Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to tell you that First Direct closed bank account of gender critical blogger

262 replies

Snorkers · 30/06/2023 16:05

https://twitter.com/WingsScotland/status/1673371351942307840

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1673371351942307840.html

Who's next? What other beliefs are no longer allowed to partake in society?

https://twitter.com/WingsScotland/status/1673371351942307840

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 11:35

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2023 11:23

Perhaps the media you read is part of your problem?

I like to read a wide range of outlets to try and get a better picture.

You seem a bit triggered, maybe have a cup of tea and a sit down?

Well so far I've read articles from the Telegraph, Mail, Express, Times, and on the FSU's own LinkedIn page, none of which have mentioned anything about being him asked for feedback or a settlement. I'd like to get a left leaning viewpoint but it appears to be mainly right leaning outlets running with this story. But I am always happy to read far and wide so please share your links and ill gladly read them.

It's very interesting that rather than engage with any of the points I raised in reply to your previous post you've chosen to try and minimise and dismiss me as triggered, why is that? I appreciate being challenged isn't always fun but don't you want to defend your views?

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2023 11:26

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 02/07/2023 10:22

For the love of god will someone tell me what a person will do to manage if they have no bank account and clearly lots and lots of businesses are moving to cashless? How will you actually live if the government move us on to a cashless society?

You can't. That's why the activists are going for the banks. The Denton's document detailed that they needed to get into all the organisations and institutions so that they could control the public and private sphere. This is a feature, not a bug.

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2023 11:23

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 10:35

Where did you see that he was asked for feedback or recieved a settlement? The articles I've seen so far suggest he proactively wrote to YBS to complain about their messaging around Pride, using their online feedback portal, not that they asked him to comment.

Interestingly, I see the reverend runs a business where christians can meet to discuss relgion, renewal and worship. I wonder if I write to him to complain about his messaging around christ if he will he let me join his meetings in future? Do you think he'd give me a platform to express my deeply held belief that organised religion is both idiotic and dangerous or is it only his beliefs that should be considered and shared wherever he wants?

In either case here's a nice free tip for anyone worried about this sort of thing.

"Keep your mouth shut unless you're in an appropriate setting."

I'm not sure why so many people still believe that they have a right to express their views to anyone, anywhere, at anytime. The equality act only protects beliefs, not views or opinions, and only if they meet a certain criteria. Freedom of expression does cover views and opinions but, it only protects from interference from state (and even then there are limitations), it doesn't give you carte blanche to say what you want without consequence.

In short you do not have a right to say what you want in any setting without facing potentially negative consequences.

Perhaps the media you read is part of your problem?

I like to read a wide range of outlets to try and get a better picture.

You seem a bit triggered, maybe have a cup of tea and a sit down?

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 11:03

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 10:35

Where did you see that he was asked for feedback or recieved a settlement? The articles I've seen so far suggest he proactively wrote to YBS to complain about their messaging around Pride, using their online feedback portal, not that they asked him to comment.

Interestingly, I see the reverend runs a business where christians can meet to discuss relgion, renewal and worship. I wonder if I write to him to complain about his messaging around christ if he will he let me join his meetings in future? Do you think he'd give me a platform to express my deeply held belief that organised religion is both idiotic and dangerous or is it only his beliefs that should be considered and shared wherever he wants?

In either case here's a nice free tip for anyone worried about this sort of thing.

"Keep your mouth shut unless you're in an appropriate setting."

I'm not sure why so many people still believe that they have a right to express their views to anyone, anywhere, at anytime. The equality act only protects beliefs, not views or opinions, and only if they meet a certain criteria. Freedom of expression does cover views and opinions but, it only protects from interference from state (and even then there are limitations), it doesn't give you carte blanche to say what you want without consequence.

In short you do not have a right to say what you want in any setting without facing potentially negative consequences.

Why would you want to join the meetings of a religious group whose views you disagree with?

It's not like this is something you need to do.

Unlike, say, have a place to store your money and the ability to, you know, pay for stuff.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 10:35

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2023 09:12

I see you are not able to quote properly so I have no idea if the first sentence is a quote or not so I'm going to respond to the final one.

The Yorkshire Bank did indeed close the Reverend's account AFTER they asked for feedback and he responded saying that he didn't think they needed PRIDE posters/flags. [As they are a bank not a political party].

They gave him compensation AFTER he went to the Free Speech Union to take them to court and they didn't want this in court so they settled before it got there. They didn't think they had made a mistake.

So they have not publicly stated that they didn't close any accounts due to disagreeing with ideology, they paid him off to stop it going to court.

He didn't do anything apart from respond to THEIR request for feedback. As a customer for 17 years, is he not allowed to respond in a way he sees fit to their request for feedback?

Where did you see that he was asked for feedback or recieved a settlement? The articles I've seen so far suggest he proactively wrote to YBS to complain about their messaging around Pride, using their online feedback portal, not that they asked him to comment.

Interestingly, I see the reverend runs a business where christians can meet to discuss relgion, renewal and worship. I wonder if I write to him to complain about his messaging around christ if he will he let me join his meetings in future? Do you think he'd give me a platform to express my deeply held belief that organised religion is both idiotic and dangerous or is it only his beliefs that should be considered and shared wherever he wants?

In either case here's a nice free tip for anyone worried about this sort of thing.

"Keep your mouth shut unless you're in an appropriate setting."

I'm not sure why so many people still believe that they have a right to express their views to anyone, anywhere, at anytime. The equality act only protects beliefs, not views or opinions, and only if they meet a certain criteria. Freedom of expression does cover views and opinions but, it only protects from interference from state (and even then there are limitations), it doesn't give you carte blanche to say what you want without consequence.

In short you do not have a right to say what you want in any setting without facing potentially negative consequences.

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 10:25

To add to my previous post, if Nationwide were any other type of business I would remove my own custom and give them feedback as to why. I have done this with many other businesses which engage in political activism I do not wish to support.

But I can't really manage without banking services. No one can.

I am in a position of relative power over ordinary businesses in the sense that I can choose whether to give them my money or not. I have no power over banks because I do not have this choice and because they can properly fuck up my life if they choose not to provide their services to me.

That's why I think banks have a greater responsibility not to discriminate against any of their customers than other businesses.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 02/07/2023 10:22

For the love of god will someone tell me what a person will do to manage if they have no bank account and clearly lots and lots of businesses are moving to cashless? How will you actually live if the government move us on to a cashless society?

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 10:15

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2023 09:12

I see you are not able to quote properly so I have no idea if the first sentence is a quote or not so I'm going to respond to the final one.

The Yorkshire Bank did indeed close the Reverend's account AFTER they asked for feedback and he responded saying that he didn't think they needed PRIDE posters/flags. [As they are a bank not a political party].

They gave him compensation AFTER he went to the Free Speech Union to take them to court and they didn't want this in court so they settled before it got there. They didn't think they had made a mistake.

So they have not publicly stated that they didn't close any accounts due to disagreeing with ideology, they paid him off to stop it going to court.

He didn't do anything apart from respond to THEIR request for feedback. As a customer for 17 years, is he not allowed to respond in a way he sees fit to their request for feedback?

I bank with Nationwide.

I am usually not shy about expressing my opinions on this topic. Not long ago they ran an ad which was essentially celebrating the inclusion of trans women in women's sport, something I fundamentally disagree with.

But I don't live in the UK anymore, I moved to the EU. Quite a few UK banks have closed the accounts of their EU resident customers, and I'm not sure whether the ones which still provide banking services to EU resident customers will allow you to open a new account if you do not live in the UK.

If Nationwide close my account and send me a cheque for my (quite substantial) closing balance, I will not be able to bank it anywhere.

So I feel it is not safe for me to give this kind of feedback.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2023 09:58

There's over 10 years of it online. Do your own research.

You made the assertion, so you provide the evidence.

2ManyPjs · 02/07/2023 09:56

@TheKeatingFive There's over 10 years of it online. Do your own research.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2023 09:54

Wings is, and always has been a despicable misogynist.

That's not evidence though, is it?

2ManyPjs · 02/07/2023 09:50

HirplesWithHaggis · 01/07/2023 15:49

Please show your evidence that Wings has posted hate filled misogynistic rants, or similarly vitriolic posts about the gay community. I have been following his blog since about 2012 and his Twitter for almost as long, and have seen nothing of the sort.

Wings is, and always has been a despicable misogynist.

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2023 09:12

electriclight · 01/07/2023 15:34

"Mmmm, wrong. Businesses are bound by the equality act; they can’t deny services on discriminatory grounds (eg because of race, sex, belief)."

You can't discriminate against 'religion and belief' but that doesn't apply to any of the cases here.

Being a bigot isn't a protected characteristic.

And the banks have publicly stated that they didn't close any accounts due to disagreeing with ideology anyway.

I see you are not able to quote properly so I have no idea if the first sentence is a quote or not so I'm going to respond to the final one.

The Yorkshire Bank did indeed close the Reverend's account AFTER they asked for feedback and he responded saying that he didn't think they needed PRIDE posters/flags. [As they are a bank not a political party].

They gave him compensation AFTER he went to the Free Speech Union to take them to court and they didn't want this in court so they settled before it got there. They didn't think they had made a mistake.

So they have not publicly stated that they didn't close any accounts due to disagreeing with ideology, they paid him off to stop it going to court.

He didn't do anything apart from respond to THEIR request for feedback. As a customer for 17 years, is he not allowed to respond in a way he sees fit to their request for feedback?

PriOn1 · 02/07/2023 09:11

When I heard intact men were being placed in the women’s prison estate in the UK, I didn’t believe it. I thought the UK was too rational.

When I heard the NHS used puberty blockers and transitioned children in various irreversible ways, I assumed those things must be well-evidenced.

I wish I could be sanguine over this and assume it was nonsense being pedalled by scaremongers but unfortunately I can no longer dismiss such claims out of hand.

I guess the upside is that this time, it is getting press attention while it is still only affecting a few people. There are now sufficient media outlets which are interested in everything related to this topic being exposed so that if it progresses, it will be subjected to scrutiny in a way that the prison service and the NHS weren’t. It certainly isn’t beyond the realm of possibility that there is someone at high level influencing banking policy. It wouldn’t be the first time.

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 07:51

I doubt anything will be done.

Schools continue with mixed sex toilets, NHS continues with Annexe B and the armed forces will throw out good staff to please those who deny biological reality. Our chances of war comes are way are bad, throwing away sensible men.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12255015/Soldier-saved-lives-Afghanistan-forced-quit-Army-agreeing-men-women.html

Hero soldier shot down by cancel culture

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: The horrors of the battlefield are as fresh for Colonel Dr Kelvin Wright today as they were at the height of the Afghan conflict.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12255015/Soldier-saved-lives-Afghanistan-forced-quit-Army-agreeing-men-women.html

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 06:13

Thanks, @MargotBamborough . I do remember reading that, legally, these contracts can't make you sign away your rights. In the same way that NDAs can't be used to cover up crimes, etc. But I'd forgotten. Thanks for the reminder. I think it's a shocking situation for people to be in.

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 05:48

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 05:21

No need to be so testy. You gave info about T&Cs. I just added an opinion that T&Cs shouldn't be able to be used to escape proper scrutiny and responsibility. I neither agreed or disagreed with you because I didn't actually think that your post gave an opinion either way. It was just pointing out a fact.

T&Cs are frequently full of terms which wouldn't stand up in a court of law. They're non negotiated contracts where the already final terms are presented by one party to the other on a "take it or leave it" basis. The party whose terms they are generally relies on the fact that the other party won't read them, or if they do they won't understand them, or if they do they won't know that some of them are unenforceable, and even if they do they're very unlikely to take it to court.

In reality you can put whatever you like in your contract but there are certain legal obligations you can't contract out of, particularly when you are a business contracting with consumers. The bigger and more powerful you are compared to your customers, and the more they need whatever it is you are providing from either you or one of your competitors, the more responsibility you have towards them.

So yeah. It's not just your opinion. What you say is correct.

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 05:21

RiverGate33 · 02/07/2023 00:35

Thanks for your reply to my reply to another point entirely. Thank you also for bringing these facts to my attention. Having lived under a rock since 1992, I was unaware that a bank account was necessary to navigate in society or that it was imperative that i should list my own opinion on this fact with my original reply lest another poster might assume I don't have one.

No need to be so testy. You gave info about T&Cs. I just added an opinion that T&Cs shouldn't be able to be used to escape proper scrutiny and responsibility. I neither agreed or disagreed with you because I didn't actually think that your post gave an opinion either way. It was just pointing out a fact.

SueVineer · 02/07/2023 01:06

Gracewithoutend · 01/07/2023 16:57

Actually we have a small number of banks closing a handful of accounts, just as they have always been able to do.
Why ignore the banks saying 'erm no actually it is nothing to do with their ideology' - because banks are liars while Nigel Farage et al are not?

Why ignore it? Because if they don't give the real reason why they closed the accounts, how can anyone fight it, or even rectify it? Even if it were criminality, they should have to outline reasons. And there are so many it happens to, I don't believe they're all lying about not getting reasons. It's not just famous people it happens to and its not only a handful.

It's all reminiscent of universities student organisations starting to deplatform people with views they dudnt like. At first, people shrugged because they didn't like and didn't agree with the people they were deplatforming so it wasn't anything to be concerned about. And then suddenly it affects someone they do like or agree with and it's all very different.

We should fight for the rights for everyone just in case one day it's our rights that are being affected.

This. We must fight for free speech even if we disagree with what is being said

RiverGate33 · 02/07/2023 00:35

Thanks for your reply to my reply to another point entirely. Thank you also for bringing these facts to my attention. Having lived under a rock since 1992, I was unaware that a bank account was necessary to navigate in society or that it was imperative that i should list my own opinion on this fact with my original reply lest another poster might assume I don't have one.

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 00:07

I'm just adding to your facts.

RiverGate33 · 02/07/2023 00:03

I don't recall mentioning anything about right or wrong, just the facts.

Gracewithoutend · 01/07/2023 22:24

Read the Ts and Cs of you current/savings account. When you open an account you accept the terms and conditions of the bank One of which is that your provider reserves the right to terminate your accounts for whatever reason they see fit as long as they give notice .

It might be that the bank hasn't broken the law but it doesn't make it right. Apart from a very few people, we can't live without bank accounts. It just isn't possible anymore. That works out in the favour of banks. Therefore they should have responsibilities. And it doesn't seem asking too much to want an explanation of why your account is being closed. I guess they don't want to have to prove anything so they can't get sued, etc, for mistakes or high-handedness. But that shouldn't be a problem because they shouldnt be doing it without having solid evidence to show you.

RiverGate33 · 01/07/2023 22:06

Read the Ts and Cs of you current/savings account. When you open an account you accept the terms and conditions of the bank One of which is that your provider reserves the right to terminate your accounts for whatever reason they see fit as long as they give notice .

HirplesWithHaggis · 01/07/2023 21:42

Trez1510 · 01/07/2023 20:28

My more educated friends would be embarrassed to know anyone who posts on this snakepit of a forum. I've certainly never told them I'm on here. So, no that doesn't work for me.

As for calling me out, nah! I've offered a solution. That's a solution that does not involve me giving a renowned misogynistic, homophobic, transphobic, megalomaniac any traffic to his rancid site.

You could quote all his vile, misogynistic, homophobic tweets, that wouldn't drive any traffic to his site, www.wingsoverscotland.com

Wings Over Scotland

The world's most-read Scottish politics website

http://www.wingsoverscotland.com

Swipe left for the next trending thread