Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yorkshire Building Society closing accounts down on people with views that don't agree with their policy

310 replies

Summer2023hasarrived · 30/06/2023 17:06

So the story goes that if you have a view on Brexit or LGBTQ?+ that isn't inline or in agreement with the people that know what view is right at The Yorkshire Building Society then they can close your account?

AIBU - stick to the day job and provide mortgages and savings

YABU - they can decide if the values of their customers don't align to shut them down

OP posts:
Thread gallery
27
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/07/2023 14:04

EuripidesEumenides · 30/06/2023 19:39

Have a gander at section 10 of the Equality Act re - political beliefs and the plentiful case law based on it then come back.

Antisemitism isn't protected by the Equality Act, no. The fact you had to use such a daft and extreme example is telling.

No, I used an extreme example to illustrate your black and white interpretation is flawed. You stated that political beliefs are protected under the equality act, I demonstrated that is not always the case.

For a belief to be considered a belief and protected under the Equality Act it must;

  1. Be Genuinely held.

  2. Be a belief rather than an opinion or viewpoint based on the present state of information available.

  3. Be a belief as to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour.

  4. Attain a certain level of cogency, seriousness, cohesion and importance.

  5. Be worthy of respect in a democratic society – not incompatible with human dignity and not in conflict with the fundamental rights of others.

Political beliefs are especially difficult to define under the act because of points 2-5. Nigel Farage might argue his accounts has been closed because of his deeply held brexit belief, but it would be just as easy to argue that this is a view not a belief (especially as he's publicly admitted brexit has failed) or that this belief doesn't pertain to a substantial aspect of human life.

It's gets even more complex because beliefs can be played off against each other and businesses have freedom of contract. Take Triodos bank as an example, they have set themselves up as an ethical bank with specific beliefs under pinning their operations. Part of this requires individuals to meet additional criteria (above legal requirements) in order to be eleigbe for a business account, specifically around transparency and responsible business practices.

They will not give an account to someone who has connections with tax havens (unless haven't they can demonstrate that this does not exist to minimise tax liability) or with a wide range of sectors including fossil fuels, factory farming, mining, to name a few.

So a Nigel Farage or a Jacob Reese-Mog or a Rishi Sunak wouldn't not be able to open up a business account with them and there's no discrimination about it even if they all have deeply held political beliefs about free market capitalism and fiscal conservatism.

Are you arguing that Tiodos should be forced to work with anyone, even those diametrically opposed to their ethos and if so why do Triodos' beliefs not deserve equal consideration in your mind?

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/07/2023 13:59

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 13:11

cakeorwine

You don't have to campaign to make other people's children sterile, you don't have to campaign to force others to tell biological lies, you don't have to campaign to harm vulnerable women and girls by making mixing sex spaces.

No, you don't have to, but you might be argued to have the right to, on the grounds of, oh what's the term, that's right, free speech.

You also don't have to spend years campaigning for the people of your country to impose economic sanctions on their own country; to whip up xenophobia; to deny climate change; or to support far-right candidates for power in the USA, France and Germany; but I suppose Farage has the right to do so under the same grounds.

If banks are denying him services just because of his views, that is unfair; but, as both Farage and the Daily Mail are notorious liars, I suspect that it may be more a matter of how he uses his money,

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 13:43

https://christianconcern.com/news/christian-charity-paid-over-20000-compensation-for-bank-account-closures/

Registering opinions is miles away from sending rape and death threats on someone and their family.

Yorkshire building society requested customers opinions then closed down an account because they didn't like his legally protected beliefs. Why bother with feedback forms of what you really want is only weather vein opinions that match yours this week.

Christian charity paid over £20,000 compensation for bank account closures - Christian Concern

Barclays Bank has been forced to pay over £20,000 compensation to a Christian ministry after bowing to the demands of LGBT activists by closing accounts. In July 2020, the bank notified Core Issues Trust (CIT) and the International Federation for Thera...

https://christianconcern.com/news/christian-charity-paid-over-20000-compensation-for-bank-account-closures

cakeorwine · 01/07/2023 13:21

Don't believe everything you read in any of the papers, but particularly not the Mail, which has a track record of twisting a grain of truth into a whole different narrative

I am sure some people are already targeting the building society, posting on its Facebook page, using Twitter, maybe emailing them based on what they've read.

It's so easy to write an article to get people upset and to get people to react.

BishyBarnyBee · 01/07/2023 13:15

Not read the full thread.

If this was true it would be outrageous.

However, it is very. very unlikely to be true.

Much more likely that people have made anonymous donations to controversial organisations, and the banks have closed the accounts because the source of the money is untraceable.

Barclay's track record on Apartheid is irrelevant here. The banks have turned a blind eye to money lending in the past and have been forced to show they are taking it seriously. Anyone who has tried to open a bank account recently will know how difficult it has become.

Don't believe everything you read in any of the papers, but particularly not the Mail, which has a track record of twisting a grain of truth into a whole different narrative.

cakeorwine · 01/07/2023 13:14

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 13:11

cakeorwine

You don't have to campaign to make other people's children sterile, you don't have to campaign to force others to tell biological lies, you don't have to campaign to harm vulnerable women and girls by making mixing sex spaces.

If you want to debate that, then why not start a thread about it?
I am sure you will get some takers.

Do you know why he had his account closed?
He doesn't
You don't

This thread is just jumping to conclusions based on something Farage thinks.

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 13:11

cakeorwine

You don't have to campaign to make other people's children sterile, you don't have to campaign to force others to tell biological lies, you don't have to campaign to harm vulnerable women and girls by making mixing sex spaces.

cakeorwine · 01/07/2023 13:11

I think it is outrageous. I said it on the Nigel Farage thread, the only reason banks should be closing accounts is because someone has, or they have strong reasons to believe they have, committed a financially related criminal offence such as money laundering or fraud, or the bank account is being used to fund terrorist activities

Do you know why he has had his accounts closed?

He doesn't know.
You don't know.
I don't know.

So you are outraged at something you don't know the facts about?

Surely you should know all the facts about something before being outraged about it?

RedToothBrush · 01/07/2023 13:11

CanCancanbefun · 01/07/2023 08:59

If and it is a big if that Nigel Farage received any money from RT it was before recent sanctions. Many others were paid good money by RT, Scottish chap who has been an MP.
The worry about the NF case is that all the banks have colluded and together banned him even though they cannot have the detail of the accounts. That is like the 1984 story.

I don't believe it's to do with RT.

I think it goes beyond that tbh.

He IS a risk for any bank.

lieselotte · 01/07/2023 13:09

I think it is outrageous. I said it on the Nigel Farage thread, the only reason banks should be closing accounts is because someone has, or they have strong reasons to believe they have, committed a financially related criminal offence such as money laundering or fraud, or the bank account is being used to fund terrorist activities.

It is not for woke bank staff to decide that someone should not have access to a bank account because they are brexity (which I am not) or believe in single sex spaces (which I do). It is particularly hypocritical in the Barclays case as they refused to get out of South Africa during the apartheid era. It is also completely irrelevant to the day to day operation of the account.

RedToothBrush · 01/07/2023 13:08

There are two, perhaps three issues here.

Farage's case is very different to others mentioned.

There is a tidal wave of turds following him around like a bad smell relating to money laundering, unexplained wealth and Russian disinformation and political interference - his known associates keep ending up in courts.

Farage is piggie backing on other concerns that others ordinary people have or can relate to to distract from his legal and financial irregularity question marks.

This is well established and about risk management for banks about their exposure to criminal activity. It's a legitimate legal issue not a freedom of speech or an abuse of power issue.

You then have freedom of speech issues which I'm not entirely convinced of. There should be oversight on this and questions asked but I remain unconvinced by the argument.

And then abuse issue which often I think are more to do with appalling service by banks and a deliberately obstructive approach to make complaints as difficult as possible to uphold. It's easier to push customers to breaking point than to deal with a problem and have to declare it to financial regulators. There is a need for oversight on this.

Don't conflate the separate issues.

Farage MO is to deliberately conflate and confuse matters for his own personal advantage.

I don't agree with his view but think he should be allowed freedom of speech. However this isn't a freedom of speech issue for his case.

The history of Farage's issues with dodgy financial issues are well documented and in the public domain.

Cakesandbabes · 01/07/2023 13:04

cakeorwine · 01/07/2023 12:55

I am sure that people in Florida won't use the LGBT leglisation there against LGBT people.

DeSantis limits trans treatments, drag shows, pronoun use in Florida - BBC News

People will absolutely use it to terrorise those they don't like IF that law really is as it sounds

Yes - I am sure people will use this actual law to terrorise people whose lifestyle they don't agree with

Which is why LGBT people and those who have LGBT family are fleeing Florida.

I meant it as anyone against anyone.
Hence saying "People will absolutely use it to terrorise those they don't like IF that law really is as it sounds." Not x group. This could be used by anyone against anyone

cakeorwine · 01/07/2023 13:01

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:58

You could stay in Florida and not campaign to have other people's children taught new ideologies that harm the minds and bodies of their children.

The point is that people on both sides of a debate are targetted for abuse on social media, cancelled, their employers are targetted, boycotted etc.

And yet it's often presented as a one way thing.

I guess that if people only follow certain media, they don't hear this other stories because those media outlets don't publish them.

And the Free Speech Union doesn't care.

cakeorwine · 01/07/2023 12:58

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:50

The Yorkshire building society seen to have set up the Anglican vicar. The free speech union are saying that he was asked to provide feedback by the building society and when they didn't like it they cancelled his account.

The Free Speech Union who don't seem to comment when other people are targetted when they speak out.

I think the Free Speech Union only care about certain types of free speech.

Academic blocked from giving civil service talk because of criticism of government | Science | The Guardian

Academic blocked from giving civil service talk because of criticism of government

Dr Kate Devlin told her invitation had been withdrawn owing to past comments on social media

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2022/oct/10/academic-cancelled-from-civil-service-talk-because-of-criticism-of-government

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:58

You could stay in Florida and not campaign to have other people's children taught new ideologies that harm the minds and bodies of their children.

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:56

We may have an answer regarding First direct cancelling one account. First direct are a division of HSBC and their global financial tracker is a trans activist.

Wings over Scotland has tweeted the evidence.

cakeorwine · 01/07/2023 12:55

Cakesandbabes · 01/07/2023 12:14

I am an obvious woman. I would totally go by he/him just to bankrupt those who come up with these things.
That is btw what will happen. People will absolutely use it to terrorise those they don't like IF that law really is as it sounds.

I am sure that people in Florida won't use the LGBT leglisation there against LGBT people.

DeSantis limits trans treatments, drag shows, pronoun use in Florida - BBC News

People will absolutely use it to terrorise those they don't like IF that law really is as it sounds

Yes - I am sure people will use this actual law to terrorise people whose lifestyle they don't agree with

Which is why LGBT people and those who have LGBT family are fleeing Florida.

DeSantis speaks to a crowd gathered in Florida

DeSantis limits trans treatments, drag shows, pronoun use in Florida

The governor says the laws will make Florida a "refuge of sanity". Critics called them "mean spirited".

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65627756

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:50

The Yorkshire building society seen to have set up the Anglican vicar. The free speech union are saying that he was asked to provide feedback by the building society and when they didn't like it they cancelled his account.

Cakesandbabes · 01/07/2023 12:14

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:07

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/michigan-house-passes-bill-that-could-make-using-wrong-pronouns-a-felony-fineable-up-to-10000/ar-AA1dgjCB

There is intolerance of anyone intolerant or unable to incorrectly sex another human.

Under the new bill, offenders are "guilty of a felony punishable by imprisonment for not more than 5 years, or by a fine of not more than $10,000."

The legislation would prohibit mental health professionals from trying to convert youths who are LGBTQ+ to heterosexuality and traditional gender expectations.

Traditional gender expressions - think about it!

I am an obvious woman. I would totally go by he/him just to bankrupt those who come up with these things.
That is btw what will happen. People will absolutely use it to terrorise those they don't like IF that law really is as it sounds.

CanCancanbefun · 01/07/2023 12:11

With discussions of proposed foreign legislation I think you are going off topic.

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:07

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/michigan-house-passes-bill-that-could-make-using-wrong-pronouns-a-felony-fineable-up-to-10000/ar-AA1dgjCB

There is intolerance of anyone intolerant or unable to incorrectly sex another human.

Under the new bill, offenders are "guilty of a felony punishable by imprisonment for not more than 5 years, or by a fine of not more than $10,000."

The legislation would prohibit mental health professionals from trying to convert youths who are LGBTQ+ to heterosexuality and traditional gender expectations.

Traditional gender expressions - think about it!

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/michigan-house-passes-bill-that-could-make-using-wrong-pronouns-a-felony-fineable-up-to-10000/ar-AA1dgjCB

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 09:36

JudgeRudy · 01/07/2023 09:30

So they are unfairly discriminating against people they feel discriminate!

The intolerance of intolerance!

Imagine MPs puffed out chests as they stand next to a flag pole with a minutes silence for the flat earth community?

Imagine NHS staff calling a 🌎 believer a liar, no flat earther was in a ward?

https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/hospital-says-patient-could-not-26506744

Hospital says patient wasn't raped because alleged attacker was transgender

The incident has drawn attention to the impact of self-ID in hospitals and other institutions like the police with Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne calling on Westministers Lords to scrap it.

https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/hospital-says-patient-could-not-26506744

SerendipityJane · 01/07/2023 09:34

Barclays eventually had to divest themselves of investments in apartheid-era South Africa because of the reputational damage it did them. A boycott can be a powerful thing if it's big enough.

Something our current Lords and Masters would make unlawful if they could.

LakieLady · 01/07/2023 09:32

FedgeHund · 30/06/2023 19:16

https://www.moodys.com/newsandevents/topics/ESG-Credit-00702C

Seems we all have personal social credit scores now.

As I say if I was, or a family member of a politician, biology teacher or NHS staff, I would be bricking it. Nigel said his families accounts were closed also.

Isn't that partly to inform potential investors about possible risk though? Poor governance and lack of attention to environmental standards can lead to liabilities down the line. And knowing ESG ratings would be helpful for people who want to support businesses that have good governance and environment-friendly practices. I don't see anything wrong with that.

I can see why a business might not want to be associated with a public figure whose views are anathema to many people, too. If I found out that my bank were looking after the money of Britain First or some other vile far-right group, I'd want to move my account, and I'd tell them why.

Barclays eventually had to divest themselves of investments in apartheid-era South Africa because of the reputational damage it did them. A boycott can be a powerful thing if it's big enough.

JudgeRudy · 01/07/2023 09:30

So they are unfairly discriminating against people they feel discriminate!