Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think posters who don't respond to the thread they started are rude?

85 replies

Reallybadidea · 30/06/2023 07:35

I'm getting increasingly fed up with replying to posters who ask for advice and then never return to the thread to thank the people who have taken the time to offer their advice.

I don't mean the ones who get flamed (can't blame them tbh), it's the ones who ask for help with a specific thing and then presumably just read the replies, take what's helpful and don't say thanks. I'm sure some of them just forget that they've posted but it seems to be happening more recently.

AIBU to think it's pretty rude?

OP posts:
Saracen · 01/07/2023 08:01

YANBU. I always respond when people have tried to help me. Even when their advice doesn't hit the mark at all, I am still grateful that they gave me their time and tried.

pictoosh · 01/07/2023 07:54

Quite possibly to laugh at everyone taking the time out to reply on a wild goose chase. Some trolls are very skilled at invoking responses, others will troll about the most mundane topics just to see the replies add up. It's pathetic but they exist.
Or that OP simply got what they wanted out of the thread and lost interest.

Like I say, don't invest anything you mind losing, including five minutes of your time. Expecting societal norms on the internet is just naive.

Macaroni46 · 01/07/2023 07:32

Damnyouautocorrect1 · 30/06/2023 11:12

The drawing one annoyed me. Expecting everyone to take the time to guess how old the painter is then not replying?

Just checked. The OP still hasn't updated. Why bother posting? 🤷‍♀️

pictoosh · 01/07/2023 07:26

thegreencarnation · 01/07/2023 05:52

I think it is customary to acknowledge help offered with a thank you.

A lot of the urgent health advice that is sought is met with dead silence. People try to help and give out information about their own conditions and treatment, and the previously desperate OP does not bother to check their thread, or if they do so bother to leave any sort of acknowledgement. That is rude, entitled, and flaky.

It's the fucking internet. Rude, entitled, flakey, dangerous, perverted, psychopathic, deceitful, bored, nasty, forgetful, selfish, taking the fucking piss out of you...they are all here. Don't expect manners. If you invest time it's clearly time you've got to waste.

thegreencarnation · 01/07/2023 05:52

I think it is customary to acknowledge help offered with a thank you.

A lot of the urgent health advice that is sought is met with dead silence. People try to help and give out information about their own conditions and treatment, and the previously desperate OP does not bother to check their thread, or if they do so bother to leave any sort of acknowledgement. That is rude, entitled, and flaky.

HRTQueen · 01/07/2023 02:00

What does it matter

often advice is asked for the op is going through a difficult time and then rounded up on

then the demands for them to come and report back or bitched about because they haven’t

it’s just another stick to beat posters with

Hawkins0001 · 01/07/2023 01:35

Yes it's rude,

LOSTAN · 01/07/2023 01:29

Totally agree OP. It's bloody rude and shows no manners.
I spent a lot of thought over a post last year when someone wanted to take their kids abroad for a short weekend. I know the city really well and saved her both time and money and offered a range of the best experiences to have to get the best out of the city for such a short stay.
The rude cow couldn't even be arsed to reply.
Tbh it has put me off giving my time to anyone unless I know them.
The problem with SM is there are many takers who never give back and can get away with it due to the anonymity.

NumberTheory · 30/06/2023 23:29

ToWhitToWhoo · 30/06/2023 22:39

Frankly, I think that your behaviour is MUCH ruder than someone not thanking people for their responses.

Especially as the poster was not using her disability as an excuse for posting a thread and failing to acknowledge responses, because she hasn't actually posted any threads and failed to acknowledge responses (nor have I.) She was pointing out that it COULD in some cases be an excuse. Very different.

The whole concept of what are and aren't' reasonable accommodations' isn't relevant to an anonymous message-board anyway. Posting here is not a job or an exam.

I take issue with the idea that a robust defence of a position that refers to someone’s own arguments and holds them accountable for them is essentially rude. And with the inherent suggestion that I am obliged to ignore the poster’s personal accusation against me.

Whether I’m rude or not isn’t the question on the thread, though. The question is whether not coming back to a thread is rude (with some exceptions as the OP acknowledges). You can get all defensive and call me as rude as you like. It doesn’t make the argument that it’s not rude if you are prone to forgetting because of ADHD any more valid.

You’re right that reasonable accommodations aren’t legally required of MN users. But the poster was making a claim that ADHD as a disability should give someone free rein to not take any responsibility for the impact of their actions - that people had to accommodate them entirely, not just reasonably. I used the legal standard as a familiar reference to make the point that even when legally required there is a reasonableness test and because I think it’s good for people to make similar allowances in general interactions even if not legally required.

I do, however agree with a previous poster that not coming back to a thread is rude, but it’s hardly the crime of the century. It’s annoying for those who respond, but that’s about it. We are strangers on the Internet, not close friends with a reason to put weight on each other’s actions. If someone does it and realises later they should roll their eyes at themselves and try and remember not to in the future, not beat themselves up about it for days.

thegreencarnation · 30/06/2023 23:15

I agree. I find it incredibly rude. People will post with what they present as a pressing problem and then apparently ignore the heartfelt advice. I think people are increasingly flaky. May be posting when pissed. And/or are just rude.

ToWhitToWhoo · 30/06/2023 22:39

NumberTheory · 30/06/2023 21:49

You didn’t just point out how easily you could do it. You used your disability as an excuse for doing it, then you tried some good old fashioned DARVO accusing me of being rude.

ADHD can be callenging (no, you aren’t the only one), but there are plenty of tools and techniques for ensuring you don’t forget things. Not employing them when other people are affected by your forgetfulness is rude. And when you mess up, not owning the fact you’ve been rude and apologising/attempting to do better won’t get you very far. Because reasonable accommodations include expecting you to use those tools and techniques.

Frankly, I think that your behaviour is MUCH ruder than someone not thanking people for their responses.

Especially as the poster was not using her disability as an excuse for posting a thread and failing to acknowledge responses, because she hasn't actually posted any threads and failed to acknowledge responses (nor have I.) She was pointing out that it COULD in some cases be an excuse. Very different.

The whole concept of what are and aren't' reasonable accommodations' isn't relevant to an anonymous message-board anyway. Posting here is not a job or an exam.

WithMyDamnHighHopes · 30/06/2023 22:13

You’re way too invested OP. They a strangers on a forum, why do you really need a thank you of any acknowledgment at all. I find that really weird.

grunttheterrible · 30/06/2023 22:05

I think it depends. I started a few relatively boring posts (different username) recently and the responses totally missed the point/ emotion (felt v chat gpt) Maybe it was a few humans but I didn't feel need to reply tbh as the advice was so unrelateable

cooshin · 30/06/2023 22:02

@NumberTheory

My mistake.

You were not being rude, just horrible.

ToWhitToWhoo · 30/06/2023 21:53

I suppose it's a bit rude. It's in the category of failing to say thank you But people have lives, jobs, families, health issues, etc; and sometimes omit to say thank you to strangers; and it's not something I'd really get worked up about

And, though it's not great manners, it doesn't mean that the person is a liar or a troll.

DaaamnYoullDo · 30/06/2023 21:52

You don't know what people are going through. Sometimes I've had the strength to ask for help but not the strength to respond to questions.

NumberTheory · 30/06/2023 21:49

cooshin · 30/06/2023 11:11

@NumberTheory

You being forgetful isn’t rude. You posting on a site asking people to give up their time and not coming back to acknowledge those responses is rude.
Knowing that you are prone to forgetting you could not post, or you could set a reminder. Your disability isn’t a bar to being polite.

I usually don't post threads, however I was just pointing out how easily it could happen. I'm not suggesting being disabled means I don't have to be polite but it does explain how I could easily forget.

You didn’t just point out how easily you could do it. You used your disability as an excuse for doing it, then you tried some good old fashioned DARVO accusing me of being rude.

ADHD can be callenging (no, you aren’t the only one), but there are plenty of tools and techniques for ensuring you don’t forget things. Not employing them when other people are affected by your forgetfulness is rude. And when you mess up, not owning the fact you’ve been rude and apologising/attempting to do better won’t get you very far. Because reasonable accommodations include expecting you to use those tools and techniques.

Throwaway246810 · 30/06/2023 21:32

I agree I take offensive to this too. I do think it's rude

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 30/06/2023 21:29

ZeroFuchsGiven · 30/06/2023 09:00

How can you forget you have posted? Do you drink a lot? Hmm

I actually don’t drink but thank you for your concern.

cooshin · 30/06/2023 11:13

Really? I think MN is an incredible resource of information and can be amazingly useful for getting a helpful answer, sometimes to really quite important things.

Yes really.

This site has plenty of trolls, bitches and liars alongside the nice genuine posters. I'm never going to ask for advice about important things because I wouldn't know if the people replying were genuine. If I need help with something important I'm going to the professionals.

Damnyouautocorrect1 · 30/06/2023 11:12

The drawing one annoyed me. Expecting everyone to take the time to guess how old the painter is then not replying?

cooshin · 30/06/2023 11:11

@NumberTheory

You being forgetful isn’t rude. You posting on a site asking people to give up their time and not coming back to acknowledge those responses is rude.
Knowing that you are prone to forgetting you could not post, or you could set a reminder. Your disability isn’t a bar to being polite.

I usually don't post threads, however I was just pointing out how easily it could happen. I'm not suggesting being disabled means I don't have to be polite but it does explain how I could easily forget.

Reallybadidea · 30/06/2023 10:34

To be fair if it was at all important I would not be posting it on MN.

Really? I think MN is an incredible resource of information and can be amazingly useful for getting a helpful answer, sometimes to really quite important things. There are some very knowledgeable posters who post frequently about their specialist subjects. Obviously there's a lot of nonsense and unhelpful slanging, but I'm really grateful for the help people offer out of the kindness of their hearts.

In case I forget later - THANKS TO ALL WHO'VE REPLIED Grin

OP posts:
Bluebells1970 · 30/06/2023 10:25

I think genuine threads on here are like hens teeth these days.

If the poster hasn't come back by the end of the second page, it's usually an indication that they're not going to.

NumberTheory · 30/06/2023 10:22

cooshin · 30/06/2023 08:45

@NumberTheory

I mean I'm actually disabled so I would consider your comment to be rude, not my forgetfulness.

You being forgetful isn’t rude. You posting on a site asking people to give up their time and not coming back to acknowledge those responses is rude. Knowing that you are prone to forgetting you could not post, or you could set a reminder. Your disability isn’t a bar to being polite.