Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want the UK to provide health plans like pet plans

57 replies

2018mumof2 · 30/06/2023 22:44

Hi I probably sound completely crackers however I have been thinking more and more since my partner got a job which includes private health care that doesn’t necessarily help with people’s health and that there must be better services to keep people’s health in check.. even if we have to pay for it.

I cannot speak for everyone as obviously every person has their own circumstances but me for instance I pay £20 per dog for a health plan which includes a 6 month review and a 12 month review, annual vaccinations etc.

I left the vets thinking today if properly managed and with the right pricing behind it why can’t there be a service like that for people? Why does it need to be something is wrong before we go to a GP, why can’t we just have a MOT type health check where your health is checked, it might warn people who fall unknowingly into obesity etc.

I would happily pay more than £20 for that kind of service for me and my family if it was available.. what do people think? I know it sound strange being compared to pets but AIBU or not?

OP posts:
Chocolateship · 01/07/2023 06:48

gamerchick · 01/07/2023 06:02

Couldn't give any fucks about anything you've just said. Not even one.

Ironically that's the same amount of fucks they'll give about your list!

It's really not a choice of NHS or US system. Most of Europe do this, and yes, we get regular checkups, no crazy bills and coverage for preexisting conditions. The NHS is just a bit shit.

Yep, plenty of models around the world between the UK and the US that work very well.

Chocolateship · 01/07/2023 06:45

Most private providers offer this and you just pay the balance monthly as a 0% APR agreement. I worked briefly for a provider who provided companies with annual health check ups for all of their staff. There are definitely benefits when you reach a certain age or if you have certain risk factors, but generally I'd save your pennies for if you have concerns and need an app.

StamppotAndGravy · 01/07/2023 06:44

It's really not a choice of NHS or US system. Most of Europe do this, and yes, we get regular checkups, no crazy bills and coverage for preexisting conditions. The NHS is just a bit shit.

Grahambella · 01/07/2023 06:31

Sorry it was change for life!

Grahambella · 01/07/2023 06:29

Other countries do do this, I have Polish friends who go Back home for health checks.

Someone said private medical doesn’t cover previous conditions, that is incorrect. Monitorium cover does cover previous conditions once you have been free of symptoms/medicine/treatment for a period of time. For example you have a breast lump checked/biopsy in 2022, (within the last 5 years), no follow up needed. Take out PMI feb 2023 your lump issue is not covered until Feb 2025 (assuming no further issue until then). So you are better off taking cover as soon as possible. I understand people will have exclusions however it’s not as bad as people often think.

Certain life and income protection policies include annual blood tests, private gp services, second opinions, encourage fitness tracking plus treatment abroad for illness like cancer. Plus they pay out if you are sick.

I agree with a previous poster that the food we consume in the UK (upf) needs to change. But too much profit abd no doubt too many politicians with their fingers in the coffers of large ‘food’ (more like non food) manufacturers. But while the NHS are harping on about diet drinks and low fat products it’s not going to improve.

Does anyone remember the healthy start (I think that was the name) campaign? Yellow background with colourful people. It was for parents if young children in the early 2000’s. They would send you vouchers for money off Diet Pepsi/coke etc. I thought at the time it was odd that a health service was supporting giving your children crap food. I am guessing it was heavily funded by a few manufacturers.

gamerchick · 01/07/2023 06:02

HaveITheRightToHoldYouYouKnowIveAlwaysToldYou · 30/06/2023 22:51

Since I can't get a GP appointment, I'm going in with a list.

totally inappropriate @gamerchick as they are done usually by health care assistants or GP assistants who likely won’t be able to help with your list or, if you insist on chatting through your list, won’t have time for your health check.

Couldn't give any fucks about anything you've just said. Not even one.

DarkForces · 30/06/2023 23:34

smilesup · 30/06/2023 23:22

I think with things like obesity surely that should be down to personal responsibility. Of course the food industry needs a massive overall (not just replacing sugar with carceogenic shite). But at the end of the day it's quite easy to know if you are overweight. More promotion of a healthy lifestyle, cheaper access to sports and quality healthy food, more education on spotting the signs of ill health all important but nothing is more important than looking after one's own body.

In that case any accident that could have been avoided should be self funded too. Why should I pay for people who choose to take more risks than me?

XenoBitch · 30/06/2023 23:33

TrifleForBreakfast · 30/06/2023 23:31

My dog is now 10 years old and I pay nearly £100 each month for his pet plan cover. That only covers him for £7000 of veterinary treatment a year. An op to remove a benign lump from his toe recently cost more than £1200.

£7000 is not going to cover much human medical care, especially if you end up with a serious ongoing illness. Just the migraine tablets I need would cost £20 a month. Goodness knows what the premiums would need to be to make it workable.

Exactly.

My mum is on tablets for Hep C. Cost for 12 weeks of the medication is over £36k.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 30/06/2023 23:33

Nobody will like this answer but this is something that is done and encouraged by private health insurance. I’m in the US.

‘Well Visits’ are a thing and encouraged as well as regular screenings at age appropriate intervals. So annual* gynecologist visits are covered, check ups with GPs (PCPs) and specific screenings (mammogram, colonoscopy, etc) are covered with a small copayment in some situations.

*Annual was what I was used to I think it’s been updated to 2-3 years with no issues but could be every 6 months if something is detected and being watched.

TrifleForBreakfast · 30/06/2023 23:31

My dog is now 10 years old and I pay nearly £100 each month for his pet plan cover. That only covers him for £7000 of veterinary treatment a year. An op to remove a benign lump from his toe recently cost more than £1200.

£7000 is not going to cover much human medical care, especially if you end up with a serious ongoing illness. Just the migraine tablets I need would cost £20 a month. Goodness knows what the premiums would need to be to make it workable.

Nat6999 · 30/06/2023 23:31

I've joined Benenden, purely for the fact it covers things like needing a scan, Xray, or to see a consultant & in case I need a routine operation. It covers most common surgeries other than heart surgery & joint replacements. If you can't get an NHS appointment within 3 weeks or surgery within 5 weeks you can choose to go private.

2018mumof2 · 30/06/2023 23:25

@ItsReallyOnlyMe Yes! That would be the type of thing I’m talking about and it doesn’t appear to have an age limit which sound good.

I don’t know if it is becoming a mum in the last few years and seeing my health change and now paying for my dogs to be insured, have health checks where I book in annual vaccinations and in the health reviews I am told your dog is on this scale (3-5 which is good) and we don’t want him to go higher that I just think why can’t we have something like this.

OP posts:
brunettemic · 30/06/2023 23:23

Your pet plan is private healthcare for your pet so just pay for private healthcare if you want the same…

smilesup · 30/06/2023 23:22

I think with things like obesity surely that should be down to personal responsibility. Of course the food industry needs a massive overall (not just replacing sugar with carceogenic shite). But at the end of the day it's quite easy to know if you are overweight. More promotion of a healthy lifestyle, cheaper access to sports and quality healthy food, more education on spotting the signs of ill health all important but nothing is more important than looking after one's own body.

ItsReallyOnlyMe · 30/06/2023 23:15

I get health checks done with these people. Is this the sort of thing you're looking for ?

https://www.bluecrestwellness.com

FloorWipes · 30/06/2023 23:12

Though it seems counterintuitive, screening for issues and treating them doesn't always improve health outcomes. Sometimes it can be completely the opposite. There are many many varied examples of this in healthcare, from maternity care to cancer. That's why we tend to focus screening on issues and populations where the benefits are shown to outweigh the costs.

Throwncrumbs · 30/06/2023 23:10

Good luck with that, the older your dog gets the premiums go up, and then lots of things are not covered. A bit like private healthcare!

XenoBitch · 30/06/2023 23:08

And if you can't pay for it?

tourdefrance · 30/06/2023 23:07

But £100 / month is still over £1,000 / year.

A lot of cancers are linked to lifestyle so if you are following the advice - bmi under 25 (can check online), less than 14 units alcohol / week, 150 mins exercise/ week, 5 fruit and veg portions / day you are probably still healthier than the majority of people in the UK.

If you're not, then will a blood test make you change?

2018mumof2 · 30/06/2023 23:07

I know it is a slippery slope but it is the term targeted way by the NHS that bothers me, health is not a general thing and it is not one size fits all.. why should there be obesity treatments etc. being paid for on the NHS but no regular two a year health checks which keep you in touch with those things.

Move away from my pet example for a moment then and focus on dentists they were once NHS primarily but patients still got 3-4 appointments a year depending on how often you were seen, just general check ups and anything further would be advised off.

why has nothing been arranged for general health like that? Posters say MOT’s are available over a certain age but why are they not enrolled out for younger to pay for it they wish? I’d happily pay for a health plan if I knew that is what it was rather than “insurance”

OP posts:
vipersnest1 · 30/06/2023 23:05

Most health insurance plans exclude previous conditions, so for me that would be:
Tinnitus (so no hearing aid help), a bone spur on my spine in my neck which is causing abnormal sensations, palpitations (probably benign), a mass in my breast which is under investigation, lower back pain due to bone marrow oedema (waiting for pain-killing injections), a rectocele and abnormal sensations in my legs and feet which have been put down to fibromyalgia.
I would probably have to pay a huge premium and would still not be eligible for the conditions I have.
I wouldn't pay, because it wouldn't be worth it.
I am due to inherit some money soon, however, and am considering spending some of it on the things that are bothering me the most - that's excluding the breast mass because I'm expecting (and hoping) that this will be dealt with quickly. All of the others are things that I'm going to be waiting months for, and some of them I've already been waiting over a year....

Effingmagicfairy · 30/06/2023 23:05

Simply health is a cash back plan, I have a yearly health check on mine, have bloods done, cholesterol checked, heart check etc. it also pays out for consultations, , chiro, Osteo, teeth, dental, eyes,

AwkwardPaws27 · 30/06/2023 23:04

I have researched full cancer checks etc. but they are over £1000 a time for a full one to be done

The pet health checks are just a consultation - they'll visually inspect their eyes, ears, coat etc, listen to their chest, palpate for obvious masses, but they aren't running full bloods or doing an MRI scan.
It's on par with a GP appointment, not a full body cancer scan.

Have a look into the pros and cons of public health screening programmes - those sorts of tests have a false positive rate which can result in unnecessary procedures for healthy people.

2018mumof2 · 30/06/2023 23:00

Yeah you can pay for things if you pay privately but they only seem to be health insurance and once you are diagnosed you get money back on treatment.

I’m taking about health payment plans such as £100 a month and you get cancer checks, blood tests, 6 and 12 month health checks

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread