Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
woodhill · 30/06/2023 17:32

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 17:15

Private school children are definitely better musicians and better at sports. Why is this?

Private schools, of course, have better facilities than state schools. But, it’s more than that. Many private school parents are not rich; they have made big sacrifices and have worked hard to give their children the best start. This attitude of hard work and commitment to excel sets an example for their children who then apply themselves not only to academics, but also to sports and music. They are dedicated in their practice and regularly surpass grade 4 on the flute, oboe and cello by age 13!

Most parents of state school kids could also help their kids be good at music and sport (but not quite as good as private school kids, obviously). But they simply can’t be bothered to put in the effort themselves. Instead they prefer to spend their money on large TVs, Netflix and cars. They do things like take their kids out of school for holidays and let them lounge around listening to tripe like grime and drill on a Saturday morning when they could be practising the violin or cornet, or training at a local rowing club.

In sum, it’s less about financial resources, and more to do with the superior moral fibre of not only privately educated kids, but also their parents.

This is somewhat true

Noduckpicsplease · 30/06/2023 17:19

Really sad to see people say that Music is not important or a 'life skill'. It's proven to improve maths skills, language.
It encourages teamwork, perseverance, self improvement.

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 17:15

Private school children are definitely better musicians and better at sports. Why is this?

Private schools, of course, have better facilities than state schools. But, it’s more than that. Many private school parents are not rich; they have made big sacrifices and have worked hard to give their children the best start. This attitude of hard work and commitment to excel sets an example for their children who then apply themselves not only to academics, but also to sports and music. They are dedicated in their practice and regularly surpass grade 4 on the flute, oboe and cello by age 13!

Most parents of state school kids could also help their kids be good at music and sport (but not quite as good as private school kids, obviously). But they simply can’t be bothered to put in the effort themselves. Instead they prefer to spend their money on large TVs, Netflix and cars. They do things like take their kids out of school for holidays and let them lounge around listening to tripe like grime and drill on a Saturday morning when they could be practising the violin or cornet, or training at a local rowing club.

In sum, it’s less about financial resources, and more to do with the superior moral fibre of not only privately educated kids, but also their parents.

woodhill · 30/06/2023 17:04

@Goldenbear

That the people can pay the school fees and they can't

mindutopia · 30/06/2023 16:27

Dh and I both went to quite posh boarding schools and while we are outdoorsy, simply because we both grew up in rural, outdoorsy areas, we must be outliers because neither of us has a smidgen of sporting or musical talent. 😂

EnergyJaguar · 30/06/2023 16:24

I stand corrected must have been kids at private school then 😂 either way I have a solution don’t call your kids silly fuckers

ElizabethBennetismybestfriend · 30/06/2023 16:23

Depends on school priorities. Dd state secondary 70% of Y7 play a musical instrument. Music is amazing there. It is better regarded in the local area than the nearby private schools for music.

LolaSmiles · 30/06/2023 16:19

Inequality runs far deeper than education in the UK. What about the better diets, living in areas with low crime rates, more spacious and separate bedrooms, tuition, selective state education, caring and encouraging parents etc which more privileged, but state educated, children enjoy? Surely any parent who tries to do their best and give their children the best start with whatever resources they have are “perpetuating inequality”. There are plenty of state schools rammed full of children from privileged backgrounds, often more privileged than some pupils in the private sector
Agree with all of this.

There are some state schools near me that I'd have to spend an extra £50,000-100,000 to buy my house in their catchment area. Many of them seem to have large disposable incomes too.

Based on Mumsnet logic the children whose parents can afford those houses and be educated in excellent state schools are salt of the earth children who know the real world, but families living up the road in houses that cost more than £100,000 less up the road and chose private because it was better than the struggling state option would apparently be super privileged, mega wealthy, don't know what reality is like.

Obviously the fact those families have a choice means they're more fortunate than many, but the idea that the state school students living in expensive areas, with wealthy parents are more in tune with the 'real world' as some Mumsnetters like to suggest is laughable.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 16:14

Andrew101 · 30/06/2023 16:11

I've watched a lot of club rugby. My son's team are all from local State Schools and every year they play against two teams who recruit most of their players from Private Schools. Up to the age of about 12 we would win most of these matches - our players, on average were taller, stronger and faster. Some of the opposition were quite weedy by comparison and not that brave.
However, the tables have turned and those teams are now winning and playing some great rugby. I guess they play more at school and have great coaches. We still have some of the best individuals with the most potential, but the other teams play the better rugby.

They will play more at school plus have loads of inter school competitions, probably two a week for part of the term, so have a lot more game experience.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 16:14

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 16:08

But of a nihilistic perspective on inequalities, I mean yes, of course it runs deeper than education but it is a good place to start🙄

By suggesting that that are plenty of schools rammed with privileged children that are more privileged than private schools you really are stretching the credulity to its limits with that remark and you are suggesting that exact thing you say you are not which is that state schools can be separate but equal if they contain 'middle class' folk which is just disingenuous.

Andrew101 · 30/06/2023 16:11

I've watched a lot of club rugby. My son's team are all from local State Schools and every year they play against two teams who recruit most of their players from Private Schools. Up to the age of about 12 we would win most of these matches - our players, on average were taller, stronger and faster. Some of the opposition were quite weedy by comparison and not that brave.
However, the tables have turned and those teams are now winning and playing some great rugby. I guess they play more at school and have great coaches. We still have some of the best individuals with the most potential, but the other teams play the better rugby.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 16:08

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 14:44

I haven’t seen any posters saying that private and state schools are equal. There are plenty of posts saying the opposite - that privately educated children are often more sporty and musical purely because of the additional opportunities. Is it fair? No of course it isn’t, but no one is pretending it is. No one is saying that some children “deserve” a lower standard of education.

Inequality runs far deeper than education in the UK. What about the better diets, living in areas with low crime rates, more spacious and separate bedrooms, tuition, selective state education, caring and encouraging parents etc which more privileged, but state educated, children enjoy? Surely any parent who tries to do their best and give their children the best start with whatever resources they have are “perpetuating inequality”. There are plenty of state schools rammed full of children from privileged backgrounds, often more privileged than some pupils in the private sector.

I don’t understand why these posts always turn into an attack on private school parents.

But of a nihilistic perspective on inequalities, I mean yes, of course it runs deeper than education but it is a good place to start🙄

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 16:03

woodhill · 30/06/2023 14:46

Politics of envy and my Dc didn't go to private school

Plus it frees up places for those who go to state schools

Don't think so, some us have different politics and different principles. I went to private school until I was 12, what do you think people are envious of exactly?

mewkins · 30/06/2023 15:33

EnergyJaguar · 30/06/2023 14:54

Today I saw a family who had obviously taken their kids out of school for an early summer British holiday. The ‘dad’ said to one of the kids who was probably about 10 come over here you silly fucker and help me build this sandcastle.

there is no hope!

so tbh if you’re engaged and not swearing at your kids. They’ll be fine,

If they're from England and already on holiday they could be private school kids anyway 😆

BandyLionAndDurdock · 30/06/2023 15:31

Private have;

Longer days so fit extra curricular activities into school day.
Have access to specialist senior teachers for the younger ones so they get lots of exposure to music and sports.
Have the equipment and space - e.g. younger ones go to lessons in the senior music rooms etc.
Engage in lots of competitions, match days, concerts etc. and have the specialist staff to do this.

Anyotherdude · 30/06/2023 15:23

I think it’s down to what you want and can afford for your DC. The people who send their DC to private schools are also paying for the state schools. Therefore it would follow that as a parent of a state-educated child, and therefore not paying large fees for school, you would, if you had the resources for a more narrow experience than the private schools, but wider than the opportunities offered in state schools, try to give them every opportunity to try out new sports, music Etc. yourself.

Once you have pinpointed what they are good at, you encourage and pay for that tuition, or support them in their sports activities. Plenty of parents of state-educated DC that I know dedicate a lot of time taking them to dance, swimming or athletics clubs, and a lot of the children do very well. The difference is that one set of parents chucks money willy-nilly at their DC’s education, while another set support them in pursuit of any talent that they’ve shown an aptitude for, without spending out on all the other “stuff” that may or may not be useful later on.

Of course there will always be families who use state schools but can’t provide extra-curricular activities, so there are an awful lot of free activities for underprivileged that can be accessed - if the parents have the time, capacity and inclination to seek it out. If they simply can’t, and their DC has a genuine talent, they will find a way later in life.

Purplebunnie · 30/06/2023 15:19

FlyingPandas · 29/06/2023 11:48

It's in large part due to the fact that most will have stringently academic entrance exams and will also actively recruit children who can offer sport/music talents as well. Add to that the fact that private schools can pay for excellent facilities, buy in expert tutors for a whole range of sports and musical abilities and allocate plenty of timetabled time for practice, and then add the fact that the parents sending DC to these schools will have a vested interest in ensuring the DC develop these talents due to paying high fees, and it's hardly surprising they are able to turn out impressive children.

A private school can also simply ask a DC to leave if they fail to continue to meet the standards required - a state school cannot do that.

Not ALL private school DC follow this pattern though - should add that I have a DC who is very happy at a highly regarded SW London indie and he is neither musical nor sporty!

The private school my DC went to did not have entrance exams - academic or otherwise. No child was asked to leave if they didn't meet standards - I worked there and it just didn't happen.

TeenLifeMum · 30/06/2023 15:03

I’m shocked by how few students at dcs’ school play an instrument. The orchestra is very small. I was at a state school and the orchestra was always big.

MrsAvocet · 30/06/2023 14:59

Today I saw a family who had obviously taken their kids out of school for an early summer British holiday
Notthe point of your post I know, but you do realise that school holidays have already started in some parts of the UK? Not every family you see out and about at present have taken their children out of school early firca cheap holiday.

EnergyJaguar · 30/06/2023 14:54

Today I saw a family who had obviously taken their kids out of school for an early summer British holiday. The ‘dad’ said to one of the kids who was probably about 10 come over here you silly fucker and help me build this sandcastle.

there is no hope!

so tbh if you’re engaged and not swearing at your kids. They’ll be fine,

woodhill · 30/06/2023 14:46

Politics of envy and my Dc didn't go to private school

Plus it frees up places for those who go to state schools

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 14:44

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 14:21

I haven't even referenced 'inner city kids', I've simply suggested that when you go to school you are influenced by your environment and it shapes who you are, the relative affluence or poverty around you determines both your life experiences and your outcomes- those are not the same in a private and state school setting. The idea being spouted by some on here is that private schools are offering a separate education but it is equal but that just isn't true, even if you are middleclass. It stretches credulity that parents that send their children to private school don't see some greater value in the experience than sending them to the local middle class school that is bursting at the seams with privilege beyond that ever seen by the 7% of children that go to private school.

Where have I changed my story? Where have I denied words that I have written? I have reread my posts and can't see where that has happened?

There are some posters on here that really seem to equate the child's deservingness for decent amenities and opportunities at school, access to music lessons with their parents' efforts to bring this about. So essentially, some children deserve a lower standard of education because their parents don't have money for fees. I think that is pretty awful tbh and how you can argue that perpetuating inequalities is a good thing is beyond me

I haven’t seen any posters saying that private and state schools are equal. There are plenty of posts saying the opposite - that privately educated children are often more sporty and musical purely because of the additional opportunities. Is it fair? No of course it isn’t, but no one is pretending it is. No one is saying that some children “deserve” a lower standard of education.

Inequality runs far deeper than education in the UK. What about the better diets, living in areas with low crime rates, more spacious and separate bedrooms, tuition, selective state education, caring and encouraging parents etc which more privileged, but state educated, children enjoy? Surely any parent who tries to do their best and give their children the best start with whatever resources they have are “perpetuating inequality”. There are plenty of state schools rammed full of children from privileged backgrounds, often more privileged than some pupils in the private sector.

I don’t understand why these posts always turn into an attack on private school parents.

woodhill · 30/06/2023 14:27

Often the parents may be good at these things and had a similar background

There will be a piano in the house for example

grass321 · 30/06/2023 14:24

Parental support also plays a big part, particularly for the more technical sports like cricket. That may also perpetuate private school privilege down the generations to some extent.

My husband has spent hours coaching our children at rugby and cricket (and helped to run club rugby and football teams so not just for selfish reasons). If you're trying to play fly half, for example, it's a definite advantage having a parent who can give you one-on-one kicking sessions. That possibly favours the kids with private school parents, or at least those with keen, sporty parents.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 14:21

twistyizzy · 30/06/2023 11:42

You know nothing about me or my children yet you make blind, sweeping statements based on extreme prejudice and blasé stereotypes.
Your posts reek of inverse snobbery and you seem to think that every state school contains knives and has extreme deprivation and that only kids from these types of schools can truly be creative. You realise that you are peddling stereotypes of state schools when the majority of them are nothing like this? Or are you saying that only inner city kids who experience extreme deprivation can be useful in the creative sphere?
Honestly, read some of your own posts back.

This is why I called troll, because you seem to live in a very black or white world which the majority of people don't live in. You seem unable to accept anything between either extreme privilege or abject poverty. You constantly change your story, deny words that you have written and twist the words of other posters.

I haven't even referenced 'inner city kids', I've simply suggested that when you go to school you are influenced by your environment and it shapes who you are, the relative affluence or poverty around you determines both your life experiences and your outcomes- those are not the same in a private and state school setting. The idea being spouted by some on here is that private schools are offering a separate education but it is equal but that just isn't true, even if you are middleclass. It stretches credulity that parents that send their children to private school don't see some greater value in the experience than sending them to the local middle class school that is bursting at the seams with privilege beyond that ever seen by the 7% of children that go to private school.

Where have I changed my story? Where have I denied words that I have written? I have reread my posts and can't see where that has happened?

There are some posters on here that really seem to equate the child's deservingness for decent amenities and opportunities at school, access to music lessons with their parents' efforts to bring this about. So essentially, some children deserve a lower standard of education because their parents don't have money for fees. I think that is pretty awful tbh and how you can argue that perpetuating inequalities is a good thing is beyond me

Swipe left for the next trending thread