Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Why are some Mumsnetters so bloody horrible!!!

111 replies

ihavechangedmyusernam · 30/06/2023 20:59

Exactly that.

I'm sure 80% of these people wouldn't dare say half the things they post to someone's face. So why online?

I don't mean the brutal honesty; I mean the unnecessary nastiness.

A few of the old-timers have said this has only become a proper issue in recent years on MN. Interesting...

OP posts:
Lacucuracha · 01/07/2023 07:14

A few of the old-timers have said this has only become a proper issue in recent years on MN. Interesting...

Not that interesting, given MNers have been saying this since 2009 😂

georgarina · 01/07/2023 07:12

It is really nasty and unpleasant tbh. I've seen people appeal to feminism and not forcing women to 'be kind' (not sure how kicking other women when they're down fits into that). There's also a kind of superiority in dispensing with manners because OP is just SO stupid and hopeless (even if in bits over DV or something equally serious) that she deserves it.

I only post threads on a different, more supportive forum because I don't want the bitchy unnecessary replies.

Unsure33 · 01/07/2023 06:55

CallieQ · 30/06/2023 22:45

Have you heard anything about the vile trolling that happens on twitter and the rest of the internet? MN is a teddy bears picnic compared to that

I agree , but at least on Twitter you can block and mute if you want to .

Unsure33 · 01/07/2023 06:52

I agree OP , I even found myself saying that twitter is less hassle than mumsnet the other day and that’s saying something . It’s like some posters think every subject is black and white and it’s their way or no way . A lot of virtue signalling to feel good about themselves . I really thought that mumsnet would be about mums joining together and suggesting change and practical solutions to problems , political change etc.

I understand that if you ask for opinions then you will have to understand that there will be varying answers , that’s life . But there is no need to be so rude and obnoxious . What does that do to help? nothing .

There is a difference between giving your opinion to try and help and just wading in and criticising just for the sake of making yourself sound better .

PuddlesPityParty · 01/07/2023 06:36

Tbh I’ve written thing on here I 100% would say IRL, as I can be a bit direct and will call people out if I need to, but been told I wouldn’t 😵‍💫 sorry but you don’t know me and just because some people would be too timid to say something doesn’t mean I am! I would note though I’m never trying to be horrible I’m just putting my POV across.

Kidsandcat · 01/07/2023 06:32

Yes, the proportion of out and out nasty posts is really high. Very sad if this is a true representation of what people really think.

Riapia · 01/07/2023 06:20

You should try to understand that any views expressed on AIBU are not necessarily those of the person posting them.
Treat everything you read with a healthy dose of scepticism.

baggiesmalls · 01/07/2023 03:55

I name change a lot now - someone actually stalked me as I'd joined the mn fb group - I was in a pretty abusive relationship and someone from that group actually went to the trouble of tracking down my then partner's ex and emailing them .

They put me in danger doing that . I was on a cruise with him when he found out what I'd said about him being abusive. I was trapped .

Who in their right mind does that ?

That was in 2018 . That's when I realised this wasn't just words on a screen - I've had months and months of not posting. And now I darent - my thread I got jumped on when I least needed it . I wouldn't post anything but the mundane now .

Cornchip · 01/07/2023 02:13

Honestly? I think you’re partially right.

I do believe there are a proportion of users on Mumsnet who are deeply unhappy in their own lives and take some sort of relief when they can exert those emotions out on someone online.

However I also think folk are more sensitive to criticism nowadays as well. It’s quite clear when you see a thread started by someone who hasn’t been told “no, you’re wrong” in a long time.

People are generally not as happy nowadays. Social media has a lot to answer for but so does the COL crisis and other factors. Which will ultimately affect how people treat others.

It also means that posters don’t tend to beat around the bush like we perhaps did in the past. Before I believe posters were less to the point as to not be rude, but now so many topics are posted which are so similar to other posts, users seem to have lost patience on these threads and skip the niceties and just get to the point, which certainly does come across as “rude”.

It’s the way of the internet and it will only get worse as time goes on.

DixonD · 01/07/2023 01:22

Mylifeislikeaboatrace · 30/06/2023 21:17

Stay how is that remotely funny?🤔

I thought it was funny too. I assume it was in jest. Or maybe I just have a weird sense of humour (not ashamed).

BonnieBobbin · 01/07/2023 01:19

The MRAs have been joined by TRAs and Tattle recruiters. They always tried to infiltrate but tbh the moderation was better. Tattle threads were deleted in a matter of posts now they can run active recruiting threads for days and MN lets them stand. So there's those type of misognists who think any woman earning an income or in the public eye should be criticised about absolutely everything. Then there's the MRA/TRA/incel crew who really, really hate that MN has a reputation of knowing what a woman is and helping women in abusive relationships.

2ManyPjs · 01/07/2023 01:17

SunsetsInVenice · 30/06/2023 22:37

Agreed. On most threads there is a sarcastic or rude response, even on the most innocent of topics. A lot of unhappy and bitter people out there I guess.

A lot of unhappy and bitter people out there I guess.

Yes I think this it, there's a lot of projection and it's become an outlet for a lot of people to unleash and direct their anger which they don't seem to be able to do IRL. I've been on and off MN for over 15 years and there's always been rude twats but it was never as hostile and aggressive as it is now. It's not just outright aggression though, there's a lot more passive aggression than there used to be, e.g. PP upthread demanding examples, when she has no interest whatsoever in seeing an examples, just being contrary for the sake of it. Unfortunately a lot of the more passive aggressive posters are the 1st and 2nd reply guys in a thread now, so it sets the tone for the rest of the thread.

Having said that, there are many lovely, funny, clever and supportive women on MN. On balance, I think MN is a force for good.

Womensrightsaretheanswer · 01/07/2023 01:09

Spidery back in the day someone would have said something hilarious and you would have been supported. Mumsnet has changed. People come on looking for a fight and have no common sense.

UniversalAunt · 01/07/2023 00:59

@MossCow Mouldies?

Spidey66 · 01/07/2023 00:49

Just to clarify I was on the bus a few days after the cast came off, about 10 days after the accident. I was still in a sling (still am now!)

CarolinaInTheMorning · 01/07/2023 00:47

I agree that it is much less hospitable than when I first joined more than a decade ago. And much less witty. I've already deregistered once and then came back. I think that as the site has grown, there are just more downright nasty people on it. And it is definitely not as entertaining as used to be.

Spidey66 · 01/07/2023 00:44

This comes up regularly.

I wouldn't say it was "most" but a sizable amount. I think the first few responses set the scene. If the first few are cruel, many of the following responses will be cruel.

I was on the end of this recently. I broke my arm about a month back. It was in a cast for a week. A few days later, I went to the High rd to use the ATM. I caught a bus back, and as a) I was in pain and b) i was struggling to negotiate moving around a moving bus with one arm while trying simultaneously to support my bad arm from being bashed I sat in a priority seat. I initially wrongly described it as a disabled seat. A slightly older lady was sitting next to me, then a much older lady got on. I felt bad about sitting in the priority seat but the other lady offered her the seat.

While I got a fair amount of support, the amount of nasty, horrible posts was awful. I got slated for describing my injury as a temporary disability, as disability can only be permanent or not at all and I had insulted all those with a permanent disability. The older lady could have fallen over and broken her hip , which would have been far more serious than me falling and that falling on a recently broken arm would not hurt at all. In fact a broken arm was just an "ouchie" and shouldn't stop doing anything. I shouldn't have been on the bus in the first place apparently and should have walked home as I mentioned it was a short journey (it was about 1.5 miles.) I was personally preventing MNers with a serious disability accessing the seat (even though I doubt they were on the exact same bus at the same time. It was relentless.

Meanwhile, back in the real world, I have found that once it is obvious you have an injury and are suffering/in pain, the vast majority of people are more than happy to help. Like today for instance. Although it was 4 weeks ago, I was in severe pain and was unable to do things with my arm I could do yesterday.. I was getting severe cramp like pain in my broken arm and couldn't lift anything at all with my left arm as a result of the pain. I had a fracture clinic appointment this am. The doctor said the arm was healing well and the pain was due to me using my muscles which have been inactive for the past month. On my way home from the hospital I stopped off at Pret for lunch. Seeing me struggle to get my purchases on the counter, and the debit card from my purse, and the assistant said she bring it to my table. I had one of their lovely popcorn bars but the pain in my arm meant I couldn't open it, so I asked the lady sitting next to me if she could help, again no problem. I bet those kicking me when I was done are not so horrible irl. At least I hope not, and that if someone with their arm in a sling asked them to open something I bet they would, because irl most people are kind. But put them behind a keyboard and they're totally different.

OneMoreCookieMonster · 01/07/2023 00:34

Can't remember when I joined probably 10ish years at least. Before I had kids and when you could come on as guest without registering. I was recommended to come on here because of how bitchy and entertaining the threads were. So, I don't think much has changed. I think ppl in general are easier to offend these days and there's so many topics that need to be tiptoed around now compared to the good ole days when one could say pretty much anything. Or you could be sarcastic, show humour without being called an --- ist of some kind, reported and moderated (perfect example in that deleted post) even in some cases banned.

GarlicGrace · 01/07/2023 00:30

Amortentia · 30/06/2023 22:42

I’ve been around for a very, very long time, I think there’s been a change. In the early days threads could be very lighthearted, supportive or razor sharp witty and intelligent. When I think of some of the posts that made it to classics back in the day I don’t think I would see posts like that now.

But, times have changed, how we articulate opinions is so different now. I am conscious my own post can be blunt. But, as a dyslexia with rubbish social skills making a coherent post gets in the way of expressing myself in a similar way I would do face to face.

However, and I might get flamed for this but, I think there has been quite a change recently. I think the attention to mumsnet is because it’s viewed as too terfy, I think it’s attracted some right weird people with malevolent intent. There have been too many weird posts, and some deliberately being nasty. Mumsnet has always attracted trolls, but they used to be hilarious and very clever. Good times.

This! Except I'm not dyslexic.

I am, however, a mean old hag with no friends in real life, nothing to do but have arguments on the internet, and am resentfully convinced that Everybody's Too Sensitive Nowadays. For good measure, I'm jealous too - of nothing in particular, just seething with jealousy at all & sundry. Happy npw?

Been around since 2008. Fifteen years older and infinitely more horrible! Suck it, beyatches Grin

I do genuinely think Everyone's Irritatingly Sensitive Nowadays. Wittily sarcastic threads get deleted as soon as they've found their rhythm; irony is dead. It was more fun when it were all fields round here, we could run amok ...

Morestrangerthings · 01/07/2023 00:19

JaneJeffer · 30/06/2023 22:35

I find it ironic that people are bemoaning the lack of humour when the humour on this thread was only appreciated by a couple of people and thanks to @StayAnonn for copying the post or I would have missed it

i agree.

LaBefana · 01/07/2023 00:08

Toloveandtowork · 30/06/2023 21:07

Maybe they are men who feel threatened by women talking, and want us all off this forum so try to make it unusable.

This made me laugh,

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 01/07/2023 00:01

ihavechangedmyusernam · 30/06/2023 20:59

Exactly that.

I'm sure 80% of these people wouldn't dare say half the things they post to someone's face. So why online?

I don't mean the brutal honesty; I mean the unnecessary nastiness.

A few of the old-timers have said this has only become a proper issue in recent years on MN. Interesting...

Because some people are bloody horrible, and statistically there are bound to be some on MN, @ihavechangedmyusernam.

But there is so much good too - support with mental health, breastfeeding, bereavement, advice on education, special needs provision, all the humorous threads - the Woolly Hugs project which started as a way for MN knitters and crocheters to make blankets to offer comfort to MNets who have lost a child or a spouse, and which has now made countless blankets for bereaved MNers, children in hospital, children in Africa, women with breast cancer and blankets to wrap premature newborns who don’t survive - as well as the money we raise for different charities through online craft sales.

Womensrightsaretheanswer · 30/06/2023 23:56

That Korean grandma thread, can't remember the name of it, would now be met with joyless people questioning how racist it is.

Womensrightsaretheanswer · 30/06/2023 23:54

It's not as funny anymore because people are so aware they are going to be attacked, so they pre-empt every comment and every statement so that no one can come back on them. It's lost the spontaneity. Plus in my opinion all the people we went to Mumsnet to escape and laugh about have all suddenly shown up and taken charge.

Crucible · 30/06/2023 23:46

AlfietheSchnauzer · 30/06/2023 21:27

One thing I have noticed, is that there's very rarely any hilarious threads anymore Confused
I used to laugh my socks off at MN threads....

Me too, haven't seen a nomination for classics on that score for so long. I've genuinely wept laughing at some of the posters on here, but not for a long long time.