Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
mewkins · 30/06/2023 10:39

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:31

It's very easy to know if a secondary school has a swimming pool or not, particularly if you are involved in swimming.

Yes I am. The clubs here use the public pools of which there are plenty too.

Strawberrycocktail · 30/06/2023 10:39

It is partly the parents and the general environment in private schools which encourages achievements in these areas. The school itselt plays a moderate part in this but parents will be supplementing this outside of school. Eg musical instruments need regular (preferably daily) practice which will be done at home with parents (or nanny) having to supervise. Sports are often supplented out of school as parents and children feel the subtle pressure to keep up and stand a chance of being selected for team competition. The sportier children will be doing extra sports outside of school and then ‘rewarded’ with selection for teams or sports competitions by the school, hence providing the incentive to do extra out of school to get this. Similarly, with music, children who practice at home and progress in their musical instrument will be rewarded with the opportunity to perform in a school concert/recital.

All this can be achieved in many state schools with additional sports and music lessons arranged through after school clubs and out of school arrange musical instrument tuition on a private co-curricular basis. The difference is there is less pressure/expectation to do this so there will be fewer children putting in the extra time on these things.

Sartre · 30/06/2023 10:35

It isn’t a private school thing, it’s a money thing. Wealthier parents have spare cash for music lessons or they play themselves because their parents had the money for it so they can teach their own DC.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:33

Actually there is one. It's a SEN school though.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:31

mewkins · 30/06/2023 10:28

Have you visited all secondary schools across 4 counties?

Odd that here there are 2 secondary schools with pools as well as several primaries.

It's very easy to know if a secondary school has a swimming pool or not, particularly if you are involved in swimming.

arghtriffid · 30/06/2023 10:31

My DS does every extra curricular activity available (his choice) LAMDA, instrument tuition, cricket, football, dance, drama etc and is active out of school. I think it is important if you are able to afford this and your child wants to do it.

All these are available at my local state primary so we are lucky.

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 10:30

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:00

The posts from @Goldenbear about needing a shit school to influence the great art that is grime and drill (awful sexist terrible drivel) are absolutely cringe.

What is true however, is that the vast majority of the innovations in popular music over the past decades have not been created by the privately educated. British-born styles that have gone on to become highly popular worldwide, such as jungle, d n b, dubstep, grime, industrial, metal, hardcore and major elements of punk and post-punk, were created by kids that went to state schools and often lived on estates and have no “grades” on, say, the clarinet.

”Musicality” as defined by playing an orchestral instrument and being able to recite pre-written pieces of music to a certain technical standard, is the poor relation to proper creativity. For some it may be an enabler, but it’s not a requirement.

But, hey, it gives parents privately educating their kids something to boast about: that x has passed grade 3 on the oboe, or y worked terribly terribly hard to reach grade 2 on timpani.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 10:29

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:25

Then this thread doesn't really apply to you.

If you refer back to the OP's initial question it really does.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 10:28

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:22

I said if you have one you are lucky! Can't think of a single one like that in four counties near me. There's one 6th form college which has a pool and pitches.

Have you visited all secondary schools across 4 counties?

Odd that here there are 2 secondary schools with pools as well as several primaries.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:25

SpringleDingle · 30/06/2023 10:25

Ha ha ha ha! I went to private school. I am tone deaf, I don't play any instruments, I have flat feet and the most sporty thing I do is walk my dog. I used to hide in the library to avoid PE!!

Then this thread doesn't really apply to you.

SpringleDingle · 30/06/2023 10:25

Ha ha ha ha! I went to private school. I am tone deaf, I don't play any instruments, I have flat feet and the most sporty thing I do is walk my dog. I used to hide in the library to avoid PE!!

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 10:24

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 10:13

You are calling troll, funny that as I have been on MN forever. You constant assertion of the troll is because you don't have a counter argument and the fact it makes you feel uncomfortable as that is the decision you have made for your children. Stop pretending private school does not have a moral dimension to it. The misplaced sense of superiority being displayed by some posters is evidence of exactly why they chose private school for their children. If there is not a difference why bother at all?

I haven’t read any posts here suggesting there isn’t a difference between state and private. There are loads of posts saying that private school children are often more sporty and musical purely because they have more opportunity and spend more time on sport on music. The posts are literally pointing out that the opportunity and time is the difference between state and private. No one is saying that makes their children superior.

I chose private school to give my children those extra opportunities, not because I think they’re superior to others.

Do I think that all state school pupils should have the same opportunities? Yes, obviously I do. Unfortunately though, we cannot afford to have Olympic size pools etc, and specialist sports and music teachers, at all state schools without huge tax rises.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:23

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 10:22

Even if they could afford it. Lets face it bands where the members have gone to state school are all about cooler- all that detachment from poorer people doesn't do their empathy any good. I read an article where the private school was delivering lessons on empathy- hilarious, a bit like volunteering from private school to work with the poor 'unfortunates' - presumably to install in the rich kids how lucky they are!

No wonder some people think you are a troll with posts like this, tbf.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 10:22

Even if they could afford it. Lets face it bands where the members have gone to state school are all about cooler- all that detachment from poorer people doesn't do their empathy any good. I read an article where the private school was delivering lessons on empathy- hilarious, a bit like volunteering from private school to work with the poor 'unfortunates' - presumably to install in the rich kids how lucky they are!

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:22

mewkins · 30/06/2023 10:20

Based on one school, or two if you count the one you've attended, you know what all secondary schools are like for sports? I live in a town with 5 state secondary schools and there is massive variation between them for sports facilities, clubs available etc. My dd's and one of the others even has a pool, tennis courts, hockey pitches etc.
You think that football is the only sport on offer?? Really?? I think you've just illustrated that your perception is very different from reality.

I said if you have one you are lucky! Can't think of a single one like that in four counties near me. There's one 6th form college which has a pool and pitches.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 10:20

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:14

This is the thing though- you have a bad experience of state school and that has given you a view of state schools. In reality there is massive variation from school to school. Some will (shock!) be better than private schools even

At sport? Unlikely. They might have a good football team. I'm sure there are some private schools that have shit extracurricular but I've no idea why people choose those.

Based on one school, or two if you count the one you've attended, you know what all secondary schools are like for sports? I live in a town with 5 state secondary schools and there is massive variation between them for sports facilities, clubs available etc. My dd's and one of the others even has a pool, tennis courts, hockey pitches etc.
You think that football is the only sport on offer?? Really?? I think you've just illustrated that your perception is very different from reality.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:18

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 10:13

You are calling troll, funny that as I have been on MN forever. You constant assertion of the troll is because you don't have a counter argument and the fact it makes you feel uncomfortable as that is the decision you have made for your children. Stop pretending private school does not have a moral dimension to it. The misplaced sense of superiority being displayed by some posters is evidence of exactly why they chose private school for their children. If there is not a difference why bother at all?

Of course there's a difference. I don't like the state schools near me so we picked a better one. If you love your state school then great. If you happen to have a state school in catchment that prioritises sport amd music while also getting excellent academic results then that's great for you. Morality didn't come into my choices, other than I think the lack of sport and music in the state system IS immoral and I'd be delighted to see this government gone and the fantastic turn around under Labour.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 10:17

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:00

The posts from @Goldenbear about needing a shit school to influence the great art that is grime and drill (awful sexist terrible drivel) are absolutely cringe.

When did I reference 'grime & drill' you are the only one who has used this as an example. Why is that because of your preconceptions on certain music being inferior to other genres. The snobbery is vulgar and many middleclass parents with children at state school don't want their children to be surrounded by parents and their offspring that share these values.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:14

This is the thing though- you have a bad experience of state school and that has given you a view of state schools. In reality there is massive variation from school to school. Some will (shock!) be better than private schools even

At sport? Unlikely. They might have a good football team. I'm sure there are some private schools that have shit extracurricular but I've no idea why people choose those.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 10:13

twistyizzy · 30/06/2023 10:01

@Terryer I'm calling troll on that poster!! Some or the comments are bordering on deranged

You are calling troll, funny that as I have been on MN forever. You constant assertion of the troll is because you don't have a counter argument and the fact it makes you feel uncomfortable as that is the decision you have made for your children. Stop pretending private school does not have a moral dimension to it. The misplaced sense of superiority being displayed by some posters is evidence of exactly why they chose private school for their children. If there is not a difference why bother at all?

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 10:08

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 09:49

😳I'm embarrassed for you with those remarks, yes it is clearly the case that your hard working children are innately superior to the riff-raff at the local compo that you drive past in your Land Rover as you ferry your children to and from school; reminding your children that the reason these state educated children are heading for loserville is because they even complain about walking in the rain (oh hang on). Or do you remind your children that being collected by the school bus at 7am is testament to their commitment to their education and hard work as opposed to the riff-raff at the local comp who simply can't be bothered to turn up to school when it isn't open!

It is a good job that you are there to remind them that their struggles are real (heavy is the head that wears the crown of an expensive education) but that ultimately, one day, like you they to will have a misplaced sense of superiority.

At no point have I said that my children are superior. This post is about sporty and musical children. My point is that sporty and musical children have to work hard even if they’re given the extra opportunities at a private school. There are plenty of state school pupils who are sporty and musical as well, who work equally as hard (the county sports team I have experience of has a mixture of children, all of who get on and don’t care where each other goes to school). There are also plenty of children and parents, state or privately educated, who wouldn’t make the most of opportunities they’re given.

My children are aware of how fortunate they are to attend their school, through no reason other than having parents who can afford the fees. I went to a state school so can see both sides. I really don’t know why these threads have to be turned into a battle against the 2 sectors.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 10:05

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:47

Dd did go to our local state for two years and it was awful. So I sadly have experience of that. I also coach kids in my spare time.

Not sure why everyone except private school parents are allowed to confidently assert what they think about kids and sport.

This is the thing though- you have a bad experience of state school and that has given you a view of state schools. In reality there is massive variation from school to school. Some will (shock!) be better than private schools even.

Everyone can assert their opinions on children and sport but surely you recognise that yours is your own experience? My children have their own experiences - they are even different from each other's. 'Sport' is used as a catch-all term on the thread and while the OP was possibly thinking lacrosse, others will be thinking about how their child is at the football pitch every night. The term 'sporty' is interesting. My kids train most days for their particular sport but my son particularly would look alarmed if you called him sporty (he hates team sports and is one of the smallest in his class). 😄

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/06/2023 10:04

JoWawa · Yesterday 11:53
Private school days tend to be longer.”

This. Lessons started at 8.40am and finished at 4.20. Clubs and music lessons continued until 5.30pm

twistyizzy · 30/06/2023 10:01

@Terryer I'm calling troll on that poster!! Some or the comments are bordering on deranged

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:00

The posts from @Goldenbear about needing a shit school to influence the great art that is grime and drill (awful sexist terrible drivel) are absolutely cringe.