Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it fair to have school facilities divided in such a way?

66 replies

Elwyn · 29/06/2023 20:15

Say there is an area dedicated to a particular sport and it is divided up into half that is used by a child who I presume presents with additional needs and their friend and the other half is used by the rest of the children who also want to do this sport (about 10 kids and it can get quite crowded). Does this happen in other schools? My child understands about the fact that children with additional needs will have extra provisions made available to them but he feels this is just creating resentment because it seems so imbalanced. I am wondering if there is anything else I can tell him that will help make sense of it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bogiss · 10/09/2023 19:14

HarrietJet · 10/09/2023 17:58

It does seem unfair. Why can't the child who needs more space just use the facilities at a different time? That would seem a better reasonable adjustment.

That relies on there being extra space in the timetable, and extra staff.

And more importantly it ostracises the disabled child more than he already has to be- with this set up he is taking part in pe lessons (which he is legally entitled to do by the way) with his peers, to the best of his ability.

Sirzy · 10/09/2023 18:05

HarrietJet · 10/09/2023 18:04

Because they can't cope with the general melee when everyone does it at the same time?

But they can with a simple reasonable adjustment.

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 18:05

Greensleeves · 10/09/2023 18:02

Show him this and tell him not to be so selfish.

Show him this and tell him it’s ok to ask questions about things he doesn’t understand, because that’s how we learn, and learning is important because then we can adjust our thinking and behaviour.

HarrietJet · 10/09/2023 18:04

Sirzy · 10/09/2023 18:00

How is that fair? Because it’s out of sight out of mind for everyone else?

why should that child have to have their break time at a different time to everyone else?

Because they can't cope with the general melee when everyone does it at the same time?

Greensleeves · 10/09/2023 18:02

Show him this and tell him not to be so selfish.

Is it fair to have school facilities divided in such a way?
Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 18:02

Doormatnomore · 10/09/2023 17:56

This could be my child. Do able bodied children have access to every club for every sport (yes). If this adjustment wasn’t made would the child be excluded from taking part altogether, probably yes.

as I always say the easiest solution if for children who think it’s unfair to permanently disable themselves and then they can have all the benefits. Then lots of people shout at me and act horrified but that’s the reality.

But it’s not the easiest solution is it? That just creates more disabled people who have to contend with a prevailing culture of exclusion. The easiest solution, if course, is for schools to be a place that gently explain the differences between equality and fairness, and promote inclusion so that the next generation is better than the last.

Sirzy · 10/09/2023 18:00

HarrietJet · 10/09/2023 17:58

It does seem unfair. Why can't the child who needs more space just use the facilities at a different time? That would seem a better reasonable adjustment.

How is that fair? Because it’s out of sight out of mind for everyone else?

why should that child have to have their break time at a different time to everyone else?

HarrietJet · 10/09/2023 17:58

It does seem unfair. Why can't the child who needs more space just use the facilities at a different time? That would seem a better reasonable adjustment.

Doormatnomore · 10/09/2023 17:56

This could be my child. Do able bodied children have access to every club for every sport (yes). If this adjustment wasn’t made would the child be excluded from taking part altogether, probably yes.

as I always say the easiest solution if for children who think it’s unfair to permanently disable themselves and then they can have all the benefits. Then lots of people shout at me and act horrified but that’s the reality.

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 17:49

Wouldyouguess · 10/09/2023 17:17

I imagine there is also some privacy for the child in question where their needs do not have to be explained to other kids in details just because they are nosy and once a week for 30 min they have to give up a bit of space for someone else.

Why do we have to entertain explicit and in depth explanation about details of someone's health/condition. I get your point, but far too often I see parents and their precious little kids chanllenging and demanding to know details they are not entitled to know, there are two sides of it.

There needs to be a conversation, for sure,but also sometimes kids and their parents need to accept some information are not to be given and they have to accept it's like that because.

A questioning child is not just being nosy, they have sensed that something is unequal and they need help to understand why. It’s perfectly possible to respond in a principled and educational way without compromising the privacy of the child with extra needs.

’Because’ it not a helpful answer to any question, and it certainly doesn’t breakdown barriers for people with disabilities. It might feel like a quick win at the time, but it doesn’t actually help.

Wouldyouguess · 10/09/2023 17:17

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 17:07

What I want is for the question to be answered fully, explaining to the child asking a perfectly legitimate question that their classmate has more space because that’s what it takes to give them the same opportunity to participate as everyone else. Instead of just shaming them with ‘well would you rather be disabled?’, which is a missed opportunity to educate about inclusion and an idiot response, frankly, that you have just perpetuated.

Please go through the thread and read my posts, where I have already explained this.

I imagine there is also some privacy for the child in question where their needs do not have to be explained to other kids in details just because they are nosy and once a week for 30 min they have to give up a bit of space for someone else.

Why do we have to entertain explicit and in depth explanation about details of someone's health/condition. I get your point, but far too often I see parents and their precious little kids chanllenging and demanding to know details they are not entitled to know, there are two sides of it.

There needs to be a conversation, for sure,but also sometimes kids and their parents need to accept some information are not to be given and they have to accept it's like that because.

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 17:07

Wouldyouguess · 10/09/2023 16:56

Someone assessed it and decided they do, you want your child to have more space but be disabled?

What I want is for the question to be answered fully, explaining to the child asking a perfectly legitimate question that their classmate has more space because that’s what it takes to give them the same opportunity to participate as everyone else. Instead of just shaming them with ‘well would you rather be disabled?’, which is a missed opportunity to educate about inclusion and an idiot response, frankly, that you have just perpetuated.

Please go through the thread and read my posts, where I have already explained this.

Wouldyouguess · 10/09/2023 16:56

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 15:01

Because it doesn’t actually address the question of whether one child with extra needs requires half the available space, does it? It just tells people to stop asking awkward questions. Because disability.

Someone assessed it and decided they do, you want your child to have more space but be disabled?

MidnightOnceMore · 10/09/2023 16:46

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 15:42

But the child with additional needs hasn’t been given half the space as compensation for a lifetime of disability, have they? They have been given it because they need it to thrive, and rightly so. That’s the conversation that needs to be had. The whole ‘stop asking questions and just be glad you’re not them’ approach is a backwards step in educating people on inclusion. That was my original point.

If a question is asked in good faith (and it usually is, especially by children) then it should be answered in good faith.

I also misinterpreted your original position @Secondwindplease - apologies for that.

Yes your explanation is pretty much what I would say. I thought you meant it was unfair they had additional resources (space in this case). Apols again.

whereonthestair · 10/09/2023 16:29

My son is a para swimmer. When he joins races with his club he is entitled to a warm up. They usually give him a lane to himself while 6-10 others warm up in other lanes. This is fairer for everyone. My son is very good for his classification but he will always be slower than able bodied swimmers if actually faster than most others in his class. If they share a lane no-one gets a good warm up. So he gets the same resources 6-10 others get as otherwise everyone suffers as able bodied children can pace each other. Or my son doesn't compete.

Lilolilibet · 10/09/2023 16:13

Holy shit.

Bogiss · 10/09/2023 16:06

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 15:42

But the child with additional needs hasn’t been given half the space as compensation for a lifetime of disability, have they? They have been given it because they need it to thrive, and rightly so. That’s the conversation that needs to be had. The whole ‘stop asking questions and just be glad you’re not them’ approach is a backwards step in educating people on inclusion. That was my original point.

If a question is asked in good faith (and it usually is, especially by children) then it should be answered in good faith.

If a question is asked in good faith (and it usually is, especially by children) then it should be answered in good faith.

I agree.

I think I misunderstood the point you were making- sorry!

ItsNotRocketSalad · 10/09/2023 15:51

DemonicCaveMaggot · 29/06/2023 20:20

Your DS can ask any of the children who are resenting this if they would be willing to have the additional needs, and everything that goes with it, for the rest of their lives, in return for having more space to play this sport at school.

I doubt that'll work. Her child is likely old enough to sense a false dichotomy even if he doesn't know the term for it.

PastTheGin · 10/09/2023 15:50

So there are 2 table tennis tables, one reserved for 2 students and the other to be shared by others.
Explain to your child that yes, this seems really unfair, but having SEN is not fair, either.
Has your child ever benefited from a protected area, eg different playgrounds in primary or an area for Year 7s only in secondary? Maybe that makes is more understandable.

Sirzy · 10/09/2023 15:46

This reminds me of the parent who complained to school that it wasn’t fair that my Ds got his own teacher and her daughter didn’t.

ds has a full time 1-1 (ta not teacher obviously!) as we fought to get the right support written into his ehcp. Him having that provision doesn’t take away from the education of anyone else in the class, infact it probably makes things better for them as the class teacher and TA aren’t spending a disproportionate amount of time supporting him.

different children will need different things in order to access things. That’s actually making things closer to fair rather than unfair

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 15:42

Bogiss · 10/09/2023 15:25

The question the op asked was “how can I talk to my son about why a disabled child gets half the sports pitch”- talking to him about the fact that half a sports pitch in pe doesn’t make up for a life time of disability and the child is better off with a rubbish pe lesson than a disability is one way of doing that. I mean, I wouldn’t necessarily take that attitude with a kid but then I’m not that mum.

Saying it doesn’t stop anyone else having an opinion… lots of other posters have managed to post theirs so clearly it doesn’t shut down discussion.

But the child with additional needs hasn’t been given half the space as compensation for a lifetime of disability, have they? They have been given it because they need it to thrive, and rightly so. That’s the conversation that needs to be had. The whole ‘stop asking questions and just be glad you’re not them’ approach is a backwards step in educating people on inclusion. That was my original point.

If a question is asked in good faith (and it usually is, especially by children) then it should be answered in good faith.

Sprogonthetyne · 10/09/2023 15:39

So 12 kids want to do this sport, and there are two pitches/ areas. The 10-2 split allows all to play, even if some find it crowded. The alternative is likely that 11 kids play 5 or 6 to a pitch and one is unable to play at all.

Out of intrest, would your DS complain if there was only one pitch and 10 kids, or is the 'problem' that the other kids appears to have more?

Would they also complain if the steps up to a building were made narrower to allow room for a ramp?

Balloonsandroses · 10/09/2023 15:37

A couple of years ago my kid was allowed to go into lunch first with one of her friends every single day. So none of the other children ever got to go into lunch first and they always had to queue for longer. Some kids complained about this and told her it wasn’t fair. Sounds unfair right?

She was on chemo at the time and felt permanently ill and exhausted to the extent of needing a wheelchair for longer distances. But she was desperate to be with her friends and to be as normal as possible and this “unfair” solution allowed her to do so.

So I’d explain it to your kid by saying that sometimes people with disabilities have different needs and need us to give them more help / support to get as close as possible to the experience that kids without disabilities are lucky enough to have.

Hope that helps.

Embarrassednamechangeadoddle · 10/09/2023 15:25

I’d probably tell my children that schools have to adapt to help children with additional needs access learning and sports. The people that support this young person have obviously planned to support this child by making sure they have space and that will help this child be involved in sport. That’s it.

Im assuming you don’t know the ins and out of the child’s needs so can’t explain anymore.

Bogiss · 10/09/2023 15:25

Secondwindplease · 10/09/2023 15:01

Because it doesn’t actually address the question of whether one child with extra needs requires half the available space, does it? It just tells people to stop asking awkward questions. Because disability.

The question the op asked was “how can I talk to my son about why a disabled child gets half the sports pitch”- talking to him about the fact that half a sports pitch in pe doesn’t make up for a life time of disability and the child is better off with a rubbish pe lesson than a disability is one way of doing that. I mean, I wouldn’t necessarily take that attitude with a kid but then I’m not that mum.

Saying it doesn’t stop anyone else having an opinion… lots of other posters have managed to post theirs so clearly it doesn’t shut down discussion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread