Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the machine in Boots is wrong I can't be 38% fat?!?

65 replies

Poolnoodlepoodle · 30/06/2023 18:41

So I paid a pound today and stood on one of those machines in Boots that weighs you and gives your body fat percentage. I was shocked by the results the weight was about what I expected (10 stone 9 lbs) which makes me overweight but not massively so (bmi 26). But the in body fat percentage was 38% !?!

How does it calculate when you hold the handles? I assume it runs electricity through you (just judging by the warnings about pacemakers etc)? Is there any chance this is wrong?? The thought I'm nearly 40% fat is shocking!

OP posts:
JogOn123 · 30/06/2023 21:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 30/06/2023 21:17

Try the threesixtyme app

Barblarble · 30/06/2023 21:12

Also as people have said, those machines aren't really reliable at all. They work like you said by passing a current through your body and using the resistance to estimate fat %, but loads of things can affect your resistance. If it's one of the ones that checks through both feet it won't know about your boobs, and if it's hand-to-hand it won't be passing any current through your bum. One study they did into the accuracy of these was that the best ones were off by 20%ish and the worst by more than a third, so even if it was a very accurate machine that would give you a range of 30%-45% body fat, which ranges from normal and healthy to into the really high categories! Not very useful to know you're in such a wide range really.

Good example of this is that they're seriously affected by how hydrated you are. If you got on one really dry and then had a couple of glasses of water and got straight back on you would have a really different % so I couldn't worry too much! Bit like BMI, useful over a population but not individually. Much better to worry about do you feel good in your body, can you do the things you want to be able to do imho.

CadMan · 30/06/2023 21:10

Sorry OP, it’s accurate!

The vast majority of us are unhealthily fat.

Usernamenotavailab · 30/06/2023 21:07

My BMI is 23, body fat 32%

i started at bmi 29, body fat 41%.

when I look at the progress graph it does seem to go down at the same rate, so I’m suspicious it’s more algorithm than impedance measurement.

742EvergreenTerrace · 30/06/2023 20:59

I am 8.5 stone and 5 foot, size 8 and we have an expensive set of digital scales that transfer your details to an app. My body fat is very nearly on the very high scale. Although It’s subcutaneous and not visceral thankfully. I think we all definitely carry more fat than what it looks like on the outside

Iwantmyoldnameback · 30/06/2023 20:49

Do you know if you eat fat because getting on the scale that gets counted in too.

CovertImage · 30/06/2023 20:46

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 30/06/2023 19:21

Hello and welcome to being a mature female and not a teenage male.
21% to 32% fat is optimal, you're a bit over weight and a bit over target fat, you are normal.

Thanks god someone sensible replied. You do know OP that health women have a considerable percentage of body fat, no matter how slim they are?

Noorandapples · 30/06/2023 20:40

If it helps, the human brain is nearly 60% fat

Youcunnyfunt · 30/06/2023 20:34

Women have a lot more body fat than men! It probably isn’t far off but the machines are more accurate when they’re on a totally flat surface and no socks on. Just so you know!
I’m on the more muscley side for someone my height and weight, and even then I’m over 20% fat (4 visceral which I think is the figure to actually focus on rather than the overall number). It’s the fat between organs that’s more worrying. I think they say anything up to level 9 is alright for visceral fat.

Ladyoftheknight · 30/06/2023 20:29

You can either lose weight or tone so you turn fat into muscle. The latter is easier to some and also improves your general health.

Weefreetiffany · 30/06/2023 20:25

Women do have fat though. Unless you’re an athlete and training for hours every day it would be unusual to be under 23% I think your periods stop if you go under 15% so while 38% sounds high, and dropping a few % would be healthy, it’s not too bad really. Definitely not something to panic over at least.

highfidelity · 30/06/2023 20:20

I stood on one a few weeks ago and was also surprised at my body fat ratio - 29.3% with a body fat mass of 16.5kg.

My BMI is 20.60 and I lift heavy weights three times a week, so was expecting a lower body fat ratio/body fat mass. That said, 29.0% is good, so really shouldn't complain.

WittyUser · 30/06/2023 20:18

I've got an 'underweight' BMI and 33% fat... Dr said completely normal...and reminded me brain and breasts are mainly fat 🙃

Poolnoodlepoodle · 30/06/2023 20:18

Yes I'm a short arse 5 foot 4 inches so don't worry!

OP posts:
CostelloJones · 30/06/2023 20:16

Please tell me you are quite short to be on the higher end of BMI at that weight because because I would LOVE to be 10st 9 😂 I didn’t think I was that bad, dread to think what % I’d be

Snoken · 30/06/2023 19:57

it’s quite likely to be correct. My bmi is 20.5 and I am 28% bodyfat. Work out every day but I am peri so I blame it on that.

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 30/06/2023 19:21

Hello and welcome to being a mature female and not a teenage male.
21% to 32% fat is optimal, you're a bit over weight and a bit over target fat, you are normal.

blackrabbitwhiterabbit · 30/06/2023 19:17

My smart watch scanned my body and said I'm 33% fat....I wear a size 10-12 and am quite tall... but I think it's correct!

Vegetus · 30/06/2023 19:17

Well it won't be right anyway, dexa scan is better but still unreliable, fat callipers are the best measurement if used by someone who knows what they're doing with them.

hlr1987 · 30/06/2023 19:13

Sorry,10% I meant then, not 15%

Poolnoodlepoodle · 30/06/2023 19:11

No I know I don't want to have no body fat but 9 stone would be a real challenge! I should have done it before lunch not after 😂

OP posts:
hlr1987 · 30/06/2023 19:04

It's not that terrible if you actually look at the numbers ...
10st 9 is 149 pounds. If you work out that 1% of body fat is about 1.5lb, then to lose 15% and be in the target that's 14.9lb of fat, or aiming to drop to 9st. The percentages aren't exact, and change a bit as you lose weight but you don't actually want to lose 38% of body fat!

Beaverbridge · 30/06/2023 19:00

You were lucky getting a machine that actually worked in Boots. My local one usually has an out of order sign on it!

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 30/06/2023 18:58

When I was at my fattest I had my fat measured on a machine and by my PT (which is worse as they use these caliper things to pinch all the fat) and they came out very similar. I was 41% fat. I got that down to 15% fat (now back to about 30% ish after pregnancy) and it was a slog but it was also too low for me (I'm 5"11).