Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think men can NEVER be mothers

282 replies

Leafstamp · 29/06/2023 13:35

I am furious that men like this think they can call themselves mums/mothers. This deserves a wide audience, hence posting in AIBU.

(11) Paul Embery on Twitter: "ITV news did a piece about the impact of soaring water bills on an everyday mother. So naturally they got a man to play the part. t.co/b0ipO7loUE" / Twitter

https://twitter.com/PaulEmbery/status/1674332639921045505

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
StephanieSuperpowers · 29/06/2023 17:47

BorneoBound · 29/06/2023 17:44

I don't see how the person calling themself a mother has any impact on you / your life - why do we have to get so worked up over what other people are doing or what they call themselves? It doesn't make you any less of a mother. Personally if I was to find myself in the position of wanting to identify as male I think it would be rational to ask my kids to refer to me as dad 🤷‍♀️ so the other way seems sensible

Poor kids.

Melroses · 29/06/2023 17:46

GiraffeDoor · 29/06/2023 17:35

Why is the premise of this whole article that energy/water bills affect mothers more than fathers anyway? My husband does probably 75% of the laundry in our house (for no reason other than I hate it).

I'm no fan of banning the word "woman" or "mother", but this absolutely is an example of a situation which never needed to be gendered in the first place.

Well it kind of does if you are being performative about it, otherwise there would be no point in.................. 🤔

Well, there you go. Stereotypes abound 🤷‍♀️

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 29/06/2023 17:45

His reference to his 'kid' gave me the ick.

BorneoBound · 29/06/2023 17:44

I don't see how the person calling themself a mother has any impact on you / your life - why do we have to get so worked up over what other people are doing or what they call themselves? It doesn't make you any less of a mother. Personally if I was to find myself in the position of wanting to identify as male I think it would be rational to ask my kids to refer to me as dad 🤷‍♀️ so the other way seems sensible

ArabeIIaScott · 29/06/2023 17:42

Summer2023hasarrived · 29/06/2023 17:24

It’s a story about how the increase in energy/water bills impacts MOTHERS, so yes, they’re heavily implying they think this dude is a mother. He/she smiles sweetly into the camera whilst pretending he is a poor mother struggling with his water bills. He washes a few bits and loads a few bits into the washing machine, swishing of the skirt as he/she goes. Well done that man showing us how hard it is

Skirt go spinny, eh.

Worth checking out that youtube/twitter account.

Helleofabore · 29/06/2023 17:37

Bromptotoo · 29/06/2023 17:24

Let's start with definitions.

Why not just accept the person in that extract is a woman?

How is the person in that clip a 'woman'?

If a male says they are a 'woman', what they mean is that they are only the manifestation of their perception of what a 'woman' is. They have not changed sex. They are still male. They can never know what a woman feels like to know whether what they feel is anything like what a woman feels like to a female who is now an adult.

Therefore how is that person a 'woman'? Because that person says so? What other identity will you accept a person is when they are not actually that identity?

SunnyEgg · 29/06/2023 17:36

Bromptotoo · 29/06/2023 17:24

Let's start with definitions.

Why not just accept the person in that extract is a woman?

A man is a man, that’s kind of basic

GiraffeDoor · 29/06/2023 17:35

Why is the premise of this whole article that energy/water bills affect mothers more than fathers anyway? My husband does probably 75% of the laundry in our house (for no reason other than I hate it).

I'm no fan of banning the word "woman" or "mother", but this absolutely is an example of a situation which never needed to be gendered in the first place.

Valhalla17 · 29/06/2023 17:32

LittleMG · 29/06/2023 14:13

I know I’m going to be really flamed and I don’t think this in a nasty way at all… but I honestly feel that when I had my child I became a mother in lots of ways, I mean like I gained this kind of second sight/intuition to my children I never had with anyone else. My husband is an amazing dad and we parent 50/50 but he does not have my intuition when it comes to my babies. Men dont get it imo

I absolutely agree with you. Mothers have a stronger connection as they carry the child, the child is formed from their body and tissues. This is why it irks me even more that this man is claiming to be a mother, they honestly have no idea and zero understanding of what it is to be a one...they've just stepped into what they believe to be the official costume. Washing up as props.

It's downright insulting.

itsmylife7 · 29/06/2023 17:30

Lots of ☀with this one.

Sneezel · 29/06/2023 17:30

The GRA itself confirms a father is always the father, and can NOT ever be the mother, and this was confirmed in the UK supreme court when Freddie Mcconnell took legal action (and lost) as she wanted to be called the 'father' of the baby she gave birth to. The importance of the terms ‘mother’ and ‘father’ were discussed in court. McConnell’s ‘right’ to be ‘validated’ as ‘father’ must be weighed against child’s right to know the truth.https://twitter.com/SVPhillimore/status/1616733253494259714
Then recently the CoTs group reported that European courts have confirmed the same thing. As they say, children don't exist to validate their father's fetishes or delusions https://childrenoftransitioners.org/2023/04/10/paperwork/

https://twitter.com/SVPhillimore/status/1616733253494259714

Leafstamp · 29/06/2023 17:29

jeaux90 · 29/06/2023 17:08

If mumsnet could stop telling us we can't say that men aren't women and deleting our messages that would be great.

Indeed, that would be great.

OP posts:
Leafstamp · 29/06/2023 17:26

Bromptotoo · 29/06/2023 17:24

Let's start with definitions.

Why not just accept the person in that extract is a woman?

Erm, cos he's not a woman.

Next.

OP posts:
Ameanstreakamilewide · 29/06/2023 17:26

Bromptotoo · 29/06/2023 17:24

Let's start with definitions.

Why not just accept the person in that extract is a woman?

Cos he's a man.

Words have meanings, don't they?

Bornin1989 · 29/06/2023 17:25

You're only a woman if you "feel" like a woman apparently. Since most women don't actually "feel" like women, we just are women, I'm guessing that doesn't count.

Bromptotoo · 29/06/2023 17:24

Let's start with definitions.

Why not just accept the person in that extract is a woman?

Summer2023hasarrived · 29/06/2023 17:24

Whichclubisittonight · 29/06/2023 14:31

ITV don‘t actually use the word mother or woman though - they just say "this bill payer" and "customer" (both verbally and on the caption below) and I imagine they are just trying to be inclusive. I mean what does it matter if the person who is struggling to pay their bills is a woman or a man, they‘re both equally valid. I don‘t have a problem with ITV here.

It‘s only the person in the video who refers to themselves as a mother.

It‘s the person who posted the twitter link who has made this into something its not "ITV did a piece on (...) everyday mothers". I don‘t think that was the point at all.

It’s a story about how the increase in energy/water bills impacts MOTHERS, so yes, they’re heavily implying they think this dude is a mother. He/she smiles sweetly into the camera whilst pretending he is a poor mother struggling with his water bills. He washes a few bits and loads a few bits into the washing machine, swishing of the skirt as he/she goes. Well done that man showing us how hard it is

BodegaSushi · 29/06/2023 17:24

Clymene · 29/06/2023 17:16

Giving a legal definition of a word isn't smug @TeaKlaxon. I'm sorry that you've interpreted it like that.

But as you've said it isn't the only meaning. Yet you tried to prove this man can't be a mother because of the legal definition. Which is it? Either 'mother' can mean different things and other people who haven't given birth can use the name, or they can't. This man thinks he's a mother

Ameanstreakamilewide · 29/06/2023 17:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ArabeIIaScott · 29/06/2023 17:20

Yeah, probably tending to the actual child.

Summer2023hasarrived · 29/06/2023 17:19

ArabeIIaScott · 29/06/2023 17:17

The person is also cosplaying being poor.

'mothers like me who struggle'. Mate. No. It's very apparent the whole thing is play acting. You're an economist with a senior role in the TUC. Unless they're not paying their staff adequately, which would be ironic.

Indeed, pretending to be poor, pretending to be a mum and pretending to be a woman. Where was the actual mum, his/her wife whilst he acted out his fantasy fetish which was shown on the ITV news?

Summer2023hasarrived · 29/06/2023 17:18

Samcro · 29/06/2023 14:22

i saw that on the news. when they said they were a mum, I admit to saying your not.

I imagine quite a lot of people spat their tea out. I thought it was a prank but no it's a trans lobby person who feels he is a woman and a mummy. Could ITV not actually find a mother anywhere or did real women and mums reject the outfit for the role!

ArabeIIaScott · 29/06/2023 17:17

The person is also cosplaying being poor.

'mothers like me who struggle'. Mate. No. It's very apparent the whole thing is play acting. You're an economist with a senior role in the TUC. Unless they're not paying their staff adequately, which would be ironic.

Sweetsweetlike1 · 29/06/2023 17:16

SmartHome · 29/06/2023 14:07

I really thought this one was a piss take it was SO ludicrous. And no actual mother would a) put the washing machine in such a stupid place b) use a washing up bowl as a laundry basket!

This

Clymene · 29/06/2023 17:16

Giving a legal definition of a word isn't smug @TeaKlaxon. I'm sorry that you've interpreted it like that.