Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be embarrassed that I did nothing?

166 replies

Sad1001 · 29/06/2023 21:38

And that I am terrible in an emergency?
Was travelling into work today, was raining and bus was packed.
As it got nearer to my stop, I stood by the exit just so I could get off at my stop easily.
Just before my stop, there was a loud bang and a woman was on the floor having tripped. She hadn't made a sound and the woman next to me asked if she was OK. Before she could reply, another woman literally pushed me out of the way, and the hurt woman said she was sure she had broken her wrist. So the bus was then stopped, an ambulance called etc.
I just feel like I acted really coldly. With all honesty, even if nobody else had stepped in, I am not sure I could have done out of shyness, awkwardness but also fear. No excuse but I have a phobia of hospitals and bone breaks.
Spent the whole day beating myself up and not really sure why I am posting but felt the need to do so.

OP posts:
hollybubs · 30/06/2023 07:18

People freeze, they can't help it. I saw a car accident once. It was bad enough that I don't remember exactly what I saw. I was in the drivers seat in a two door car, and the person behind me was yelling at me to get out so they could get out and help. I was completely frozen for a minute, I could not move.

BlurredVision · 30/06/2023 07:18

The laughing thing happened to me once. My BIL got a dog and my husband took it for a walk. He didn't know anything about dogs and thought he could take it off lead for a run around. I told him not to but he did anyway. The dog went crazy, running in and out of traffic, we couldn't catch him, he was going to cause an accident. I was in absolute panic but laughing so hard. I remember how awful it was I couldn't even get the words out, I felt totally powerless.
And even though I've done first aid training and am usually calm I was one of 'bystanders' at an event when someone collapsed. We all froze but luckily others took charge.

LittleBlueBrioTrain · 30/06/2023 07:17

I think the point people are missing re: laughter is that it's a sympathetic response - by the same sympathetic nervous system that results in the fight/flight/fear response and completely involuntary in the described scenarios.

Ilkleymoor · 30/06/2023 07:13

If that was the case, hysteria and shock wouldn't be real. We can't control all emotions all the time because they can be driven by an intense physical situation reaction. Unfortunately some of these are not socially acceptable. But they are real.

FlopsiesAngrySandwich · 30/06/2023 07:13

Lillyrosemay · 30/06/2023 03:07

It’s absolutely not normal to see an elderly man lay bleeding on the ground and stand laughing with tears running down your face.

It is a statistically normal, physiological response to stress.
It is NOT a choice ffs.

It is however a choice for people to jump on and attack this poster.

off · 30/06/2023 07:04

You can make a phone call while laughing. It's embarrassing, sure.

Ladybug14 · 30/06/2023 07:03

But surely we are all capable of controlling inappropriate emotions?

Ilkleymoor · 30/06/2023 07:01

The poster who laughed is being truthful and generous to the OP to show there are worse reactions. And the people trying to make out she's a psycho, grow up. Laughter and hysteria through shock or fear are very similar and while it wouldn't be great to be on the receiving end, it is totally unintentional.

PriOn1 · 30/06/2023 06:59

It sounds like she had plenty of help, OP. And just because you didn’t react this time, doesn’t mean you won’t be able to in future in different circumstances.

As for the laughing, isn’t it bizarre? But those who’ve explained it have made me feel better because it happened to me once when my sister fell. It felt so automatic that I wondered whether it was kind of pre-programmed by a lifetime of watching slapstick comedy, but I didn’t feel remotely amused. Luckily for me, it only lasted a second and then I was able to ask if she was okay. Other posters seem to have it much more severely, which must actually be really difficult.

Letsgotitans · 30/06/2023 06:58

AndTheSurveySays · 29/06/2023 21:51

I once came across an elderly man that had fallen over and was half lying in the road, his head was bleeding. What did I do? I burst out laughing, really laughing with tears down my face. Thankfully a couple of other people turned up a few mins later and saw to him/ called an ambulance.

How awful for that poor man, I actually hope he wasn't conscious at this point to hear some laughing hysterically at him in that awful condition, not just initially with shock, but for a few minutes! Give it whatever psychological name you want, if your are in this situation again you really need to get some control over yourself!

DrSbaitso · 30/06/2023 06:58

I've heard about this laughter as a nervous reaction thing, with people laughing at funerals and horrible accidents.

Thank God I've never come across it. I know it's involuntary and not caused by amusement but I really don't like to think of what my own reaction would be.

If you feel bad because you didn't know what to do and want to be better in an emergency, take a first aid course. That's much more constructive than pulling yourself apart.

Ladybug14 · 30/06/2023 06:54

AndTheSurveySays · 29/06/2023 21:51

I once came across an elderly man that had fallen over and was half lying in the road, his head was bleeding. What did I do? I burst out laughing, really laughing with tears down my face. Thankfully a couple of other people turned up a few mins later and saw to him/ called an ambulance.

I appreciate it might have been a nervous reaction, but are you unable to control yourself? That really is an unpleasant reaction to have.

off · 30/06/2023 06:51

I think you're probably better than that Oddsocks — I suspect that by the time "a few minutes" had passed, you'd have managed to at least call an ambulance.

Yes, people act in different ways. Other people judge the ways people act. Some people can't help reacting instinctively with a violent response when surprised, and people judge that. Some people apparently can't help reacting like laughing-for-minutes poster when they come across people in need of urgent help, and people judge that too.

Clafoutie · 30/06/2023 06:50

PatienceIsAVirtueInMM · 30/06/2023 03:36

You should be embarrassed.
Imagine if it was someone you loved and they stood there and made excuses for doing absolutely nothing.

Completely unfair. The fact that the OP even posted on here shows they are likely a compassionate person.

OddsocksinmyDocs · 30/06/2023 06:46

off · 30/06/2023 06:43

Did you continue freezing and backing away for several minutes, when you were the only person around who could get the person help?

And no, she wasn't "in shock", she had an emotional reaction.

Thankfully, people went to help but had they not, I probably would still have backed away.

Apologies, she was having an emotional reaction which made her not act rationally 🙄 People act in different ways!

off · 30/06/2023 06:43

OddsocksinmyDocs · 30/06/2023 06:37

Have you ever actually been in shock before?

I once saw a man fall so hard to the ground, he actually bounced and ended up with blood pouring from his head. I was late teens. My instant reaction was to freeze and then started backing away. Did I want to help? Absolutely! Yet my body reacted differently to what I was thinking.

'For all she knew...' and for all you know, she could have been in shock!

Did you continue freezing and backing away for several minutes, when you were the only person around who could get the person help?

And no, she wasn't "in shock", she had an emotional reaction.

OddsocksinmyDocs · 30/06/2023 06:43

off · 30/06/2023 06:38

Not sure why it says "taken" there. Think that was meant to say "fallen".

I'm surprised by the number of people defending the laughing-for-minutes poster. We all know people react differently — sometimes it takes a moment to realise, sometimes another person will take over, sometimes you're not sure what to do, sometimes your immediate reaction is unfortunate or inappropriate. But very few people would see a vulnerable person so obviously in need of immediate emergency assistance, realise they were the only person available to help, and just stand there for minutes, laughing away, and doing nothing at all. It's completely different to every other story on here — OP was perfectly normal.

But its not as uncommon as you obviously believe to be true which is why people have defended the poster!

ARareKindaBear · 30/06/2023 06:39

I have the nervous laughter too and it’s worse if people have very visible injuries. I remember one time I was at work and a colleague walked in with her arm in a sling and I burst out laughing, I was mortified and left the room (made out id just received a funny text).

problem is I laughed everytime I saw her, it went on for weeks. I still don’t know why I kept laughing

off · 30/06/2023 06:38

Not sure why it says "taken" there. Think that was meant to say "fallen".

I'm surprised by the number of people defending the laughing-for-minutes poster. We all know people react differently — sometimes it takes a moment to realise, sometimes another person will take over, sometimes you're not sure what to do, sometimes your immediate reaction is unfortunate or inappropriate. But very few people would see a vulnerable person so obviously in need of immediate emergency assistance, realise they were the only person available to help, and just stand there for minutes, laughing away, and doing nothing at all. It's completely different to every other story on here — OP was perfectly normal.

OddsocksinmyDocs · 30/06/2023 06:37

off · 30/06/2023 06:33

So? You're the only adult on the scene, you deal with it. Either stifle your laughter, or apologise for it, and get an ambulance called for the elderly man with a head injury taken in a dangerous place. You don't just let minutes go by, standing there giggling away. For all she knew, the man had had a stroke, and those few minutes were the difference between him ever walking again or not.

Have you ever actually been in shock before?

I once saw a man fall so hard to the ground, he actually bounced and ended up with blood pouring from his head. I was late teens. My instant reaction was to freeze and then started backing away. Did I want to help? Absolutely! Yet my body reacted differently to what I was thinking.

'For all she knew...' and for all you know, she could have been in shock!

off · 30/06/2023 06:33

OddsocksinmyDocs · 30/06/2023 06:28

She was probably in shock!

So? You're the only adult on the scene, you deal with it. Either stifle your laughter, or apologise for it, and get an ambulance called for the elderly man with a head injury taken in a dangerous place. You don't just let minutes go by, standing there giggling away. For all she knew, the man had had a stroke, and those few minutes were the difference between him ever walking again or not.

OddsocksinmyDocs · 30/06/2023 06:28

off · 30/06/2023 06:07

And apparently continued having that reaction for several minutes, as the elderly man lay there, half in the road with a probable head injury, until someone turned up who was able to act like an adult and manage themselves.

Every other instance in this thread of someone having that laugh reaction was either a teen, or someone who at least tried to stifle that uncontrollable reaction and act appropriately, because it is unacceptable for a functioning adult in that situation to stand there indulging their laughter for several minutes, and not help the potentially dying vulnerable person in any way whatsoever.

She was probably in shock!

DrSbaitso · 30/06/2023 06:12

Perhaps take a first aid course so you feel (and are) better equipped to assist in future.

off · 30/06/2023 06:07

Boomshock · 30/06/2023 04:35

It's an uncontrollable reaction,
Your own response on this thread is awful so take a look at yourself.
You don't sound considerate at all, you're berating a person for having a reaction they couldn't control.

And apparently continued having that reaction for several minutes, as the elderly man lay there, half in the road with a probable head injury, until someone turned up who was able to act like an adult and manage themselves.

Every other instance in this thread of someone having that laugh reaction was either a teen, or someone who at least tried to stifle that uncontrollable reaction and act appropriately, because it is unacceptable for a functioning adult in that situation to stand there indulging their laughter for several minutes, and not help the potentially dying vulnerable person in any way whatsoever.

OddsocksinmyDocs · 30/06/2023 06:03

PatienceIsAVirtueInMM · 30/06/2023 03:36

You should be embarrassed.
Imagine if it was someone you loved and they stood there and made excuses for doing absolutely nothing.

And you should be embarrassed for being so judgemental. The OP was quite clearly shocked by the events - I'd have been the same - but as people have posted, if there weren't other people, the OP would probably have stepped in.