Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to tell you that First Direct closed bank account of gender critical blogger

262 replies

Snorkers · 30/06/2023 16:05

https://twitter.com/WingsScotland/status/1673371351942307840

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1673371351942307840.html

Who's next? What other beliefs are no longer allowed to partake in society?

https://twitter.com/WingsScotland/status/1673371351942307840

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 14:26

In the Handmaid's Tale the Gilead regime overpowered women by suddenly removing their access to money.

Thats an excellent point

pointythings · 01/07/2023 14:25

@TheKeatingFive my DC is an adult. They don't agree with puberty blockers for children. They also don't agree that trans = mental illness. Both things are extremes.

OMG12 · 01/07/2023 14:24

MySugarBabyLove · 30/06/2023 16:46

There will absolutely be more to this. I mean there’s gender critical and then there’s being a proponent of hate speech.

If e.g. said blogger abused members of staff for instance, I know of a financial institution who launched a pride campaign recently and the person at the centre of it was harassed and attacked by so-called gender critical people, seeking out details about their home life, publishing their address on social media, I don’t care if you’re gender critical, behaving like that isn’t free speech.

Nigel farage has links to Russian money, it’s entirely possible that there is a UN sanction against his name, in which case the banks have no choice.

So yeah, I call bollocks. But why not whip up a frenzy eh?

So where do you stand on JK Rowling and all the people who have been Doxed for their gender critical beliefs? Presumably you agree that any of the trans community who has done that should have their bank accounts closed

MargotBamborough · 01/07/2023 14:23

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 14:19

In terms of ideologies, banks are businesses. They don't have to keep you as a customer if they don't want to.

Banks are necessary for modern life. It is not reasonable for them to be only accessible to those with in vogue beliefs.

This.

What if all banks collectively decided not to provide services to anyone who expressed beliefs they disagree with, such as the belief that biological sex is binary and immutable which is a fact, not a belief?

Nobody can participate in society without banking services. They'd effectively be banning the expression of that belief.

Why should banks have the right to do that?

This is sinister.

Oh and by the way, it's straight out of dystopia fiction.

In the Handmaid's Tale the Gilead regime overpowered women by suddenly removing their access to money.

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 14:22

Hands could be feet in ten years time.

That (of course) sounds ludicrous, but who the fuck knows, given what's happened with 'gender'.

Its all getting very Orwellian - I keep coming back to this

The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 14:19

In terms of ideologies, banks are businesses. They don't have to keep you as a customer if they don't want to.

Banks are necessary for modern life. It is not reasonable for them to be only accessible to those with in vogue beliefs.

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 14:16

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 14:07

The point is, that it doesn't matter what flavour of victim it is.

Exactly.

Who could have imagined, 10 years ago, that saying men can't become women would have you accused of bigotry, transphobia, open to being 'cancelled' or dismissed from your job? Not me.

So who knows what kind of beliefs are next to be deemed offensive and merit the same treatment?

It was all a big joke 10 years ago with a tiny proportion of unwell men people didn't bother.

Hands could be feet in ten years time.

I am baffled at the terror of a few prayers and terror of parents talking to their children about people with very new ideologies keen on keeping children in a permanent pre pubescent state.

pointythings · 01/07/2023 14:14

@AlisonDonut you don't know that Farage and Tice don't have proceedings against them. The banks are not allowed to say anything. Those investigating certainly wouldn't say anything.

In terms of ideologies, banks are businesses. They don't have to keep you as a customer if they don't want to. They aren't allowed to discriminate on any protected characteristic, but political beliefs are not protected so they can ditch any account they want to - whether it belongs to a GC extremist or a TRA extremist. That is legal. Frankly I don't like the extremists on either side - I'm the parent of someone who is trans and the rhetoric from both sides makes me sick. My DC feels the same.

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 14:07

The point is, that it doesn't matter what flavour of victim it is.

Exactly.

Who could have imagined, 10 years ago, that saying men can't become women would have you accused of bigotry, transphobia, open to being 'cancelled' or dismissed from your job? Not me.

So who knows what kind of beliefs are next to be deemed offensive and merit the same treatment?

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 14:03

Wouldn't that be against data protection and cast suspicion on individuals and companies who are ultimately innocent? Don't you think anyone whose bank account was closed for this reason would be jumping up and down in the press too?

There needs to be clear guidelines about what an appropriate reason to close a bank account would be. Which should only be financially related.

If they want to jump up and down to the press in those circs, they're welcome to, but at least everyone is clear that the motivation isn't around 'values' or 'wrongthink'

AlisonDonut · 01/07/2023 14:02

pointythings · 01/07/2023 13:58

@AlisonDonut I don't want to hand over anything. I'm just pointing out that in @FedgeHund 's example the bank was deemed to have got it wrong and paid compensation. The system worked. At the same time, banks have a responsibility laid down in law to make sure they are not complicit in illegal activities, and I'm fine with that - do you want your bank to be processing the proceeds of crime?

If an account is processing proceeds of crime, that would make it a police matter.

This is about people having their accounts cancelled because of pressure from activists for wrong think. Unless you think that Triggernometry were processing proceeds of crime?

By saying 'it only happens when red flagged or proceeds of crime' it also makes the person look guilty of a crime when all they did was not want pride flags in their face, or teens to have their breasts removed, or not want rapists in women's prisons and it then targets them in even more dangerous ways than the original thought crime.

pointythings · 01/07/2023 13:58

@AlisonDonut I don't want to hand over anything. I'm just pointing out that in @FedgeHund 's example the bank was deemed to have got it wrong and paid compensation. The system worked. At the same time, banks have a responsibility laid down in law to make sure they are not complicit in illegal activities, and I'm fine with that - do you want your bank to be processing the proceeds of crime?

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 13:56

People want to bring in a new ideology, a world view others disagree with, they want to outlaw parents, NHS staff and religious people from chatting to, praying with children and vulnerable adults with autism for instance.

Children who have been told that they are a soul trapped in in the wrong body, that they can change sex, that after a mastectomy their breasts will grow back with hormones like a males do, if they change their mind.

A man who isn't on board with this new ideology, deserved rape and death threats along with his bank account being removed ? 🤔

Even if he wants to pray with someone gay and both consent, why is the harm that gay man does to himself worse than the harm being done to a gay man given a penis inversion and castration with consent given to the NHS?

AlisonDonut · 01/07/2023 13:54

pointythings · 01/07/2023 13:46

@FedgeHund if a bank gets it wrong, there's nothing wrong with having a provision for compensation.

Mind you, the sooner they make all so called conversion therapy illegal, the better - and then this organisation would be engaged in illegal activities. All the evidence shows that conversion therapy is psychologically damaging - even when people engage in it willingly. You haven't picked the best flavour of victim here.

The point is, that it doesn't matter what flavour of victim it is.

I cannot believe some people are so willing to just hand over their rights and just shrug their shoulders, when the same situation could easily happen to them.

Baffling.

electriclight · 01/07/2023 13:50

"If they're investigating potentially criminal financial activity in the account, then they can say so."

Wouldn't that be against data protection and cast suspicion on individuals and companies who are ultimately innocent? Don't you think anyone whose bank account was closed for this reason would be jumping up and down in the press too?

They don't want to get into it and they don't have to give a reason. Everyone who takes out a bank account knows that and signs to agree to it. If you don't like it, put your money elsewhere.

electriclight · 01/07/2023 13:47

To @AlisonDonut

electriclight · 01/07/2023 13:47

No, I know that Barclays paid £20k settlement to avoid the far larger cost of going to court. It denied discrimination and asserted that it had a legal right to close any account with appropriate notice. They didn't apologise to Core Issues Trust (chief executive describes himself as ex-gay, huge widespread suspicion of conversion therapy) or reinstate their account.

They also sued Transport of London who removed their posters saying 'Not Gay. Post Gay. Ex Gay and Proud. Get over it!' And failed of course. So they are abhorrent, litigious and very prickly about being told they're wrong.

pointythings · 01/07/2023 13:46

@FedgeHund if a bank gets it wrong, there's nothing wrong with having a provision for compensation.

Mind you, the sooner they make all so called conversion therapy illegal, the better - and then this organisation would be engaged in illegal activities. All the evidence shows that conversion therapy is psychologically damaging - even when people engage in it willingly. You haven't picked the best flavour of victim here.

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 13:37

People are extremely naive to be dismissing this stuff. But people are naive, I guess 🤷‍♀️. Wait til it happens to them and they learn the hard way.

One simple step would be to require banks to provide a reason for closing an account - which they haven't done in these cases (or that's my understanding).

If they're investigating potentially criminal financial activity in the account, then they can say so. Reasons to do with 'values' are not appropriate. People cannot function without bank accounts, it's not ethical for banks to hold this kind of power over whether views are 'acceptable' or not.

AlisonDonut · 01/07/2023 13:27

electriclight · 01/07/2023 12:20

It makes me think of the people posting in community fb groups about they've been unfairly struck off by their GP or dentist, just because they (insert innocent behaviour here).

Meanwhile, the staff say nothing but have excellent reasons for seeing you on your way.

So here they are, whining about closed bank accounts just because...

But whipping up hatred and division amongst the gullible as they do it.

Sorry did you miss the report that Barclays paid off a Christian group whose account they closed due to being pressurised by an LGBT group?

The laws that protect them, protect all of us. That's the point.

electriclight · 01/07/2023 13:10

Why the fuck are you quoting me when you post these links?

Nothing to do with what I said. You have no idea what my views are on any topic.

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:29

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/michigan-house-passes-bill-that-could-make-using-wrong-pronouns-a-felony-fineable-up-to-10000/ar-AA1dgjCB

I guess rape victims can always try to catch out NHS staff for abusing them as the above article shows, later on when Labour comes into power and brings in legislation like this, by suddenly becoming a man and waiting for the slip of the tounge - revenge and compensation for the rape victim NHS staff abused.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/michigan-house-passes-bill-that-could-make-using-wrong-pronouns-a-felony-fineable-up-to-10000/ar-AA1dgjCB

FedgeHund · 01/07/2023 12:24

electriclight · 01/07/2023 12:20

It makes me think of the people posting in community fb groups about they've been unfairly struck off by their GP or dentist, just because they (insert innocent behaviour here).

Meanwhile, the staff say nothing but have excellent reasons for seeing you on your way.

So here they are, whining about closed bank accounts just because...

But whipping up hatred and division amongst the gullible as they do it.

https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/hospital-says-patient-could-not-26506744

Umbridge NHS staff who say "You must not tell lies"?

Hospital says patient wasn't raped because alleged attacker was transgender

The incident has drawn attention to the impact of self-ID in hospitals and other institutions like the police with Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne calling on Westministers Lords to scrap it.

https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/hospital-says-patient-could-not-26506744

electriclight · 01/07/2023 12:20

It makes me think of the people posting in community fb groups about they've been unfairly struck off by their GP or dentist, just because they (insert innocent behaviour here).

Meanwhile, the staff say nothing but have excellent reasons for seeing you on your way.

So here they are, whining about closed bank accounts just because...

But whipping up hatred and division amongst the gullible as they do it.