Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Applesinmyhouse · 01/07/2023 09:36

My state secondary had a very good music, and come to think of it, drama department. There was a school band, and the music teachers held practices and encouraged pupils to stay after hours and they’d have jam sessions and the like. All instruments, from guitars to clarinets. The school was in a nice London suburb and a lot of the parents were wealthy. I’d imagine it’s to do with demographics.

Another76543 · 01/07/2023 09:32

42isthemeaning · 01/07/2023 09:14

Money makes everything easier and better. It is not a level playing field. I think private schools should be banned** says a PP

Imagine changing this to:

Money makes everything easier and better. It is not a level playing field. I think private healthcare should be banned.

Would you also agree with this?

Exactly. If we want a truly level playing field we would also need to ban any private tuition (including music and sport), giving money to children to buy houses, buying books for our children etc. We would also need to say that all children automatically go to their nearest school - no discrimination based on entrance exams or religion, and no parental choice over the school applied to. Some people are very quick to declare that things should be banned, just as long as it doesn’t affect them.

Hro01 · 01/07/2023 09:30

I went to a private school from age 9 to 18. I wasn’t particularly musical before I joined, but once I was there I had weekly instrumental lessons, weekly ensemble lessons, plus 2 choirs after school each week. My love of music was fostered and maintained throughout my time there, and I left the school as a music scholar. Got two degrees in music and became a music teacher (in a state school). I think private school teachers have more time to get to know you and to help you find your passion.

Sports are roughly the same timetable-wise as state schools.

Academically, we were held to a higher standard than state schools I think… entrance exams, very regular tests, resitting exams through the summer if we didn’t pass end of year exams etc

Others may disagree, but this was my experience.

42isthemeaning · 01/07/2023 09:14

Money makes everything easier and better. It is not a level playing field. I think private schools should be banned** says a PP

Imagine changing this to:

Money makes everything easier and better. It is not a level playing field. I think private healthcare should be banned.

Would you also agree with this?

EctopicSpleen · 01/07/2023 08:22

Bookonthebeach · 01/07/2023 05:48

I teach in a private school and have taught in a state school. The advantage of private schools is that they have specialist music and sport teachers who themselves play or perform at a very high level, so can really help develop those skills in their pupils. In a state school, it is often the case that the child's teacher will teach them for every subject from maths to languages to music. Nobody can be good at everything and so these teachers just have to muddle through and do the best they can. I found it very difficult when I don't play a sport or an instrument to teach the skills to others, particularly in classes of 30. Now I leave it to the professionals and stay in my academic lane! Small class sizes also certainly help hone in on developing each child's individual ability.

Looking from the other side, I have one child at a a private school. He swims like a fish. Is he just naturally good at it? Perhaps there was an aptitude, but the fact that there is a 25m pool on site where he gets 2hrs small group coaching a week and also regularly takes part in competitions against other schools sure as hell helps. In the (rural, isolated) comp I attended we never had a swimming lesson because the nearest pool was nearly 20 miles away. Most of my classmates couldn't swim. One drowned. Quite aside from sport and music lessons, some of them weren't getting enough to eat.
Recent figures have shown the UK slipping down the international rankings of children's heights because so many children are malnourished. It shouldn't surprise us that the 7% who can afford school fees, and can therefore all be assumed to be getting a enough to eat and a good quality diet, have enough energy to devote to sport and music that they are better on average at these activities than the other 93% which includes all of the 40% of children in this country who live in poverty.

Another76543 · 01/07/2023 08:00

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 23:15

My Mum had to work full time when I was two years old, the private school let me sit in the classroom whilst she taught and then I went to the nursery so it was very very cheap. My Dad hated the idea, hence me leaving at 12!

So your family were happy to be employed by a private school for 10 years, benefitting from other parents paying fees, and you benefitted from a private education for 10 years. The fact that the fees might have been “very very cheap” is entirely irrelevant - a lot of parents wouldn’t be in a position to afford that education. All these years later you are now lecturing others on choosing to benefit from the system which you and your family have benefitted from yourselves. So it was ok for your family to make those choices, but other families shouldn’t be doing the same because it’s unfair and goes against your family’s socialist principles?

Catlady1978 · 01/07/2023 07:59

Smaller class sizes for a start means children get more 1-1 time with teachers. The lack of budget constraints which maintained or academy schools have to tackle year in, year out. Private school children are given more opportunities to try different sports too or excel at traditional sports - rugby being a prime example. Teaching of this in state schools is patchy and at some points dangerous as there is lack of understanding around rules and safe practice.

roundcork · 01/07/2023 07:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

Libra24 · 01/07/2023 07:18

I think in part you answered your own question because you said the family values that are being shared already put an emphasis on sport and that is in and out of school.
But not only can they probably afford the private school but have been able to afford lots of additional enrichment up to this point in life and will continue to do so. Including music from a young age.

Entrance exams (which are often tutored for and tutoring continues once in the school) not only select the children but have an effect on who even tries to apply in terms of willingness to put their children through the rigors of high academic expectations. You may admire these children for the achievements now but did you want to/ afford to take your kids to music class / sports class / additional tutoring sessions for a few years to get to this point? My kids get upset about nursery... I can't imagine all this additional activity being part of our lives but some kids thrive in that way.

It's a shame there aren't more opportunities for state schools and funding is so poor but I feel there's enough pressure on kids to do well without it being my whole identity too. If my kids are kind and happy. Good people. That's my goal. Not saying these kids won't be of course, but they aren't better because they can play an instrument or run fast x

Leastsaidsoonestscrewed · 01/07/2023 07:16

DH went to a very good public school and is tone deaf...

wizzyderbyshire · 01/07/2023 07:05

Nephew, by marriage, went to a top private school - somewhere in the region of £40,000 a year, and music lessons were at additional cost. We had a bit of a snoop on the school website - the sporting facilities alone were way superior to anything the vast majority of state schools could offer.
The school days were long, there were some lessons on, some, Saturday mornings and there were opportunities for enrichment in the evening.

At that level, it is a different world. He’s at Cambridge now.

Reugny · 01/07/2023 07:04

ChristmasFluff · 30/06/2023 21:44

Load of shite. Went to a 1970s comprehensive - actually, was its first year comp - was a secondary modern before that.

But we had music lessons - I have clarinet and descant recorder to grade 6, can do all the other recorders to grade 3. Credit where it's due, for all my mum's faults, she bought me a clarinet on the never-never when the school said I had an aptitude.

That's probs part of the problem. My dad was hugely musical, never had the chance to pursue itm but could pursue it through me. Not sure other families on the breadline would prioritise a clarinet.

So yeah - it's not the private school - it's the funding and the ability of parents to pay for an instrument.

We also had Latinlessons. Will always remember surprising some bloke in Cambridge cos the oik could read Latin. I get the feeling we were some kind of experiment that was meant to fail but didn't, so had to be stopped by the national curriculum.

I did Latin and the comp school I went to still boasts of teaching it today.

In regards to music lessons - in state schools provision is patchy and in my LA you have to pay for your child to do have lessons during school hours regardless of whether primary or secondary.

There as we're my DD is going to school they give them some free lessons on certain instruments in primary to see if they have the aptitude. The school also has a choir.

Dorisbonson · 01/07/2023 06:37

Escapefromhell · 29/06/2023 11:51

Private school kids aren’t more sporty and better musicians. They have simply had all the opportunities.

This is just like saying that the GB Olympic team is better at dressage and sailing than Uganda’s.

What like parents who take their kids to swimming twice a week, tennis three times, football twice and rugby once? Parents make choices, some parents drive their kids everywhere for sport, do the laundry, buy the kit, some parents cook food from scratch and others don't.

Same parents make sure their kids do the homework set by school.

Unless you have absolutely zero spare cash there is nothing to stop anyone taking their kids to cheap sports clubs like Rugby and Football, plenty of free 2nd kit for both too. Cheap swimming may also be available through local authorities.

At the end of the day, you make choices and set examples. You can say it's cost, my son's prep school is cheap and teaching focused, it's sports facilities are awful, so we take him to other places to play sport.

WasJuliaRight · 01/07/2023 06:35

I dread to think how much my nephew’s education cost, he’s was never sporty, didn’t play any instruments, received mediocre GCSE grades and works as a gardener with one of his mates. He’s happy though.

readingrocks · 01/07/2023 06:35

redbigbananafeet · 29/06/2023 14:05
Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:55

@JoWawa is that something they should be looked at in state schools so more enrichment can be offered to close the gap?
And where does the money go fund that come from?

Well some money could come from lifting the charitable status that many independent schools have! They qualify for this if the school offers some public benefit but this is often a bit half-hearted in practice. Does your local independent school offer an hour's public swim a week? Does the local choir practice there an hour a week? That kind of thing...

Bookonthebeach · 01/07/2023 05:48

I teach in a private school and have taught in a state school. The advantage of private schools is that they have specialist music and sport teachers who themselves play or perform at a very high level, so can really help develop those skills in their pupils. In a state school, it is often the case that the child's teacher will teach them for every subject from maths to languages to music. Nobody can be good at everything and so these teachers just have to muddle through and do the best they can. I found it very difficult when I don't play a sport or an instrument to teach the skills to others, particularly in classes of 30. Now I leave it to the professionals and stay in my academic lane! Small class sizes also certainly help hone in on developing each child's individual ability.

grass321 · 01/07/2023 05:16

Why does it matter if they excel at sports and music? Does it mean they will have a more fulfilling life or does it just enable the parents to show off their children’s achievements to their friends? Why put all the pressure on children to have to play multiple instruments and compete at a higher level?

According to our head, there's a strong correlation between those pupils that invest a lot of time in sport and music, and academic grades. May not lead to a more fulfilling life, further to your point, but could do if those grades open new doors.

Honestly, part of me feels a bit resentful of the weekends we've given up ferrying our kids around the country to sports matches. And the cost of equipment and training schemes. It's not for our benefit, although I (mostly...) enjoy watching them play matches. My kids are sports scholars but it's not something I mention to my friends, nor any other sporting achievements.

We've made that commitment because sport is a passion for our children. It provides a break from their academic study, it's healthy and they enjoy the team element. As they get older, they have the opportunity to mentor younger players, as adults have done for them. Plus the discipline needed to play sport at a higher level. All their choice and if they've stopped enjoying a particular sport, we've been happy to support their decision to leave programmes.

Manthide · 01/07/2023 05:12

EctopicSpleen · 30/06/2023 21:17

in sport, they are certainly better at Eton fives, much better at lawn tennis and very much better at polo. in fact when you're a state school kid and busy clapping the half-coconuts together because you don't have a horse, it is a bit hard to hit the ball at the same time.
It is not just sports and music but also languages. Because you might actually be taught more than one. And classics. Again, because you might be taught some.
For music, private school kids are much better at singing the school song. Firstly because it is likely to be in Latin (see classics above) and secondly because your school might have one. State school kids just have to hum.
Seriously, what do people expect? That pouring expert tuition and resources into specific areas, perhaps from as early as the age of 4, would have no effect?

The school song bit made me laugh. Ds has an awful voice but loved the sound of it and really enjoyed having to sing the school song. There were also house singing competitions that were very competitive ( boys school).

Manthide · 01/07/2023 05:03

JoWawa · 29/06/2023 11:53

Private school days tend to be longer.

And my son's private school also had school on Saturday morning

weareallout · 01/07/2023 01:35

Oh ffs.
Money
Stare schools accommodate everyone one and operate on a shoestring. Lunchtimes are short ' after-school stuff has to be run by teachers for free. Private is miles off that

Georgeandzippyzoo · 01/07/2023 01:31

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:55

@JoWawa is that something they should be looked at in state schools so more enrichment can be offered to close the gap?

Won't make a difference because the funding for our state schools is abysmal (one reason for the current strikes). Most primary schools I know have a range of sports equipment bought using the sainsburys vouchers because its not in schools budgets to actually replace / buy new !

whodawhodaeho · 01/07/2023 00:38

‘For example it blows me away that boys sing in choirs, that would never have happened at my old school. ‘

sorry, but was your previous school from the 1950s???? FFS.
amazing though it may seem to some, state schools do have music for boys and sport for girls…

XelaM · 01/07/2023 00:31

Latymer*

XelaM · 01/07/2023 00:29

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 20:58

Even if you live in an expensive area there is social housing and flat that are rented out to a family of 4 for 2 bedrooms. DH designs housing in the most expensive parts of London and the proportion has to be social housing. Outside of London that situation is probably more favourable. If you are referencing primary school, yes, catchments are small but secondary is not the same. I live in a leafy area and my DC go to an oversubscribed state secondary comprehensive, there are many people that are not affluent and they intake is far and wide.

🙄 Several of my daughter's friends are at state grammar schools - DAO and Latiner. These families are WAY wealthier than us, live in massive houses in much nicer areas than we do. Some of these families have up to 5 properties. My daughter couldn't even sit the exam for DAO as our postcode wasn't good enough for them 🤪 I'm a single working mum paying extortionate private school fees not because we are in any way superior but because our state options are awful by virtue of living in a crappy area. Are my daughter's "state school" friends facing terrible adversity while she's living it up with Royalty? Errr.. no.

Creative34 · 01/07/2023 00:19

SleeplessinScarbourough · 29/06/2023 12:00

It’s because their parents think they are better than everyone else and they impart that expectation upon their children who by the time they are 11, also think they are better than everyone else - expecting crowds to part for them, expecting traffic to stop for them, celebrating the misfortune of others if it benefits them and pretending the common folk don’t exist.

Someone’s bitter about private school 😂😂😂

How can you tell what these parents and children are thinking and expecting? I’m guessing you picked up those powers on your non private school journey.