Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year old boy - in the womens toilet with mum or in the mens toilet by himself?

769 replies

ItsBarbieBitchhhh · 30/06/2023 12:23

Assuming there’s no SEN involved, what’s your opinion? This was started on the back of a current thread in case people think I’m being goady!

Yabu - there’s no issue bringing a 10 year old boy into the womens toilet with me.

Yanbu - they should go into the mens toilet by themselves.

OP posts:
verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:13

Well said, Brefugee.

YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging · 30/06/2023 16:13

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:06

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging if you seriously mean that you take any random relative who wants to into the disabled with you then that is extremely weird. I'm obviously not saying you or your son shouldn't use it, but as a severely disabled person myself I don't think you should be delaying others who genuinely need the space.

@verysmellyjelly no i don’t generally- one is 9 and goes in the mens, there are 2 girls who generally go in the ladies together (I will go in the ladies with them if it’s a big enough space and leave the disabled for other people), but my 5 year old nephew comes in with me- he is too little to go in the men’s alone for one thing, and he can’t wait outside the disabled alone because it can take me a while and he might wander off… ideally I have a few of them at the same time and the older ones watch the younger ones and I get to use the loo alone!

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:14

@wutheringkites I didn't say ten year olds were men. I said they are not very young children, and that some are entering adolescence.
Do you consider a ten year old a "very young child"?

Comedycook · 30/06/2023 16:14

Ten year old boys are children first and foremost. They are not men. They are just as vulnerable to adult males as ten year old girls. However my Ds at ten wouldn't go into the ladies loo, so I'd have to risk assess as best I could and mitigate against any risk by standing at door and calling in to him

EarringsandLipstick · 30/06/2023 16:14

CornflakesOnTheSolesOfHerShoes · 30/06/2023 16:10

I have a nine-year-old DS and there’s absolutely no bloody way I would send him into the men’s on his own, the very thought makes me feel ill. I also have a daughter, and fully appreciate the anger at the erosion of single-sex spaces. Men have no business in women’s toilets, and children in school should be using the facilities appropriate to their sex. But a small, vulnerable nine-year-old is not the appropriate target of that anger, and should absolutely not be put at risk in a public place.

This hasn’t actually come up for us as DS has an iron bladder, never needs the loo while out, and if we’re on a long journey or something and it’s necessary then he goes with DH. So I haven’t had confront the possibility of sending him in on his own but really can’t imagine being remotely comfortable with it for a while yet.

What way is your 9 yo vulnerable?

lieselotte · 30/06/2023 16:14

Sen or not I would tell a 10 year old boy he ought to be ashamed of himself coming into the women's, and reminding him he looks old enough to face criminal charges

I would advise you that if you are in Scotland the age of criminal responsibility is 12.

But in any event no police force in England/Wales is going to entertain complaints about a child who looks like they might be 10 going into the opposite sex loo.

My son is 4 and I've already been challenged by someone for taking him into the women's toilet How stupid. What on earth is wrong with people. That said, the whole silly trans issue gets conflated with this and makes people far more sensitive than they should be.

Brefugee · 30/06/2023 16:15

just for the ones who really aren't paying attention: i (and i suspect other pp) don't want boys to be in danger.

We don't want more men and boys going into women and girls' sex-segrated spaces than are already going in there.

Campaign for safer facilities for boys. I'll join you. But it really really reads in so many posts her that the comfort of girls is just to be ignored. It isn't.

wutheringkites · 30/06/2023 16:16

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:14

@wutheringkites I didn't say ten year olds were men. I said they are not very young children, and that some are entering adolescence.
Do you consider a ten year old a "very young child"?

My previous post was that 10 year old boys are not men and then you tagged me saying that many will have entered adolescence. Apologies if I misunderstood but I'm not sure why you tagged me otherwise.

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:16

@wutheringkites do you consider a ten year old a very young child?

Calloffruity · 30/06/2023 16:17

Brefugee · 30/06/2023 16:15

just for the ones who really aren't paying attention: i (and i suspect other pp) don't want boys to be in danger.

We don't want more men and boys going into women and girls' sex-segrated spaces than are already going in there.

Campaign for safer facilities for boys. I'll join you. But it really really reads in so many posts her that the comfort of girls is just to be ignored. It isn't.

None of them are interested in campaigning for safer places. Far easier to just teach their sons that as males they come first.

wutheringkites · 30/06/2023 16:18

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:16

@wutheringkites do you consider a ten year old a very young child?

No, and I haven't said they are. I consider a 10 year old to be a child. Some will be bigger, more confident or more mature than others.

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:18

Just as an additional note, it is considered normal development for boys to be in Tanner stage two or three of puberty at age ten. They certainly won't all be - it is also normal to reach those stages later. But many, many ten year olds have begun to mature into adolescence. I'm sure a Year Six teacher could confirm this, if any happen to be on the thread.

YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging · 30/06/2023 16:18

Samcro · 30/06/2023 16:11

this
I do wish people would stop using disabled toilets as the solution.

They are the bloody solution for me! Sorry I have committed the crime of being both disabled and the mother of a boy… who is also disabled. Sometimes it takes a while for me to use the disabled loo, and sometimes it then takes a while for my son to use the disabled loo. Would you like me to leave the other small children out in the shopping centre/motorway services etc? Does it actually harm you in any way if they stand in the disabled loo while I pee?!

PuttingDownRoots · 30/06/2023 16:18

My DD is 10.
There is a boy on her Rugby team that is twice her size... he could pick her up with one arm.
There is also a boy smaller than her. (Both are a similar age)

The bigger one could be quite intimidating towards girls if similar age in the toilets. The younger looking boy wouldn't.

People probably wouldn't look twice at the smaller one, but would at the second one. But both the same maturity and potentially the same level of vulnerability.

StaunchMomma · 30/06/2023 16:19

Would depend on the toilet for me - standard restaurant/shop/public toilet then absolutely fine but the dodgy loos in our nearest town where everyone knows the druggies do their business? Absolutely not!

I wouldn't be offended if I saw a 10 year old boy in the ladies loos - we all use cubicles and it is likely to be for a reason.

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:19

In short, ten is materially not the same as seven. By ten, all boys should be in the men's (or if SEND mean it is actually needed and therefore justified, using the disabled toilet with any necessary support).

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:21

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging A lot of posters have suggested that non disabled male children use the disabled loo. I doubt that poster meant you as both you and your son are disabled and so it's perfectly fair to use the disabled. Smile

Sprogonthetyne · 30/06/2023 16:23

Generally in the men's, possibly in with mum if its a particularly risky situation (eg. Deserted, grotty service station at 2am).

Unicorntearsofgin · 30/06/2023 16:25

I’d say from about 7 in the men’s. If you uncomfortable or worried about this look for someone with gender neutral toilets as there are often ones available.

i do think single sex spaces matter so I’d try and find a way around using them with my DS

CornflakesOnTheSolesOfHerShoes · 30/06/2023 16:25

EarringsandLipstick · 30/06/2023 16:14

What way is your 9 yo vulnerable?

In the same way as any other young child would be vulnerable if sent alone into a room full of strange men to pee!

AccountantMum · 30/06/2023 16:27

I have a daughter in year 6 and the boy's in her class seem a lot more like children than men - some appear a lot younger than others (and younger than the 10/11 year old girls).

I would think most 10 year old boys want to use the boy's toilets - but there are generally cubicles in the women's toilets and if a 10 year old is scared to use the men's toilet alone or it seems dangerous then it makes sense for them to use the women's.

My 11 year old daughter asks me to go in the toilets (not cubicle) with her sometimes and in the past has found it awkward while out with her dad alone as she doesn't want to go into the men's or alone - however the men's toilets often don't have cubicles so it's more difficult.

I don't think many women really care if a 10 year old boy see's them washing their hands? - and not many at all would want anyone (girl/boy/man/woman) watching them actually use the toilet.

wutheringkites · 30/06/2023 16:28

@Unicorntearsofgin

In my experience, there are very few gender neutral toilets. I can't think of anywhere I go with my son that has them, apart from coffee shops that tend to have a single toilet.

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 16:28

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:18

Just as an additional note, it is considered normal development for boys to be in Tanner stage two or three of puberty at age ten. They certainly won't all be - it is also normal to reach those stages later. But many, many ten year olds have begun to mature into adolescence. I'm sure a Year Six teacher could confirm this, if any happen to be on the thread.

And your point is??
The UK/WHO growth charts show 98% of 10 year olds to be less than 150cm tall and less than 45kg. In other words: tiny, no physical threat to anyone, and not remotely capable of fending off an assault from an adult male if sent to the mens on their own.
And anecdotally, having just been to a Y5 end of year concert, not a sign of puberty in any of them. No breaking voices. no adam's apples, nothing. Just a bunch of small, sweet kids. A bit of a problem for the choirmaster as no baritones for the lower parts. I'm sure you're as disappointed as he was.

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:28

@AccountantMum Is anyone actually saying they are men? I don't think anyone is arguing that.

YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging · 30/06/2023 16:29

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:21

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging A lot of posters have suggested that non disabled male children use the disabled loo. I doubt that poster meant you as both you and your son are disabled and so it's perfectly fair to use the disabled. Smile

@verysmellyjelly probably not, I’m probably being sensitive because I’m having one of those day 🤦‍♀️ and I do spend a lot of time having to explain to people who enjoy gate keeping toilets that my son is actually disabled. Actually has a physical disability relating to his bowl as well as having special needs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread