Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:35

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:33

But they literally aren't better musicians as evidenced by non high brow music i.e the stuff the majority of people listen to!

Private schools actively discourage self - expression, it is all about self control and being controlled which is probably why they are more likely to excel at classical music where that technical skill is needed.

This is just utter bollocks

@Goldenbear I get that you don't like private schools and feel that they perpetuate inequality and I have some sympathy with that view. But your frankly bizarre insistence that the only music deserving of respect is rap and grime is just...silly.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:33

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 21:17

in sport, they are certainly better at Eton fives, much better at lawn tennis and very much better at polo. in fact when you're a state school kid and busy clapping the half-coconuts together because you don't have a horse, it is a bit hard to hit the ball at the same time.
It is not just sports and music but also languages. Because you might actually be taught more than one. And classics. Again, because you might be taught some.
For music, private school kids are much better at singing the school song. Firstly because it is likely to be in Latin (see classics above) and secondly because your school might have one. State school kids just have to hum.
Seriously, what do people expect? That pouring expert tuition and resources into specific areas, perhaps from as early as the age of 4, would have no effect?

But they literally aren't better musicians as evidenced by non high brow music i.e the stuff the majority of people listen to!

Private schools actively discourage self - expression, it is all about self control and being controlled which is probably why they are more likely to excel at classical music where that technical skill is needed.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:29

Yes they do, precisely because they want to avoid our childhood. However, I think this is overcompensating and actually a huge waste of money as my DS is likely to achieve higher grades in GCSES and we have spent 0 on fees. My DH tells me in Architecture at least they are not interested in the school you go to, he is a director and wants to know you actually have talent in design.

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 21:28

"the superior moral fibre of not only privately educated kids, but also their parents"

Fuck me. Now I've seen it all. I've been in and out of a fair few private schools in the last few years, and have yet to see anything resembling superior moral fibre. I have seen a lot of dough, a fair few fancy cars, and a lot of insufferably smug people looking down their noses at others.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:19

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:05

And like I said, that is a very nihilistic way of viewing the issue, shall we just not bother then. I mean fundamentally, education and lack of it is so intrinsically linked to poverty. We are worryingly ok with this inequality. My state second in the 90s had loads of opportunities for me as a cellist and pianist, equally playing fields for sports. My parents were the Beat generation and active young socialists, they protested and strived for education for all, it is thoroughly depressing how we just accept that education promotes inequalities and the above is only for the rich. Not exactly progress.

And yet your siblings choose to privately educate.

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 21:17

in sport, they are certainly better at Eton fives, much better at lawn tennis and very much better at polo. in fact when you're a state school kid and busy clapping the half-coconuts together because you don't have a horse, it is a bit hard to hit the ball at the same time.
It is not just sports and music but also languages. Because you might actually be taught more than one. And classics. Again, because you might be taught some.
For music, private school kids are much better at singing the school song. Firstly because it is likely to be in Latin (see classics above) and secondly because your school might have one. State school kids just have to hum.
Seriously, what do people expect? That pouring expert tuition and resources into specific areas, perhaps from as early as the age of 4, would have no effect?

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:05

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 20:58

Even if you live in an expensive area there is social housing and flat that are rented out to a family of 4 for 2 bedrooms. DH designs housing in the most expensive parts of London and the proportion has to be social housing. Outside of London that situation is probably more favourable. If you are referencing primary school, yes, catchments are small but secondary is not the same. I live in a leafy area and my DC go to an oversubscribed state secondary comprehensive, there are many people that are not affluent and they intake is far and wide.

And like I said, that is a very nihilistic way of viewing the issue, shall we just not bother then. I mean fundamentally, education and lack of it is so intrinsically linked to poverty. We are worryingly ok with this inequality. My state second in the 90s had loads of opportunities for me as a cellist and pianist, equally playing fields for sports. My parents were the Beat generation and active young socialists, they protested and strived for education for all, it is thoroughly depressing how we just accept that education promotes inequalities and the above is only for the rich. Not exactly progress.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 20:58

LolaSmiles · 30/06/2023 16:19

Inequality runs far deeper than education in the UK. What about the better diets, living in areas with low crime rates, more spacious and separate bedrooms, tuition, selective state education, caring and encouraging parents etc which more privileged, but state educated, children enjoy? Surely any parent who tries to do their best and give their children the best start with whatever resources they have are “perpetuating inequality”. There are plenty of state schools rammed full of children from privileged backgrounds, often more privileged than some pupils in the private sector
Agree with all of this.

There are some state schools near me that I'd have to spend an extra £50,000-100,000 to buy my house in their catchment area. Many of them seem to have large disposable incomes too.

Based on Mumsnet logic the children whose parents can afford those houses and be educated in excellent state schools are salt of the earth children who know the real world, but families living up the road in houses that cost more than £100,000 less up the road and chose private because it was better than the struggling state option would apparently be super privileged, mega wealthy, don't know what reality is like.

Obviously the fact those families have a choice means they're more fortunate than many, but the idea that the state school students living in expensive areas, with wealthy parents are more in tune with the 'real world' as some Mumsnetters like to suggest is laughable.

Even if you live in an expensive area there is social housing and flat that are rented out to a family of 4 for 2 bedrooms. DH designs housing in the most expensive parts of London and the proportion has to be social housing. Outside of London that situation is probably more favourable. If you are referencing primary school, yes, catchments are small but secondary is not the same. I live in a leafy area and my DC go to an oversubscribed state secondary comprehensive, there are many people that are not affluent and they intake is far and wide.

Malbecfan · 30/06/2023 20:52

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 17:15

Private school children are definitely better musicians and better at sports. Why is this?

Private schools, of course, have better facilities than state schools. But, it’s more than that. Many private school parents are not rich; they have made big sacrifices and have worked hard to give their children the best start. This attitude of hard work and commitment to excel sets an example for their children who then apply themselves not only to academics, but also to sports and music. They are dedicated in their practice and regularly surpass grade 4 on the flute, oboe and cello by age 13!

Most parents of state school kids could also help their kids be good at music and sport (but not quite as good as private school kids, obviously). But they simply can’t be bothered to put in the effort themselves. Instead they prefer to spend their money on large TVs, Netflix and cars. They do things like take their kids out of school for holidays and let them lounge around listening to tripe like grime and drill on a Saturday morning when they could be practising the violin or cornet, or training at a local rowing club.

In sum, it’s less about financial resources, and more to do with the superior moral fibre of not only privately educated kids, but also their parents.

What a strange response.

Firstly, every year we have a number of students starting at my state school who perform way above grade 4 on an instrument. Both my DDs did; in DD1's class at least 20% of the class did. We regularly get post grade 8 students start year 7.

I, my colleagues and parents of my students would not concur with your assertion that our offspring are "..not quite as good as private school kids.." No, they are significantly better, and demonstrate humility, a trait that some posters seem not to recognise. You carry on with your twaddle about superior moral fibre. I will thank my lucky stars that I don't have to interact with such a supercilious being in person on a regular basis.

MrsAvocet · 30/06/2023 18:48

I just don't see it as a private school vs state school issue but more of a money issue.
I think so too. Private school attendance is probably a proxy for affluence most of the time and it's correlation not causation.
That said, DS has been to courses at some private schools with spectacular facilities, better than any he has experienced at private clubs. And if they have multiple sports facilities it must make cross training easier. My DS currently has to go to one place for his actual sports coaching and somewhere completely different for gym work. We spend a lot of time on the road. I could imagine that if he could do all that at school and utilise what is now "dead" time for either more training or doing homework instead he would make more progress generally.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 18:38

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:21

I just remembered that one of my daughter's classmates is an actual junior star skiier, competes internationally. He's barely at school because he's training all year round (abroad for obvious reasons). So him being a star athlete has very little to do with the private school he (on paper) attends and all to do with his parents having the money to pay for his elite training.

Well, skiing isn't known for its economic diversity, in this country at least. Show jumping is more diverse! (Not eventing however)

Terryer · 30/06/2023 18:37

Riapia · 30/06/2023 18:36

Also better behaved and better mannered. Superior all round.
Probably due to spending time away from their feckless parents.
😉😁😁😁😁

Childish and unpleasant.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 18:36

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:25

Yes that's true. It's much more convenient if it's all done at school. But it's not necessarily better quality training than if done outside of school

Yes it's still the same training.

Riapia · 30/06/2023 18:36

Also better behaved and better mannered. Superior all round.
Probably due to spending time away from their feckless parents.
😉😁😁😁😁

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:25

Terryer · 30/06/2023 18:18

If you work full time long hours it's quite attractive to have good quality sports provisional taken care of in school hours or, as mine have been, driven to pathway training and overseen by the sports teacher before being returned to school.

Yes that's true. It's much more convenient if it's all done at school. But it's not necessarily better quality training than if done outside of school

Andrew101 · 30/06/2023 18:22

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 18:17

It was intended as a pastiche of what is often implied on such MS threads by private school parents. Perhaps I was too subtle.

More fool me 😂😂

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:21

I just remembered that one of my daughter's classmates is an actual junior star skiier, competes internationally. He's barely at school because he's training all year round (abroad for obvious reasons). So him being a star athlete has very little to do with the private school he (on paper) attends and all to do with his parents having the money to pay for his elite training.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 18:18

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:15

Fair enough. I just don't see it as a private school vs state school issue but more of a money issue. Parents who have money to throw at their kids sports/music extra-curricular activities can do so regardless of where that child attends school and being privately educated has no bearing on how much you can achieve in either sports or music.

If you work full time long hours it's quite attractive to have good quality sports provisional taken care of in school hours or, as mine have been, driven to pathway training and overseen by the sports teacher before being returned to school.

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 18:17

Andrew101 · 30/06/2023 17:54

Arrogance and rudeness - is that part of your superior moral fibre? Music no, but I'd bet every inch my children are as sporty and academic as yours. And the schooling is free, so more fool you.
Only 32" thank you.

It was intended as a pastiche of what is often implied on such MS threads by private school parents. Perhaps I was too subtle.

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:15

Terryer · 30/06/2023 18:05

Any private school I've been involved with will encourage their talented pupils to try out for county or regional pathways. Depends on the quality of the club or pathway though.

Fair enough. I just don't see it as a private school vs state school issue but more of a money issue. Parents who have money to throw at their kids sports/music extra-curricular activities can do so regardless of where that child attends school and being privately educated has no bearing on how much you can achieve in either sports or music.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 18:05

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:02

Regarding sport - aside from a few schools with elite swimming programs, are the private school sports provisions really better than dedicated sports clubs? Private schools have the facilities for kids to try out many different sports, but to train to a high level you would still be better off doing that outside of school

Any private school I've been involved with will encourage their talented pupils to try out for county or regional pathways. Depends on the quality of the club or pathway though.

XelaM · 30/06/2023 18:02

Regarding sport - aside from a few schools with elite swimming programs, are the private school sports provisions really better than dedicated sports clubs? Private schools have the facilities for kids to try out many different sports, but to train to a high level you would still be better off doing that outside of school

Andrew101 · 30/06/2023 17:54

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 17:15

Private school children are definitely better musicians and better at sports. Why is this?

Private schools, of course, have better facilities than state schools. But, it’s more than that. Many private school parents are not rich; they have made big sacrifices and have worked hard to give their children the best start. This attitude of hard work and commitment to excel sets an example for their children who then apply themselves not only to academics, but also to sports and music. They are dedicated in their practice and regularly surpass grade 4 on the flute, oboe and cello by age 13!

Most parents of state school kids could also help their kids be good at music and sport (but not quite as good as private school kids, obviously). But they simply can’t be bothered to put in the effort themselves. Instead they prefer to spend their money on large TVs, Netflix and cars. They do things like take their kids out of school for holidays and let them lounge around listening to tripe like grime and drill on a Saturday morning when they could be practising the violin or cornet, or training at a local rowing club.

In sum, it’s less about financial resources, and more to do with the superior moral fibre of not only privately educated kids, but also their parents.

Arrogance and rudeness - is that part of your superior moral fibre? Music no, but I'd bet every inch my children are as sporty and academic as yours. And the schooling is free, so more fool you.
Only 32" thank you.

IWFH · 30/06/2023 17:50

In sum, it’s less about financial resources, and more to do with the superior moral fibre of not only privately educated kids, but also their parents.
You are clearly a true paragon of wisdom. I bow down to your superior moral fibre. 🤣

mewkins · 30/06/2023 17:46

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 17:15

Private school children are definitely better musicians and better at sports. Why is this?

Private schools, of course, have better facilities than state schools. But, it’s more than that. Many private school parents are not rich; they have made big sacrifices and have worked hard to give their children the best start. This attitude of hard work and commitment to excel sets an example for their children who then apply themselves not only to academics, but also to sports and music. They are dedicated in their practice and regularly surpass grade 4 on the flute, oboe and cello by age 13!

Most parents of state school kids could also help their kids be good at music and sport (but not quite as good as private school kids, obviously). But they simply can’t be bothered to put in the effort themselves. Instead they prefer to spend their money on large TVs, Netflix and cars. They do things like take their kids out of school for holidays and let them lounge around listening to tripe like grime and drill on a Saturday morning when they could be practising the violin or cornet, or training at a local rowing club.

In sum, it’s less about financial resources, and more to do with the superior moral fibre of not only privately educated kids, but also their parents.

😄

Swipe left for the next trending thread