Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to end relationship with my brother because I cba?

238 replies

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 10:53

Hello and thanks for reading.

Im going to sound awful for this post I know but I need to vent it and get impartial advice. I’m prepared for vipers.

Background: I have 5 half siblings. I grew up in the same house with 4 of them. We are all adults now with our own families and get on well but not close.
The fifth sibling was my dads son who is 15 years older than me and I did not grow up with and did not know or meet until after my dad died.

Met this sibling when I was 19 and they were 34. They have no other siblings.
He’s a nice man but due to the age gap and not being raised together we have 0 in common.
However due to him having no siblings he has tried really hard over the years to force a relationship.
He’s gone out of his way to make this happen. Travelling across the country to things like my graduation and the birth of my child. Sending presents and cards on birthdays and at Christmas. Always trying to ring me and arrange meet ups.
He has a wife and kids and they are also super enthusiastic to have a relationship.

Now this is where I feel an awful person. I do not reciprocate the feelings at all and find it smothering and a bit weird if I’m honest.
We have nothing in common other than sharing a dad neither of us really knew.
He makes more effort than me and my siblings do for eachother and is really over familiar. When he and his family come they insist on staying in my house when my own siblings get a hotel. I have a house with spare rooms so can’t really say no but it’s awkward.
They try and arrange joint family holidays which I make excuses not to do and send me drawings their kids have done in the post.

Because we weren’t raised together and there is a huge age gap it’s essentially a stranger trying to exert themselves into your life at every opportunity.
My other siblings I have little in common with but we have a shared history and familiarity so have our own banter and jokes and understand each others quirks and ways so I can spend a weekend with them and tell them to go away or whatever. When they’re being annoying. My nieces and nephews feel like ‘mine’ and it feels like family and not a weird chore i’m doing.

Since having my child my brother and his family have stepped it up a notch and constantly want to meet and be in contact as he’s an ‘uncle’ now.
Their kids ranging from 2 - 19 year old (massive age gaps) call me auntie and my DP uncle and it feels awkward as they are literal strangers.
My DB and his wife will try and give parenting tips on visits which comes across as rude as critical because there is no foundation of a relationship like our own siblings so it feels like a stranger/acquaintance saying it.

I have tried to distance myself over the years but they don’t get the hint. I don’t respond to calls and take days to reply to texts but they still persist. They will go through their calendar for that year until they find a date we are free for a visit even if it’s 6 months away. They send expensive and thoughtful presents for all our birthdays which makes me feel indebted to them to continue the relationship.
They've even tried to ‘book on’ to our family holidays when we’ve told them we’re going somewhere (saying they might come too and looking up tickets on their phone there and then, I’m not joking!).
They keep pestering to spend Christmas together which I’ve managed to bat off! We have loads of other very close family and now our own kids to be contending with, we don’t want to host strangers on top on Christmas Day and it’s weird they even want to spend such a day together.

I know it sounds selfish but I have loads of siblings already as does DP. Infact DP has 4 full siblings who also have families so between us we have loads of siblings, nieces and nephews which is difficult enough to keep up with. However my DB and his family demand more attention than all our siblings put together! Because they only have me as ‘family’ they put all their attention onto us.

I personally would be happy with just sending an annual Christmas card and seeing their updates via social media at most. I don’t have the time or interest.
But I don’t want to hurt them either. They are nice people. I understand they want extended family as they don’t have it, but I can’t provide it.

What do I do?

I’ve tried every kind of ‘drifting away’ method possible. I feel like the only way out is to have some kind of huge fall out and go no contact because they will go to such great lengths to maintain this relationship that there is no other way. Even if I up and moved to Australia I have 0 doubt they’d use their annual leave to visit annually. That’s how full on they are.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 30/06/2023 15:56

She met him at 19, a stranger.

They have never connected.

Sad but life.

We have siblings we love and care about that but we still only attend the really big moments in each others lives, like weddings and funerals, certainly not graduations, religious ceremonies and the like, occasionally big birthday gatherings.
There is no way any of us feel so compelled, although we all care about each other.

OP, you sound like you are a huge people pleaser that is deeply resentful.

Personally I couldn't, nor wouldn't be prepared to spend so much time with someone that I felt so disinterested and indifferent towards.

So what if you share DNA, that certainly doesn't mean you will have anything in common with each, particularly as you met so late in life, relatively speaking.

So many posts are of the be kind suck it up position.

It's sad and tedious, because men never seem to have this constant pressure to be kind and ignore their own preferences.

Nanny0gg · 30/06/2023 15:52

Hollyppp · 30/06/2023 14:24

I really feel for him. He sounds nice!!

I think he (they) sound intense!

cassandre · 30/06/2023 15:47

I can't believe how many people are telling you you should carry on as you are, OP.

This is an unequal relationship that seems to be entirely on his terms, not yours. The fact that he's older than you (which was the case when you first met, and set the pattern for your relationship) and the fact that he's a man might contribute to the way he's not taking your feelings into account. But whatever the cause, it's not OK. The relationship you describe with your other siblings sounds much more equal and therefore much more healthy.

Is there a middle ground between doing everything on his terms and cutting him off altogether? As other posters have said, I would be polite but honest with him and set some boundaries. You're not comfortable hosting him and his family overnight. You need phone calls to be less frequent. These are completely reasonable boundaries to set.

His feelings may be hurt, but that's the consequence of him disregarding your feelings for so long. If he really cares about you and wants to preserve a relationship, he will change his behaviour and listen to what you say about your own needs and desires. If it turns out that he wants all or nothing, then that would be a good reason to cut him off entirely. But I would try honesty first.

It also sounds like he's trying to buy your love and loyalty through money and gifts, like the sibling equivalent of a Disney dad. That's not healthy either as it puts you under an obligation to be grateful.

No one has the right to be an intimate part of your life, not even a sibling, unless YOU want them to. As a therapist once said to me, take control. And don't feel guilty. Good luck!

edenhills · 30/06/2023 15:40

Sorry if you've said and I've missed it but exactly how long has this "stranger" been in your life?

Nordicrain · 30/06/2023 15:38

I think it sounds like he is better off without you.

bonzaitree · 30/06/2023 15:37

How are you different OP?

Are you just polar opposites on everything?

oprahfan · 30/06/2023 15:31

What @underneaththeash says. Exactly this. Please look again, and think again.

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 15:21

Still reading replies.

very mixed bag of responses which kind of reflects how I feel.

I’ve maintained the relationship for over a decade reluctantly in order to ‘be kind’ and not ‘awful’ or ‘selfish’ like other posters have put it. But do I have to do this now for the rest of my life? Every year I have to host a family I don’t want to really see to make them happy? I have to answer phone calls, attend all their events and celebrate all their milestones until the day I die?

As my life moves on with a growing family, babies, work, partner, parents etc I have such little bandwidth left that I am finding it exceedingly difficult to continue with an intense relationship I have little interest in.

If I do have a very rare free weekend with resources to host or travel, I want to use that to maintain relationships I genuinely care about but have little time for these, like friends I’ve had since school or elderly aunts who don’t have long left but live a distance. Selfish as it seems but I spend weeks on the build up to these ‘meet ups’ filled with anxiety and dreading it. Then when they’re here or I’m there I’m counting down the hours until it’s over. The entire time is filled with small talk or they want to get into debates due to their strong opinions about various topics (veganism or something). We are just such different people.

I have tried to find common ground of course I have, I don’t just sit there silent. But there is little there. We were raised completely differently, with different outlooks and interests.

I wish I’d been stronger at 19 and stopped all contact after the first meet tbh.

So now I’m at a crossroads and this thread hasn’t really changed anything, if anything I’m more confused.

You got some posters who get how I feel and say it’s okay to walk away, but then there are even louder comments saying it’s a horrible thing to do and I should be grateful. So what do I do? Just accept this is it now and mentally prepare myself for however many decades of unwanted hosting, phone calls and family holidays?

But if I don’t accept it I am a bad person?

ahhhhh!!

OP posts:
Pallisers · 30/06/2023 15:15

bonzaitree · 30/06/2023 14:45

Hm is it that he doesn’t understand or is it that OP hasn’t told him / made it clear to him?

I don't think many of us feel the need to make clear to siblings that they shouldn't surprise us by showing up on our holiday abroad.

Sallywallywoowoo · 30/06/2023 14:56

Honestly I don't get it at all. I have a half sister who is 24, I'm 45. She loves in another country so I don't see her very often and tbh we don't really speak very often either. BUT when we do see each other we are SISTERS. There's no half about it. We don't really have too much shared history because we've never lived in the same country and our shared parent is dead. But I love her as much as I love my "full" sister. The 3 of us would do anything for each other.
I think you're being weird and mean.

Lovesacake · 30/06/2023 14:51

He’s not a stranger if he’s been in your life for over 12 years!
and by the ages you’ve given you’ve known some of his kids since birth, and he’s known yours since birth….so they definitely aren’t strangers!

Comedycook · 30/06/2023 14:51

You sound like you're lacking in emotional intelligence op. You're interpreting his behaviour as over familiar...it's pretty obvious he's trying to make a connection. Its a very sad thread. You appear to be quite selfish, you're ok as you have family so sod him. The more time you spend together the more you will genuinely get to know each other and build a real familiarity.

SoWhatEh · 30/06/2023 14:50

imagine a random person...

But it's not a random person. It's your brother. A blood relation. You say you have nothing in common, but if you allowed them into your life, you'd have shared experience in common - the kids could play with cousins and see them at Christmas.

But they also sound a bit pushy as though they have no respect for boundaries, so I can imagine how off-putting that is.

Could you meet up once or twice a year on neutral territory? Suggest a day at a wildlife or amusement park. Or a day at London museums with dinner and a show.

That way they are not so intrusive but you get to maintain a relationship.

bonzaitree · 30/06/2023 14:45

AbsoIutelyLovely · 30/06/2023 14:44

COMPLETELY AGREE

I find many of the other responses really alarming. He sounds like he has absolutely no understanding of other peoples boundaries and needs.

Hm is it that he doesn’t understand or is it that OP hasn’t told him / made it clear to him?

AbsoIutelyLovely · 30/06/2023 14:44

billy1966 · 30/06/2023 14:37

OP, you absolutely have my sympathy.

He may mean well but you feel as you do and that is absolutely your right.

You don't owe him a relationship or a part of your life.

Of course I can understand your value to him and his wish for a relationship, but he doesn't have any right to one.

That level of intrusion into my life like that would make me itch.

However much he wants a relationship with you because of his lack of family, you really are not under any obligation to meet that need.

Haven't read them, but these types of threads will attract the "women suck it up and be kind " posts, but as a post menopausal woman I think nope, you don't have to allow him to trample on your boundaries and constantly insert himself in your lives.

Staying in your home, tagging along on holidays? Nope.

Absolutely not, if that is not what you want.

I think you need to either have a chat or write him a letter.

You can try and do it kindly, but it will likely really upset him as he is so needy and is do intent on being in your life.

You can try and frame it kindly.
You have a really busy life, with a huge family and you simply are not able to, nor wish to give up all the time he requires.

You can say you have no wish to hurt him, that you really wish him well, but that you have X number of siblings and friends, a career, young children and you do not have the time.

Tell him you are happy to exchange cards, but beyond that you really do not have the time and space in your life.

This whole relationship from the beginning has been lopsided and about his needs.

Obviously you were very silly to have entertained it for so long.

Your choices are to suck it up, refuse to reply to his contacting you, or try and send a polite, 'kind as you can' letter, wishing him well but explaining you neither have the time nor the energy/interest in being closely involved.

You need to own that you are going to hurt him, and accept that.

You have indulged him for years when you didn't want to, which is why your other siblings find it so hilarious.

Most people would have put boundaries in years ago.

The alternative is to keep saying no to meeting up and have a conversation that tells him you are too busy and that you have other pressing priorities.

I do feel sorry for him, but as a woman there is always someone that needs our support, time, imput, and it gets very wearing.

Best of luck.

COMPLETELY AGREE

I find many of the other responses really alarming. He sounds like he has absolutely no understanding of other peoples boundaries and needs.

bonzaitree · 30/06/2023 14:43

why not give him a call and say you’re really busy at the moment and feeling short of time and overwhelmed and that you will see him in the autumn (be vague) but you might be “off the radar” for a while.

then just ignore calls / texts etc until you want to meet on your terms in November or whenever?

Newestname002 · 30/06/2023 14:43

Nobody has an absolute right, however "nice" they are, to insert themselves into your life, whoever they are. Nor try and bulldoze themselves into your own precious family holiday. Nor "insist" on inviting themselves to events you are hosting and staying in your home with their family.

However, if you want to get some distance and less intensity between them and you, you may need to stop hinting and be clearer about the level of contact you would be more comfortable with and put some proper boundaries in place. That will be hard given the time that's already elapsed but maybe that's what you may need to think about. 🌹

bonzaitree · 30/06/2023 14:39

Recently my brother didn’t turn up to a holiday my dad booked and paid for. Said he was going to go then the day before claimed it was not possible.

he hasn’t got me a birthday present or card for 15 years. He never gets family present or cards even for Mother’s Day which makes my mum cry every year.

Id have your brother in a heartbeat.

billy1966 · 30/06/2023 14:37

OP, you absolutely have my sympathy.

He may mean well but you feel as you do and that is absolutely your right.

You don't owe him a relationship or a part of your life.

Of course I can understand your value to him and his wish for a relationship, but he doesn't have any right to one.

That level of intrusion into my life like that would make me itch.

However much he wants a relationship with you because of his lack of family, you really are not under any obligation to meet that need.

Haven't read them, but these types of threads will attract the "women suck it up and be kind " posts, but as a post menopausal woman I think nope, you don't have to allow him to trample on your boundaries and constantly insert himself in your lives.

Staying in your home, tagging along on holidays? Nope.

Absolutely not, if that is not what you want.

I think you need to either have a chat or write him a letter.

You can try and do it kindly, but it will likely really upset him as he is so needy and is do intent on being in your life.

You can try and frame it kindly.
You have a really busy life, with a huge family and you simply are not able to, nor wish to give up all the time he requires.

You can say you have no wish to hurt him, that you really wish him well, but that you have X number of siblings and friends, a career, young children and you do not have the time.

Tell him you are happy to exchange cards, but beyond that you really do not have the time and space in your life.

This whole relationship from the beginning has been lopsided and about his needs.

Obviously you were very silly to have entertained it for so long.

Your choices are to suck it up, refuse to reply to his contacting you, or try and send a polite, 'kind as you can' letter, wishing him well but explaining you neither have the time nor the energy/interest in being closely involved.

You need to own that you are going to hurt him, and accept that.

You have indulged him for years when you didn't want to, which is why your other siblings find it so hilarious.

Most people would have put boundaries in years ago.

The alternative is to keep saying no to meeting up and have a conversation that tells him you are too busy and that you have other pressing priorities.

I do feel sorry for him, but as a woman there is always someone that needs our support, time, imput, and it gets very wearing.

Best of luck.

Hollyppp · 30/06/2023 14:24

I really feel for him. He sounds nice!!

Appleblossompetal · 30/06/2023 14:22

A lot of us don’t have much in common with our own families but we maintain relationships due to shared history and experiences which bonds us

Surely it’s also genetics? I guess try to imagine how you would feel if it was the other way round and you only had one half sibling and no other family and really wanted them to be a part of your life.

OldHouseLover · 30/06/2023 14:18

I have mixed feelings about this as dh has a half sibling 15 years older (they had the same Dad). They have lived in different countries since ds was 10 yrs old & half sibling (hs) was 25. During those years when things were tough for dh - poor etc & hs was a fully functioning adult who made ZERO effort to stay in contact.

Fast forward to about 15 years ago- now dh is ab adult with a good career & we have a house & dc & hs suddenly reappears. Their kids are mostly grown up & they now have time for holidays & have decided that we have a nice house in a scenic location in another country & all of a sudden hs wants a close relationship

Poor dh was taken in at first & opened his arms (& house & wallet) only to slowly realise that hs has no REAL interest. No contact from one visit (holiday!!) To the next...books flights without even asking if it suits us...openly says they come coz it's a holiday.. doesn't put a hand in their wallet whilst here..etc

If they were great company or lovely & thoughtful it would be different. But they're dull company & spend ALL their time moaning & complaining about medical ailments despite only being in early 60s. Its hard work.

Dg is trying to pull back but hs has the hide of a rhino & doesn't take hints & just books the annual flights regardless. And gets odd if it clashes with something we have already planned.

It's v difficult not to feel we're being used for a free trip each year...

Pallisers · 30/06/2023 14:16

SunnyFrost · 30/06/2023 11:55

I think responses here have been very harsh. Finding a sibling as an adult is totally different to one you’ve grown up with and the bottom line is you don’t feel comfortable with the high level of contact and closeness this man is pushing on you. And that’s ok.

How often do we read on here that women should assert boundaries and not let men trample over them in the spirit of being ‘nice’ or ‘kind’? Yet when a woman posts on here feeling smothered and overwhelmed by excessive contact from someone she feels no particular connection with, all that goes out of the window and she’s basically told she’s a massive bitch because he needs a family from somewhere. Ok then.

It sounds very intense and bottom line is you do not owe this man and his family any type of relationship you’re not comfortable with. Can you have a chat and explain that you’re really glad you found each other and you value having him and his family in your life but you’re finding it a tricky relationship to navigate, having not grown up together and being a naturally more private person. Ask him to give you a bit more space to allow whatever type of sibling relationship you might end up having to grow naturally and make clear that you’re feeling pressured. If he doesn’t back off then you might need to be a bit more blunt and risk a proper falling out. But that’s ok. You don’t have to sacrifice what you want and need in order to ensure this man gets what he wants and needs. And don’t let the typically wild responses on AIBU convince you otherwise.

I agree with every word of this.

They sound very very intense - inviting themselves for xmas, trying to crash your holiday. you are not being horrible in trying to contain this relationship to what suits you.

Verv · 30/06/2023 14:12

I think go NC because he's wasting his time and money. Poor bloke.

FlamingMadKatie · 30/06/2023 14:09

I'm so surprised you're having such battering on here. They may be nice people, but my goodness they're not your responsibility. Just because they want a close relationship doesn't mean you should be forced to agree. I think all you can do is continue to politely keep your distance but I think I'd be frank about not having capacity for anyone else at Christmas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread