Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yorkshire Building Society closing accounts down on people with views that don't agree with their policy

310 replies

Summer2023hasarrived · 30/06/2023 17:06

So the story goes that if you have a view on Brexit or LGBTQ?+ that isn't inline or in agreement with the people that know what view is right at The Yorkshire Building Society then they can close your account?

AIBU - stick to the day job and provide mortgages and savings

YABU - they can decide if the values of their customers don't align to shut them down

OP posts:
Thread gallery
27
Summer2023hasarrived · 03/07/2023 19:44

So it seems the original story in the DM means some don't consider it valid. However, the story has spread further afield and has also been debated on morning shows. It seems it really is a thing and not the DM making things up as some would suggest not true unless it's in The Times. 😂

OP posts:
ChristinaXYZ · 03/07/2023 16:20

As people are complaing about the Daily Mail coverage here's a good piece by the consumer rights journalist Katie Morley in the Telegraph
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/personal-banking/current-accounts/arrogant-banks-woke-keep-money-safe/

She points out all the ways banks are immoral and lacking in standards - the failure to pass on interest rates to savers, the failure to help customers who have been scammed, etc, etc.

"So yes, when it comes to morals there truly may be no-one worse to judge than the banks. They can hand out as many pronoun badges, hold as many Pride events and cancel as many Nigel Farage-types as they like, but at the end of the day customers will see it all for what it really is: virtue signalling designed to further their own money-making agenda.

The bottom line is that no-one should be denied a bank account on the basis of their views. Government intervention to stop this faux moral grandstanding cannot come soon enough. "

Arrogant banks are too busy being ‘woke’ to keep our money safe

Virtue-signalling lenders are simply furthering their own profiteering agenda

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/personal-banking/current-accounts/arrogant-banks-woke-keep-money-safe

ChristinaXYZ · 03/07/2023 16:19

Fallenangelofthenorth · 02/07/2023 00:27

Well you could also be quite rightly sued if you discriminated on a protected characteristic. One of which is what your refer to as "terf" which in itself is a slur.

The banks are not any old private business. They are to some extent under-written by the tax payer in the sense that we trust them with our money, many of us hardly having any cash in the house now, because we know the government using tax payers money will refund us if the bank crashes. This is itself unlikely because the governemnt will likely bail the banks out as in the financial crisis. So bearing in mind we ALL pay for it - all this and backing and all the regulators etc - they can provide ALL of us, whether they like us or not, with their services.

Or looking it another way @IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems why should I and any other tax payer pay for the regulation and support of banks whose politics I do not like? Where is the freedom there? No-one has a choice in that so stuff any idea the banks should have any choice the other way.

They clear answer has to be, to anyone not a naive as fuck, that banks should not flaunt their politics nor discriminate on the grounds of belief.

ChristinaXYZ · 03/07/2023 15:07

pointythings · 30/06/2023 17:15

In the case of Farage and Tice it is nothing to do with their views. It's about them Politically Exposed Persons (there are regulations around this) and about the very high likelihood of them having received Russian money. Banks are legally allowed to close anyone's account if they suspect dodgy dealings, because under UK law they are liable for any associated costs and prosecutions.

And you need better source material than the Mail. Really, you do.

Yet if was just because they are PEP then we'd see as many left wingers as right wingers beign affected.

See this - I know Daily Mail again but it is Dominic Lawson writing from experience about the refusal of bank to open an acocunt for his disabled daughter!

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-12256943/Its-not-just-Nigel-Farage-daughter-blocked-opening-bank-account.html

I think @pointythings you are bing really naive and we all should be worried about this.

The Guy who runs the WingsOverScotland website, who is gender critical has had his acocunts closed withuot explanation by HSBC - https://twitter.com/WingsScotland/status/1675185927998566401 and the vicar who when asked for his opinion said somthing about pride flags has had his account close by YBS is also not a PEP.

This is serious over-reach by the banks. They may be businesses and you may think businesses can work with who they like - but there are laws about discriminating over beliefs, and banks, unlike other businesses are backed by the government with our taxation money in the form of guarantees and bailouts. We leave our money with banks because we know the governement will pays us (up to the limited amount, something like 85k) if things go wrong. Otherwise more of us would keep it under the mattress. The governement needs to act on this discrimatory practice of account closing, and fast.

Not just Farage: My daughter was blocked from opening a bank account

DOMINIC LAWSON: Nigel Farage is even angrier than usual. With good reason. The former leader of the Brexit Party revealed last week his bank would be closing his accounts.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-12256943/Its-not-just-Nigel-Farage-daughter-blocked-opening-bank-account.html

justasking111 · 03/07/2023 14:40

Back benchers, link please @FedgeHund

FedgeHund · 03/07/2023 14:34

The other thread linked to a radio 4 discussion and apparently friends and cousins are now being refused bank accounts also, backbenchers are also being refused mortgages.

saraclara · 03/07/2023 13:09

justasking111 · 03/07/2023 09:09

From what I can gather the banning extends to other close family members. It's frightening to be honest.

It's really not. They will only consider family members' accounts where they suspect money laundering or similar. It's too easy for people to try to avoid detection by transferring money to family members.

justasking111 · 03/07/2023 09:09

From what I can gather the banning extends to other close family members. It's frightening to be honest.

FedgeHund · 03/07/2023 06:24

PEP not PRO

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 12:29

Calvin Robinson has a video on his Twitter feed with the Vicar, they discussed the feedback from and what was written.

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 02/07/2023 09:37

Cakesandbabes · 02/07/2023 08:40

Actually gender critical views are philosophical belief. And protected unless I am mistaken and missed some development

The law has only been tested in regards to employment law. My statement is about the refusal of B2B goods and services where it might tarnish the reputation of my own business.

I wouldn't refuse a sale of one item to someone who held TERF views - it's unlikely that I'd know anyway.

I would however refuse to associate my business with an event that is actively promoting, or fundraising for, a cause that I believe to present a risk to the reputation of the business. We are always very visible within events when we are there, and all it would take would be one picture on social media and we would lose contracts elsewhere.

More widely, by sheer chance, almost all my staff are either LGBT or POC. They're also on casual contracts and can pick and choose their shifts. I'd find it impossible to staff an event that my staff found personally offensive. Pretty sure they'd all laugh in my face if I asked them to work the Tory party conference...

And for that reason, we would be unavailable, or the quote request would mysteriously make it into the spam folder.

justasking111 · 02/07/2023 08:46

Say you had an account at first direct or YBS and a disgruntled family member or colleague contacted them re your views. Would you deserve that??? You're not in the public eye. After all the reporting that went on during covid more people do have an appetite for it.

Cakesandbabes · 02/07/2023 08:40

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 02/07/2023 00:34

Being a TERF is a political belief.

Political beliefs are not protected characteristics.

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/equality-act/protected-characteristics

Gender reassignment is a protected characteristic though - so neither of us could discriminate on the basis that a prospective client was trans (not that I would).

Actually gender critical views are philosophical belief. And protected unless I am mistaken and missed some development

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 07:58

RiverGate33 · 02/07/2023 00:00

Try navigating your life today without a bank account. You cant even get a job without a bank account let alone mortgage credit card phone plan utilities...

Try being a girl needing a period protection change in a mixed sex toilet at school, so you take the day off.

Try needing NHS care and not being able to access it as staff will carry out Annexe B, so you self exclude.

Nobody will do anything about bank accounts, they do nothing about schools or the NHS. Our army will be useless in a war because everyone is terrified of certain people who rule is all.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12255015/Soldier-saved-lives-Afghanistan-forced-quit-Army-agreeing-men-women.html

Hero soldier shot down by cancel culture

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: The horrors of the battlefield are as fresh for Colonel Dr Kelvin Wright today as they were at the height of the Afghan conflict.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12255015/Soldier-saved-lives-Afghanistan-forced-quit-Army-agreeing-men-women.html

Fallenangelofthenorth · 02/07/2023 00:43

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 02/07/2023 00:34

Being a TERF is a political belief.

Political beliefs are not protected characteristics.

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/equality-act/protected-characteristics

Gender reassignment is a protected characteristic though - so neither of us could discriminate on the basis that a prospective client was trans (not that I would).

Carry on then

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 02/07/2023 00:34

Fallenangelofthenorth · 02/07/2023 00:27

Well you could also be quite rightly sued if you discriminated on a protected characteristic. One of which is what your refer to as "terf" which in itself is a slur.

Being a TERF is a political belief.

Political beliefs are not protected characteristics.

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/equality-act/protected-characteristics

Gender reassignment is a protected characteristic though - so neither of us could discriminate on the basis that a prospective client was trans (not that I would).

Protected characteristics | Equality and Human Rights Commission

Brief descriptive overview of the nine Protected Characteristics

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/equality-act/protected-characteristics

Fallenangelofthenorth · 02/07/2023 00:27

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 02/07/2023 00:13

It's a private business and they have the right to take or refuse business as they see fit.

I run a business and we have a clause in our T&C's that ensures we don't find ourselves providing services to, for instance, a fundraising event for a cause that I think would reflect badly on the business. There is a zero percent chance that I would provide services to a pro-Brexit, TERF or Tory fundraising event, for instance. If that means I lose money, I'm fine with that. I'd sooner sit on my behind and earn zilch than get involved with such a cause.

Well you could also be quite rightly sued if you discriminated on a protected characteristic. One of which is what your refer to as "terf" which in itself is a slur.

RiverGate33 · 02/07/2023 00:22

It's actually mutually owned by its members. I hope the pendulum prevailing political thought never swings in the direction that private businesses could render you an unperson in your own country but then I'm a bleeding heart liberal.

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 02/07/2023 00:13

It's a private business and they have the right to take or refuse business as they see fit.

I run a business and we have a clause in our T&C's that ensures we don't find ourselves providing services to, for instance, a fundraising event for a cause that I think would reflect badly on the business. There is a zero percent chance that I would provide services to a pro-Brexit, TERF or Tory fundraising event, for instance. If that means I lose money, I'm fine with that. I'd sooner sit on my behind and earn zilch than get involved with such a cause.

RiverGate33 · 02/07/2023 00:00

Try navigating your life today without a bank account. You cant even get a job without a bank account let alone mortgage credit card phone plan utilities...

RiverGate33 · 01/07/2023 23:47

The account holder responded to one of those customer feedback requests that are sent to your email -- in which he basically said that financial institutions shouldn't be social engineers (about pride month).

Juicyj1993 · 01/07/2023 22:15

I worked for a bank call centre for a while. And it may well have less to do with the views being mentioned in the article, but how they have been communicated to the bank. For example were calls made that became abusive? Did the user make an excessive number of calls that made them a nuisance?

I can remember getting a call from a woman who wasn't happy that there was a pride collection pot in the Brighton branch. She was shouting, screaming and swearing over the phone as well as using some horrible slurs. We didn't make the decision to close her account after that one call, but her account was noted and if she'd made a habit of it her account would have been closed. Not because she held views that were different, but because she was a rude, aggressive, nasty piece of work. And I'm sure if she ended up having her account closed she would have told anyone who would listen that it 'only because she thought there was a more worthy cause than pride' and not the real reason.