Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be embarrassed that I did nothing?

166 replies

Sad1001 · 29/06/2023 21:38

And that I am terrible in an emergency?
Was travelling into work today, was raining and bus was packed.
As it got nearer to my stop, I stood by the exit just so I could get off at my stop easily.
Just before my stop, there was a loud bang and a woman was on the floor having tripped. She hadn't made a sound and the woman next to me asked if she was OK. Before she could reply, another woman literally pushed me out of the way, and the hurt woman said she was sure she had broken her wrist. So the bus was then stopped, an ambulance called etc.
I just feel like I acted really coldly. With all honesty, even if nobody else had stepped in, I am not sure I could have done out of shyness, awkwardness but also fear. No excuse but I have a phobia of hospitals and bone breaks.
Spent the whole day beating myself up and not really sure why I am posting but felt the need to do so.

OP posts:
Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 10:24

@Lacucuracha - there is nothing to suggest that OP was rubber necking. Although I don’t deny people do. She said before the woman could even answer the person who asked if she ok, OP was pushed out the way. It sounds like she was taking a second for her brain to process. You are attributing malice to something where there is no evidence of it.

Lacucuracha · 30/06/2023 10:19

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 10:17

@Lacucuracha - please take some time to read the thread. Many posters have explained natural responses to shock. This is nothing to do with empathy even though I know people like to armchair diagnose sociopathy. The tunnel vision of some of the viewpoints on here are really something. I have helped and been helped in situations like OP describes numerous times but I’ve never once stood in judgement of those who didn’t. We can never really know someone’s intentions or why they are unable to help.

I haven’t said OP should have helped. I said she should have got out of the way.

Please don’t try and pretend that a lot of people are not just rubberneckers.

neverbeenskiing · 30/06/2023 10:19

Lacucuracha · 30/06/2023 10:18

Comprehension not a strong point for you?

Where did I say she deliberately places herself there?

So if you recognise that her reaction was not deliberate then what was the point of your question? Other than attempting to make someone who has already said they're beating themselves up feel even more like shit.

Lacucuracha · 30/06/2023 10:18

neverbeenskiing · 30/06/2023 10:15

Do you generally waste people’s time and stand in the way of people trying to help someone?

What a stupid, pointless question. Yes, I'm sure OP spends all her free time wandering round looking for emergency situations so she can deliberately place herself in the path of people trying to help.

Comprehension not a strong point for you?

Where did I say she deliberately places herself there?

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 10:17

@Lacucuracha - please take some time to read the thread. Many posters have explained natural responses to shock. This is nothing to do with empathy even though I know people like to armchair diagnose sociopathy. The tunnel vision of some of the viewpoints on here are really something. I have helped and been helped in situations like OP describes numerous times but I’ve never once stood in judgement of those who didn’t. We can never really know someone’s intentions or why they are unable to help.

neverbeenskiing · 30/06/2023 10:15

Do you generally waste people’s time and stand in the way of people trying to help someone?

What a stupid, pointless question. Yes, I'm sure OP spends all her free time wandering round looking for emergency situations so she can deliberately place herself in the path of people trying to help.

Lacucuracha · 30/06/2023 10:12

hollybubs · 30/06/2023 10:03

Do you generally waste people’s time and stand in the way of people trying to help someone?

This thread is really showing who the kind, empathetic people are.

Yes, they’re the ones who don’t stand around and gawk when someone needs help and get out of the way automatically to let others help.

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 10:05

hollybubs · 30/06/2023 10:03

Do you generally waste people’s time and stand in the way of people trying to help someone?

This thread is really showing who the kind, empathetic people are.

@hollybubs indeed.

hollybubs · 30/06/2023 10:03

Do you generally waste people’s time and stand in the way of people trying to help someone?

This thread is really showing who the kind, empathetic people are.

Lacucuracha · 30/06/2023 09:49

I am not sure I could have done out of shyness, awkwardness but also fear.

Is this why you haven’t returned to the thread?

Do you generally waste people’s time and stand in the way of people trying to help someone?

neverbeenskiing · 30/06/2023 09:37

I feel like the thread has been de-railed somewhat but to answer your OP, I don't think you have anything to be embarrassed about. Many people would have reacted the way you did. We all have different strengths. I'm excellent in a life or death emergency, but I get myself worked up about daft trivial stuff like not being able to find a parking spot!

PaperNests · 30/06/2023 09:36

I think your reaction was totally normal OP, presumably it's what most people on the bus did too.

I'd had years of first aid training and was working as a carer but when on a night shift, just the two of us, my colleague had a seizure I was completely useless. It was totally unexpected, no history, she was sat on a chair chatting and then went into a seizure with her head somehow arched over the back of the chair banging her head on the wall, blood pouring out. I completely froze. I knew from my training she needed to be on the floor in the recovery position but my brain just couldn't work out how to get her there from the position she was in. I rang an ambulance straight away but then couldn't tell them the address or give directions and I kept ending the call. It was terrible. I've avoided all first aid training and not worked in care since as I realised I'm completely useless at it and can't be the 'trained first aider' as people will look to me to guide them which I can't do in an emergency even though I know it on paper.

Thankfully the ambulance tracked the call and arrived within minutes and my colleague was completely fine. But it can happen to anyone even with first aid training. I think it's the unexpected context.

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 09:31

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:29

@BadNomad and what is wrong with suggesting that it is possible to improve one's acute stress response? I have had therapy myself and can attest that it works.

As with many things, it’s not the core message it’s how and when you are choosing to deliver it.

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:29

@BadNomad and what is wrong with suggesting that it is possible to improve one's acute stress response? I have had therapy myself and can attest that it works.

BadNomad · 30/06/2023 09:25

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:21

@BadNomad have you been raped or sexually assaulted before? Have you had any professional therapy to deal with it? I have been physically and sexually assaulted, spent a couple of days in the hospital and then have had counselling and therapy to deal with it. I can sense that you are talking through your hat.

You're the one judging people for their involuntary reactions during stressful situations and telling them to go learn a better way to react.

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 09:24

I once knew someone who farted uncontrollably when nervous, poor man. He was very embarrassed about it. The body is a very strange thing.

NeverEndsWell · 30/06/2023 09:23

OP I wouldn't worry about the way you reacted. As others have said, we honestly don't know how we will react to an unexpected event, a lot of people do freeze.

With regards to the laughter post, nervous laughter is, of course, real:

Yale University psychologist Stanley Milgram conducted one of the earliest and most infamous studies with data about nervous laughter in the 1960s.
His study revealed that people often laughed nervously in uncomfortable situations. People in his study were asked to give electric shocks to a stranger, with the shocks becoming increasingly powerful (up to 450 volts).
But the “strangers” in this case were researchers involved in the study — they weren’t actually being shocked. But participants were more likely to laugh at the violence of the situation the higher the volts went.
Neuroscientist V.S. Ramachandran explored this idea in his book “A Brief Tour of Human Consciousness.” He proposes that laughter first appeared in human history to indicate to those around us that whatever made us laugh wasn’t a threat or worth worrying about.
Ramachandran also suggested that laughter helps us heal from trauma by distracting ourselves from the pain and associating that pain with positive emotion. This could be why nervous laughter can happen even at funerals or other sad and traumatic events.
A newer 2019 research also suggests that laughter or mirth is a way for us to reduce fear, anxiety, or stress. The researchers theorize that mirth can help us turn off a negative reaction to uncomfortable or illogical things we encounter.
A 2015 study from a team of Yale researchers also found that people tend to respond with a variety of unexpected emotions in response to strong outside stimuli.
The researchers discovered an association between the strong emotions you feel when you see a cute baby, like wanting to pinch its cheek and speak to it in weird voices, and the urge to laugh when you’re nervous or anxious.
So nervous laughter may also just be part of a larger pattern within the brain to react with strong emotions of all sorts to emotionally provocative stimuli, no matter if it seems appropriate.

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:21

@BadNomad have you been raped or sexually assaulted before? Have you had any professional therapy to deal with it? I have been physically and sexually assaulted, spent a couple of days in the hospital and then have had counselling and therapy to deal with it. I can sense that you are talking through your hat.

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 09:18

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:12

Sorry what are you on about? All I did was to point out that if you find out freezing and not coping well in emergency situations, you should be doing something about it. There are proven ways of improving your acute stress response.

You are coming across as quite hostile and judgemental. If that was your intention then crack on. I am just suggesting that you take a moment to consider how your posts are coming across and how you are reacting to people’s posts to you, before shaming others for their reactions.

Nussbaum · 30/06/2023 09:17

ladydimitrescu · 30/06/2023 07:42

@Nussbaum the only ridiculous thing is everyone acting like that's a perfectly normal acceptable response when it's really really not!!

It IS a perfectly normal response, it's within the emotional parameters of responsive reactions.

BadNomad · 30/06/2023 09:16

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:08

Yes, I would advise rape victims to see therapy for their trauma. I have been sexually assaulted before, just managed to flee before being penetrated. You can choose to make that step from victim to survivor – to moving forward with your life and take the control back.

Take back control so if that situation happens again they can react differently in the moment? Which implies if they'd acted differently the first time, it wouldn't have happened.

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:12

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 09:04

@DressDilemma - have you considered working on your knee jerk reaction to people who disagree with your outlook? I think it may help you to build resilience in this area.

Sorry what are you on about? All I did was to point out that if you find out freezing and not coping well in emergency situations, you should be doing something about it. There are proven ways of improving your acute stress response.

DressDilemma · 30/06/2023 09:08

BadNomad · 30/06/2023 09:03

@DressDilemma Nice. Would you tell rape victims who freeze instead of fight that they need to build better coping mechanisms instead of feeling out of control and helpless? Maybe don't judge people's involuntary reactions.

Yes, I would advise rape victims to see therapy for their trauma. I have been sexually assaulted before, just managed to flee before being penetrated. You can choose to make that step from victim to survivor – to moving forward with your life and take the control back.

Kingsparkle · 30/06/2023 09:04

@DressDilemma - have you considered working on your knee jerk reaction to people who disagree with your outlook? I think it may help you to build resilience in this area.

BadNomad · 30/06/2023 09:03

@DressDilemma Nice. Would you tell rape victims who freeze instead of fight that they need to build better coping mechanisms instead of feeling out of control and helpless? Maybe don't judge people's involuntary reactions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread