Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to end relationship with my brother because I cba?

238 replies

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 10:53

Hello and thanks for reading.

Im going to sound awful for this post I know but I need to vent it and get impartial advice. I’m prepared for vipers.

Background: I have 5 half siblings. I grew up in the same house with 4 of them. We are all adults now with our own families and get on well but not close.
The fifth sibling was my dads son who is 15 years older than me and I did not grow up with and did not know or meet until after my dad died.

Met this sibling when I was 19 and they were 34. They have no other siblings.
He’s a nice man but due to the age gap and not being raised together we have 0 in common.
However due to him having no siblings he has tried really hard over the years to force a relationship.
He’s gone out of his way to make this happen. Travelling across the country to things like my graduation and the birth of my child. Sending presents and cards on birthdays and at Christmas. Always trying to ring me and arrange meet ups.
He has a wife and kids and they are also super enthusiastic to have a relationship.

Now this is where I feel an awful person. I do not reciprocate the feelings at all and find it smothering and a bit weird if I’m honest.
We have nothing in common other than sharing a dad neither of us really knew.
He makes more effort than me and my siblings do for eachother and is really over familiar. When he and his family come they insist on staying in my house when my own siblings get a hotel. I have a house with spare rooms so can’t really say no but it’s awkward.
They try and arrange joint family holidays which I make excuses not to do and send me drawings their kids have done in the post.

Because we weren’t raised together and there is a huge age gap it’s essentially a stranger trying to exert themselves into your life at every opportunity.
My other siblings I have little in common with but we have a shared history and familiarity so have our own banter and jokes and understand each others quirks and ways so I can spend a weekend with them and tell them to go away or whatever. When they’re being annoying. My nieces and nephews feel like ‘mine’ and it feels like family and not a weird chore i’m doing.

Since having my child my brother and his family have stepped it up a notch and constantly want to meet and be in contact as he’s an ‘uncle’ now.
Their kids ranging from 2 - 19 year old (massive age gaps) call me auntie and my DP uncle and it feels awkward as they are literal strangers.
My DB and his wife will try and give parenting tips on visits which comes across as rude as critical because there is no foundation of a relationship like our own siblings so it feels like a stranger/acquaintance saying it.

I have tried to distance myself over the years but they don’t get the hint. I don’t respond to calls and take days to reply to texts but they still persist. They will go through their calendar for that year until they find a date we are free for a visit even if it’s 6 months away. They send expensive and thoughtful presents for all our birthdays which makes me feel indebted to them to continue the relationship.
They've even tried to ‘book on’ to our family holidays when we’ve told them we’re going somewhere (saying they might come too and looking up tickets on their phone there and then, I’m not joking!).
They keep pestering to spend Christmas together which I’ve managed to bat off! We have loads of other very close family and now our own kids to be contending with, we don’t want to host strangers on top on Christmas Day and it’s weird they even want to spend such a day together.

I know it sounds selfish but I have loads of siblings already as does DP. Infact DP has 4 full siblings who also have families so between us we have loads of siblings, nieces and nephews which is difficult enough to keep up with. However my DB and his family demand more attention than all our siblings put together! Because they only have me as ‘family’ they put all their attention onto us.

I personally would be happy with just sending an annual Christmas card and seeing their updates via social media at most. I don’t have the time or interest.
But I don’t want to hurt them either. They are nice people. I understand they want extended family as they don’t have it, but I can’t provide it.

What do I do?

I’ve tried every kind of ‘drifting away’ method possible. I feel like the only way out is to have some kind of huge fall out and go no contact because they will go to such great lengths to maintain this relationship that there is no other way. Even if I up and moved to Australia I have 0 doubt they’d use their annual leave to visit annually. That’s how full on they are.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 01/07/2023 17:30

Vgbeat · 01/07/2023 09:07

I'm sorry but I feel.incredibly sorry for your brother and you don't sound the most empathetic person. Here is someone who sounds they have been ignored their entire life by your dad and his new family. He desperately wants to belong. He is only a stranger as you are making him one. How about taking the time to know him and his family, maybe find some common interests that the beauty of family you don't all have to be them same. Maybe take the stick out and enjoy that someone likes you and wants to spend time with you.

Why do his desires outweigh the OP's?

One can feel sorry for the brother AND still sympathize with OP being 'overrun' by him. The feelings aren't mutually exclusive. It's up to OP's brother to manage his own expectations, not for OP to give into them. OP has the right to set her own boundaries and have the relationship that works for her, even if that's no relationship at all. Perhaps if the brother hadn't been so overbearing, the OP might have been able to find a comfortable middle ground. As it is he's pushed and pushed into her life and now she has no more 'give' in her.

And that doesn't make her 'not empathetic'. Empathy means understanding another's feelings, it doesn't mean giving in to them. Just because you may 'empathize' with my desire to live in your house that certainly doesn't mean that you have to give it to me!

Avondale89 · 01/07/2023 14:50

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 18:29

@Avondale89 not true. I am taking everyone’s opinions on board but the advice I’m receiving is mostly that I’m an awful person and the only way to not be an awful person is to continue this relationship forevermore.

I have TRIED. People are acting like I’ve not ever given it a chance. I was a bridesmaid at the wedding, I’ve hosted them in my home many times despite hating every minute, I’ve answered their calls, I’ve sent their kids presents at birthdays and Christmas. I’ve done more than give it a chance. I’ve given him and his family more attention and time than I have my other siblings whom i have an actual bond with.

Nothing has changed if anything it’s just gotten worse.

Why do you give a shit what strangers on the internet think? It’s your life and your family.

Clearly if you want this man out of your life, which you’re well within your rights to, then you’re going to have to be a lot clearer and more forceful about it. I wouldn’t waste any more angst or time on it.

RisingSunn · 01/07/2023 14:39

Sorry I meant “just a DNA link” comments from other posters - not OP.

RisingSunn · 01/07/2023 14:36

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 18:29

@Avondale89 not true. I am taking everyone’s opinions on board but the advice I’m receiving is mostly that I’m an awful person and the only way to not be an awful person is to continue this relationship forevermore.

I have TRIED. People are acting like I’ve not ever given it a chance. I was a bridesmaid at the wedding, I’ve hosted them in my home many times despite hating every minute, I’ve answered their calls, I’ve sent their kids presents at birthdays and Christmas. I’ve done more than give it a chance. I’ve given him and his family more attention and time than I have my other siblings whom i have an actual bond with.

Nothing has changed if anything it’s just gotten worse.

I think here lies the problem. You don’t need to do all of the reciprocal things. Set up boundaries! That could be one phone call a year if you think you would be happy with that level of contact.

The cut off and block without providing the opportunity to rectify his behaviour is what I found off.

If after being clear with him he is this forceful and intrusive then that is a completely different conversation.

Also I find this “it’s just a DNA link” really strange - maybe it’s just me.

Titerama · 01/07/2023 12:43

It’s not the OP’s job to fix the harm done to her half-brother by their shared parent not being in his life.

She is allowed to say a firm no, and set boundaries.

Surprised to see so many replies advocating for fear obligation and guilt to govern the OP’s actions.

Curseofthenation · 01/07/2023 10:09

YANBU. An hour long call once a week? It's too much. Imagine if you did that with all of your DC's aunts and uncles. Sweet lord.

I would tell you're brother that you'd like to reduce the calls to once a month. Just say that life is too busy/hectic and you can no longer fit it in.

In terms of an annual visit, I do think that is quite nice tbh. Even if you don't enjoy it all that much, it is a good deed to your brother - who has no one else.

LlynTegid · 01/07/2023 09:43

I think you may need to be direct and expect a response indicating sadness or anger, if you really want to have little or nothing to do with them.

Vgbeat · 01/07/2023 09:07

I'm sorry but I feel.incredibly sorry for your brother and you don't sound the most empathetic person. Here is someone who sounds they have been ignored their entire life by your dad and his new family. He desperately wants to belong. He is only a stranger as you are making him one. How about taking the time to know him and his family, maybe find some common interests that the beauty of family you don't all have to be them same. Maybe take the stick out and enjoy that someone likes you and wants to spend time with you.

Addicted2Kale · 30/06/2023 23:29

I couldn't be bothered to read your life story. I got the point in two sentences. It baffles me that he wasting so much time and energy getting to know you. You're not worth it and you don't want it.

So tell him straight, like I'm telling you straight. But don't spend 8 hours waffling like you have here. Tell him you don't want him in your life and to leave you alone. Then block. Very simple.

Mylifeislikeaboatrace · 30/06/2023 23:15

👏Sometimes being kind should jog on and close the door behind it.

AcrossthePond55 · 30/06/2023 23:02

billy1966 · 30/06/2023 22:14

It's astounding in 2023 to read so many posts from people urging this poor woman to just "be kind" and forget that she has any agency whatsoever in her life.

She's had years and years of putting up with someone with a biological link to her, much older than her, whom has elbowed in on her life, despite her having fxxk all interest in him and their genetic link.

Unbelievable.

So delighted that I am raising my daughters to bat this type of intrusive, unwanted attention away, .....brutally, if necessary.

I would absolutely hate for any of my girls to be tolerating this unwanted attention from ANY man, even one who rocked up and said they share their DNA.🙄

She doesn't want him in her life.
End of.

She doesn't owe him his Disney family dream.

Just because they share DNA does not mean because she has a vagina, she owes him his happy family connection and experience, when SHE does not feel any connection with him.

This sure as hell would not happen if she was a man.

He'd have been blocked, muted, left unanswered, the minute it was established there was no connection.

But on MN it is a parallel universe.

I'm so thankful IRL, my friends wouldn't tolerate this for a second and would have told their daughters to tell him back off firmly, and cut him off if he didn't listen.

Hear hear!!! No one is 'owed' a relationship with ANYONE for any reason.

If this was a neighbour or coworker forcing themselves into OP's life I have a feeling certain answers would be quite different. Because they share DNA that means that OP must allow this person into her life according to his 'desires'? No, it does not. It's a shame OP didn't cut this off earlier but she was young and impressionable. Just because she's allowed it to drag on doesn't mean she can't now put up stronger boundaries. Or go completely NC, if she so chooses.

This is one of the reasons I've never wanted to go searching for my birth family. There are too many horror stories of pushy 'relatives' planting themselves on doorsteps. My cousin's 1/2-sibling 'found' her and although the 1/2-siblings are respectful of her boundaries, her bio-mother keeps pushing for a mother/child relationship and my cousin doesn't want or need that and it's very upsetting to my cousin. And very unfair!

billy1966 · 30/06/2023 22:14

It's astounding in 2023 to read so many posts from people urging this poor woman to just "be kind" and forget that she has any agency whatsoever in her life.

She's had years and years of putting up with someone with a biological link to her, much older than her, whom has elbowed in on her life, despite her having fxxk all interest in him and their genetic link.

Unbelievable.

So delighted that I am raising my daughters to bat this type of intrusive, unwanted attention away, .....brutally, if necessary.

I would absolutely hate for any of my girls to be tolerating this unwanted attention from ANY man, even one who rocked up and said they share their DNA.🙄

She doesn't want him in her life.
End of.

She doesn't owe him his Disney family dream.

Just because they share DNA does not mean because she has a vagina, she owes him his happy family connection and experience, when SHE does not feel any connection with him.

This sure as hell would not happen if she was a man.

He'd have been blocked, muted, left unanswered, the minute it was established there was no connection.

But on MN it is a parallel universe.

I'm so thankful IRL, my friends wouldn't tolerate this for a second and would have told their daughters to tell him back off firmly, and cut him off if he didn't listen.

Mylifeislikeaboatrace · 30/06/2023 21:23

'He's family' if you don't want a relationship with him then you don't have to. I'm sure you aren't the nasty person posters seem to think you are. But them what does it matter what randoms think? YOU need to decide what YOU want to do.

Familiesarecomplicated · 30/06/2023 21:11

Also, do give him the chance to understand and recalibrate before assuming you have to put your foot down - if he doesn’t know how you feel, how would he know that he needs to back off a bit? Just in general some transparency wouldn’t go amiss here.

Familiesarecomplicated · 30/06/2023 21:08

OP I confess to not having read the full thread, but I have read all your posts, so apologies if doubling up on advice. I understand the dilemma but what I think the biggest issue seems to be your reluctance to find some deeper empathy for your DB, while also taking control of your part of the relationship and providing an appropriate level of honesty. Of course, if you keep meeting with someone you’re “putting up” with and humouring and effectively lying to someone by omission they are always going to be a stranger to you and you will always feel their presence as an imposition. Because you say you’re a people pleaser and he is a lot older, it seems as though you’ve just tried to go with the flow and (now that no longer works for you) you think your only option is to cut the whole thing dead.

perhaps it might be possible for you to imagine, from his pov, what it might have been like growing up without his dad and later discovering he had a half sibling (but only after your dads death?) Do you know much about his childhood, whether it was easy and loving or not? Being a single mum can be really hard - he may have experienced some tricky times being raised by one (I am one, so I don’t say that with any judgement). Perhaps when he found out about you he imagined what HE would have liked when he had been your age (a sibling visiting uni) and tried to provide you with it? Perhaps he sees himself as a little bit responsible now your dad has gone and he is a lot older than you?

Maybe, by thinking about his situation empathetically and with a little less judgement you can reframe what he has been doing not as peculiar and desperate, but as an act of love (albeit and unwelcome one as far as you’re concerned). Some people (especially those deprived of close family connections) do feel that the biological connection is meaningful, and it does seem as though he has certainly been more than prepared to put effort into the relationship.

Maybe now you’re older it’s time to set aside some time, see him just the two of you and talk to him more honestly but compassionately about your feelings. Perhaps you can find a middle ground you’re comfortable with and say that, for instance, you’d love to meet up as families a couple of time a year for a day - while your kids are little can he come your way? When they all get older a day out together somewhere (national trust place / event) might work? It’s ok to say you feel you’re letting him down, that you worry you aren’t able to reciprocate the birthday cards/gifts etc. it’s ok to admit some fault and some frailty. It’s also ok to say you need some space and some activities and moments just feel too personal and intimate to share (eg Christmas/family holidays). it’s ok to say you don’t know if you can remember to always be sending birthday cards, and if you fail to then you worry he will be overly hurt. It would be nice to show some appreciation of the times (like when you were at uni) that he went out of his way to make a relationship with you.

Its complete fair to set boundaries, but the way you talk about it feels as though you don’t feel equipped to handle a more honest conversation and, as a result, stand to blow the whole thing up. It might be lovely for the children to have a connection as they grow. And for older children/teens to have connected older teens/young adults can be a real benefit for them (and for you as a parent).

Sorry, this is long. I guess I’m saying it doesn’t have to be so black and white. There actually is a way through this that could be mutually beneficial and enjoyable. Maybe it will always mean a bit more to him, maybe it’ll always feel a bit of a chore to you. But sometimes even a connection sustained by regular but brief meetings can become important and meaningful, if not to you then to others in the group.

I have family I only see a couple of times a year, but when you add that over a lifetime it is enough to form what feels like an important connection and on balance it’s definitely been a net positive. Perhaps you can build something that turns into the same and in 25 years you’ll be glad you did? (And perhaps your other siblings, instead of taking the piss out of him, could offer you some support and welcome him into the group by stopping by once a year, meeting him and his family etc. Even if it’s just essentially a lot of strangers having a chat over lunch, that’s hardly the most onerous annual event imaginable, and it may have emotional/practical benefits you can’t currently predict, in future).

Perhaps if you actually let him know you then you won’t constantly feel he is a complete stranger…

Good luck whatever you decide to do.

ANewAdventure · 30/06/2023 20:35

Having come back to read more - yes, you definitely need to put boundaries in place. Be up front and tell him that some of his actions make you feel uncomfortable. If you can find a middle ground, then great. If he can’t respect that, that may reflect more on him. I do think you’ve been a bit dismissive, but I can see that his lack of boundaries has put you on the back foot all this time, and it’s hard to feel a genuine connection with someone so suffocating.

ComeTheFckOnBridget · 30/06/2023 19:56

I don't think youre horrible at all.

Don't get me wrong, I feel a bit sorry for him wanting a closer relationship than you do - he clearly has an emotional need for a sibling, which you do not...So I agree with the advice you've had about boundaries (and think he's definitely overstepped natural boundaries).

I'd be careful about being blunt, but would restrict communications to Christmas and birthday cards.

Iknowthis1 · 30/06/2023 19:52

If you actually gave him some attention he wouldn't have to try so hard and appear so needy.

You are coming across as selfish and severely lacking in empathy.

excelledyourself · 30/06/2023 19:46

MissChatterbox1 · 30/06/2023 13:24

Also in an ideal world what I would have wanted is to have met for the first time to satisfy each other’s curiosity. Then when realising that we have little in common to have maintained contact through the odd Christmas/birthday card and maybe go for a meal every couple of years if in each others area.

That would be ideal in all honesty. None of this forced intense closeness.

You need to have a conversation with him, or your resentment is going to build and you're going to really hurt him.

Obviously the set up above isn't going to be enough for him. It's your ideal, but not his.

How much, if any, are you willing to compromise?

Gerwurtztraminer · 30/06/2023 19:35

I agree with everything @billy1966 and @Testina and @Mummy08 & others have said. You are not horrible /awful/cold/ unkind for not wanting this relationship. Ignore all the posters trying to tell you this; they can't understand what it's like in your shoes. Yes you made some mistakes in not putting your foot down earlier, accepting gifts etc but that's OK, you were young and unsure how to deal with a very pushy,weirdly insistent older man.

I also have half siblings I wasn't brought up with who I met as an adult. Some much older and some closer in age to me. They are nice enough people but luckily we all knew we didn't have enough in common to sustain any sort of long term contact. One is extremely and vocally religious with views I find unacceptable, that alone was a deal-breaker for me.

I think you need to write a brief, to the point letter. Not an email, a real letter in the post. Explain you understand he wants a close, high level of contact relationship but it isn't what you want or need. State you feel it's gone too far with visits and presents etc and you are now withdrawing so all that will now stop. Say you understand he'll be hurt by this and you are sorry, but it's what is right for you and your family. Wish him well, sign off. Don't reply to any response.

LuckyPeonies · 30/06/2023 19:11

OP, i don’t blame you. It all sounds burdensome, intrusive and smothering. Perhaps his wife has a small family as well, and they are desperate for a connection. The only way to cope is to enforce strict boundaries, nothing beyond your comfort level. That will either work or cause him to be offended and distance himself. Win/win for you, either way.

Daleksatemyshed · 30/06/2023 18:47

It's noticable how many posters are doing the classic he's family so you have to be nice to him but if you don't feel like he's family it's always going to be difficult. Be honest, if this was someones partner there'd be a few red flags here- he buys her presents she hasn't asked for, he visits without asking if it's OK and he's trying to push a level of connection that the Op doesn't want. Just because someone's family doesn't mean they can walk straight through all your boundaries

Mummy08m · 30/06/2023 18:47

My dad was also intrusive, controlling and manipulative to me growing up. Kept making me feel under an obligation because of the blood tie even though he hadn't raised me.

No, he never sexually harassed me (thank god, I'm not downplaying how much more awful that would have been) but guys, come on. How bloody low are we setting the bar?! He didn't assault me so he's a nice guy...?!

My relationship with him was miserable and awful and I got nothing out of it except anxiety, fear, obligation, stress. Ok, the occasional expensive gift that I didn't want and wasn't worth the huge obligation cost.

I thought I'd regret going no contact. Its been 6 years and I haven't had even one twinge of doubt I did the right thing.

Mummy08m · 30/06/2023 18:41

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 30/06/2023 18:01

People are really suggesting her brother is creepy for visiting her??? He's not some creepy stranger he's her brother!!!

Fine if she decides to have nothing to do with him, but there is nothing creepy about him trying to have a relationship. He's not sexually harassing her. That is beyond creepy to suggest.

It may not be sexual. I didn't say it was.

But it absolutely is harassment.

PupInAPram · 30/06/2023 18:39

OP, be blunt. Nothing else will work and they need to know. Maybe post a letter with some of what you've said here about not feeling any true connection.