Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think men can NEVER be mothers

282 replies

Leafstamp · 29/06/2023 13:35

I am furious that men like this think they can call themselves mums/mothers. This deserves a wide audience, hence posting in AIBU.

(11) Paul Embery on Twitter: "ITV news did a piece about the impact of soaring water bills on an everyday mother. So naturally they got a man to play the part. t.co/b0ipO7loUE" / Twitter

https://twitter.com/PaulEmbery/status/1674332639921045505

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
VashtaNerada · 22/09/2023 02:39

I think that “mothering” is different to “fathering” (largely due to gender stereotyping and expectations over the years). Single parents do both and those in same-sex relationships often do both.

Louiseeee · 22/09/2023 00:55

very sorry I clicked YABU by accident

TorqueWrench · 22/09/2023 00:49

Sayitaintso33 · 22/09/2023 00:41

Mothering is a social construct. That is why men can be mothers. They can't be women because that is a matter of biology.

Hmm, I'm not sure. Female animals seem to do most of the mothering in nature.

Sayitaintso33 · 22/09/2023 00:41

Mothering is a social construct. That is why men can be mothers. They can't be women because that is a matter of biology.

Maatandosiris · 21/09/2023 13:06

Ladyoftheknight · 30/06/2023 21:55

You say this but you're clearly not open to discussing other opinions than yours. She's a mother because she's a parent and says she's a mother. Almost any mother you know could be trans, if you don't know it doesn't seem to hurt you though... Maybe worry about more important issues like rising energy costs!

Actually 99 .9% of mothers I know could not be this person, I have seen them pregnant. The mothers who adopted are mothers by definition of being a female parent (as defined in the dictionary).

The people I know who provided the sperm are fathers- the male parent, male being and adult human male. Males are the class who produce sperm.

Wishing to be something different neither alters biology nor the English language.

Language is important. Otherwise I could say

During my popsicle minute yesterday I drank the sofa and ate the lampshade.

When really during my lunch hour today I ate a sandwich and walked the dog.

You can’t go round substituting words. They have meanings which are necessary for society to function

Maatandosiris · 21/09/2023 12:41

lifeturnsonadime · 02/07/2023 21:29

I challenge any mother to justify this.

Just wrong.

So saddening that this man has used this baby as a prop to his fetish.

This has got to stop. Now.

It’s bizarre, on the “breastfeeding” post there seems an effort to equate transwomen with black people, gay people and disabled people. I’ve seen this a lot, it’s almost like this narrative is scripted

IsadoraQuagmire · 21/09/2023 12:41

nothingcomestonothing · 21/09/2023 08:25

Actual experts, or people who identify as experts?

The "experts" are probably India Willoughby and Freda Wallace 🤡🤡

Maatandosiris · 21/09/2023 12:36

TorqueWrench · 21/09/2023 00:33

With experts predicting that the first male womb transplant is 5-10 years away I think we'll likely see men giving birth in our lifetime. I'm most curious to see how the first mumsnet thread on that goes!

Can you link to these experts with peer reviewed research papers on how this will be possible. I’m still waiting for the explosion in personal helicopter taxis predicted in Brave New World

Maatandosiris · 21/09/2023 12:34

Helleofabore · 21/09/2023 08:20

Then you’d be able to explain the steps via the ethical standards board that currently has made maybe one change in one hundred years to move the time of embryo destruction by a matter of days to allow stem cell experiments, will allow embryos to be used for such unethical experiments?

All those people who are making such rash declarations forget that small issue…

And the two other very relevant ones. The rat experiment in China. And the lamb in the bag experiment.

There are so many serious ethical considerations.

However, the reality is that so many people who declare this is going to happen don’t seem to comprehend the female endocrine system and other parts of the body that control a pregnancy is NOT present in a male body. And no one has worked out how to transplant all of those parts while suppressing the genetic coding of the male body so a male body can develop an embryo to deliver a live and healthy infant.

An infant that has not been effectively grown in a bag implanted into a male and then injected with all the substances a male simply cannot produce that medical experts have no fucking idea what conditions that will cause the human as they develops into adulthood.

This is fucking Mumsnet! And some posters seriously have either never thought about it, or they ignore the child is a human or something. I actually believe that I don’t think they actually understand pregnancy at all.

Great post. It’s almost like people are wishing for a dystopian future

Maatandosiris · 21/09/2023 12:31

It’s easy, we have this marvellous thing called the dictionary - this defines a mother as a female parent. The term parent isn’t in question so we look at the definition of female.

Female - of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of gametes (ova) that can be fertilized by male gametes.

Therefore a man (an adult human male) can never be a mother.

Language means something. It is important.

Baldieheid · 21/09/2023 12:20

Sayitaintso33 · 21/09/2023 12:01

I don't think men can be a women but I do think they can be mothers, just as they can be housewives if they want.

Jfc. What the hell are you smoking?

Terfsichore · 21/09/2023 12:06

Sayitaintso33 · 21/09/2023 12:01

I don't think men can be a women but I do think they can be mothers, just as they can be housewives if they want.

Don't be stupid 🤡

Clymene · 21/09/2023 12:02

Sayitaintso33 · 21/09/2023 12:01

I don't think men can be a women but I do think they can be mothers, just as they can be housewives if they want.

The word mother means female parent. Men cannot become mothers. Because they are men.

Sayitaintso33 · 21/09/2023 12:01

I don't think men can be a women but I do think they can be mothers, just as they can be housewives if they want.

Bornin1989 · 21/09/2023 10:43

Helleofabore · 21/09/2023 08:20

Then you’d be able to explain the steps via the ethical standards board that currently has made maybe one change in one hundred years to move the time of embryo destruction by a matter of days to allow stem cell experiments, will allow embryos to be used for such unethical experiments?

All those people who are making such rash declarations forget that small issue…

And the two other very relevant ones. The rat experiment in China. And the lamb in the bag experiment.

There are so many serious ethical considerations.

However, the reality is that so many people who declare this is going to happen don’t seem to comprehend the female endocrine system and other parts of the body that control a pregnancy is NOT present in a male body. And no one has worked out how to transplant all of those parts while suppressing the genetic coding of the male body so a male body can develop an embryo to deliver a live and healthy infant.

An infant that has not been effectively grown in a bag implanted into a male and then injected with all the substances a male simply cannot produce that medical experts have no fucking idea what conditions that will cause the human as they develops into adulthood.

This is fucking Mumsnet! And some posters seriously have either never thought about it, or they ignore the child is a human or something. I actually believe that I don’t think they actually understand pregnancy at all.

Indeed. To add that "all those people making such rash declarations" think that women's role in a pregnancy is passive, with our vagina just being "a hole" for the baby to come out of.

Mysogynistic bollocks - reducing women to holes once more. I don't see how a baby would come out of transwoman's vagina anyway, which indeed is 'just a hole' given it has zero in common with a vagina other than its location.

nothingcomestonothing · 21/09/2023 08:25

TorqueWrench · 21/09/2023 00:33

With experts predicting that the first male womb transplant is 5-10 years away I think we'll likely see men giving birth in our lifetime. I'm most curious to see how the first mumsnet thread on that goes!

Actual experts, or people who identify as experts?

Helleofabore · 21/09/2023 08:20

TorqueWrench · 21/09/2023 00:33

With experts predicting that the first male womb transplant is 5-10 years away I think we'll likely see men giving birth in our lifetime. I'm most curious to see how the first mumsnet thread on that goes!

Then you’d be able to explain the steps via the ethical standards board that currently has made maybe one change in one hundred years to move the time of embryo destruction by a matter of days to allow stem cell experiments, will allow embryos to be used for such unethical experiments?

All those people who are making such rash declarations forget that small issue…

And the two other very relevant ones. The rat experiment in China. And the lamb in the bag experiment.

There are so many serious ethical considerations.

However, the reality is that so many people who declare this is going to happen don’t seem to comprehend the female endocrine system and other parts of the body that control a pregnancy is NOT present in a male body. And no one has worked out how to transplant all of those parts while suppressing the genetic coding of the male body so a male body can develop an embryo to deliver a live and healthy infant.

An infant that has not been effectively grown in a bag implanted into a male and then injected with all the substances a male simply cannot produce that medical experts have no fucking idea what conditions that will cause the human as they develops into adulthood.

This is fucking Mumsnet! And some posters seriously have either never thought about it, or they ignore the child is a human or something. I actually believe that I don’t think they actually understand pregnancy at all.

Clymene · 21/09/2023 07:13

TorqueWrench · 21/09/2023 00:33

With experts predicting that the first male womb transplant is 5-10 years away I think we'll likely see men giving birth in our lifetime. I'm most curious to see how the first mumsnet thread on that goes!

'Experts'

TorqueWrench · 21/09/2023 00:33

With experts predicting that the first male womb transplant is 5-10 years away I think we'll likely see men giving birth in our lifetime. I'm most curious to see how the first mumsnet thread on that goes!

POTC · 21/09/2023 00:28

I was brought up by my father. I'd have had no objection to him saying he had the role of both mother and father to me, because he did.

Rainbowshit · 20/09/2023 23:49

Sally2791 · 20/09/2023 22:41

Well I think they can…

Well you'd be very wrong then.

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 20/09/2023 22:42

I can only think they have a weird fetishism where they want to take over all women's spaces in some kind of power play

And the woke majority let them

Sally2791 · 20/09/2023 22:41

Well I think they can…

FemaleAndLearning · 08/07/2023 09:33

The baby girl is now about 3. She is referred to as my kid so I don't think mum is around.

Catsanfan · 05/07/2023 16:11

Abhorrent individual

Swipe left for the next trending thread