Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get a tablet for 2 year old?

110 replies

Scotlandma · 30/06/2023 10:22

I feel like I often see very young children with tablets and I’ve heard they can also be very educational but I’m not sure if it’s recommended for 2 year olds?

(my child is not yet 2 I’m thinking for their birthday)

for background my child is in full time nursery so doesn’t get very much screen time in the week and on the weekend I tend to be out running errands but TV does help whilst I’m trying to cook dinner or occasional send a quick email in the evening.

I’m not thinking of the kind of situation where we have to bring an iPad to a restaurant (I’m not judging that situation but DS behaves quite well out) more so for car rides or almost as a toy that DS can choose to play with.

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 02/07/2023 18:14

Our 5yr old and 2yr old both have one.
They rarely use them but they're great for overnight trips away which we do most months. We also drive to France (9.5hrs).

Some of the posts on here are almost hysterical about them....we still read (haven't gone a day in their entire lives without being read to), use stickers, play doh, colouring books, Lego, park, walks, crafts, we go away at least once a month, take them on trips, theatre, swimming, hobbies etc. Just because children own a tablet doesn't mean they're doing nothing else. It's just a very good addition to the already very full lives they have. The educational apps really are excellent. Our 5yr old goes in the year above for English and Maths, he's very bright. No behaviour problems. The tablet has not hindered him in the slightest but he has learnt lots using it. 2yr old uses hers probably a couple of times a month. We'd never take them to a restaurant but they do have their uses.

mustardrarebit · 02/07/2023 18:14

Sorry if this has already been suggested, perhaps get a Yoto player instead. My 2yo daughter and her 6 and 10 yo sisters all love theirs and use them daily. 2yo loves Peppa Pig, Caspar Babypants songs, Funnybones and loads that I've recorded for her myself. She reads the books at the same time. Preferable to screens, for me.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 02/07/2023 18:06

Favouritefruits · 02/07/2023 17:25

I was against tablet for children until I watched a TV documentary a few years ago, it tested children who used tablets and children that didn’t, toddlers that used tablets scored higher in almost everything. The tasks were drawing lines and reactions, amongst other things. The scientists concluded that there’s no benefit of children being kept away from tablets but there maybe a benefit of children using tablets.

😂

This "research" was presumably done by people who thought it was a good idea to give their small children tablets, and set about "proving" why they were right.

It is utter bollocks. Small children need time, attention, talking, singing and reading.

We used to do very, very long car journeys with our DC when they were very small (and one of mine was horrendously difficult).

I-spy ('something blue', 'something round' etc for very small children), audio books, child-friendly CDs (we had cassettes when my DC were small, but presumably people would have phones or whatever now). I used to give them a little something to open at certain points of the journey, so long as they hadn't picked fights with one another. They were just silly little post-office type toys but they were enough of an incentive for low-tech children. They could have a boiled sweet when we saw the first sign to Glasgow. That kind of thing.

Apart from the fact that they're developmentally useless (IMO), I think it's a bit sad if technology replaces parents engaging with their children.

MammaEvz3 · 02/07/2023 17:57

My 6 and 3 year olds have them. We probably wouldn't have gotten one for the 3 year old yet but it was easier for him to have his own than keep trying to pinch his sisters. They have really limited access to them and can go a whole week or longer without using them. We keep them and they only have them when allowed. They are incredibly useful for long car journeys. It keeps them quiet so their baby brother can sleep and they don't distract my driving. I can't cope with a lot of noise in tglhe car. Posters saying children can look out the window are living in some kind of unrealistic fantasy world. The doesn't keep them entertained at all.
Anyway I think they can be useful but 2 is a bit too young in my opinion.

Favouritefruits · 02/07/2023 17:25

I was against tablet for children until I watched a TV documentary a few years ago, it tested children who used tablets and children that didn’t, toddlers that used tablets scored higher in almost everything. The tasks were drawing lines and reactions, amongst other things. The scientists concluded that there’s no benefit of children being kept away from tablets but there maybe a benefit of children using tablets.

Theloosegoose · 02/07/2023 16:59

It's a no from me.

MrsMarzetti · 02/07/2023 16:11

You can kiss goodbye to your child behaving well when you are out if you buy a tablet. They are a bit like dummies, they little one will crave it and cry until he gets it.

Northumberlandgirl · 02/07/2023 16:04

On holiday recently the family sitting on the next table to us with two children of about 3 and 5 years of age. Both children on iPads and father on his phone throughout breakfast. Is this really the example we want to show to our children?

thespy · 02/07/2023 15:31

I'd hold off as long as possible but in any case think about whether they could navigate it successfully on their own or even hold on to it without it dropping onto the floor of the car - someone mentioned the safety aspect, I'm thinking about meltdowns when they drop it, can't reach it and you are driving!

sarah419 · 02/07/2023 15:30

Scotlandma · 30/06/2023 10:22

I feel like I often see very young children with tablets and I’ve heard they can also be very educational but I’m not sure if it’s recommended for 2 year olds?

(my child is not yet 2 I’m thinking for their birthday)

for background my child is in full time nursery so doesn’t get very much screen time in the week and on the weekend I tend to be out running errands but TV does help whilst I’m trying to cook dinner or occasional send a quick email in the evening.

I’m not thinking of the kind of situation where we have to bring an iPad to a restaurant (I’m not judging that situation but DS behaves quite well out) more so for car rides or almost as a toy that DS can choose to play with.

Would you give your kid a cigarette? Ipads/electronics etc are addictive. Nothing will live up to them either. So even if you put a limit on screen time, how will a book seem as exciting as an iPad? I would seek professional advice on this through podcasts etc. see what professionals are saying!

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 02/07/2023 15:07

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 02/07/2023 12:09

Fully fully agree.
Imagine telling these folks commenting here that you would take away their smartphones

I haven't got a smartphone and have no desire to have one.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 02/07/2023 15:07

explainthistomeplease · 30/06/2023 11:52

Arguments that you g children need tablets in order to 'navigate technology' really are bogus. My kids are mid twenties and so the tech didn't exist when they were tiny. Yet they cope just fine. One of them uses very complex tech in a science based job.

What they did have when they were young though was books and toys.

A lack of a tablet at a young age will not hamper a child. Quite the reverse!

Same for my children. Though I'd say "bollocks" rather than "bogus".

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 02/07/2023 12:09

hauntedvagina · 30/06/2023 10:53

Fully agree with you. My children have always had access to iPads with age appropriate games available for them to play on. My youngest rarely asks for it, but he certainly knows how to use it. I'm of the mindset that if you withhold something, the child will become more obsessed with it.

Navigating technology will be just as important as learning to read and write for this generation.

Fully fully agree.
Imagine telling these folks commenting here that you would take away their smartphones

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 02/07/2023 12:04

Not an ipad, but mine’s got one. She’s 2.5
It works wonders on long car drives, plane rides or if/when I struggle with work vs childcare.
She’s not on it all day, not even every day, and usually plays puzzles or memory games.
Full parental control (I work in cybersecurity so that’s important) and no internet access.
We love it

StephanieSuperpowers · 02/07/2023 12:02

My DD is 8, she has occasional access to a tablet, but she doesn't have one. There's no need.

Emmamoo89 · 02/07/2023 11:58

Each to their own imo.

Busywithsomething · 02/07/2023 11:58

Well I wouldn't. kids only have short attention spans but giving them screens is not going to help. Bad parenting IMHO. Sorry OP.

Hermione101 · 02/07/2023 11:55

UndercoverCop · 01/07/2023 17:06

DS will be fine next birthday, not getting a tablet. He also does not resolve anything on our phones regardless of location.
We go on long car journeys, fly etc he's fine. Colouring books, stickers, toys, books, audiobooks played through the car stereo or yoto.
We play table top and card games as a family.
They're not necessary.

we also do all this and have zero problems traveling.

Hermione101 · 02/07/2023 11:54

Two is way too young and they don’t need it for car trips. I regularly fly long haul with my six year old and he will get it for last hour of the flight. We do other activities for the rest of the 9 hours. It’s fine and it works for the both of us.

I don’t know about SEN children, so this is not a comment on how they use tech to communicate etc.. however I disagree that young children need to learn their way around an ipad or they risk being “left behind.”My son only started using one when he was in year 1 and he’s fine. There’s a lot more that goes into learning how to use/create tech than using an iPad.

extramile · 02/07/2023 11:40

I agree with holding off as long as possible, although a lot probably depends on the child. My children got a shared tablet for games when my son was 8 and my daughter was 6. Ever since it has been difficult to keep my son away from screens, although my daughter has a wider range of interests and is much more balanced in her usage (they are now 12 and 10).

Regarding tablet use in the car, I don't think anyone else has mentioned the safety aspect of this. Unless the tablet is secured in a holder, it becomes a very dangerous heavy projectile in the event of a collision, and can kill or injure a child. https://news.sky.com/story/girl-3-dies-after-tablet-computer-hits-her-during-car-crash-11510044

Girl, 3, dies after tablet computer hits her during car crash

The incident raises concerns about parents allowing children to play with devices to keep them occupied during long car journeys.

https://news.sky.com/story/girl-3-dies-after-tablet-computer-hits-her-during-car-crash-11510044

UndercoverCop · 01/07/2023 17:07

*five

Duttercup · 01/07/2023 17:06

My nearly 3 year old does a 4-5 hour car journey regularly without much entertainment. She just doesn't know any different. I'm not judging anyone in any direction but they're definitely not needed for successful car journeys!

UndercoverCop · 01/07/2023 17:06

DS will be fine next birthday, not getting a tablet. He also does not resolve anything on our phones regardless of location.
We go on long car journeys, fly etc he's fine. Colouring books, stickers, toys, books, audiobooks played through the car stereo or yoto.
We play table top and card games as a family.
They're not necessary.

Gigi606 · 01/07/2023 17:03

We have tablets for (just) 2 yo and 4 yo. (since she was about 2) Used only for short periods of quiet time as an alternative to TV, or on planes/holiday. We don’t use them in restaurants unless it’s a holiday meltdown situation and we don’t use them in the car. We only have CBeebies games and downloaded TV content so they have very limited and monitored choice of what to play and watch. We don’t let them sit and scroll through YouTube. 4yo uses a tablet at (state) school (reception) so that’s worth bearing in mind. There are some lovely educational and age appropriate games and activities available which the kids love and they’re learning as they go - tablets are great if you control access, hold your boundaries on use and monitor the content.

metellaestinatrio · 01/07/2023 17:03

No way! My oldest is 7 and we still don’t have tablets and I plan to hold off as long as possible.

On a recent holiday I think our kids were pretty much the only ones on the plane (and it was half term, so lots of kids) who weren’t plugged into a screen - people even had them for c.18 month olds. Yes, that meant we had to parent fairly intensively for the 3 hour flight - lots of card games, colouring, stickers, reading etc. - but parents managed it 15+ years ago!

My children do watch TV, but that seems to me to be more interactive - they watch together, talk about what’s happening, act it out, have to negotiate over who gets to pick the next programme etc. rather than all staring at their own individual screen, lost to the world. And my 92 year old great aunt can work an iPad, so I hardly think we are holding our children back in their development by not buying a tablet until they are older.

Swipe left for the next trending thread