Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yorkshire Building Society closing accounts down on people with views that don't agree with their policy

310 replies

Summer2023hasarrived · 30/06/2023 17:06

So the story goes that if you have a view on Brexit or LGBTQ?+ that isn't inline or in agreement with the people that know what view is right at The Yorkshire Building Society then they can close your account?

AIBU - stick to the day job and provide mortgages and savings

YABU - they can decide if the values of their customers don't align to shut them down

OP posts:
Thread gallery
27
RedToothBrush · 19/07/2023 17:48

Farage remains a grifter and dangerous.

Hth.

ToWhitToWhoo · 19/07/2023 17:47

There is a difference between refusing a person an account because of some disagreement and refusing to bankroll a campaign to which one objects.

I suspect that Farage is deliberately blurring the line between the two.

If you think that banks should not be able to refuse to fund campaigns, fine, but then you lose your right to object if they fund Extinction Rebellion/ Just Stop Oil/ Stonewall/ the Communist Party/ etc.

Bosky · 19/07/2023 13:03

RedToothBrush · 05/07/2023 16:01

50 percentage of the population have a below average IQ. Or are just too bloody lazy to fact check. Or like the narrative because it matches their world view so don't seek an alternative explaination in case it undermines their world view.

Ahem! "50 percentage of the population have a below average IQ. Or are just too bloody lazy to fact check. Or like the narrative because it matches their world view so don't seek an alternative explaination in case it undermines their world view."

How are you feeling about those accusations now?

Of course 50% of the population have a below average IQ - that's how IQ scores work.

Brain power drops with failure to employ intellectual curiosity and with reliance on stereotypes and prejudices.

How are the facts impacting on your own world view, given that they fail to support the explanations in this thread that you favour, being based as they are on negative assumptions about Farage?

For example, that he would have been rude to staff and that sort of behaviour would not have been tolerated?

"The dossier noted that there was 'no evidence of regulator or legal censure' of Mr Farage, that he was 'professional, polite and respectful' to staff and that he had recently been downgraded from a 'higher risk politically exposed person [PEP]' to lower risk, and was on the way to being classed as no risk at all."

The Coutts dossier is published in full here, if you are not "just too bloody lazy to fact check":

Revealed: The full Coutts Farage dossier. How bank admitted ex-Ukip leader DID meet 'commercial criteria' but used tweet of Ricky Gervais trans joke and Novak Djokovic ties to decide he was 'at odds with our position as an inclusive organisation'

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12314423/The-Coutts-Farage-dossier-bank-admitted-ex-Ukip-leader-DID-meet-commercial-criteria-used-tweet-Ricky-Gervais-trans-joke-Novak-Djokovic-ties-decide-odds-position-inclusive-organisation.html

Like I have said before, I am no fan of Farage. I find him very irritating TBH.

However, I have rather less respect now for the professionalism of Coutts employees and management, who seem to think that it is acceptable to conduct an official evaluation of a customer that includes Twitter-incel shitposting level comments such as, "He is considered by many to be a disingenuous grifter".

Coutts is owned by Nat West with rather more of us likely to hold accounts with Nat West than Coutts. There are threads about other Banks that have closed accounts of customers without explanation. Are any of them less likely to treat customers whose views they disagree with any less contempt?

Revealed: The Coutts dossier on Nigel Farage in full

The 40-page file shows that the bank cited his retweet of a Ricky Gervais joke and his friendship with Novak Djokovic to raise concerns he was 'xenophobic and racist'.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12314423/The-Coutts-Farage-dossier-bank-admitted-ex-Ukip-leader-DID-meet-commercial-criteria-used-tweet-Ricky-Gervais-trans-joke-Novak-Djokovic-ties-decide-odds-position-inclusive-organisation.html

lieselotte · 19/07/2023 11:27

RedToothBrush · 05/07/2023 16:01

50 percentage of the population have a below average IQ. Or are just too bloody lazy to fact check. Or like the narrative because it matches their world view so don't seek an alternative explaination in case it undermines their world view.

Who says it's a hoax?

Anyway I don't like the man or his viewpoints, but you can't deny someone banking services because you don't like their opinions. It may be that other aspects were relevant here, but it's a fact that people have had their bank accounts closed for spurious reasons, both in the UK and overseas.

lieselotte · 19/07/2023 11:25

SingingNettles · 01/07/2023 21:11

I’d love to know what he considers ‘LGBT ideology’ and what the contents of his email were

I suspect there are a lot of businesses who’d have reservations about continuing with a client who’s sending them complaint emails

They can always block him :)

Anyway most businesses won't accept emails, it is very difficult to contact them at all, so it's hardly going to be a big issue.

Bosky · 18/07/2023 23:05

This thread popped up in "Similar Threads" to one I am on in FWR and it looks like it needs an update. Most (all?) of the allegations about Farage earlier in this thread appear to have been refuted by the documents supplied by Coutts in response to Farage's Subject Access Request.

I am no fan of Farage but Coutts has obviously made a big mistake going for him - and then lying about the reasons that they closed his account. He has kicked up a right stink and that will help people who do not have his public profile.

It used to be a legal right for everyone in the UK to have a Bank Account and that was achieved through the Post Office Bank. There is even more need for that right to be reinstated in Legislation now, when so few people are paid in cash and so many payments are required to be cashless.

Pop these links into one of the usual Archive sites:

Nigel Farage’s Coutts account closed as bank felt he did not ‘align with their values’
Documents obtained by ex-Ukip leader show reputational risk committee ‘exited’ him after considering his views on issues such as Brexit

Extracts

"Earlier this month, the BBC and the Financial Times reported claims that the reason Mr Farage’s accounts were closed was that they fell below the financial threshold required by the bank. The BBC quoted sources “familiar with” the Coutts decision.

Yet in the 40 pages of documents released to Mr Farage after he made a subject access request to Coutts, the bank repeatedly says he “meets the EC [economic contribution] criteria for commercial retention”."

"Minutes of a meeting of Coutts’ wealth reputational risk committee held on Nov 17 2022 state: “The committee did not think continuing to bank NF was compatible with Coutts given his publicly-stated views that were at odds with our position as an inclusive organisation.

“This was not a political decision but one centred around inclusivity and purpose.”

Mr Farage has said Coutts told him he was not being treated as a Politically Exposed Person (PEP) – a legal term for customers who are deemed risky for political reasons – but the dossier specifically states that he is one.

He writes: “Whoever at Coutts thought it clever to feed friendly media outlets outright lies about me sorely misjudged the situation.”

The document contains 39 mentions of Mr Trump, and Mr Farage says: “The fact that I support Donald Trump is part of this charge sheet.”

"It says he is seen as “xenophobic and racist”, repeats claims that he was a “fascist” in his schooldays, and says he said things in the past that are “distasteful and appear increasingly out of touch with wider society”.

Mr Farage writes that the dossier “reads rather like a pre-trial brief drawn up by the prosecution in a case against a career criminal. Monthly press checks were made on me. My social media accounts were monitored. Anything considered ‘problematic’ was recorded. I was being watched”.

"Mr Farage now says he cannot get an account with any other bank, having been turned down by 10 banks since Coutts withdrew its services. Members of his family have also been refused accounts by other banks, and one family member was told their account was being closed."

Speaking on Mr Farage’s GB News show, Lord Lamont, a former chancellor, said: “I was appalled when I looked at the documents.

“It seems to me a right to have a bank account is a fundamental right... but it appears that the executives of the bank were going through your views and saying they were not compatible with their values. That is not the function of a bank. It’s extraordinary that a bank should set itself up as some judge of political correctness.”

Some senior Tory MPs have called for a change in the law on PEPs to prevent abuse of the system. Under UK financial law, gatekeepers of the banking system must perform enhanced checks on people classed as PEPs, their families and close associates.

The Treasury has confirmed that it is reviewing whether banks are blacklisting customers with controversial political views. Under the new Financial Services and Markets Act, the Financial Conduct Authority will look at how banks deal with PEPs in a review to take place within the next year.

A spokesman for the Treasury said: “It would be of serious concern if financial services were being denied to anyone exercising their right to lawful free speech.

“We will soon set out plans to crack down on this practice by toughening the rules around account closures, protecting freedom of expression. In the meantime, people can complain to the Financial Ombudsman Service which has the power to direct a bank to reopen an account.”

Continues at:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/18/nigel-farage-coutts-bank-account-closed-align-with-values/

The real reason Coutts closed my accounts – and it has nothing to do with my finances
I have seen the Stasi-style surveillance report used to justify the bank’s extraordinary action – it is, frankly, shocking"

Extracts

"My fate was sealed at a meeting of the bank’s wealth reputational risk committee on Nov 17, 2022.

Executives agreed that, once my mortgage expired, I was to be “de-banked”. I know this because, via a subject access request, I have seen the 36-page Stasi-style surveillance report used at that meeting to justify this extraordinary action. This report is, frankly, shocking.

The first thing to say is that Coutts’s decision to cancel me had nothing to do with my finances. Contrary to the damaging briefings made to the BBC and the FT this month about my holdings falling below the bank’s threshold, the report states several times that my “economic contribution” is sound and my funds are “sufficient to retain on a commercial basis”.

It even acknowledges that I am a positive net financial contributor to the bank. Whoever at Coutts thought it clever to feed friendly media outlets outright lies about me sorely misjudged the situation."

"This report is proof that any Coutts customer who holds even vaguely conservative views should be treated with disdain. My friendship with the family of Novak Djokovic, who stood firm over his belief that he should have the freedom to choose whether to receive the Covid vaccine, is mentioned on the charge sheet.

So is my retweeting of a Ricky Gervais gag and my belief in leaving the European Convention on Human Rights. What do these things have to do with my bank account?"

Vladimir Putin’s Russia was the obvious choice for their smear campaign. Indeed, the Labour MP Sir Chris Bryant is mentioned twice for his false allegation – made in the Commons chamber last year but never repeated outside it – that I received £548,573 in one calendar year “from the Russian state”.

Yet Coutts’s report notes (presumably through gritted teeth) that it found no evidence of my having any links to Russia. And it checked thoroughly."

"The most extraordinary comments of all are the areas of the report talking about me “not aligning with [Coutts’s] views” and suggesting I must be barred because I do not support the diversity, policies and “purpose” of Coutts, as though Britain is a political regime and I am a dissident.

What should any of us make of this word “purpose”? Surely the purpose of a commercial organisation is to act with integrity and to make a profit for shareholders – in the case of Coutts, by the way, that means all of us. For its biggest shareholder is the state, which retains a 38.6 per cent stake in this bank and the wider RBS group, including NatWest."

"Over the last few years, thousands of all banks’ customers have seen their applications to open accounts refused, or existing accounts closed.

This happens for various reasons. Perhaps a business takes too much cash, as the bank sees it. The nature of being deemed a politically exposed person or a member of their extended family is another possibility. But existing rules mean the banks never have to explain a “de-banking”.

I’m probably the first public figure to challenge the behaviour of our banking industry in this way. It is clear Coutts thought it could spin its way out of my “de-banking” and perhaps even emerge with its image enhanced. Not this time."

"This story is not just about me. You could be next. Refinitiv, which monitors creditworthiness, can examine social media posts made by any of us on Facebook or elsewhere. If this situation is left unchecked, we will sleepwalk towards a China-style social credit system in which only those with the “correct” views are allowed to fully participate in society."

Continues at:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/18/nigel-farage-coutts-uk-bank-accounts/

Nigel Farage’s Coutts account closed as bank felt he did not ‘align with their values’

Documents obtained by ex-Ukip leader show reputational risk committee ‘exited’ him after considering his views on issues such as Brexit

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/18/nigel-farage-coutts-bank-account-closed-align-with-values/

Thatgirl1981 · 12/07/2023 06:37

JayWayney · 12/07/2023 03:47

So poor old Mr F lost his bank account and lied. I wonder if he had any sympathy for all those UK citizens living in Europe when his blessed brexit made movement of money between the UK and the EU more difficult and some banks decided to close the accounts of those in Europe. It caused a lot of difficulty for a lot of people.

https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/news/2020/11/eu-bank-accounts-closed-brexit/

What about the cluster bombs

what about cheese

wondered when someone who being on Brexit

you are essentially saying so we’re clear I hate farage coz of Brexit so I am glad he’s had his bank account taken away
democratic votes mean nothing if I don’t get my own way and because of this my political enemies deserve everything they get.

the quiet part always gets said out loud

like I said on another thread we are starting to see the excess of the left

Thatgirl1981 · 12/07/2023 06:32

ToWhitToWhoo · 12/07/2023 02:47

Well, there's at least one group of people, who usually AREN'T left-wing:

Bankers.

Seems they are all support the tenant of the new left wing religion the critical theory’s

any one who is for free speech
any one who is critical of the new faith or articals of it

religious people
anyone who is openly right wing

bankers have seen got to punish

and I love this their a private business so they can do as they wish I still haven’t had a answer if they hate blacks like me should I have my bank account closed if not why not after all their private

never thought I would see so many who call them self progressives
shilling for discrimination and the banks 😂

JayWayney · 12/07/2023 03:47

So poor old Mr F lost his bank account and lied. I wonder if he had any sympathy for all those UK citizens living in Europe when his blessed brexit made movement of money between the UK and the EU more difficult and some banks decided to close the accounts of those in Europe. It caused a lot of difficulty for a lot of people.

https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/news/2020/11/eu-bank-accounts-closed-brexit/

ToWhitToWhoo · 12/07/2023 02:47

Thatgirl1981 · 11/07/2023 23:59

😂 you really haven’t been keeping up then
every celebrity is left wing pretty much

every author

most heads of chairtys
most heads of intuitions like universities
most sports people

Well, there's at least one group of people, who usually AREN'T left-wing:

Bankers.

Thatgirl1981 · 11/07/2023 23:59

ToWhitToWhoo · 11/07/2023 22:18

Yet if was just because they are PEP then we'd see as many left wingers as right wingers beign affected.

How do you know they're not? The right wingers (or certain ones) may just be making more fuss about it.

Also, on the whole, leftists are less likely to be seeking to open accounts tailored to the super-rich.

I think a lot of this is just that Nigel F. isn't quite as super-rich as he'd like to be.

😂 you really haven’t been keeping up then
every celebrity is left wing pretty much

every author

most heads of chairtys
most heads of intuitions like universities
most sports people

ToWhitToWhoo · 11/07/2023 22:18

Yet if was just because they are PEP then we'd see as many left wingers as right wingers beign affected.

How do you know they're not? The right wingers (or certain ones) may just be making more fuss about it.

Also, on the whole, leftists are less likely to be seeking to open accounts tailored to the super-rich.

I think a lot of this is just that Nigel F. isn't quite as super-rich as he'd like to be.

Wenfy · 11/07/2023 21:33

Thatgirl1981 · 11/07/2023 21:27

Should they be allowed to refuse black people ? I assume you agree we me not being able to bank

Yorkshire Building Society like most building societies in the UK DID refuse black and Asian people as well as women in the past. That’s why they’re doing this now. As many have created strict rules as a result.

Thatgirl1981 · 11/07/2023 21:27

Florenz · 08/07/2023 19:57

Banks are private businesses, they should be allowed to refuse to do business with whoever they want.

Should they be allowed to refuse black people ? I assume you agree we me not being able to bank

Thatgirl1981 · 11/07/2023 21:26

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 08/07/2023 20:29

Political views are not a protected class, so no, that's not true.

I assume you're assuming "belief" covers political views, but I've yet to see anyone make this stand up in court. Even deeply held philosophical beliefs, like veganism, aren't really protected.

https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights

So if your ok if the water company switches your water of because they believe your a twat then

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 08/07/2023 21:15

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 08/07/2023 20:29

Political views are not a protected class, so no, that's not true.

I assume you're assuming "belief" covers political views, but I've yet to see anyone make this stand up in court. Even deeply held philosophical beliefs, like veganism, aren't really protected.

https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights

Agreed; "religion or belief" was intended to cover people with beliefs that have similarities with religion, but are not organised religion - such as pagans, humanists, atheists and similar.

"Belief" was never intended to include flat earthers, transphobes, anti vaxxers or brexiteers.

No Doubt you will be the first to complain when a company refuses to do business with you for your regressive misogynistic views.

My views are not regressive or misogynistic; you are simply refusing to accept that you are on the wrong side of history.

However, I wouldn't knowingly have given my trade to an organisation that was transphobic or homophobic. If they turned down my business, I'd consider it a narrow escape.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 08/07/2023 20:29

EuripidesEumenides · 30/06/2023 17:45

No they really can't decide not to do business with anyone for any reason anymore. That's why you don't see signs saying "No Dogs. No Blacks. No Irish." these days.

Discrimination against political views is illegal in precisely the same way as discrimination against sexuality, race, religion or disability.

Political views are not a protected class, so no, that's not true.

I assume you're assuming "belief" covers political views, but I've yet to see anyone make this stand up in court. Even deeply held philosophical beliefs, like veganism, aren't really protected.

https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights

Florenz · 08/07/2023 19:57

Banks are private businesses, they should be allowed to refuse to do business with whoever they want.

GreekDogRescue · 08/07/2023 19:54

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 02/07/2023 00:13

It's a private business and they have the right to take or refuse business as they see fit.

I run a business and we have a clause in our T&C's that ensures we don't find ourselves providing services to, for instance, a fundraising event for a cause that I think would reflect badly on the business. There is a zero percent chance that I would provide services to a pro-Brexit, TERF or Tory fundraising event, for instance. If that means I lose money, I'm fine with that. I'd sooner sit on my behind and earn zilch than get involved with such a cause.

No Doubt you will be the first to complain when a company refuses to do business with you for your regressive misogynistic views.

Bromptotoo · 08/07/2023 18:33

topnoddy · 08/07/2023 17:20

Wasn't Farage's account closed because he had got enough money to have a Coutts account ?

That seems to be the case but being an outspoken person with a large public profile and with people alleging links to dodgy money, whether from Russia or elsewhere, may be in the mix too. Dodgy politician and not enough money are not binary alternatives!!

I'm still waiting for a properly evidenced story, covered across media whether the Mail or The Guardian, of an ordinary person - rather than a campaign group - having their bank to tell them, in the nicest possible way, to sod off solely on account of controversial views whether on Brexit, Gender or anything else.

topnoddy · 08/07/2023 17:20

Wasn't Farage's account closed because he had got enough money to have a Coutts account ?

Exasperatednow · 05/07/2023 21:06

If I was a conspiracy theorist (like Farage), I'd begin to think that mumsnet had been infiltrated by motivated conspiracy theorists given the posters who have recently popped up on a couple of recent threads (including this one).

Swipe left for the next trending thread