Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year old boy - in the womens toilet with mum or in the mens toilet by himself?

769 replies

ItsBarbieBitchhhh · 30/06/2023 12:23

Assuming there’s no SEN involved, what’s your opinion? This was started on the back of a current thread in case people think I’m being goady!

Yabu - there’s no issue bringing a 10 year old boy into the womens toilet with me.

Yanbu - they should go into the mens toilet by themselves.

OP posts:
ItsBarbieBitchhhh · 30/06/2023 18:35

Cucucucu · 30/06/2023 18:25

Does your sister have any MH issues or is neurodiverse? If not then sorry but she shouldn’t be tense from seeing a 10 year old boy

Some teenage girls are always stressed at having to change a period pad in the girls toilets at school. I remember my friends and I used to wait until someone put the taps or the hand dryer and then we’d take our pad off of the wrapper.

If you may not be comfortable in a space that’s for women/girls only, you’re going to feel way less comfortable coming out of a cubicle and seeing a boy in that same space. It’s nothing to do with MH issues or being neurodierse. It’s just about being an awkward teenager

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 30/06/2023 18:33

anyone who has issue with it tough it’s not like he is perving.

What a ridiculous statement.

It's not about 'perving' 🤢

In all spheres of life we manage appropriate privacy requirements, and biological sex comes into this. In my house my DSs wing be around their older sister when she's getting changed, but they themselves share a room so will be undressing in front of each other.

It's about the accepted norms that we apply based on biological sex. Not some bizarre suggestion that 10 yo boys are perverts or predators 🙄

Sycasmores · 30/06/2023 18:30

I think most 10 year old boys wouldn't be happy in the women's but I wouldn't care if one was in there. I'd rather he be safe than anything else. A prepubescent child I just can't get het up about. I don't want adult men in their even if they're wearing a frock mind!

EarringsandLipstick · 30/06/2023 18:29

In the same way as any other young child would be vulnerable if sent alone into a room full of strange men to pee!

So, not vulnerable then. A typical 10 yo who is more than capable of using the men's toilets.

I agree with PP, if you are in a dangerous location where you'd have a serious concern about using any of the facilities, you might make a different decision.

However, in reality, in most normal locations & situations, a 10 yo boy should use the facility for their sex. It always amazes me, the level of hysteria this seems to evoke in some posters.

ItsBarbieBitchhhh · 30/06/2023 18:28

ErrolTheDragon · 30/06/2023 18:25

Why not advocate for the mens toilet to be safer spaces?

And/or, more parent&child loos in larger places like shopping centres and motorway services, and places that have a lot of parents and children such as zoos and museums. Theyrs good not only for mothers and sons but even moreso for fathers and daughters - DH often took dd out at the weekend and wasn't keen on taking her in gents loos with urinals.

Yes exactly this. It can also be a bit complicated when a dad is outside with his daughter. Dad doesn’t want to bring daughter into the mens toilet because of urinals and how dirty they apparently are. Dad can’t bring daugher into the womens toilet as it’s not a space for him.

Why not have more parent & child toilets especially in family friendly places?

OP posts:
Cucucucu · 30/06/2023 18:25

ItsBarbieBitchhhh · 30/06/2023 18:13

I think this is it really.

There really is danger everywhere, even if the mens toilet. As soon as your child enters the male toilet, I think it’s helpful to say/shout, ‘I’m just here if you need me son’ or something along those lines. I personally don’t think it’s okay to teach your child that because there may be potential danger, that they can come into a space that isn’t designated for them.

I have my 15 year old sister in mind when writing this comment. She’s a very anxious yet confident young girl however everytime she comes out of a cubicle to see a young boy either standing there or washing their hands, she instantly freezes up. You can see her body getting tense. Now to me as a grown woman, I see the boy and carry on doing what I’m doing. To some girls such as my sister, it throws them off completely. My sister will wlso avoid going to public toilets on the next few outings.

Now some may think that’s an overreaction. I think it just shows how many parents allow things to happen and don’t think how it could impact anyone else. Everyone seems dead set about keeping single sex spaces exclusive to the relevant sex but when it comes to their own son, the rules can be bent?

Going back to the comment that I’ve quoted, instead of having a ‘well my son is too young to go into the mens by himself’ type of attitude. Why not advocate for the mens toilet to be safer spaces?

Does your sister have any MH issues or is neurodiverse? If not then sorry but she shouldn’t be tense from seeing a 10 year old boy

ErrolTheDragon · 30/06/2023 18:25

Why not advocate for the mens toilet to be safer spaces?

And/or, more parent&child loos in larger places like shopping centres and motorway services, and places that have a lot of parents and children such as zoos and museums. Theyrs good not only for mothers and sons but even moreso for fathers and daughters - DH often took dd out at the weekend and wasn't keen on taking her in gents loos with urinals.

Cucucucu · 30/06/2023 18:24

I see no issue and wouldn’t bother me at all

ItsBarbieBitchhhh · 30/06/2023 18:13

Brefugee · 30/06/2023 16:15

just for the ones who really aren't paying attention: i (and i suspect other pp) don't want boys to be in danger.

We don't want more men and boys going into women and girls' sex-segrated spaces than are already going in there.

Campaign for safer facilities for boys. I'll join you. But it really really reads in so many posts her that the comfort of girls is just to be ignored. It isn't.

I think this is it really.

There really is danger everywhere, even if the mens toilet. As soon as your child enters the male toilet, I think it’s helpful to say/shout, ‘I’m just here if you need me son’ or something along those lines. I personally don’t think it’s okay to teach your child that because there may be potential danger, that they can come into a space that isn’t designated for them.

I have my 15 year old sister in mind when writing this comment. She’s a very anxious yet confident young girl however everytime she comes out of a cubicle to see a young boy either standing there or washing their hands, she instantly freezes up. You can see her body getting tense. Now to me as a grown woman, I see the boy and carry on doing what I’m doing. To some girls such as my sister, it throws them off completely. My sister will wlso avoid going to public toilets on the next few outings.

Now some may think that’s an overreaction. I think it just shows how many parents allow things to happen and don’t think how it could impact anyone else. Everyone seems dead set about keeping single sex spaces exclusive to the relevant sex but when it comes to their own son, the rules can be bent?

Going back to the comment that I’ve quoted, instead of having a ‘well my son is too young to go into the mens by himself’ type of attitude. Why not advocate for the mens toilet to be safer spaces?

OP posts:
HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 30/06/2023 17:46

I genuinely wouldn't bat an eyelid at a 10 year old in the ladies if he was with his mum. What threat would he be to me?

It's not about you. As many have already said, it's about girls who don't want to see boys their own age or older in their toilets. Just like adult women don't want to see adult men in their toilets.

MrsRandom123 · 30/06/2023 17:34

My son is nearly 9 & without my husband or option of a single toilet if it’s busy say shopping centre no chance he’s going in mens alone so will come in with me & anyone who has issue with it tough it’s not like he is perving. Probably by 10 he’ll go in himself but i’ll be standing right outside and door open / checking who is in & i imagine there would be more men have issue with that (especially if other little boys are doing the toilet) v woman in a locked cubicle with privacy - he’s hardly a perv. I see lots of boys in with their mums it’s only on here its such a big deal but its not worth the miniscule risk in my opinion so i don’t care what anyone thinks

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 30/06/2023 17:29

A NT 10 year old boy should be in the men's. I say that as a single parent of male children. Although I'm never sure what being a single parent has to do with it, unless people think that married/coupled parents never take the children out on their own so dad is always there to take boys into the men's.

The only place I would have hesitated when they were that age was a motorway service station due to the size.

AriettyClock22 · 30/06/2023 17:21

Depends on the setting. Ideally they should be in the men's. However if it's a massive toilet complex in a shopping centre or something then I wouldn't be too keen. 10 is still pretty young and they could be vulnerable.

I genuinely wouldn't bat an eyelid at a 10 year old in the ladies if he was with his mum. What threat would he be to me?

SlashBeef · 30/06/2023 17:20

I send my 10 yo in the men's and say a loud "I'll wait right outside for you!!" as he goes in. That's mainly for my own peace of mind I guess.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 30/06/2023 17:15

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 30/06/2023 13:51

My daughter was vulnerable to the male child who abused her in the female changing rooms at the swimming pool.

As were the numerous other girls we later found out he'd abused.

Nobody abuses someone who'll fight back. A male child isn't going to abuse me. That doesn't mean he isn't going to abuse female children.

I’m really sorry to hear about this. It happened to me too. Unfortunately as I was told on a previous thread, that’s a risk that many are happy with to protect boys from men. It’s not right.

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 17:12

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:31

@EctopicSpleen My point is that the traditional changing room age of eight is reasonable, as nine onwards is the established medical age from which male puberty normatively begins. That doesn't mean all male children begin (let alone finish) puberty at that age!

If you have a problem with how puberty works, take it up with medicine, not with me. It makes sense for very young children to be able to go into a toilet with their mum. But children who are over the age where puberty can normatively begin are no longer very young. I don't see what you aren't getting...?

Onset of puberty is a bogus criterion when the actual issue is safety. You are also misrepresenting the medical reality. The average onset of male puberty is 11-12 while other physical changes such as voice breaking don't on average occur till 13. While it is not classed as medically abnormal for a 9 or 10 year old male to have started puberty, it's rare at 10 and exceptionally rare at 9.
And if 13 and 14 year olds are assaulted in public toilets, (see eg
https://www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/23295367.carlisle-pensioner-denies-sex-assault-13-year-old-public-toilet
https://www.dorset.live/news/dorset-news/boy-14-sexually-assaulted-public-7233526 )
think how much more vulnerable a 10 year old is.

Regarding whether traditions are "reasonable", stop and think how comfortable you would be explaining to one of the many parents whose children have been assaulted in men's toilets why it is "reasonable" that they should continue to use them.

"Campaigning for safer spaces" as others have suggested is all very well, but not much compensation if your child is assaulted before that campaign has had any effect. Or to put it another way, virtue signaling doesn't confer a protective halo.

All of us can agree it would be lovely to live in an ideal world where there are no paedophiles, no sexual assaults, and no need for 10 year old boy to use the female loos. Those of you who think you're already living in that world need a reality check. You must have led lovely, sheltered lives, but really - wake up .

My 10 year old will continue to avoid the men's toilets and use the women's where necessary. By all means tell us we should be ashamed (we're not). We will in turn tell you to do one, and elaborate on this them with colourful metaphors.

wutheringkites · 30/06/2023 16:37

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging

I'm sorry this happens to you. My SIL often gets this when with her son too.

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:32

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging I'm sorry to hear you're having a rubbish day! That sucks BrewCake

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:31

@EctopicSpleen My point is that the traditional changing room age of eight is reasonable, as nine onwards is the established medical age from which male puberty normatively begins. That doesn't mean all male children begin (let alone finish) puberty at that age!

If you have a problem with how puberty works, take it up with medicine, not with me. It makes sense for very young children to be able to go into a toilet with their mum. But children who are over the age where puberty can normatively begin are no longer very young. I don't see what you aren't getting...?

YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging · 30/06/2023 16:29

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:21

@YouknowaswellasIdothatthepipeswantlagging A lot of posters have suggested that non disabled male children use the disabled loo. I doubt that poster meant you as both you and your son are disabled and so it's perfectly fair to use the disabled. Smile

@verysmellyjelly probably not, I’m probably being sensitive because I’m having one of those day 🤦‍♀️ and I do spend a lot of time having to explain to people who enjoy gate keeping toilets that my son is actually disabled. Actually has a physical disability relating to his bowl as well as having special needs.

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:28

@AccountantMum Is anyone actually saying they are men? I don't think anyone is arguing that.

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 16:28

verysmellyjelly · 30/06/2023 16:18

Just as an additional note, it is considered normal development for boys to be in Tanner stage two or three of puberty at age ten. They certainly won't all be - it is also normal to reach those stages later. But many, many ten year olds have begun to mature into adolescence. I'm sure a Year Six teacher could confirm this, if any happen to be on the thread.

And your point is??
The UK/WHO growth charts show 98% of 10 year olds to be less than 150cm tall and less than 45kg. In other words: tiny, no physical threat to anyone, and not remotely capable of fending off an assault from an adult male if sent to the mens on their own.
And anecdotally, having just been to a Y5 end of year concert, not a sign of puberty in any of them. No breaking voices. no adam's apples, nothing. Just a bunch of small, sweet kids. A bit of a problem for the choirmaster as no baritones for the lower parts. I'm sure you're as disappointed as he was.

wutheringkites · 30/06/2023 16:28

@Unicorntearsofgin

In my experience, there are very few gender neutral toilets. I can't think of anywhere I go with my son that has them, apart from coffee shops that tend to have a single toilet.

AccountantMum · 30/06/2023 16:27

I have a daughter in year 6 and the boy's in her class seem a lot more like children than men - some appear a lot younger than others (and younger than the 10/11 year old girls).

I would think most 10 year old boys want to use the boy's toilets - but there are generally cubicles in the women's toilets and if a 10 year old is scared to use the men's toilet alone or it seems dangerous then it makes sense for them to use the women's.

My 11 year old daughter asks me to go in the toilets (not cubicle) with her sometimes and in the past has found it awkward while out with her dad alone as she doesn't want to go into the men's or alone - however the men's toilets often don't have cubicles so it's more difficult.

I don't think many women really care if a 10 year old boy see's them washing their hands? - and not many at all would want anyone (girl/boy/man/woman) watching them actually use the toilet.

CornflakesOnTheSolesOfHerShoes · 30/06/2023 16:25

EarringsandLipstick · 30/06/2023 16:14

What way is your 9 yo vulnerable?

In the same way as any other young child would be vulnerable if sent alone into a room full of strange men to pee!