Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yorkshire Building Society closing accounts down on people with views that don't agree with their policy

310 replies

Summer2023hasarrived · 30/06/2023 17:06

So the story goes that if you have a view on Brexit or LGBTQ?+ that isn't inline or in agreement with the people that know what view is right at The Yorkshire Building Society then they can close your account?

AIBU - stick to the day job and provide mortgages and savings

YABU - they can decide if the values of their customers don't align to shut them down

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
27
PilsAwfulDilemna · 31/07/2023 13:39

I don't understand the voting system but no.
They should not be closing down accounts like this no!

Summer2023hasarrived · 31/07/2023 13:16

Bosky · 29/07/2023 02:52

I was in the minority who voted Remain in the Referendum. Leave won. I accept that. I always believed there should have been a 2/3 majority to overturn the status quo but it was set as a simple majority and I accept that too. That's having respect for democracy.

The referendum was 2016 - seven years ago.

It has been reported that there were over 80 references to Brexit in the 40 pages of Coutts' Committee records relating to the Bank's decision to boot Farage.

That sounds like an obsession. And a worrying disrespect for the democracy of a country whose taxpayers bailed out NatWest to the tune of £45bn in 2008 and whose Government owns nearly 40% of its shares.

I am not surprised that Farage and Miller, uber-Brexiteer and uber-Remainer, are united on the issue of political interference by Banks.

Miller has a weak argument since Monzo has a policy of refusing all Political Party bank accounts.

However, what Monzo demonstrates is that, without legislation or significant shareholding to compel Banks to offer services to political parties, that Banks have the power to determine whether we have ANY political parties.

No wonder their authoritarian, moralistic staff have a disrespect for democracy and think they are above the law.

Very true.

OP posts:
Bosky · 29/07/2023 02:52

I was in the minority who voted Remain in the Referendum. Leave won. I accept that. I always believed there should have been a 2/3 majority to overturn the status quo but it was set as a simple majority and I accept that too. That's having respect for democracy.

The referendum was 2016 - seven years ago.

It has been reported that there were over 80 references to Brexit in the 40 pages of Coutts' Committee records relating to the Bank's decision to boot Farage.

That sounds like an obsession. And a worrying disrespect for the democracy of a country whose taxpayers bailed out NatWest to the tune of £45bn in 2008 and whose Government owns nearly 40% of its shares.

I am not surprised that Farage and Miller, uber-Brexiteer and uber-Remainer, are united on the issue of political interference by Banks.

Miller has a weak argument since Monzo has a policy of refusing all Political Party bank accounts.

However, what Monzo demonstrates is that, without legislation or significant shareholding to compel Banks to offer services to political parties, that Banks have the power to determine whether we have ANY political parties.

No wonder their authoritarian, moralistic staff have a disrespect for democracy and think they are above the law.

Summer2023hasarrived · 28/07/2023 17:19

Swrigh1234 · 21/07/2023 07:45

Oops, half the comments on this thread didn’t age well, did they.

A lot of egg on a lot faces. The workesters have gone very quiet.

Indeed, they saw his name, saw a DM link and immediately jumped on the he is a liar, the DM isn't a reliable source surely use a better one and various other comments.

I don't like him but it's clear that banks lie. The CEO has resigned due to her and the actions of the bank she represented. He has been apologised to and others say they also have accounts closed by a number of banks. Those are the ones that don't mind coming forward.

Since when are banks there to moralise they should stick to banking. He isn't heading up a terrorist cell just has views on things like LGBTQ?+ etc that many don't support and some views Brexit that lots voted for.

OP posts:
ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 15:29

Gina Miller has thanked Farage for his tweet

twitter.com/thatginamiller/status/1684924476004134912?s=46&t=WHoOZ_3Kv5G6-FyQuvE0LQ

ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 14:39

Farage disagrees with it and says he stands with Gina Miller. Is he being obtuse? Is she?

https://twitter.com/nigelfarage/status/1684916350207066112?s=46&t=WHoOZZ_3Kv5G6-FyQuvE0LQ

"This is just plain wrong at every level. I stand with @ thatginamiller."

Two people at opposite ends of the Brexit debate, affected by the same issue. You don't have to agree with someone else's views to realise that what's going on, stinks.

Flickersy · 28/07/2023 12:16

ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 11:34

What is a political bank account and why did they first do business with her?

What happens to us as a society in terms of a plurality of views and debate, if no pressure groups or political groups can open bank accounts?

Political groups and parties can open bank accounts.

The accounts they use are more stringently regulated than your average current account.

Not all banks offer this service - Monzo apparently being one of them.

It is clear the account was opened in error and Monzo should have rejected the application. But now they've realised the error it is rectified.

Againstmachine · 28/07/2023 11:49

ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 11:34

What is a political bank account and why did they first do business with her?

What happens to us as a society in terms of a plurality of views and debate, if no pressure groups or political groups can open bank accounts?

A political bank account is for a political party.

Plenty of groups can open bank accounts.

Stop being obtuse

ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 11:34

What is a political bank account and why did they first do business with her?

What happens to us as a society in terms of a plurality of views and debate, if no pressure groups or political groups can open bank accounts?

Againstmachine · 28/07/2023 11:23

ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 11:19

Not really this is a political bank account which monzo does not allow.

ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 11:19

Also happening to pressure groups

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/28/gina-millers-political-party-bank-account-to-be-shut-monzo/

ResisterRex · 28/07/2023 11:12

It has been happening to ordinary people:

www.jamesesses.com/p/exclusive-evidence-reveals-big-bank

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/saving/article-12340459/CRANE-CASE-vulnerable-laws-got-debanked-HSBC.html?aids

If you stand for nothing, you'll fall for anything. The SAR on Farage shows they had no reason to debank him, other than they didn't like what he said in public.

Do you think free speech is important or not? Do you think banks have the right to decide whether they like your personal views or not? What happens once we've all be cowed into never saying the wrong thing, think it'll stop there? Of course it won't.

There is now reportedly a 10,000 strong FB group of people considering submitting their own SAR. Those take a few weeks so this story could run and run.

Think it couldn't happen to you? It could. If I had SM accounts, I'd be closing them and requesting all my data was scrubbed under the right to be forgotten.

PatientZorro · 28/07/2023 10:24

ilovesooty · 30/06/2023 17:17

This is hardly going to apply to average people not in the public eye.

Clickbait.

Except of course that it has been happening to ordinary people not in the public eye

WorldCuppa · 27/07/2023 00:04

Yorkshire Building Society today declined to comment on the case but a spokesman said: 'We do not close savings accounts based on different opinions regarding beliefs. We would only make the difficult decision to close a savings account if a customer is rude, abusive, violent or discriminates in any way, based on the specific facts and behaviour in each case.'
YABU for believing anything that crock of shite writes.

Summer2023hasarrived · 26/07/2023 23:25

cakeorwine · 04/07/2023 19:18

Farage may have lied. As for the others claiming similar practices including the vicar because he complained about the number of Pride flags? Who knows. There are a number of people now reporting similar problems with banks

But your thread clearly states that people are being closed down because of their views?

You read something, it obviously pushed a button inside you, and you reacted and decided to start a thread claiming that this had happened.

It's easy to do. It's easy to read something, take it as truth, especially if it appeals to your beliefs and to spread it.

It appears that banks really do close accounts for the reasons Farage claimed. The head of Coutts has apologised and resigned. He is milking it now because what he said was true.

@cakeorwine you say it is easy to take something as truth and if it appeals to beliefs then spread it as truth. Well it WAS true. Some people just assume things are fake because they don't like the person who states it happened. It appealed to your view and you ran with the narrative that he must be lying.... 😂

OP posts:
Summer2023hasarrived · 26/07/2023 23:18

grannysmithspips · 22/07/2023 17:15

I absolutely agree. Don't know why anybody has apologised to him.

I think they apologised to him because they were wrong to:

  1. release his private information
  2. to release incorrect information to the BBC
  3. to close an account because they don't like his views (not illegal views)

I think that's why they apologise. That's also why the head of Coutts Bank resigned. That's why the story is running. Some people may not like the source of the original story and therefore rubbish it, however, it turned out to be true.

OP posts:
grannysmithspips · 22/07/2023 17:15

RedToothBrush · 19/07/2023 17:48

Farage remains a grifter and dangerous.

Hth.

I absolutely agree. Don't know why anybody has apologised to him.

Bosky · 21/07/2023 13:53

ToWhitToWhoo · 19/07/2023 17:47

There is a difference between refusing a person an account because of some disagreement and refusing to bankroll a campaign to which one objects.

I suspect that Farage is deliberately blurring the line between the two.

If you think that banks should not be able to refuse to fund campaigns, fine, but then you lose your right to object if they fund Extinction Rebellion/ Just Stop Oil/ Stonewall/ the Communist Party/ etc.

Some confusion here. There is a difference between a bank refusing a person to to have an account with them, which has a knock-on effect of them being able to have an account with any bank, and a financial institution bankrolling a political campaign.

"Bankrolling: To provide financing, whether as a loan, grant, or simply as part of a budget. For example, a company may bankroll its research and development by providing funding for it in the budget. Likewise, a credit union bankrolls a business when it allows a client to take out a second mortgage on a home"

https://financial-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/bankrolling

It is the difference between providing finance (loan, overdraft, mortgage, etc.) and providing the most basic financial service provided by a bank, ie. an account.

Ironically, given that definition, Coutts considered whether there was justification to close Farage's account when he had paid off his mortgage. If it thought that he was going to fund a political campaign which it did not like by taking out a second mortgage then they could refuse to provide him with another mortgage at that point. Whether or not that was his intention if indeed he did seek another mortgage, he could then, if he wished, try to move his account and/or seek an alternative source of finance.

The action of closing someone's bank account seriously limits their ability to open a bank account elsewhere - to the point of preventing them from having a bank account for any reason, personal or campaigning.

Since the issue you suggest is potential, legal, political campaigning it is therefore an action that penalises a person for expression of their personal political beliefs that goes well beyond the remit of an individual financial institution. It triggers a blacklisting reaction across the financial sector that can start an avalanche subsuming families, friends, colleagues and acquaintances, it is undemocratic and possibly in breach of the Equality Act 2010, GDPR and goodness knows what other legislation and regulations.

Another example of knock-on effects is cited by Simon Heffer (the historian, journalist and author who wrote vile lies about the Hillsborough disaster so, for the avoidance of doubt, I am not a fan of Heffer either):

How I was nearly ‘de-banked’ because of my friendship with Nigel Farage
The former Ukip leader's friendships appear to have been shared right across the financial services industry

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/07/20/simon-heffer-coutts-friends-with-nigel-farage-debanked/

(Open access but It has been archived at Archive Today if it goes behind a paywall).

If concern about NF re-mortgaging is the real reason for Coutts closing NF's account, they do not say so. They also do not argue that allowing NF to have an account with them has actually caused them any "reputational damage". That would be difficult to argue as justification and would also open up the can of worms about who they have been happy to let bank with them and who and what they have bankrolled.

To repeat, I am not a fan of Farage.

There are some campaigns that I think are worthwhile and some that I would not support. Some are clearly bankrolled by banks, corporations, tax-payer funded grant-giving organisations and charities, some allegedly "grassroots" campaigns are astroturfed by private philanthropy, while others really are supported only by individuals with limited resources digging into their pockets.

Most people, myself included, would be delighted if Banks stopped disregarding the needs of ordinary customers to provide accessible services offline.

"NatWest Group to close 142 bank branches in 2023"
Find out if your local bank branch will be shutting its doors
10 July 2023
https://www.which.co.uk/news/article/natwest-group-bank-branch-closures-in-2023-aXUN72y5QXYk

When they treat high-profile customers with such contempt you can be sure that they are going to treat ordinary customers far worse. What really takes the biscuit is that tax-payers bailed out the Banks and the Government still holds nearly 40% shares in Nat West.

They have fucked-up big time yet again.

NatWest goof is a boon for sketchy bank clients
21 July 2023
https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/natwest-goof-is-boon-sketchy-bank-clients-2023-07-21/

The NatWest Group logo is seen in this illustration taken March 12, 2023. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration

Breakingviews - NatWest goof is a boon for sketchy bank clients

A row between right-wing talking head Nigel Farage and UK bank NatWest could have much broader consequences. Late on Thursday, CEO Alison Rose apologised to Farage after closing his account, while the UK government said it would force lenders to respec...

https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/natwest-goof-is-boon-sketchy-bank-clients-2023-07-21

Swrigh1234 · 21/07/2023 07:45

Oops, half the comments on this thread didn’t age well, did they.

A lot of egg on a lot faces. The workesters have gone very quiet.

MissingMoominMamma · 20/07/2023 21:33

On this premise alone, I’d open an account with them.

But I think they might have apologised to Farage??

FedgeHund · 20/07/2023 21:29

LlynTegid · 20/07/2023 21:23

Whilst the government have said they will act, at least to ensure a basic bank account is available to all, and for account closures to have notice, I am not sure they will go through with it. They have on several issues been all talk and no action.

Notice they acted on the day of three by-elections, perhaps hoping to minimise their losses.

I agree this government is all talk and no baggy trousers.

LlynTegid · 20/07/2023 21:23

Whilst the government have said they will act, at least to ensure a basic bank account is available to all, and for account closures to have notice, I am not sure they will go through with it. They have on several issues been all talk and no action.

Notice they acted on the day of three by-elections, perhaps hoping to minimise their losses.

FOJN · 20/07/2023 20:55

50 percentage of the population have a below average IQ. Or are just too bloody lazy to fact check. Or like the narrative because it matches their world view so don't seek an alternative explanation in case it undermines their world view.

Well this is awkward. Do we have a case of confession through projection?

EuripidesEumenides · 20/07/2023 20:43

ToWhitToWhoo · 19/07/2023 17:47

There is a difference between refusing a person an account because of some disagreement and refusing to bankroll a campaign to which one objects.

I suspect that Farage is deliberately blurring the line between the two.

If you think that banks should not be able to refuse to fund campaigns, fine, but then you lose your right to object if they fund Extinction Rebellion/ Just Stop Oil/ Stonewall/ the Communist Party/ etc.

I'm not sure it's that clear cut. EAD Solicitors and others vs Abrams EAT 2015 found discrimination against an organisation could potentially breach the Equality Act if it's effectively a proxy for discriminating against a particular person within the organisation and by extension that person's beliefs.

Moneynewpence · 20/07/2023 20:35

Summer2023hasarrived · 30/06/2023 17:06

So the story goes that if you have a view on Brexit or LGBTQ?+ that isn't inline or in agreement with the people that know what view is right at The Yorkshire Building Society then they can close your account?

AIBU - stick to the day job and provide mortgages and savings

YABU - they can decide if the values of their customers don't align to shut them down

It's made up victimcosplay by people with repellent views.