Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to end relationship with my brother because I cba?

238 replies

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 10:53

Hello and thanks for reading.

Im going to sound awful for this post I know but I need to vent it and get impartial advice. I’m prepared for vipers.

Background: I have 5 half siblings. I grew up in the same house with 4 of them. We are all adults now with our own families and get on well but not close.
The fifth sibling was my dads son who is 15 years older than me and I did not grow up with and did not know or meet until after my dad died.

Met this sibling when I was 19 and they were 34. They have no other siblings.
He’s a nice man but due to the age gap and not being raised together we have 0 in common.
However due to him having no siblings he has tried really hard over the years to force a relationship.
He’s gone out of his way to make this happen. Travelling across the country to things like my graduation and the birth of my child. Sending presents and cards on birthdays and at Christmas. Always trying to ring me and arrange meet ups.
He has a wife and kids and they are also super enthusiastic to have a relationship.

Now this is where I feel an awful person. I do not reciprocate the feelings at all and find it smothering and a bit weird if I’m honest.
We have nothing in common other than sharing a dad neither of us really knew.
He makes more effort than me and my siblings do for eachother and is really over familiar. When he and his family come they insist on staying in my house when my own siblings get a hotel. I have a house with spare rooms so can’t really say no but it’s awkward.
They try and arrange joint family holidays which I make excuses not to do and send me drawings their kids have done in the post.

Because we weren’t raised together and there is a huge age gap it’s essentially a stranger trying to exert themselves into your life at every opportunity.
My other siblings I have little in common with but we have a shared history and familiarity so have our own banter and jokes and understand each others quirks and ways so I can spend a weekend with them and tell them to go away or whatever. When they’re being annoying. My nieces and nephews feel like ‘mine’ and it feels like family and not a weird chore i’m doing.

Since having my child my brother and his family have stepped it up a notch and constantly want to meet and be in contact as he’s an ‘uncle’ now.
Their kids ranging from 2 - 19 year old (massive age gaps) call me auntie and my DP uncle and it feels awkward as they are literal strangers.
My DB and his wife will try and give parenting tips on visits which comes across as rude as critical because there is no foundation of a relationship like our own siblings so it feels like a stranger/acquaintance saying it.

I have tried to distance myself over the years but they don’t get the hint. I don’t respond to calls and take days to reply to texts but they still persist. They will go through their calendar for that year until they find a date we are free for a visit even if it’s 6 months away. They send expensive and thoughtful presents for all our birthdays which makes me feel indebted to them to continue the relationship.
They've even tried to ‘book on’ to our family holidays when we’ve told them we’re going somewhere (saying they might come too and looking up tickets on their phone there and then, I’m not joking!).
They keep pestering to spend Christmas together which I’ve managed to bat off! We have loads of other very close family and now our own kids to be contending with, we don’t want to host strangers on top on Christmas Day and it’s weird they even want to spend such a day together.

I know it sounds selfish but I have loads of siblings already as does DP. Infact DP has 4 full siblings who also have families so between us we have loads of siblings, nieces and nephews which is difficult enough to keep up with. However my DB and his family demand more attention than all our siblings put together! Because they only have me as ‘family’ they put all their attention onto us.

I personally would be happy with just sending an annual Christmas card and seeing their updates via social media at most. I don’t have the time or interest.
But I don’t want to hurt them either. They are nice people. I understand they want extended family as they don’t have it, but I can’t provide it.

What do I do?

I’ve tried every kind of ‘drifting away’ method possible. I feel like the only way out is to have some kind of huge fall out and go no contact because they will go to such great lengths to maintain this relationship that there is no other way. Even if I up and moved to Australia I have 0 doubt they’d use their annual leave to visit annually. That’s how full on they are.

OP posts:
DPotter · 30/06/2023 12:11

It's funny isn't it - so many posts on here will say - set your boundaries, don't put up with people trying to force relationships with you. And yet the minute, the very second there's some form of genetic link - all previous bets are off. It is expected you spend every waking moment together, allow them to walk over every boundary you have. Even if you don't like them, in fact especially if you don't like them the not-liking-them is actually your fault.

The OP feels no connection with this person - she didn't click, but felt some obligation to be polite, to be nice and now it's too much. She's chosen to use the word 'stranger' to describe that emotion.

So Misschatterbox - your emotions and feelings about this man are totally fine - they are your feelings and you are entitled to experience them. They are not wrong and you are not at fault.

What to do about it, is not so simple and frankly depends upon how brave you're feeling.

There's the Nuclear option of calling him and saying look, I'm sorry but I feel this relationship has run its course and I will be backing out. Wish you the best - Goodbye.

Or there's being more consistent with your boundaries, eg
tell him hour long calls are too much - family, work pressure etc. and certainly not talking to his youngest - that's just daft and forcing you and young nephew / niece into a situation neither of you feels comfortable with. So you either tell him - brief calls, or after 15 mins - say Oops young child has just kicked the dog and I've got to go.

tell him, that given the current economic situation the expensive Christmas / birthday presents are too much, and suggest a £5 limit and just for the children. Heavens I've had this conversation with my sister back in the day so totally appropriate.

when he asks to visit - suggest meeting half way for a day / overnight. If he want to visit you - tell him you feel uncomfortable with house guests so here are some local hotels etc.

Work out some phrases and practise saying them out aloud. Think through how he may counter them and come up with some responses.

If he doesn't take the hint - then he's just forcing a relationship on to you you don't ant and you're back to the nuclear option.

My bottom line on this - you don't owe this man a relationship just because you have the same father.

BemusedBrenda · 30/06/2023 12:07

I find it so odd that people put genetic connections on such a pedestal. This is really no different from someone trying to force you to be their friend and to engineer closeness, except that this man feels entitled to because he is technically related to you. I have siblings I lived with growing up and ones I did not. It is a totally different relationship - you are so right that shared experiences and history are what build that feeling of "family".

If you don't want to have an "it's not you, it's me" break-up style conversation with him, all you can really do is ramp up the distancing. Ignore the calls, politely decline all invitations or suggestions to visit.

RisingSunn · 30/06/2023 12:04

I definitely think you can enforce some boundaries here.

Family is so valuable - however they come about. I think cutting off a half brother like this is awful. He seems a wonderful uncle for your children (even though they have loads already).

He has no other extended family - can’t you make a tiny bit of space for him?

amispeakingintongues · 30/06/2023 12:03

But he's not a stranger, at all. He's your family.

You don't have to spend all the time with him but NC is just dramatic and selfish.

Velvian · 30/06/2023 11:55

I know they're not directly related, but could you bring him in to wider sibling group, so that the pressure is diluted?

Although you don't feel that connection. Your DC will, as he will have always been their uncle and his DC their cousins. It could be a source of support and connection that they are glad of.

It also sounds like part of your very strong reaction is nothing to do with your brother, but maybe with your mutual dad and whatever complications surround that.

SunnyFrost · 30/06/2023 11:55

I think responses here have been very harsh. Finding a sibling as an adult is totally different to one you’ve grown up with and the bottom line is you don’t feel comfortable with the high level of contact and closeness this man is pushing on you. And that’s ok.

How often do we read on here that women should assert boundaries and not let men trample over them in the spirit of being ‘nice’ or ‘kind’? Yet when a woman posts on here feeling smothered and overwhelmed by excessive contact from someone she feels no particular connection with, all that goes out of the window and she’s basically told she’s a massive bitch because he needs a family from somewhere. Ok then.

It sounds very intense and bottom line is you do not owe this man and his family any type of relationship you’re not comfortable with. Can you have a chat and explain that you’re really glad you found each other and you value having him and his family in your life but you’re finding it a tricky relationship to navigate, having not grown up together and being a naturally more private person. Ask him to give you a bit more space to allow whatever type of sibling relationship you might end up having to grow naturally and make clear that you’re feeling pressured. If he doesn’t back off then you might need to be a bit more blunt and risk a proper falling out. But that’s ok. You don’t have to sacrifice what you want and need in order to ensure this man gets what he wants and needs. And don’t let the typically wild responses on AIBU convince you otherwise.

Panteranoir · 30/06/2023 11:55

Hi Op I have four half siblings, only one of whom I grew up with. I feel absolutely no bond with the three I only got to know as an adult.

As usual mumsnet has shown it's finest empathetic users in splendid fashion.

People seem to assume that because you have a genetic link, when you meet it will be all hearts and flowers and getting to know each other. All three of my half brothers are pretty much strangers to me.

I'm sure some people will say I'm a horrible person, but like you I have met them and know I have no common ground with them. I feel bad for them because they all have different mums so are effectively each the only child of that union. However they all have grown up with half siblings of their own that they are close to. I'd be happy to meet up with them a couple of times a year for a meal, but it would be an effort rather than a joy. Whereas I'd walk over hot coals for my siblings (and have for the half sibling I grew up with, who I only ever think of as my sister iyswim).

My DS hasn't even spoken to our latest half sibling as she's now been through this scenario twice of having a new family member, realising they don't connect and doesn't even want to do it again.

I will also say that two of my in laws also found out they had a half sister as adults. Even the one that did try and forge a relationship eventually came to nothing. I don't think it's at all uncommon.

Don't beat yourself up OP, you can't choose your family and if it doesn't fit why force something that doesn't feel right?

EvilElsa · 30/06/2023 11:53

I feel really sad for him and his family, but I do kind of get where you are coming from. If you are not feeling it, you are not feeling it. Such a shame.
I think you will have to say something if you really want to end things full stop. Be fully honest with him and say you find the relationship too much and want to step back a bit for now. He will be hurt undoubtedly, but you need to decide which you would rather do. Spend your time thinking up plans to dissuade them from visiting, or make a quick, clean break.

LadyJ2023 · 30/06/2023 11:52

I feel totally sorry for him fo you think the life he was given growing up was his choice. He wants to feel a family and loved and you can't take that into consideration. I see I'm not the only one saying it either. You really need to evaluate this situation and think how awful would you feel all alone. Cmon make the effort they actually sound like they go way out the way to show there care and your not even attempting to give anything back

Throwncrumbs · 30/06/2023 11:51

That’s quite sad. He only has you as a sibling while you have others. I feel quite sorry for him. You sound awful tbh. Maybe your other half siblings feel the same about you and you don’t get their hints about them not wanting to see you, have a think about that. Poor bloke deserves better!

BallantyneValentine · 30/06/2023 11:49

We have difficult relationships with some relatives but relatives are precious. I think if you are feeling intruded upon it is going to create some serious ick. It sounds like you put up with it for the sake of a relationship but now you are in the full on resentment phase because you ignored the initial feelings. I would revisit your boundaries. Something between full NC and this level of contact might be possible unless you are way past that.

hiredandsqueak · 30/06/2023 11:49

YANBU I find my siblings I grew up with hard work so see them rarely, I wouldn't have the time or energy for a half sibling I don't think. Some people are more people orientated I think and sounds like your half sibling is one of those.

ANewAdventure · 30/06/2023 11:48

I see that he’s a bit full on, and if you were just asking about limiting contact a bit and putting some boundaries in place I’d be on your side. But frankly you’re being totally unreasonable. You keep saying he’s a stranger - but he’s not, is he? He’s been in your life for multiple years, he visits, spends time with you, talks on the phone. Calling him a “stranger” is just mean.

You said you didn’t meet him until after your father died. Is there more emotion around your parents, your father having a previous life, etc, caught up in this rejection of him?

Harshbutfair · 30/06/2023 11:45

Be careful who you shit on on the way up

Shitshowatthefuckfactory · 30/06/2023 11:44

I feel kind of sorry for him.

But also I don't think you're in the wrong to want to step back on the intensity of a relationship with someone you feel no affinity with.

Clarice99 · 30/06/2023 11:44

I'm going against the grain here. I don't think you sound horrible; however, I do feel you could set some boundaries to. For example, have a conversation with him, one to one, and tell him that you are not comfortable with house guests, and he is to book accommodation and not expect to stay at your home.

He sounds quite lonely and desperate for a family connection which is quite sad. Try and see things from his perspective about him needing that family connection and perhaps with the boundaries in place, you can work on building a relationship.

Mummy08m · 30/06/2023 11:44

I wouldn't like this either. I have a (younger) half-brother who, at one stage, kept trying to get in contact and I just wasn't interested. He's the son of my feckless, aggressive, estranged dad, from a second wife who I barely knew, they weren't married long. I felt cynical that my half-brother wanted support from me (financial or otherwise - I had reasons for suspecting this) but even if he didn't, he was a complete stranger to me. Anyway I managed to give cool enough replies that he gave up in the end.

I don't believe in the importance of a genetic link. If you haven't grown up together, and don't feel you want to be friends, you don't owe him anything. I chuckled at the pp who said "but you didn't grow up with your dh either, is he not family". That's so not comparable! You chose your dh, you love him, you have things in common with him (maybe age, values, interests, etc). You haven't chosen this man as family. You have nothing in common and you don't particularly like him. Who cares if he's a nice man. Millions of nice men out there that I don't exchange Christmas presents with.

Where you went wrong was going along with all this. Why invite him and his family to your house? You should have been much firmer and more boundaried from the start. This will require a long gradual back-pedalling.

DriveMeCrazy1974 · 30/06/2023 11:41

I think you're being incredibly harsh. However, I also understand why. I grew up without a father, but I knew his name and I know he has 2 other children out there. I also know that part of me has spent years wondering what he was like (I know he died a few years ago) but also wondering about the rest of my relatives who I've never met.
I wouldn't want to force myself upon these people, but, there is always that thing of wondering who you are like, what personality traits you share etc and, out of morbid curiosity more than anything, if I had the opportunity, I'd love to spend time getting to know them. I have 2 other brothers, so it's not like I'm an only child, but I think, if I didn't have them, I would be even more keen to spend time with 'new' relatives that I'd found out about.

Can't you just see the visits with him as kind of like spending time with an older relative, something you don't want to do very often, but you know it's kind of a moral obligation once in a while? Failing that, maybe tell him that it's not easy for you to have people to your home anymore and meet up at hotels or restaurants?

Maevie · 30/06/2023 11:41

I'm with you OP. I have a cousin like this (I have great close cousins on one side who I grew up with, and one on the other side who I never met until adulthood) and he seems a decent person as much as I can tell, but I have no desire for another person in my life when I'm barely able to find time to keep up with my own friends and close family. Life is busy!

However, it doesn't matter how you are related or how nice the person is. Nobody ever has any right to force you into a relationship you do not want. You make your own decisions. Be polite of course, but don't be forced. It's not okay.

As to how you slowly eke him out of your life, I suggest busyness. My cousin eventually got the hint but it did take a couple of years. I was always busy, rarely specified what I was busy with. The other option is to be honest in the kindest way you can, and again use busyness as a reason. It is really hard though.

Ikeatears · 30/06/2023 11:40

This strikes a bit of fear in me. I'm adopted and made contact last year with my 2 half brothers. One hasn't maintained much of a relationship and that's fine. He's been nice but we don't meet up or message. I send birthday and Christmas cards but that's it, more or less. He's the same with our other brother.
The other brother has fully embraced our relationship and our families have spent the year getting to know each other. We send photos of the kids, congratulate them on achievements and meet up regularly both with and without the children. I've also made a good friendship with my SIL.
If I thought he was feeling like you, I would be so upset. Not because it's his duty as family but because he knows me now, so it would feel personal.
That being said, dh and I have lots of siblings and prefer the company of some over others. We invite them on our own terms and we just say no if we don't fancy doing something. I'm not sure it has to be all or nothing.

SparklingLime · 30/06/2023 11:39

His behaviour is clearly very intense and intrusive. But if you post in AIBU, you'll mainly get people wanting to tell you just how utterly unreasonable you are. Try again in Relationships, may be?

CuriouslyDifferent · 30/06/2023 11:38

I think, you need to be blunt and honest with him. In a 1-2-1

its going to be brutal, cos he does sounds like he’s doing his best, but if it’s not what you want, or you need it to back off a bit, then you need what you need.

Maybe you can couch it in terms of setting some boundaries, but, from what you describe, maybe you want zero contact.

I don’t want to say you are either of the reasonable, I just think it’s a rubbish situation that’s getting out of control.

Holly60 · 30/06/2023 11:37

He sounds lovely and you sound incredibly ungrateful.

It stood out that you say you get on well with your other siblings but that you aren't close. Do you struggle with getting too close to people in general?

You also keep saying you have nothing in common with his family whilst at the same time refusing to do anything that might give you something in common. If you spent the time together that he seems to want to, you'd end up with lots of shared experiences that would give you stuff to chat and laugh about.

I feel really sad for him that he got you as his only sibling. I hope his future will be filled with his children and their families and that will give him the loving extended family he deserves.

CultureAlienationBoredomandDespair · 30/06/2023 11:35

I find it odd you keep saying he’s basically a stranger when it seems you’ve been in each other’s lives for several years and regular contact. Perhaps you’re projecting feelings towards your dad into him as he sounds like a lovely guy and nothing is ringing alarm bells apart from your behaviour.

Darby3785 · 30/06/2023 11:34

They sound like they are ecstatic to have you in their family OP, all that effort they are making really warmed my heart.

To be honest, if you can't be bothered, they are better off without you not the other way around. Ignoring them and wanting to stage a huge fall out with them so you don't have to talk to them, the issue isn't with them and i think you need to get to the bottom of why you feel this way.

If you do really want to push him away, then you need to tell him what you have told us. That should do it! It will cause a lot of hurt and there may be no going back. I've had family disregard me like I don't matter due to issues they have and it's not easy. I needed therapy so please do think about the effect this is going to have

I just hope you don't regret it if you do decide to cut him and his family off.