Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year old boy - in the womens toilet with mum or in the mens toilet by himself?

769 replies

ItsBarbieBitchhhh · 30/06/2023 12:23

Assuming there’s no SEN involved, what’s your opinion? This was started on the back of a current thread in case people think I’m being goady!

Yabu - there’s no issue bringing a 10 year old boy into the womens toilet with me.

Yanbu - they should go into the mens toilet by themselves.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 01/07/2023 17:36

@Cantstaystuckforever "If there's truly not a risk from strangers in public toilets, then why is so much of Mumsnet using the risk of assault to be a major reason why they are so violently against unisex toilets or self-identified women using the ladies toilets or changing rooms?"

There is a different debate about adults. Men very frequently assault or harass women. It's routine. Incidentally, my concern about unisex loos and self identifying women is not about assault. It is the same argument that I use about about boys over 8 is loos used by girls- privacy and dignity.

Florenz · 01/07/2023 17:31

Boys should really be going to the men's toilets by the time they get to Junior School which is 8 years old.

Teder · 01/07/2023 17:25

On a personal note, I am not bothered or upset or offended if a 10 year old boy is in the ladies. However, there are some very risk averse parents on here. At that age, they are getting closer to independence. They need to be making steps towards learning to use the mens. I’m not suggesting you start off with a motorway service station toilet but start taking steps for them to develop some confidence. They may avoid using the toilet when out and about with mates but at some point, they will need to use the toilet and parents owe to their sons to help them learn.
Before anyone asks, yes, I have a son and yes, it’s scary sending them into the big bad world and my boy in the men’s toilet is one of those worries BUT I cannot keep him wrapped up in cotton wool forever. Life is risky. I help him manage those risks as much as possible. Some risks will be there and I cannot do anything about it. I’d be horrified in my 11 year old son was subjected to something in a toilet and I’d be horrified of my 16 year old son were subjected to something. I’d love to keep them at home and away from the dangers of the world. It’s not realistic.

Cantstaystuckforever · 01/07/2023 17:18

CurlewKate · 01/07/2023 11:28

@Cantstaystuckforever "A lot of MNers seem to forget that unfortunately young boys are also at significant risk of assault. The rate is a horrifying 15% of girls getting some level of abuse before 16, but the rate for young boys is still 5%"
Frankly, I'm surprised it's not higher. But the risk is not from strangers. Particularly not from strangers in public loos. That's why kids are no longer taught about Stranger Danger.

As I've said, I do believe that the vast majority of 10 years olds in the vast majority of situations should use the male toilets. But it shouldn't be a blanket rule . If there's truly not a risk from strangers in public toilets, then why is so much of Mumsnet using the risk of assault to be a major reason why they are so violently against unisex toilets or self-identified women using the ladies toilets or changing rooms?

Of course there is a risk. And some of the women on here shouting about how a 9 year old boy with SEN using the women's would be 'trampling over the rights of women and girls' should at least be honest that they are happy to reduce the safety of a vulnerable group young children so that our (apparently more precious) daughters don't have to use the loo with a pre-pubescent boy, or reducing the ability of boys to go to some places, and also inconveniencing disabled people as using the disabled toilet (when it even exists) becomes the only alternative in some situations.

ATeamsvan · 01/07/2023 16:45

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:06

@ATeamsvan I think we can be fairly confident you haven't been measuring their genitals, so let's just assume you don't know which Tanner stage they are at, shall we? Confused

I presume what you're trying to imply is that you think they ought to be allowed into women's toilets. You haven't convinced me this is defensible.

Not in the slightest, my ten year old uses male toilets. I was questioning your view that at ten most boys are well into puberty.

wutheringkites · 01/07/2023 16:27

@verysmellyjelly

I think it is arrogant to presume to speak on behalf of women in general.

Your views and opinions are not more important or valid than anyone else's.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:43

@wutheringkites My comment couldn't have been clearer about the fact that I was suggesting women in general would likely look kindly on a disabled DS with a disabled mother.

I can't fix your intentionally malicious misreading.

However, it is also just ludicrous to pretend all disabilities are equal and equivalent. They are not.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:42

@ChillysWaterBottle Children's safety is extremely important to feminists, actually. So please don't use that as your cheap excuse for why it's okay to invade single sex spaces.

wutheringkites · 01/07/2023 15:41

@verysmellyjelly

There are no trump cards in womenhood or disability.

Your opinion as a woman is not more important or valid than mine is.

Your experience of disability is not more important or valid than @YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging

The arrogance of presuming to 'extend her grace' is breathtaking to me.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:41

Tophy124 · 01/07/2023 15:37

@verysmellyjelly no my son comes EQUAL to my daughter. But you conveniently ignored that part. I will continue to do what is right for my family.

And you’re the one making judgements about what disabilities are ok or not by commenting on the person who can’t use the men’s for her disabled child and saying exceptions can be made. You being disabled means nothing to me or my own sons issues does it, I could care less if you think he’s ok to use a disabled toilet or not as I know he qualifies.

Your comment makes no sense.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:40

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging I don't think you come across as male first, just someone who has a DS and a tricky situation!

Tophy124 · 01/07/2023 15:37

@verysmellyjelly no my son comes EQUAL to my daughter. But you conveniently ignored that part. I will continue to do what is right for my family.

And you’re the one making judgements about what disabilities are ok or not by commenting on the person who can’t use the men’s for her disabled child and saying exceptions can be made. You being disabled means nothing to me or my own sons issues does it, I could care less if you think he’s ok to use a disabled toilet or not as I know he qualifies.

ChillysWaterBottle · 01/07/2023 15:36

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:16

No thought for women and girls' right to privacy and dignity...? Is that completely unimportant to you?

About as important to me as my child's safety is to them.

Also I am a woman and children using toilets with their mothers as they see fit is no threat to my privacy or dignity. Don't claim to speak on my behalf.

YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging · 01/07/2023 15:35

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:22

@Tophy124 ...lol, none of my posts are "anti-male", they just don't put men and boys first and women and girls last.

But of course that's enough to get them labelled as anti-male by some people. Grin

@verysmellyjelly I probably am coming across as a bit male first- it’s because my male child is the one that causes the toilet issue in my life so he is at the forefront of my mind when I think about this issue.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:34

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging Yeah, I don't understand anyone who is criticising you personally, or who doesn't get that your take has a lot of nuance to it! Sometimes one can support a certain stance and yet one particular action forcibly has to break it (eg vegan but has to take a medication with an animal product in).

YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging · 01/07/2023 15:31

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:16

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging Didn't you mention upthread that your DS also uses a mobility aid? Apologies if I'm remembering incorrectly! I think in practice people would extend a lot of grace in that situation where someone is going to the only accessible cubicle in a clearly poor layout.

I have experienced loos where there is an accessible cubicle in a larger toilet block and I think they're pretty awful, so I have a lot of sympathy for you both in that situation.

Yeah- he has autism, adhd, dyspraxia and a condition with his stomach/bowl. I would genuinely love it if he could go to the men’s loo-

I am from a long line of strident separatist feminists… think women only communes and spare rib- the idea I should magic up a man to take everywhere with me has enraged me.

I get the women’s space thing, I really do. I’m just stuck in a situation (created by bad building planning, ableism and capitalism) that doesn’t suit me, my child or women in general.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:31

flowergirl2020 · 01/07/2023 15:26

Depends on circumstances and scenario. Ex secondary school teacher and although 10 may seem mature there's a vast number of students who get groomed etc at this age and older. When I used to be out and about with my step son at this age he went in the women's with me. Not taking any chances especially when responsible for someone else's child. He went on the cubical alone and we just switched over - could still hear him/see him through hinges. Got my own 16 month old boy now and tbh I'll prob do same with him after some of the horror stories I've heard through work and safeguarding professionals.
No one ever said anything to me when I did it.

It's so selfish to take an older male child into a female single sex space. Confused

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:30

Tophy124 · 01/07/2023 15:28

As for posters saying they would confront mothers and sons using disabled toilets, not all disabilities are visible so give your head a wobble.

Who is saying all disabilities are visible?

Give your head a wobble is just inane.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:29

@Tophy124 Your reply is just...wild. Male children's needs are not always automatically meant to come first, just so you know. If you think that is a feminist take, you are utterly deluded.

I also actually am a severely disabled person, so please take your ableist rubbish far away and [redacted by me to stick to TGs]. Grin

Tophy124 · 01/07/2023 15:28

As for posters saying they would confront mothers and sons using disabled toilets, not all disabilities are visible so give your head a wobble.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:27

@wutheringkites When both mother and DS are disabled, the lack of decent accessible loos is the actual issue here. Something disabled people have been campaigning for for decades. And yet there are plenty of people in this thread happily saying they'd send their DS in there... Along with a widespread societal proliferation (certainly not just mothers of sons!) of people suggesting the disabled loo as a good option. As many of my comments have reiterated, I actually have loads of sympathy for that poster who is clearly in a genuinely difficult situation. But the solution is probably a lot more, and better, accessible toilets.

Tophy124 · 01/07/2023 15:26

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:22

@Tophy124 ...lol, none of my posts are "anti-male", they just don't put men and boys first and women and girls last.

But of course that's enough to get them labelled as anti-male by some people. Grin

No you out the needs of adult women above those of male children. You also find it appropriate to make a mother of a disabled son feel uncomfortable using the bathrooms they need to access. Not very feminist of you to suggest male
children always need a male chaperone is it? Aren’t women equally capable of caring for our male children?

I find a lot of the comments you’ve made odd and they are so not in line with my thinking we clearly won’t agree, but my daughter and my sons safety is equally important to me and so I will be treating them the same and keeping them away from situations they may become SA victims or get themselves in a situation where they need me and I can’t go in (me going into a male toilet with men urinating not in cubicles is not the same as my male child coming into a cubicle with me).

Also a lot of disabilities are invisible.

flowergirl2020 · 01/07/2023 15:26

Depends on circumstances and scenario. Ex secondary school teacher and although 10 may seem mature there's a vast number of students who get groomed etc at this age and older. When I used to be out and about with my step son at this age he went in the women's with me. Not taking any chances especially when responsible for someone else's child. He went on the cubical alone and we just switched over - could still hear him/see him through hinges. Got my own 16 month old boy now and tbh I'll prob do same with him after some of the horror stories I've heard through work and safeguarding professionals.
No one ever said anything to me when I did it.

wutheringkites · 01/07/2023 15:23

@verysmellyjelly

I don't think boys are oppressed but I do think some of the comments made towards @YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging are a bit 'I'm alright Jack'.

Some posters seem to not see mothers of boys as women in their own right. If women are stuck at home because there are no appropriate facilities for them then it's not ok.

verysmellyjelly · 01/07/2023 15:22

@Tophy124 ...lol, none of my posts are "anti-male", they just don't put men and boys first and women and girls last.

But of course that's enough to get them labelled as anti-male by some people. Grin