Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to end relationship with my brother because I cba?

238 replies

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 10:53

Hello and thanks for reading.

Im going to sound awful for this post I know but I need to vent it and get impartial advice. I’m prepared for vipers.

Background: I have 5 half siblings. I grew up in the same house with 4 of them. We are all adults now with our own families and get on well but not close.
The fifth sibling was my dads son who is 15 years older than me and I did not grow up with and did not know or meet until after my dad died.

Met this sibling when I was 19 and they were 34. They have no other siblings.
He’s a nice man but due to the age gap and not being raised together we have 0 in common.
However due to him having no siblings he has tried really hard over the years to force a relationship.
He’s gone out of his way to make this happen. Travelling across the country to things like my graduation and the birth of my child. Sending presents and cards on birthdays and at Christmas. Always trying to ring me and arrange meet ups.
He has a wife and kids and they are also super enthusiastic to have a relationship.

Now this is where I feel an awful person. I do not reciprocate the feelings at all and find it smothering and a bit weird if I’m honest.
We have nothing in common other than sharing a dad neither of us really knew.
He makes more effort than me and my siblings do for eachother and is really over familiar. When he and his family come they insist on staying in my house when my own siblings get a hotel. I have a house with spare rooms so can’t really say no but it’s awkward.
They try and arrange joint family holidays which I make excuses not to do and send me drawings their kids have done in the post.

Because we weren’t raised together and there is a huge age gap it’s essentially a stranger trying to exert themselves into your life at every opportunity.
My other siblings I have little in common with but we have a shared history and familiarity so have our own banter and jokes and understand each others quirks and ways so I can spend a weekend with them and tell them to go away or whatever. When they’re being annoying. My nieces and nephews feel like ‘mine’ and it feels like family and not a weird chore i’m doing.

Since having my child my brother and his family have stepped it up a notch and constantly want to meet and be in contact as he’s an ‘uncle’ now.
Their kids ranging from 2 - 19 year old (massive age gaps) call me auntie and my DP uncle and it feels awkward as they are literal strangers.
My DB and his wife will try and give parenting tips on visits which comes across as rude as critical because there is no foundation of a relationship like our own siblings so it feels like a stranger/acquaintance saying it.

I have tried to distance myself over the years but they don’t get the hint. I don’t respond to calls and take days to reply to texts but they still persist. They will go through their calendar for that year until they find a date we are free for a visit even if it’s 6 months away. They send expensive and thoughtful presents for all our birthdays which makes me feel indebted to them to continue the relationship.
They've even tried to ‘book on’ to our family holidays when we’ve told them we’re going somewhere (saying they might come too and looking up tickets on their phone there and then, I’m not joking!).
They keep pestering to spend Christmas together which I’ve managed to bat off! We have loads of other very close family and now our own kids to be contending with, we don’t want to host strangers on top on Christmas Day and it’s weird they even want to spend such a day together.

I know it sounds selfish but I have loads of siblings already as does DP. Infact DP has 4 full siblings who also have families so between us we have loads of siblings, nieces and nephews which is difficult enough to keep up with. However my DB and his family demand more attention than all our siblings put together! Because they only have me as ‘family’ they put all their attention onto us.

I personally would be happy with just sending an annual Christmas card and seeing their updates via social media at most. I don’t have the time or interest.
But I don’t want to hurt them either. They are nice people. I understand they want extended family as they don’t have it, but I can’t provide it.

What do I do?

I’ve tried every kind of ‘drifting away’ method possible. I feel like the only way out is to have some kind of huge fall out and go no contact because they will go to such great lengths to maintain this relationship that there is no other way. Even if I up and moved to Australia I have 0 doubt they’d use their annual leave to visit annually. That’s how full on they are.

OP posts:
TeleTropes · 30/06/2023 13:31

I wouldn’t consider a person I speak to regularly on the phone for 1h, whose children I have met and who have stayed at my house a “random” or a “stranger”. How have you not get to know him in all this time?

You can have a relationship with him (if you want) while not seeing him as family.

It’s up to you to set boundaries in the relationship, which it doesn’t sound like you have done (I wouldn’t have anyone staying at my house, no matter how much they insisted).

Conkersinautumn · 30/06/2023 13:27

I get it, there's nothing between you and he's trying way to hard to be a very close family member. I'd want to push away too.

I'd bring up that you're still struggling with the revelation of him and that you understand he's not had siblings until now but that he needs to give the relationship space to grow, rather than overwatering it (if he likes a gardening analogy)

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 13:24

Also in an ideal world what I would have wanted is to have met for the first time to satisfy each other’s curiosity. Then when realising that we have little in common to have maintained contact through the odd Christmas/birthday card and maybe go for a meal every couple of years if in each others area.

That would be ideal in all honesty. None of this forced intense closeness.

OP posts:
Sigmama · 30/06/2023 13:23

Well at least he'll die before you so you won't have to deal with him anymore

AgathaSpencerGregson · 30/06/2023 13:22

Time40 · 30/06/2023 11:25

The problem here is that he feels that there is an important relationship just because of the family tie, and you feel that the family tie is unimportant - having grown up with people is the thing that makes you feel that they are "yours". I don't think he's weird or smothering; you just have very different ways of thinking about family relationships. Also, you haven't "clicked" with him, so even after years, he still feels like a stranger.

There is no easy way out of this. If you want to cut ties with him and his family, you are going to cause an awful lot of hurt - you just need to decide if your desire to be free of him is worth the pain you will cause.

What does your DP think of your brother and his family? Does he like them, and not mind spending time with them?

You say he's a nice man, and you also say that he still seems like a stranger. Have you tried talking to him in more depth, and trying to get to know him better?

Cut him off if you really want to, OP - but don't underestimate the value of having people in your life who really care about you. I bet your brother would come through for you if you needed help.

What a wise and thoughtful post. I don’t mean to sound patronising. It’s just increasingly rare to see things discussed in such a way.

Blughbablugh · 30/06/2023 13:19

As someone who has a brother who has actively avoided me for the past few years and who my dc don't even know exist due to his absolute lack of interest or effort, yabu!

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 13:14

Thanks for all your responses I am really taking them all on board and thinking from those perspectives.

The reason I say ‘stranger’ is because I don’t feel closer to him than I would an acquaintance.

Imagine being a 19 year old girl in her first year of uni and meeting a 34 year old man with an ex wife and kids. A man who you have 0 in common with. No simile interests, no same sense of humour, completely different life stages. Imagine that man then deciding to travel all the way up to your uni halls every other term when your at uni after the first meeting and checking into a hotel so you can ‘hang out’ for the weekend. It was so awkward but he was nice enough and I am a people pleaser so felt I couldn’t say no. This luckily only lasted until my second year when I was then sent away for placements.
However this for me was odd behaviour back then and even now but I understand he was desperate for connection to forced myself through these awkward visits.

But why would a man with an established life and kids want to travel up to uni halls regularly to hang out with a 19 year old he has little in common with just because we share the same father?

As time has gone on this has continued. The deeper I’ve gotten in the more I feel I can’t say no.

I managed to not see him for 2 years whilst I was travelling and he’d still constantly try and call me more than my other siblings ever would. When I got back I met his now wife for the first time who was nice but again, nothing in common and not someone I would ever socialise with. The second time I met her she asked me to be her bridesmaid! It meant so much to them I said yes as I was on the spot and only 23 and they were both around 40 and took me to dinner.

The whole experience was a nightmare and gave me anxiety as I was expected to act like close family and attend wedding photo shoots and all sorts with a bunch of much older strangers I had nothing in common with just to appease them.

This has escalated over the years in this way.

My other siblings are not related to him. They find the whole thing hilarious and strange. It’s like my DB has an imagine of how families should be and is trying to recreate that. For example, when I bought my first house, my other siblings got me bottles of Prosecco and champagne, congratulated me, that was that. My DB however bought me a load of brand new house appliances costing a small fortune and then he and his wife invited themselves over to see it and were a bit critical of my other siblings for not putting in so much effort. But for me my siblings reactions were normal and they were the ones being OTT.

Also I don’t think genetic link seems to be enough for a relationship without history or common interests. We don’t watch the same shows, like the same music or even have the same sense of humour. I’m very sarcastic and self deprecating and my DB and his wife would take these comments literally or not understand why I find something funny causing awkward silences.
They are all vegans whereas we are meat eaters so we don’t even have food in common.

My other siblings I also don’t have much in common with, but we have the same sense of humour so can laugh for hours and understand each others weird ways from growing up and can happily tell each other to piss off without causing offence. If we go on a weekend away together we can play our childhood board games and catch up on gossip about childhood friends and family.
If me and my siblings didn’t grow up together then we wouldn’t have this foundation so probably wouldn’t ever hang out or even cross paths.

In regards to my father being the reason I feel this way, maybe so? My bio dad I only ever met a couple of times in my life. However I had a stepdad who was like my dad and I’ve never really been bothered about my bio dad not bothering. I never sought him out. My needs were met from a paternal perspective so I felt neutral about it.

OP posts:
OneHurtSpaggettio · 30/06/2023 13:12

Hi OP,

Firstly, sorry about the people who are calling you horrible. I don’t think you are horrible, FWIW, just another human being who is responding to both the past and the present in the best way they know how.

Secondly, to me, my analysis of the situation is:

A) You grew up as 1 of 5 siblings, being the only one (I assume) in the household who had a different father. Being part of a large family of siblings holds its own challenges and resentments in terms of feeling as though your parents are meeting your emotional needs, but also being the only “other” sibling, also adds to these feelings, which I feel has made you have a relatively cool to cold relationship with your siblings, as a self-protection mechanism.

Most people want to spend time with their siblings because they love them and trust that they have your best interests at heart and the associated closeness that comes with that, but that seems absent, which is what is colouring your impression of the “other brother.” It is a learned response from how you had to relate to your siblings in order to protect your emotions when growing up.

B) Other brother enters the scene when you are 19 and seems to want all of the love and closeness and mentorship that was absent in your relationships with your other siblings, but you are unable to emotionally respond because of how you have been “programmed” to receive sibling relationships. The difference here is that you do not have the shared history to tie you to this brother, and you are unable to form the emotional closeness that he wants because of the vulnerability that would require of you, so your needs are unable to align.

I also wonder if “other brother” reminds you of the pain of having not known your father, and in keeping other brother at arm’s length, you are again responding to how you emotionally coped with being estranged from your bio dad whilst growing up in a family where you were the “other sibling” ie didn’t share the same parents as the other 4 siblings. This feeling of wanting to reject other brother’s love in order to protect your heart could very well be subconscious.

Solution:
The only solution is to sit down with yourself and practice radical honesty about why you don’t want this relationship with other brother.

You then need to speak to other brother and explain to him that for a number of years you have felt as though he is trying to create emotional bonds, connections and love that you feel unable to receive or respond to, which creates a cycle of blame/shame within yourself which only pushes you from him further.

Explain to him that you would like a break from the relationship and that you will be in touch when/if you feel differently.

It is critical to both your emotional health and to his that you are honest.

GlassWall · 30/06/2023 13:06

Magssss · 30/06/2023 12:49

Would you be interested in having a connection with him if he wasn’t so suffocating or do you prefer no connection at all?

This.

OP, I can see both sides — his desperate longing to be involved, you finding it way too much, and without his obvious desire for a sibling, when you already have several.

I was also struck by you saying several times that you have ‘nothing in common — what is it you mean by this? Do you dislike him as a personality?

TheGreenSketch · 30/06/2023 12:59

I hope he finds some friends or a long lost cousin who’d welcome him, as you're not worth the effort at all.

Testina · 30/06/2023 12:54

Well, you don’t owe him anything so of course you can cut him off.

But half your OP is telling us that you’ve had years of him staying with you, attending your graduation, phoning you every week etc… and half of your OP is you telling us he’s a stranger to you. It’s not both 🤷🏻‍♀️

He’s not a stranger - he’s just not someone you like enough to be bothered with.

schnauzerbeard · 30/06/2023 12:52

I wish my brothers would make this effort

Magssss · 30/06/2023 12:49

Would you be interested in having a connection with him if he wasn’t so suffocating or do you prefer no connection at all?

Daleksatemyshed · 30/06/2023 12:46

The trouble is Op that you have a completely different view of this to your half DB. If he grew up as an only child he might have always wanted a sibling and be thrilled to have finally met you, whereas you already had siblings and just wanted a casual relationship. He's pushing for the close relationship he thinks you would have had but by coming on so strong he's actually frightening you off. Is there are way you can see him now and again but without it being a big intense occasion? If he keeps trying to get into your life uninvited I can see you falling out with him which would be a shame

Natty13 · 30/06/2023 12:32

All the posters saying "but he's family" make me wonder how you define family. For me, it isn't just having a DNA link to someone. If I found out tomorrow that my brother wasn't biologically related to me by some fluke, he'd still be my brother. Many of the posters saying he's your family are basing that on you having the same father (whom neither of you had much of a relationship with). So if either of you had a DNA test and found out that man wasn't your father, would he still be your brother?

I don't think the OP owes him anything on the basis of "family" however I can think that and still feel very sorry for the man.

pandarific · 30/06/2023 12:26

@MissChatterbox1 is there a bit of a class or money or culture difference between you and your brother? You emphasise you have ‘nothing in common’ with him several times. Is there something about this that rubs you up the wrong way? Or is it the link with your dad you didn’t really know that you don’t like?

Though I can understand your feelings it might be better to just explain you find the problem behaviours a bit full on, and if he could just relax a bit might be your best bet for a quieter life.

FluffyFlannery · 30/06/2023 12:21

What a horror you are. You don't deserve such a lovely man in your life.

Watchinghurling · 30/06/2023 12:18

Honestly, I think you're really lucky to have him. He's a half brother and takes a real interest in your life. My own full brother is OK but isn't even a tenth as involved with me. He takes some interest sometimes but generally no. I see him face to face about twice a year. I would like to have a sibling who I was more connected to.

NBLarsen · 30/06/2023 12:18

You're allowed to have a relationship or not however you choose, that's up to you, this is your life.

However, it sounds as though you decided from the very beginning that you wouldn't be close to him and you've closed your mind to any of his attempts to build that relationship. I wonder if you resent him because of your opinion of your father, when in fact, you have that in common.

If you'd been open to building something with him you could have had a great relationship, regardless of age or any other circumstance. He is your brother.

kindmama15 · 30/06/2023 12:18

I’ve got no family if I found I had a half sibling when I had no others I’d make the effort to, he sounds lovely even if a tad over the top (if he’s never had a sibling he’s trying his hardest!) you sound quite bitter that you’ve got a half sibling which is a shame as you may need them one day!

dottypotter · 30/06/2023 12:18

RisingSunn · 30/06/2023 12:04

I definitely think you can enforce some boundaries here.

Family is so valuable - however they come about. I think cutting off a half brother like this is awful. He seems a wonderful uncle for your children (even though they have loads already).

He has no other extended family - can’t you make a tiny bit of space for him?

Agree, be kind. Turn the situation around and your him, how would you feel?

standardduck · 30/06/2023 12:17

I think people are being really harsh.

I don't think you are an awful person for not wanting to have a close relationship with him and his family. But I think you need to be quite honest with him, otherwise it's not fair on him. He is thinking of you as a family and makes a lot of effort, while you find him a bit of a burden.

SequinsandStilettos · 30/06/2023 12:16

What about your other three siblings - does he have close contact with them too? How did/do they deal with it?

girlfriend44 · 30/06/2023 12:16

Twice you've mentioned age gaps, it's not necessary. He is your brother full stop whatever age. Really irrelevant.
It's how people are as people bot their ages.

Butchyrestingface · 30/06/2023 12:12

I too feel sorry for him. He hasn't had the benefit of a shared biography with 4 half siblings that you do and is happy to have found what he thinks of as extended 'family' in adulthood.

That said, I'm surprised he hasn't sensed something is off given your attitude.
What age is your child, @MissChatterbox1 ? How do they get on with him and his family? I'm tended to feel a child can never have too many doting aunties and uncles and in your place, would want to foster a relationship with extended family for that reason.

That said:

When he and his family come they insist on staying in my house when my own siblings get a hotel. I have a house with spare rooms so can’t really say no but it’s awkward.
They try and arrange joint family holidays which I make excuses not to do

I can see how this must feel really intense, particularly if you don't have that sort of relationship with your other siblings that you grew up with.

Did you always feel this strongly about it, or is since you've had a child the feelings are more intense?

Swipe left for the next trending thread