Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it fair to have school facilities divided in such a way?

66 replies

Elwyn · 29/06/2023 20:15

Say there is an area dedicated to a particular sport and it is divided up into half that is used by a child who I presume presents with additional needs and their friend and the other half is used by the rest of the children who also want to do this sport (about 10 kids and it can get quite crowded). Does this happen in other schools? My child understands about the fact that children with additional needs will have extra provisions made available to them but he feels this is just creating resentment because it seems so imbalanced. I am wondering if there is anything else I can tell him that will help make sense of it.

OP posts:
WhamBamThankU · 10/09/2023 15:23

So if your child was the one who required this adjustment to access the same class would you be saying it's not fair to the other kids? Absolutely not.

PurpleNebula84 · 10/09/2023 15:23

@EbiRaisukaree I was going to post exactly what you did... Great minds lol.

MidnightOnceMore · 10/09/2023 15:21

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 15:01

Because it doesn’t actually address the question of whether one child with extra needs requires half the available space, does it? It just tells people to stop asking awkward questions. Because disability.

Yes, I think you should stop asking those questions. The person in charge who has far more info than anyone else has deemed this to be a reasonable adjustment.

If you had the same needs you'd get the same.

I don't need a blue badge. I don't need the 1-person office my colleague does. It's not my place to start asking if other people need them. It's a nasty line of questioning designed to undermine the needs of people with SEN/disabilities.

refreshingseahorse · 10/09/2023 15:20

EbiRaisukaree · 10/09/2023 15:03

Fair doesn’t always mean equal. This is a very simple visual illustration which a child should be able to understand. Sometimes people need more in order to put them in the same position as everyone else.

I've seen that one with the caption ' this is theft, none of them paid for a ticket', and now I can't look at it in the same way 🤣

Starlightstarbright2 · 10/09/2023 15:16

EbiRaisukaree · 10/09/2023 15:03

Fair doesn’t always mean equal. This is a very simple visual illustration which a child should be able to understand. Sometimes people need more in order to put them in the same position as everyone else.

This is the exact picture I was thinking of when I read the post .

My Ds does have Sn’s - the mantra life isn’t fair is one he gets told because it isn’t .

life is so much challenging for parents and children with Sn’s - my Ds will try and fit in with NT children best he can but if the school deem this necessary then there is a reason.

There are so many children struggling in mainstream schools which are unsuitable because the word inclusivity is a nice buzz word that is not funded - so yes NT kids do lose , ND kids lose too.

EbiRaisukaree · 10/09/2023 15:03

Fair doesn’t always mean equal. This is a very simple visual illustration which a child should be able to understand. Sometimes people need more in order to put them in the same position as everyone else.

Is it fair to have school facilities divided in such a way?
Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 15:01

Bogiss · 10/09/2023 14:53

How does that shut the debate down?

Because it doesn’t actually address the question of whether one child with extra needs requires half the available space, does it? It just tells people to stop asking awkward questions. Because disability.

Yarnysaurus · 10/09/2023 14:59

User2637485 · 10/09/2023 13:29

@Elwyn you will learn very quickly on Mumsnet that there is no such thing as disadvantaging NT children. Standards can drop in the school because funding has to be allocated elsewhere, but NT are never disadvantaged.

By 'NT' do you mean 'non-disabled'?

MidnightOnceMore · 10/09/2023 14:56

I am wondering if there is anything else I can tell him that will help make sense of it. I'd tell him it isn't unfair IMO and start an age-appropriate conversation about equity.

I'd tell him other children will hopefully be told by their own parents not to resent reasonable adjustments.

Bogiss · 10/09/2023 14:53

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 13:58

It should be possible to have a discussion about equity and inclusion without using ‘just be grateful you don’t have a disability’ to shut it down.

How does that shut the debate down?

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 13:58

DemonicCaveMaggot · 29/06/2023 20:20

Your DS can ask any of the children who are resenting this if they would be willing to have the additional needs, and everything that goes with it, for the rest of their lives, in return for having more space to play this sport at school.

It should be possible to have a discussion about equity and inclusion without using ‘just be grateful you don’t have a disability’ to shut it down.

ASimpleLampoon · 10/09/2023 13:54

It's none of your business or your childs. As pp said, I'm sure the child would happily swap any funding for not being disabled \ disadvantaged.

Teach your child inclusivity. Better still, learn about it yourself

Bogiss · 10/09/2023 13:48

User2637485 · 10/09/2023 13:29

@Elwyn you will learn very quickly on Mumsnet that there is no such thing as disadvantaging NT children. Standards can drop in the school because funding has to be allocated elsewhere, but NT are never disadvantaged.

What do you mean?

User2637485 · 10/09/2023 13:29

@Elwyn you will learn very quickly on Mumsnet that there is no such thing as disadvantaging NT children. Standards can drop in the school because funding has to be allocated elsewhere, but NT are never disadvantaged.

Bogiss · 10/09/2023 10:19

vipersnest1 · 29/06/2023 21:42

Would you have wanted my DC2 (who is legally blind) to be put in amongst their classmates during a physical activity that would endanger them if too many people were there, @Elwyn?
This kind of thread really pisses me off, to be blunt.
Whilst your child experiences the minor inconvenience due to being a bit crowded, the child with needs gets to actually be able to take part in some form, even if it is at a different level.
Go and have a word with yourself. Angry

This.

Can you imagine the uproar if the other children were hit with bats, knocked over every lesson, had their feet run over or were hit in the face with balls?

You don’t know why the child needs the extra space, it could well be best for the rest of the class as well as for the disabled child.

JaiynDough · 10/09/2023 09:58

Depends why the child needs half the area.

Why can't they join the others?

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/09/2023 09:57

Presumably there’s a reason the child has been given an area for play to themselves. It could be they get overwhelmed in busy spaces or could be they have behaviours which involve targeting other children etc. Unfortunately most mainstream schools aren’t well resourced when it comes to being able to set up the environment for students who can’t cope being in a busy classroom/ playground etc without repurposing existing facilities.

Wouldyouguess · 10/09/2023 09:54

Yabbadabbadotime · 29/06/2023 21:37

The use of the space ought to be alternated so everyone gets a chance to participate properly. It might mean everyone gets slightly fewer goes but that's ok.

Its not equity to take participation away from one group and give it to a smaller one. Reducing & overcrowding half the space is rendering it essentially not useable, it doesn't seem a fair solution to the larger group.

Having SEN is also not exactly 'fair, is it. The other kid sonly have to suck up having less space once a week or whatever.

Wouldyouguess · 10/09/2023 09:53

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 21:33

it's awful to isolate some children and insist on showing their "difference" to the others. It's the best way to make sure they keep being excluded, then you have parents rightly upset because their child keep being excluded from friendship groups and parties.

Offering reasonable adjustments should be done in a much more inclusive way.

Does anyone ever bother to wonder if the child, or the 2 children, who are separated that way are happy about it?

Maybe the child in question is not isolated but does not deal well in big groups and needs the space. I guess you know zero about SEN.

Stompythedinosaur · 10/09/2023 09:23

I think you're being ridiculous to feel so strongly about this.

The other dc will manage.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 10/09/2023 09:10

Whether an individual child being given half the sports area is the right approach, would depend entirely on the individual child, their limitations and the rest of the group involved. I assume that the teachers who are responsible for the education and well being of the children are better able to assess that, than a group of random strangers on t’internet.
For SOME children, a more inclusive approach will work, but not for all.

SchoolShenanigans · 30/06/2023 13:39

It's literally impossible to know without knowing the child, what needs they have and the dimensions and situation of the premises.

YABU to think random strangers can advice on if this is a reasonable adjustment. YABU to think your child knows enough about another child's health needs to determine if it's fair allocation.

Qilin · 30/06/2023 13:33

Does anyone ever bother to wonder if the child, or the 2 children, who are separated that way are happy about it?

Yes, many people do consider this. It's very often part of someone's job to do just that.
It may seem isolating to an outsider but may be just what the child needs. Some children really don't feel that need of being with others - infact for some children it's quite the opposite.

vipersnest1 · 29/06/2023 23:05

@Yabbadabbadotime, these are the words that OP posted:
'about 10 kids and it can get quite crowded'
I'm didn't assume it, OP actually said it, if you care to RTFT - it's not good form to quote others out of context.
You are quoting 28 when OP posted 10 kids, to refer back to the original post.
Don't put words into my mouth.
'Its ok for op to think this isn't the best way to do it.'
That's your opinion and it carries very little weight given the views that have been expressed here, and those are not only mine.

Yabbadabbadotime · 29/06/2023 21:48

*Whilst your child experiences the minor inconvenience due to being a bit crowded

Everyone's assuming it's "a bit crowded".

What if its two tennis courts, and to faciliate one child having a whole court to themself and a partner, you have to put 28 others on the other court? The 28 clearly wouldn't be able to meaningfully play. Would that be fair and inclusive?

Better to have rotations of who uses the space. Also less likely to breed resentment towards one child.

There are better and worse ways to share and be inclusive.

Poorly thought out inclusion = better than no inclusion

Well planned inclusion = better still.

Its ok for op to think this isn't the best way to do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread