Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to tell you that First Direct closed bank account of gender critical blogger

262 replies

Snorkers · 30/06/2023 16:05

https://twitter.com/WingsScotland/status/1673371351942307840

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1673371351942307840.html

Who's next? What other beliefs are no longer allowed to partake in society?

https://twitter.com/WingsScotland/status/1673371351942307840

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Imnotswallowingthat · 02/07/2023 21:32

The most galling thing is that these banks are quite happy to accept vast sums of dirty money from regimes such as Saudi or Qatar dressed up as business investment funds. Nice fees in it for them, no questions asked.

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 21:22

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 21:04

No, what I am saying is that people need to understand that they don't have a right to have their views heard by everyone, everywhere, all the time. There's a time and place for expressing opinions.

I've managed to go my entire adult life without being barred from places or having accounts closed down, despite holding strong views that often go against the mainstream, simply by NOT writing to every organisation I disagree with or being stupid enough to post under my real name on social media.

If you're big / arrogant / stupid enough to air your opinions where they're neither wanted or asked for then you're big enough to deal with the consequences.

I also don't understand why you'd want to bank with / support an organisation who are diametrically opposed to your core beliefs when there are alternatives out there you could use?

What a lot of things you don't understand.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 21:04

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 14:15

You think ministers of the country's official religion àpeople who don't believe humans can change sex should be required to seek out niche financial institutions if they want to participate in the economy?

What the...?

No, what I am saying is that people need to understand that they don't have a right to have their views heard by everyone, everywhere, all the time. There's a time and place for expressing opinions.

I've managed to go my entire adult life without being barred from places or having accounts closed down, despite holding strong views that often go against the mainstream, simply by NOT writing to every organisation I disagree with or being stupid enough to post under my real name on social media.

If you're big / arrogant / stupid enough to air your opinions where they're neither wanted or asked for then you're big enough to deal with the consequences.

I also don't understand why you'd want to bank with / support an organisation who are diametrically opposed to your core beliefs when there are alternatives out there you could use?

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 20:34

Many of these investigatory bodies deal in intelligence, not evidence, evidence comes later. Shutting down a person of interest’s account is often done to see where they move their money to as much as to limit their financial agency.

if you worry about what FSIs get up
to you REALLY don’t want to hear about telcos!

Yeah, well, we went to war with Iraq based on intelligence - and the evidence never came later.

It's all very well them playing their little games of chess to see next moves, etc. It must be very interesting for them in their safe offices where their money and lives aren't threatened. What price do they pay when they've made a mistake? Er, that would be zippo. Where do people go for help? There's nowhere to go.

I do worry what these bodies get up to, as should everyone who is at their mercy - which is the entire country. I can't believe how insouciant people are over losing basic rights to faceless bureaucrats that you can't fight.

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 20:09

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 20:06

Many of these investigatory bodies deal in intelligence, not evidence, evidence comes later. Shutting down a person of interest’s account is often done to see where they move their money to as much as to limit their financial agency.

if you worry about what FSIs get up
to you REALLY don’t want to hear about telcos!

How is this relevant to the church minister who had his account closed?

He's not a politically exposed person, is he?

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 20:06

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 19:44

I understand that there are laws that dictate about not informing and tipping off. It might be that banks aren't breaking the law. But the law needs to be reformed. Honestly, if you're doing something illegal and the ban shuts your bank account, isn't that the biggest tip off of all? If someone's money laundering and the bank closes their account, do we really think they're scratching their heads and wondering if they'd made an off colour remark about trans people? Or are they going, shit, they're onto the money laundering.

These investigatory bodies should need to have evidence before they shut accounts. I know that that is frustrating and certainly there'd be no one standing up for any child trafficker not to have their account closed, but should we allow them to do that to catch these criminals when it means that innocent people lives are being destroyed and they have no way of defending themselves? If we allow bodies to shut bank accounts without evidence, mistakes are made. Does anybody seriously think that the police, etc, and the banks don't make mistakes?

The state, which includes all these financial authorities, have allowed the banks to exert huge power over our lives. We are completely controlled by them and can't exist without them. You can't operate any longer by keeping your money in the mattress. So if the state and the banks are going to have this huge power over our lives, they have to be more accountable. Just to close accounts without any explanation or given evidence is no longer justifiable because they're catching up all sorts of people in their nets that are innocent and have no recourse.

Murderers have more rights. There are legal requirements for arrests and detention times. But for banking customers there aren't. I know that sounds dramatic but honestly if you get trapped in the hole of not being able to pay any of your bills, not be able to get any wages, etc, it really is that dramatic and stressful.

Many of these investigatory bodies deal in intelligence, not evidence, evidence comes later. Shutting down a person of interest’s account is often done to see where they move their money to as much as to limit their financial agency.

if you worry about what FSIs get up
to you REALLY don’t want to hear about telcos!

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 19:56

AgathaSpencerGregson · 02/07/2023 19:44

If farage were on a restricted parties list I think we’d know about it. Those are publicly available.

I don’t know what a “restricted party” is. Farage is a PEP. As are all current and ex MPs and MEPs. Lists of PEPs are held by all financial institutions and are obviously not public.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 02/07/2023 19:44

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 19:14

In many cases, particularly in cases involving PEPs, banks cannot tell the account owner why the account is being closed, as doing so would in itself be a tipping off offence. If you get a notice from the FCA, or from the SFO, or from the security services telling you to close someone’s account, tipping them off as to why would be an invitation to a standup meeting with no coffee.

If farage were on a restricted parties list I think we’d know about it. Those are publicly available.

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 19:44

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 19:14

In many cases, particularly in cases involving PEPs, banks cannot tell the account owner why the account is being closed, as doing so would in itself be a tipping off offence. If you get a notice from the FCA, or from the SFO, or from the security services telling you to close someone’s account, tipping them off as to why would be an invitation to a standup meeting with no coffee.

I understand that there are laws that dictate about not informing and tipping off. It might be that banks aren't breaking the law. But the law needs to be reformed. Honestly, if you're doing something illegal and the ban shuts your bank account, isn't that the biggest tip off of all? If someone's money laundering and the bank closes their account, do we really think they're scratching their heads and wondering if they'd made an off colour remark about trans people? Or are they going, shit, they're onto the money laundering.

These investigatory bodies should need to have evidence before they shut accounts. I know that that is frustrating and certainly there'd be no one standing up for any child trafficker not to have their account closed, but should we allow them to do that to catch these criminals when it means that innocent people lives are being destroyed and they have no way of defending themselves? If we allow bodies to shut bank accounts without evidence, mistakes are made. Does anybody seriously think that the police, etc, and the banks don't make mistakes?

The state, which includes all these financial authorities, have allowed the banks to exert huge power over our lives. We are completely controlled by them and can't exist without them. You can't operate any longer by keeping your money in the mattress. So if the state and the banks are going to have this huge power over our lives, they have to be more accountable. Just to close accounts without any explanation or given evidence is no longer justifiable because they're catching up all sorts of people in their nets that are innocent and have no recourse.

Murderers have more rights. There are legal requirements for arrests and detention times. But for banking customers there aren't. I know that sounds dramatic but honestly if you get trapped in the hole of not being able to pay any of your bills, not be able to get any wages, etc, it really is that dramatic and stressful.

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 19:37

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 19:14

In many cases, particularly in cases involving PEPs, banks cannot tell the account owner why the account is being closed, as doing so would in itself be a tipping off offence. If you get a notice from the FCA, or from the SFO, or from the security services telling you to close someone’s account, tipping them off as to why would be an invitation to a standup meeting with no coffee.

How convenient for banks who wish to close the accounts of non politically exposed persons who happen to have views they disagree with without needing to give a reason why.

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 19:14

TheKeatingFive · 01/07/2023 13:37

People are extremely naive to be dismissing this stuff. But people are naive, I guess 🤷‍♀️. Wait til it happens to them and they learn the hard way.

One simple step would be to require banks to provide a reason for closing an account - which they haven't done in these cases (or that's my understanding).

If they're investigating potentially criminal financial activity in the account, then they can say so. Reasons to do with 'values' are not appropriate. People cannot function without bank accounts, it's not ethical for banks to hold this kind of power over whether views are 'acceptable' or not.

In many cases, particularly in cases involving PEPs, banks cannot tell the account owner why the account is being closed, as doing so would in itself be a tipping off offence. If you get a notice from the FCA, or from the SFO, or from the security services telling you to close someone’s account, tipping them off as to why would be an invitation to a standup meeting with no coffee.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 02/07/2023 18:59

Thank you @Gracewithoutend

You have articulated exactly how I feel.

If banks can do this there must be a ‘National’ bank where ostracised folk can have access to online banking services.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 02/07/2023 18:54

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 18:22

I really don't understand this attitude at all. I think its quite scary how unconcerned we are to give up rights that people have fought hundreds of years for. It's like free speech and people's rights can be put aside just because you don't like the beliefs of the man concerned.

If the guy went into a garden centre and expressed loudly that all their plants are manky and always are, so the garden centre banned him, I wouldn't bothered. You can live without plants and, anyway, there are loads of other garden centres he can go to.

But that's not the same with banks. Banks have made it that you can't live without a bank account. They've encouraged and incentivised cashless shops. I remember when they announced that cheques were being phased out. Ultimately, they had to row back on that but you can see how the wind is blowing. I live in a small town and we now have one bank that opens two mornings, 9-12, a week. To bank you need to be able to go online and some people can't do that. The banks have taken so much control of our lives, they should have an equal amount of responsibility on their shoulders. Because in many ways, banks are part of the state. They are controlling and directing how we handle one of the most important things in any society, money. They've made it's you can't live without them, that they are vital to your existence in uk society. And the banks run a sort of cabal so when you get refused at one bank, the others don't want to touch you either.

They have such immense power over our lives. They shouldn't have the right to close a bank account of someone because they don't like them or their views. They shouldn't have the ability to do that. And people like you who say everyone should just keep their opinions to themselves are setting up a scary future. That no one can fight or protest against an issue they don't agree with. You should be able to contact companies and express your views at their policies. Banks are entitled to ignore you but they shouldn't be entitled to blow up your life over it. The power imbalance is huge.

I've said before, it's like universities.

They ban Jacob Rees Mogg.
Thats OK, I don't like his politics.
They ban Boris Johnson.
That's OK. I don't like his politics and he's a tosser.
They ban JK Rowling.
That's OK, I...Wait a minute, thats shocking. I agree with her. They shouldn't be banning people.

We're now in a situation where not only can banks close your account, but they're not even obligated to give you a clear reason and evidence for that opinion. You can't reason with them or fight against them or prove yourself innocent because you have no idea why it's happened. And people shrug their shoulders and assume the customer must be at fault. But it could happen to any one us, indeed it has happened to some of us, and what happens to us then?

Totally agree with you Grace. Really there is nobody that can argue with your statement. x

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 18:44

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 18:22

I really don't understand this attitude at all. I think its quite scary how unconcerned we are to give up rights that people have fought hundreds of years for. It's like free speech and people's rights can be put aside just because you don't like the beliefs of the man concerned.

If the guy went into a garden centre and expressed loudly that all their plants are manky and always are, so the garden centre banned him, I wouldn't bothered. You can live without plants and, anyway, there are loads of other garden centres he can go to.

But that's not the same with banks. Banks have made it that you can't live without a bank account. They've encouraged and incentivised cashless shops. I remember when they announced that cheques were being phased out. Ultimately, they had to row back on that but you can see how the wind is blowing. I live in a small town and we now have one bank that opens two mornings, 9-12, a week. To bank you need to be able to go online and some people can't do that. The banks have taken so much control of our lives, they should have an equal amount of responsibility on their shoulders. Because in many ways, banks are part of the state. They are controlling and directing how we handle one of the most important things in any society, money. They've made it's you can't live without them, that they are vital to your existence in uk society. And the banks run a sort of cabal so when you get refused at one bank, the others don't want to touch you either.

They have such immense power over our lives. They shouldn't have the right to close a bank account of someone because they don't like them or their views. They shouldn't have the ability to do that. And people like you who say everyone should just keep their opinions to themselves are setting up a scary future. That no one can fight or protest against an issue they don't agree with. You should be able to contact companies and express your views at their policies. Banks are entitled to ignore you but they shouldn't be entitled to blow up your life over it. The power imbalance is huge.

I've said before, it's like universities.

They ban Jacob Rees Mogg.
Thats OK, I don't like his politics.
They ban Boris Johnson.
That's OK. I don't like his politics and he's a tosser.
They ban JK Rowling.
That's OK, I...Wait a minute, thats shocking. I agree with her. They shouldn't be banning people.

We're now in a situation where not only can banks close your account, but they're not even obligated to give you a clear reason and evidence for that opinion. You can't reason with them or fight against them or prove yourself innocent because you have no idea why it's happened. And people shrug their shoulders and assume the customer must be at fault. But it could happen to any one us, indeed it has happened to some of us, and what happens to us then?

This.

Gracewithoutend · 02/07/2023 18:22

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 10:35

Where did you see that he was asked for feedback or recieved a settlement? The articles I've seen so far suggest he proactively wrote to YBS to complain about their messaging around Pride, using their online feedback portal, not that they asked him to comment.

Interestingly, I see the reverend runs a business where christians can meet to discuss relgion, renewal and worship. I wonder if I write to him to complain about his messaging around christ if he will he let me join his meetings in future? Do you think he'd give me a platform to express my deeply held belief that organised religion is both idiotic and dangerous or is it only his beliefs that should be considered and shared wherever he wants?

In either case here's a nice free tip for anyone worried about this sort of thing.

"Keep your mouth shut unless you're in an appropriate setting."

I'm not sure why so many people still believe that they have a right to express their views to anyone, anywhere, at anytime. The equality act only protects beliefs, not views or opinions, and only if they meet a certain criteria. Freedom of expression does cover views and opinions but, it only protects from interference from state (and even then there are limitations), it doesn't give you carte blanche to say what you want without consequence.

In short you do not have a right to say what you want in any setting without facing potentially negative consequences.

I really don't understand this attitude at all. I think its quite scary how unconcerned we are to give up rights that people have fought hundreds of years for. It's like free speech and people's rights can be put aside just because you don't like the beliefs of the man concerned.

If the guy went into a garden centre and expressed loudly that all their plants are manky and always are, so the garden centre banned him, I wouldn't bothered. You can live without plants and, anyway, there are loads of other garden centres he can go to.

But that's not the same with banks. Banks have made it that you can't live without a bank account. They've encouraged and incentivised cashless shops. I remember when they announced that cheques were being phased out. Ultimately, they had to row back on that but you can see how the wind is blowing. I live in a small town and we now have one bank that opens two mornings, 9-12, a week. To bank you need to be able to go online and some people can't do that. The banks have taken so much control of our lives, they should have an equal amount of responsibility on their shoulders. Because in many ways, banks are part of the state. They are controlling and directing how we handle one of the most important things in any society, money. They've made it's you can't live without them, that they are vital to your existence in uk society. And the banks run a sort of cabal so when you get refused at one bank, the others don't want to touch you either.

They have such immense power over our lives. They shouldn't have the right to close a bank account of someone because they don't like them or their views. They shouldn't have the ability to do that. And people like you who say everyone should just keep their opinions to themselves are setting up a scary future. That no one can fight or protest against an issue they don't agree with. You should be able to contact companies and express your views at their policies. Banks are entitled to ignore you but they shouldn't be entitled to blow up your life over it. The power imbalance is huge.

I've said before, it's like universities.

They ban Jacob Rees Mogg.
Thats OK, I don't like his politics.
They ban Boris Johnson.
That's OK. I don't like his politics and he's a tosser.
They ban JK Rowling.
That's OK, I...Wait a minute, thats shocking. I agree with her. They shouldn't be banning people.

We're now in a situation where not only can banks close your account, but they're not even obligated to give you a clear reason and evidence for that opinion. You can't reason with them or fight against them or prove yourself innocent because you have no idea why it's happened. And people shrug their shoulders and assume the customer must be at fault. But it could happen to any one us, indeed it has happened to some of us, and what happens to us then?

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 14:57

And for what it's worth, I don't think even people from bizarre and hateful cults should be denied banking services.

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 14:56

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 14:46

You think ministers of the country's official religionàpeople who don't believe humans can change sex should be required to seek out niche financial institutions if they want to participate in the economy?

What the...?

Personally I don't agree with the Anglican church. I have to say many Catholics are looking on (we have our own issues in our church) at the woke new religion takeover of the CoE after they took our buildings and land when they were the new religion.

I still think that the man has the right to his own beliefs, nobody wants a return to Tudor times.

This talk of the woke wanting those who don't agree joining niche financial institutions and exclusion from standard across to money if they don't join the woke way - quite Biblical.

I was being a little facetious; I know that the majority of British people aren't religious.

But it's not as if the Anglican minister being denied banking services is from some bizarre and hateful cult. His views are mainstream.

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 14:46

You think ministers of the country's official religionàpeople who don't believe humans can change sex should be required to seek out niche financial institutions if they want to participate in the economy?

What the...?

Personally I don't agree with the Anglican church. I have to say many Catholics are looking on (we have our own issues in our church) at the woke new religion takeover of the CoE after they took our buildings and land when they were the new religion.

I still think that the man has the right to his own beliefs, nobody wants a return to Tudor times.

This talk of the woke wanting those who don't agree joining niche financial institutions and exclusion from standard across to money if they don't join the woke way - quite Biblical.

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 14:15

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 11:56

Are you really not spotting the irony in your question??

I wouldn't really want to join a meeting with a religious group whose views I don't share. I also wouldn't think it were my place to write to them and complain about their views or how they conduct their business.

So why did the reverend feel the need to do just that? He could have just stayed quiet and campaigned for his beliefs in an appropriate setting.

Presumably, he has been able to open a bank account elsewhere already, to deposit that alleged settlement, so all he needs to do in future is not express his views about how a business conducts itself or choose a bank that aligns with his views (although i would imagine even they do not want customers writing in moaning about how they operate constantly).

I mean it took me less than 10 seconds of googling to find Kingdom Bank, "a UK based Christian bank that offers Christians a unique way to steward their money with Kingdom values" which sounds perfect for such a pious individual.

You think ministers of the country's official religion àpeople who don't believe humans can change sex should be required to seek out niche financial institutions if they want to participate in the economy?

What the...?

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 13:40

I must admit I thought there was some quite delicious irony in the end where he says he'd like people to write to YBS and warn them to not "go down this rabbit hole of having a particular world view, a particular set of values, because you're going to alienate a lot of customers". The hypocrisy of a religious devotee saying that is quite staggering really.

I am guessing the Vicar is a boomer, when he grew up the majority world view would have been his, it has been for a very long time. He will be quite accepting of a falling away from Christ as is happening, it says that happens nearer the end in the Bible.

The newer world views may seem quite set to some. I very much doubt Gender identity is going to be around in 2000 years as the main religion.

HirplesWithHaggis · 02/07/2023 13:21

2ManyPjs · 02/07/2023 09:56

@TheKeatingFive There's over 10 years of it online. Do your own research.

Then it should be easy for you to provide an example or two. Otherwise you're just posting unsupported, even libellous, allegations.

His website is www.wingsoverscotland.com and his Twitter handle is @ WingsScotland. It's all open to the public, there's no cost to view his blog, he doesn't carry advertisements, so gains nothing from your clicks and views. He produces excellent, researched and evidenced journalism - one of his stories was the start of current police investigations into SNP finances.

I would urge everyone to go have a look for his misogyny and homophobia.

Wings Over Scotland

The world's most-read Scottish politics website

http://www.wingsoverscotland.com

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 13:19

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 12:26

Calvin Robinson from GB news, in his Twitter has a link to the Vicar discussing the feedback form, it also was in newspapers coverage.

This one https://twitter.com/calvinrobinson/status/1675274090649714694?

Have had a listen and the vicar himself says "YBS have always been sending stuff out to it's members, saying give us your feedback, how are we doing, we want to hear from you. You know this kind of stuff, so just before June kicked off it was noticeable that they were going to push pride, the pride lgbtq thing for the month of June. So I thought well OK I'll give them some feedback". So it doesn't sound as though YBS were out asking for feedback or opinions on their commitment to Pride at all.

I suppose you could argue that by canvassing customers in general you open yourself to this sort of thing but in my experience companies tend to ask for feedback on their services and the like, not on their corporate partnerships.

He also doesn't mention any settlement offer, rather that he'd just like them to apologise.

I must admit I thought there was some quite delicious irony in the end where he says he'd like people to write to YBS and warn them to not "go down this rabbit hole of having a particular world view, a particular set of values, because you're going to alienate a lot of customers". The hypocrisy of a religious devotee saying that is quite staggering really.

https://twitter.com/calvinrobinson/status/1675274090649714694

FedgeHund · 02/07/2023 12:26

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 11:35

Well so far I've read articles from the Telegraph, Mail, Express, Times, and on the FSU's own LinkedIn page, none of which have mentioned anything about being him asked for feedback or a settlement. I'd like to get a left leaning viewpoint but it appears to be mainly right leaning outlets running with this story. But I am always happy to read far and wide so please share your links and ill gladly read them.

It's very interesting that rather than engage with any of the points I raised in reply to your previous post you've chosen to try and minimise and dismiss me as triggered, why is that? I appreciate being challenged isn't always fun but don't you want to defend your views?

Calvin Robinson from GB news, in his Twitter has a link to the Vicar discussing the feedback form, it also was in newspapers coverage.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/07/2023 11:56

MargotBamborough · 02/07/2023 11:03

Why would you want to join the meetings of a religious group whose views you disagree with?

It's not like this is something you need to do.

Unlike, say, have a place to store your money and the ability to, you know, pay for stuff.

Are you really not spotting the irony in your question??

I wouldn't really want to join a meeting with a religious group whose views I don't share. I also wouldn't think it were my place to write to them and complain about their views or how they conduct their business.

So why did the reverend feel the need to do just that? He could have just stayed quiet and campaigned for his beliefs in an appropriate setting.

Presumably, he has been able to open a bank account elsewhere already, to deposit that alleged settlement, so all he needs to do in future is not express his views about how a business conducts itself or choose a bank that aligns with his views (although i would imagine even they do not want customers writing in moaning about how they operate constantly).

I mean it took me less than 10 seconds of googling to find Kingdom Bank, "a UK based Christian bank that offers Christians a unique way to steward their money with Kingdom values" which sounds perfect for such a pious individual.

Swipe left for the next trending thread