul, abusive father shouting at him......

Please don't leave him alone with your son, don't have any more children with him and think seriously about your future with this man.

Ollifer · 01/07/2023 18:11

h3ll0o · 01/07/2023 18:05

We’re in this situation at the minute apart from we’re day 2 and our LO is three. I struggle with lack of sleep, get stuck on telling my LO to simply go back to sleep as I’m exhausted (often in a grumpy tone) and then are mega stressy in the day.

My little one learnt early on that I’m not at my best when I’m lacking sleep so she shouts for her dad in the night and I focus on days. She came down to be with me this morning and we both left dad to lie in as long as is needed. We had lots of screaming before bed as the itching wouldn’t go away and a late night.

As long as you all have empathy and respect for each other things will work out. I do get a bit aggressive when overwhelmed (I was raised in a house with domestic abuse) but it isn’t often and my daughter accepts and understands I feel dreadful and am trying my best.

How does your husband react after he has been aggressive and things calm down?

Your daughter accepts and understands your aggression? She's three...I doubt she does.

h3ll0o · 01/07/2023 18:05

We’re in this situation at the minute apart from we’re day 2 and our LO is three. I struggle with lack of sleep, get stuck on telling my LO to simply go back to sleep as I’m exhausted (often in a grumpy tone) and then are mega stressy in the day.

My little one learnt early on that I’m not at my best when I’m lacking sleep so she shouts for her dad in the night and I focus on days. She came down to be with me this morning and we both left dad to lie in as long as is needed. We had lots of screaming before bed as the itching wouldn’t go away and a late night.

As long as you all have empathy and respect for each other things will work out. I do get a bit aggressive when overwhelmed (I was raised in a house with domestic abuse) but it isn’t often and my daughter accepts and understands I feel dreadful and am trying my best.

How does your husband react after he has been aggressive and things calm down?

5128gap · 01/07/2023 18:01

I'm in my 50s so I'm probably likely to be 'traditional' but the thought of shouting in the face of an uncomfortable baby who wants reassurance horrifies me. When they're unwell and upset the natural reaction is to want to make that better, however 'strict' you are. His behaviour is not the sign of a traditional parent. It's the sign of a hard, cruel and uncaring one.

Mojoj · 01/07/2023 17:59

Yet another man who "doesn't function well with little sleep". Wee diddums. I know it doesn't help but I am sick to the back teeth of hearing yet another woman complaining about her useless lump of a husband who basically can't be bothered actually parenting and who would rather shout in the face of an ill baby. Wtf?

mathanxiety · 01/07/2023 17:52

how does it affect him for you to comfort your baby, if he doesn’t have to get up?!

Indeed.

The accusation that an 18 month old is being manipulative shows resentment of the attention you are giving your sick baby.

In his mind he deserves all of your attention - he sees himself in competition with the baby for your attention, and if one is 'winning' the other must be 'losing'. The accusation is designed to stick a wedge between you and your child. That's narcissistic jealousy rearing its head (and the complete lack of self awareness that often goes with narcissism).

I'd be interested to learn how you found out that your H doesn't do very well on broken or lost sleep.

samqueens · 01/07/2023 17:46

OP - I read your update and certainly hope this is something that can be solved with a parenting class (or a book - there are a million out there).

But just in case this is the tip of the iceberg I really strongly suggest you read the Lundy Bancroft book Why Does He Do That? (you can download on kindle app, read discreetly, and just to arm yourself with a red flag radar for future).

The fact that you aren’t sure if you’re being unreasonable is a bit of a concern - as most PP’s have said, you are clearly not being U.

Being a parent with a job and a life means that sleep deprivation is par for the course. If your H can’t handle it, but also won’t cede to you doing nights while he does days with good humour, then that’s not a good sign - how does it affect him for you to comfort your baby, if he doesn’t have to get up?! He should be glad one of you can do it and give you some extra rest the day after to balance things out.

Toddlers also have a lot of big / contradictory feelings. Is he going to send your child the message that essentially it’s not ok to have feelings? That’s not very healthy…

Obviously it is great if the book doesn’t reasonate with you (either now or in future), and even better if your H is willing to meet you half way, do some reading himself and modify his behaviour in the best interests of your child and your marriage. But sometimes that’s not what happens, and a lot of things can go undetected when your together but don’t have children - and babies can also trigger changes in partner behaviour.

Forewarned is forearmed, so I hope you are able to read that book. And I hope your H bucks his ideas up as his lack of empathy is indeed rather worrying… (and no, you are not crazy to think so)

avocadotofu · 01/07/2023 17:44

He sounds awful quite frankly. What he says sounds awful on paper TBH. He doesn't sound like he understands child development AT ALL. Your poor little one. Have you had a chance to sit down and talk about your approach to things? If he's not up for adapting/being evidence based then I can't see a way forward for you.

Nowthenhere · 01/07/2023 17:37

"You need to sleep somewhere else until our child is well. You're making their safe haven very stressful and unnecessarily so. If he gets tonsillitis or a sore throat from screaming for support I will expect you to arrange GP and explain the circumstances."

"You expect me to ignore a person who has only just come into this world, who only knows us to support their needs during the night. What if I ignored you when you were frightened, upset or in pain? Fortunately you're able to get in a car and pick up the meds you need to make yourself well and understand that the illnesses aren't for ever. Your child however, is not that far developed"

Alternatively just open the door, throw an outfit of his out and ask him to vacate the home. Lock doors and enjoy your child, he sounds kind and loving and nothing like the broken that is your husband.

ItsNotWhatItsNot · 01/07/2023 17:33

‘When you find yourself contemplating calling in a professional to explain civil, grown-up behaviour and empathy toward a small, vulnerable being, his own flesh and blood, to a man, you are fighting a losing battle.’

This. The barest of minimum decent father would be desperately educating himself on child development, parenting, how to develop empathy since he has none. Your update does not help, he still sounds appalling.

Chocolateship · 01/07/2023 17:23

Your child will get more annoying to be honest, when they're 3 or so and they understand things more and purposefully push boundaries (which is a usual part of development) you really need to know how to control and deal with frustration without taking it out on the child. He needs to prioritise sorting this.

mathanxiety · 01/07/2023 17:20

My DH is not a cruel or angry man - I think he needs to check his own emotions when dealing with our DS at night for sure, but I can say with 100% certainty that he’s not abusive.

You know the phrase "In vino veritas"?

Well, there is an analogy.

It involves the instinctive response by a parent to babies and small children at 2am. That's when you see the real person.

AtrociousCircumstance · 01/07/2023 17:15

Horrible man.

What a nasty prick. Your poor kid.

Your child will need your kindness and compassion very deeply as he navigates childhood with a ‘father’ like that. Stay true to your positive instincts about parenting OP.

10HailMarys · 01/07/2023 17:09

Cockortwowhisperer · 01/07/2023 06:15

I think your husband should probably be allowed to parent his kid how he wants, and you the same. it’s ok to have different styles of parenting, you just need to respect each other and support each other.
Friends of mine just leave their kid to cry all the time. They tell me it works but needs a bit of getting used to.

It’s Ok to have different styles of parenting. It’s not OK to be aggressive towards an 18-month old toddler who is barely more than a baby and is also ill with chicken pox. This isn’t an older child having a tantrum. It’s a baby who is itchy and unwell and is waking up feeling miserable. Nobody should ‘respect and support’ a parent who thinks an 18-month-old baby is being deliberately manipulative and shouts in their face.

Avondale89 · 01/07/2023 17:09

Were you definitely “peeved” at 2am, or were you acting on instinct this behaviour was fucking unacceptable? Your OP mentioned him being aggressive. I wonder if in the cold light of day you’ve shrugged it off and minimised it as a way to cope. It’s easily done.

Ultimately I hope he sees the error of his ways and is able to have empathy for his child. I actually don’t believe this has anything to do with parenting styles. He just doesn’t have any empathy for his ill baby. I’m surprised some people on here seem to be brushing it off. I’m sure if a woman posted on here that she had just been aggressive to her toddler crying with chicken pox it wouldn’t be seen as a parenting “style”.

mathanxiety · 01/07/2023 16:59

And @DassDio just to clarify - tone of voice is one thing to you and quite another to the 18 month old who needs comfort.

But it is the accusation he is leveling at the child - the baby - of manipulation that is the chilling part of all of this.

You are dealing with a narcissist.

mathanxiety · 01/07/2023 16:57

I’m hoping that having a professional explain that ‘toddlers cant regulate emotions and meltdowns aren’t them being naughty or manipulative’ might make him listen and understand.

I agree with every word @Suprima posted on this.

OP, your child will be potty training in the next year or so. How is your H going to behave when things don't go his way?

Your child is also going to get fond of the word No. How will your H react when he starts using it?

When you find yourself contemplating calling in a professional to explain civil, grown-up behaviour and empathy toward a small, vulnerable being, his own flesh and blood, to a man, you are fighting a losing battle.

Goldbar · 01/07/2023 10:56

I would tell him that having a child means you need to meet their needs first and your own needs and wants come second. He needs to grow up and deal with this.

Suprima · 01/07/2023 10:26

DassDio · 01/07/2023 08:44

Hi All - thank you for taking time to post and comment. I just want to elaborate a little as I realise I wrote this post whilst peeved at 2am and I think it’s probably misled some of you a little.
My husband doesn’t shout at our DS - he says “No!” In a firm voice but doesn’t shout. His behaviour is more frustrated and less aggressive. This behaviour only comes on when DS is up in the night - during the day my DH is far more patient. We’ve been together for over a decade and he has always been one to struggle with limited sleep.
There have been a couple of suggestions around parenting classes and finding a way to make our parenting styles more consistent - I think these are probably my best options and I’m really grateful for the idea. I’m hoping that having a professional explain that ‘toddlers cant regulate emotions and meltdowns aren’t them being naughty or manipulative’ might make him listen and understand.
My DH is not a cruel or angry man - I think he needs to check his own emotions when dealing with our DS at night for sure, but I can say with 100% certainty that he’s not abusive.

Thanks again :)

Just because you say he doesn’t shout and you don’t think he’s abusive does not vindicate him. The fact that you need to get a bloody professional in to explain to him that his child is not manipulative is horrific.

Even saying firmly ‘no. Go to bed’ even without shouting when you have a sick baby who needs comfort from their caregivers is incredibly cruel. Not understanding or providing the physical assurance they need is spiteful. This isn’t a clash of parenting styles- it’s a complete lack of empathy (your words….) for a tiny, helpless thing.

I can’t imagine him doing such a thing but if my husband even attempted to be ‘old school’ with our sick baby who needed their parents- I would be hitting the roof.

I hope you take this all a bit more seriously with the next thing that makes you twitch rather than channeling your energy into protesting how he isn’t actually abusive. Because based on what you’ve written, even taking out the shouting- he is cruel. Doesn’t matter how patient is apparently is in the day. Broken sleep gives no one a free pass to be a callous prick.

stephaniezanoni · 01/07/2023 09:13

Sounds awful on paper. I'd be done if anyone had spoke to my baby like that. Easier to say than do I know but Jesus your husband sounds like a horrible bully.

DassDio · 01/07/2023 08:44

DassDio · 01/07/2023 01:56

Recently our DS has had the dreaded chicken pox. He’s only 18 months old and has been managing pretty well during the day with it, but it’s really shaken his night routine. He has never been the best sleeper, only going through the night from around 15 months, but this has seen 1-2 hour stints of crying out/wanting cuddles/etc. and a number of settles beforehand. My husband and I both work full time and are lucky enough to be able to work remotely, but it’s been pretty exhausting.

My husband has never been pleasant on limited sleep so I have always defaulted to handling the bulk of night time duties since DS was born. He helps out, but he’s often grumpy about it and it definitely affects him more than me. I think I’ve been trained to have limited sleep these days.

Anyway, since the chickenpox started (7 days ago) it’s felt like he lacks any empathy for our toddler. He seems to think our 18 month old is trying to manipulate us to get what he wants all the time. I’ve tried to explain that they don’t have the brain development to consciously try to manipulate so young, but he won’t hear it. At night, when DS is upset and hard to console, my husband will say “No!” In his face and “Back to sleep. now!” Which probably doesn’t sound that bad on paper but it comes across quite aggressive in person. This never has the results he’s hoping for and often just escalates the crying. Husband will often storm out of the room and declare “leave him to cry”. If I try to go in to calm DS down, husband gets very annoyed at me and it will lead to an argument. DS doesn’t always go back to sleep for me quickly, but he doesn’t scream and cry. He typically asks for cuddles, water, or a bum change. In truth I get the feeling he’s uncomfortable from the chickenpox and he just wants reassurance that we’re there.

I think our parenting styles are ultimately very different, he’s a bit old fashioned and strict, I’m more emotionally driven, which means clashes are guaranteed. But am I being unreasonable to think that husband is lacking in empathy here? Any ideas on how to help him look at the situation differently? I feel like I’ve done all the research into baby development and modern parenting recommendations, but husband still thinks he knows better. Is that me being arrogant or him being dismissive?!

Hi All - thank you for taking time to post and comment. I just want to elaborate a little as I realise I wrote this post whilst peeved at 2am and I think it’s probably misled some of you a little.
My husband doesn’t shout at our DS - he says “No!” In a firm voice but doesn’t shout. His behaviour is more frustrated and less aggressive. This behaviour only comes on when DS is up in the night - during the day my DH is far more patient. We’ve been together for over a decade and he has always been one to struggle with limited sleep.
There have been a couple of suggestions around parenting classes and finding a way to make our parenting styles more consistent - I think these are probably my best options and I’m really grateful for the idea. I’m hoping that having a professional explain that ‘toddlers cant regulate emotions and meltdowns aren’t them being naughty or manipulative’ might make him listen and understand.
My DH is not a cruel or angry man - I think he needs to check his own emotions when dealing with our DS at night for sure, but I can say with 100% certainty that he’s not abusive.

Thanks again :)

OP posts:
Someboysaretryintoohard · 01/07/2023 08:07

It boils down to selfishness. He wants his needs met in terms of sleep ahead of meeting your poorly ds's needs for comfort.

My dh has done similar. I just handle everything where I can. My worst fear would be 50:50 where I can't watch over them with him. You have my empathy op.

Ollifer · 01/07/2023 07:54

RedHelenB · 01/07/2023 07:37

It really isn't. Social Services wouldn't do anything, different parenting styles are allowed.

Yep I can agree with this. My ex acted quite like the ops husband and in the family courts eyes it's just different parenting styles and he got 50/50.

AthenaPopodopolous · 01/07/2023 07:51

He is right to a certain extent. When a toddler tries your patience and he’s so tired and getting angry, the best thing to do is leave the child safe in the cot and leave. If you mollycoddle him too much he will just refuse to sleep.
I bet he has the idea of manipulation from his parents, that generation had a stricter parenting style which quite often worked. The reason being larger families meant you didn’t have the time to pander to a crying child who doesn’t like to be left. At 18 months you do need to assert yourself and enforce a sleep routine though, for your own sanity and your husbands. The extra sleep will help everyone’s mood.

LT2 · 01/07/2023 07:45

YANBU

I have a 17 month old. I gave always done all of the wake ups too. For different reasons though - breastfed, still fed to sleep. He's always slept so much better with me that I decided to co-sleep. DH in our room, me in DS's room.
I remember being told off at night like that (albeit I must have been older to remember, guessing around 3) so I think it has made me find me be the opposite with my DS.
The way your husband is handling won't work!

Swipe left for the next trending thread