Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Raspberrysins · 01/07/2023 00:11

I’m a teacher at a private school (state for many years before that). I can say that yes, on average the students are more musical and sporty. For example it blows me away that boys sing in choirs, that would never have happened at my old school. A lot is down to the school day being much longer. We finish at 4 and lunch is 1h 10. Meaning lots of music and sports take place at that time. It’s also quite a ‘middle class’ thing to learn instruments I think. Obvs there are costs involved with it too. Students there tend to be more competitive too

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 23:41

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 22:42

Probs because they don’t really know anything about music but are impressed by someone saying their kid got grade x on some instrument they’ll probably never pick up again once they leave school.

I’ve made a few records myself. Some were rather critically acclaimed and sold well. I have no grades, can’t “play” in the conventional sense, and did not go to private school.

Yes, the evident lack of knowledge of musical genres confirms that private schools really can't be 'better' at music.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 23:32

StellaJohanna · 30/06/2023 22:28

It's a business. People send their kids to private schools and pay a lot of money because they want their children to have the advantage over other children socially as well as academically. For example, people who can play several musical instruments are more interesting people than those who can't. They are also more disciplined. Private schools teach children to lead and state schools teach children to follow orders. It is qualitatively different.

What bollocks you talk and actually your private school advantage is going to bite you in the arse in many jobs now as unfortunately for you, the plebs have been allowed to take up positions where they are recruiting these kids. "Does this person in front of me actually have any talent?" I am sorry but you cannot teach Charisma however many notes you dish out for an education. Does the person have any 'original thoughts' whose creativity will give us a competitive advantage. Oh no they don't as they all think the same, act the same and have no idea of the diversity of the general public.

NameChangeThreeThousand · 30/06/2023 23:16

StellaJohanna · 30/06/2023 22:28

It's a business. People send their kids to private schools and pay a lot of money because they want their children to have the advantage over other children socially as well as academically. For example, people who can play several musical instruments are more interesting people than those who can't. They are also more disciplined. Private schools teach children to lead and state schools teach children to follow orders. It is qualitatively different.

people who can play several musical instruments are more interesting people than those who can't. They are also more disciplined

I don't really agree. Some of the most interesting people I know left the local comp at 14 having never laid a finger on an instrument. That's not to say I don't also know some interesting and lovely people who play instruments! But playing a instrument does not make you more interesting than people that don't play. One of the most interesting people I've ever met had no education, never even touched an instrument, spent time in prison and the only time he'd been near a private school was to spray it with graffiti in his teens!

More disciplined? Again, playing an instrument as a kid might help with discipline (all that practice you have to do!) But kids and adults who don't play instruments are not necessarily less disciplined than those that do (did). Both my DC are tone deaf, yet are still v disciplined! They learnt discipline through sport, through study, through being parented.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 23:15

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 22:00

My parents were the Beat generation and active young socialists, they protested and strived for education for all

You’ve stated more than once that you attended private school yourself at some point in your life. So, your parents were active socialists who strived for education for all whilst sending their own child to a private school.

My Mum had to work full time when I was two years old, the private school let me sit in the classroom whilst she taught and then I went to the nursery so it was very very cheap. My Dad hated the idea, hence me leaving at 12!

Terryer · 30/06/2023 22:52

Probs because they don’t really know anything about music but are impressed by someone saying their kid got grade x on some instrument they’ll probably never pick up again once they leave school

I spent the day with private school parents today - end of term. Some of them were brayingly loud and a bit annoying, but I can honestly say none were as up themselves as some posters on this thread 😅

Xenia · 30/06/2023 22:47

Live and let live. I actively chose to pay school fees from 5 - 18 (and university fees) as did my parents - our choice. Other people don't. I am not very sporty but we are quite a musical family and some of the children are keen on sports. It is complicated in the SE as there are also some fairly good state schools too but even in those you tend to find the private schools are better at things like music. It was hammered home to me when my sons' prep school with 3 local state schools teamed up for music outside at some Christmas lights turn on locally. There was a vast difference between the choirs which seemed a bit strange to me as the voice is free of charge and if you are good at it usually just means you have worked very hard on it rather than needing money but it may just be the teachers work shorter hours in state schools

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 22:42

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:43

Please quote me where I have referenced rap and grime. I don't have any snobby perceptions of them like you but I equally have not even used those words. I listed Hip hop, drum and bass, indie and rock not one mention of grime or rap. You are under the impression that these are all the same things, I wonder why that is?

Probs because they don’t really know anything about music but are impressed by someone saying their kid got grade x on some instrument they’ll probably never pick up again once they leave school.

I’ve made a few records myself. Some were rather critically acclaimed and sold well. I have no grades, can’t “play” in the conventional sense, and did not go to private school.

StellaJohanna · 30/06/2023 22:28

It's a business. People send their kids to private schools and pay a lot of money because they want their children to have the advantage over other children socially as well as academically. For example, people who can play several musical instruments are more interesting people than those who can't. They are also more disciplined. Private schools teach children to lead and state schools teach children to follow orders. It is qualitatively different.

NameChangeThreeThousand · 30/06/2023 22:22

I agree. I started a similar post on this last year

My DS swim club has lots of kids from private school. They all swim in school team and get several hours coaching at school, on top of the local club. Meanwhile the state kids just get the club sessions. So guess who ends up winning all the medals and reaching the top positions in the sport??? Not to mention that our club offers private 1:1 sessions which the kids who go to private school can all afford. So they get 1:1 sessions and several hours extra coaching at school. Seems v unfair. But I don't know what the answer is!! If you have the money, you want the benefits.

The only way to make it fairer would be for state schools to boost their extracurricular provisions. They don't because sport and music are not prioritised and they have no targets to meet. Change needs to come from government level so sport and music provision in school is valued and prioritised. League tables around sport and music, not just grades A to C in maths and English GCSE.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 22:18

Ginandtonic1234 · 30/06/2023 22:16

But state school children can find passions and interests to breed confidence without having to excel and compete. My children go to state schools. One loves musical theatre and the other loves karate. They aren’t the best or competing at a high level but they enjoy themselves and are happy.

Then that's great.

Ginandtonic1234 · 30/06/2023 22:16

Terryer · 30/06/2023 22:13

Excelling at something other than academics breeds confidence. I can't quite believe I'm having to tell adults that.

But state school children can find passions and interests to breed confidence without having to excel and compete. My children go to state schools. One loves musical theatre and the other loves karate. They aren’t the best or competing at a high level but they enjoy themselves and are happy.

Barbadossunset · 30/06/2023 22:14

Malbecfan & EctopicSpleen, Godessofthunder was being sarcastic.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 22:13

Ginandtonic1234 · 30/06/2023 22:11

Why does it matter if they excel at sports and music? Does it mean they will have a more fulfilling life or does it just enable the parents to show off their children’s achievements to their friends? Why put all the pressure on children to have to play multiple instruments and compete at a higher level? I want my children to be happy and healthy, to discover their own passions and follow their own path. The OP sounds like she just wants to keep up with the Jones’.

Excelling at something other than academics breeds confidence. I can't quite believe I'm having to tell adults that.

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 22:13

Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:56

I was originally talking about composers of classical music, not playing other people's work, but I also think being able to play someone elses classical music is worth respect. You don't, that's fine are you 12

Not sure why “are you 12”?

Terryer · 30/06/2023 22:12

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 22:08

I respect it, yes. But I respect innovation more.

Well, there's lots of very innovative modern classical music if you ever find yourself looking for something new to listen to.

Ginandtonic1234 · 30/06/2023 22:11

Why does it matter if they excel at sports and music? Does it mean they will have a more fulfilling life or does it just enable the parents to show off their children’s achievements to their friends? Why put all the pressure on children to have to play multiple instruments and compete at a higher level? I want my children to be happy and healthy, to discover their own passions and follow their own path. The OP sounds like she just wants to keep up with the Jones’.

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 22:08

Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:56

I was originally talking about composers of classical music, not playing other people's work, but I also think being able to play someone elses classical music is worth respect. You don't, that's fine are you 12

I respect it, yes. But I respect innovation more.

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 22:02

"it's not the private school - it's the funding and the ability of parents to pay for an instrument."

This. In spades. The ability and willingness to pay does correlate with school type, even if the musical aptitude doesnt.
I will also say that the most impressive school music concert I've seen was in a state school (with a music specialism, and several NYO members in the orchestra). The rather snooty local private schools were not a patch on it.

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 22:00

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:05

And like I said, that is a very nihilistic way of viewing the issue, shall we just not bother then. I mean fundamentally, education and lack of it is so intrinsically linked to poverty. We are worryingly ok with this inequality. My state second in the 90s had loads of opportunities for me as a cellist and pianist, equally playing fields for sports. My parents were the Beat generation and active young socialists, they protested and strived for education for all, it is thoroughly depressing how we just accept that education promotes inequalities and the above is only for the rich. Not exactly progress.

My parents were the Beat generation and active young socialists, they protested and strived for education for all

You’ve stated more than once that you attended private school yourself at some point in your life. So, your parents were active socialists who strived for education for all whilst sending their own child to a private school.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:56

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 21:51

It’s true though. Giving a recital of a piece of classical music someone else has written, at a given level of competence, is what private school kids are often better at. But that’s not creativity as such. It’s just a tired conformist convention of what it meant to be “accomplished”.

Metal, dubstep, industrial, large chunks of punk, post-punk and indie, grime, hardcore, jungle, d n b: all genres that have become globally popular and for the most part invented by mostly state school kids, often with no musical grades.

I was originally talking about composers of classical music, not playing other people's work, but I also think being able to play someone elses classical music is worth respect. You don't, that's fine are you 12

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 21:51

Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:35

This is just utter bollocks

@Goldenbear I get that you don't like private schools and feel that they perpetuate inequality and I have some sympathy with that view. But your frankly bizarre insistence that the only music deserving of respect is rap and grime is just...silly.

It’s true though. Giving a recital of a piece of classical music someone else has written, at a given level of competence, is what private school kids are often better at. But that’s not creativity as such. It’s just a tired conformist convention of what it meant to be “accomplished”.

Metal, dubstep, industrial, large chunks of punk, post-punk and indie, grime, hardcore, jungle, d n b: all genres that have become globally popular and for the most part invented by mostly state school kids, often with no musical grades.

ChristmasFluff · 30/06/2023 21:44

Load of shite. Went to a 1970s comprehensive - actually, was its first year comp - was a secondary modern before that.

But we had music lessons - I have clarinet and descant recorder to grade 6, can do all the other recorders to grade 3. Credit where it's due, for all my mum's faults, she bought me a clarinet on the never-never when the school said I had an aptitude.

That's probs part of the problem. My dad was hugely musical, never had the chance to pursue itm but could pursue it through me. Not sure other families on the breadline would prioritise a clarinet.

So yeah - it's not the private school - it's the funding and the ability of parents to pay for an instrument.

We also had Latinlessons. Will always remember surprising some bloke in Cambridge cos the oik could read Latin. I get the feeling we were some kind of experiment that was meant to fail but didn't, so had to be stopped by the national curriculum.

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 21:43

Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:35

This is just utter bollocks

@Goldenbear I get that you don't like private schools and feel that they perpetuate inequality and I have some sympathy with that view. But your frankly bizarre insistence that the only music deserving of respect is rap and grime is just...silly.

Don't forget beatbox. Recent research has shown they share this ability with other lower primates such as orangutans.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 21:43

Terryer · 30/06/2023 21:35

This is just utter bollocks

@Goldenbear I get that you don't like private schools and feel that they perpetuate inequality and I have some sympathy with that view. But your frankly bizarre insistence that the only music deserving of respect is rap and grime is just...silly.

Please quote me where I have referenced rap and grime. I don't have any snobby perceptions of them like you but I equally have not even used those words. I listed Hip hop, drum and bass, indie and rock not one mention of grime or rap. You are under the impression that these are all the same things, I wonder why that is?