Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Tigertealeaves · 29/06/2023 13:33

Haven't read the entire thread, but state music teacher here. We have additional funding so ALL our students have the chance for free instrument tuition - even 1:1 tutoring for free, if they will commit to attending ensembles. The teachers are professional musicians and are really good. Unfortunately many of the students simply don't appreciate the value of this (because free, or no family culture of valuing music) and practice is not always enforced at home. Or there is no practice space at home and the student refuses to stay after school. Students also drop out of rehearsals and concerts last minute, even lovely kids, and parents let them. Often they are dealing with so much outside school - amd within school. The students/families that do seize all the opportunities achieve up to grade 8... however when something is not being paid for, it appears to be taken less seriously. On the plus side, those who do engage are doing it from genuine love and not because a parent made them.

Testina · 29/06/2023 13:30

It’s not rocket science.
It’s money, and expectations - from the parent and the school.

My friend switched her daughter (mine’s bestie) to private for Y5.

I’ll take ONE example - netball.

Mine continued to play it in occasional games at school, with a teacher who didn’t know the rules. They had one goal post. After a few weeks they switched to football, because the focus was on widening participation and all kids having a little go at all sports, specialising in none. There was one tournament organised by the council all year, and the teacher played everyone to have a go.

At the private… there was a team, and competition to be on it. If you weren’t good enough, you didn’t play. Netball was played in PE, and also an after school club that ran all year. All PE teachers were Level 2 netball coaches - shared with the senior school, no class teachers led PE. They had workshops delivered by the local netball superleague team players. Remember the one goal post? They had 4 courts fully set up and hosted tournaments. Opportunities for matches? Regular games in private school only league.

That’s before you go anywhere near parents with money (for schools) also having money for clubs.

It’s money and expectations and the opportunities that come from both of those things.

mewkins · 29/06/2023 13:29

Back when I was a kid and growing up in 90s London we had a lot of access to free music lessons in state schools and were strongly encouraged to join orchestras etc. That was when the arts were seen as important.

I had a few friends at private school at the same time and their end of year concerts were no better than ours 😅.

Likewise, if you look at the rich history of British popular music, the majority of important artists have come from very ordinary working class families with the odd exception (Joe Strummer I think).

I once mentioned this on a thread only for delightful poster to explain (as if to a poor state thicko) that of course she wasn't interested in popular music 😄.

Anyway if someone chucks enough money at you to learn a skill and puts pressure on you, I'm sure it's fairly straightforward to become at least proficient in that skill.

PlasticineKing · 29/06/2023 13:27

In my experience, private schools are heavily into resources, routine and enrichment. School
days run like clockwork to fit everything in. They do have slightly longer days in primary and quite a bit longer in high school, with Saturday school common, but not in all schools. Although weekend sports fixtures as they get a bit older. They tend to build physical activity into every day, and have lots of specialist staff too. I’d be a bit worried at what you were paying for if these things didn’t all happen.

DD (young end of primary school) has PE on Mondays plus outdoor learning, games on Tuesdays, Wednesday is swimming, Thursday is a sport that has an outdoor company in to run it. Friday outdoor learning. Music twice a week and French twice a week. After school clubs are a mix of sporty and fun. Starts recorder next year with the whole class and then private additional tuition becomes available the following year, although we’re currently looking for a drum teacher. Latin further up the school. Library trips every week, normally a school trip per term and residential start very early too. Heavily into the arts and school shows and productions.

Academically, they are pushed. But equally there is a lot of resource for kids who need extra support in particular areas. I would imagine they are working 6-12 months ahead of curriculum in most areas.

For what it’s worth, I grew up in a WC skint family. DH less so, but not rolling in it. We’ve made some very savvy decisions and it’s paid off for us. It was never a guarantee that things would turn out this way. I never expected life to be like this. We are definitely on the more “down to earth” side of families though. There is a lot of entitlement, but we actively don’t do that. We’re not twats.

Also, I would have been happy for DD to go to the local state school if things hadn’t turned out this way for us. I would still be doing reading and maths with her most days, and she’d possibly do a bit more out of school to supplement less resources in state sector. But many many people already do that, and often to excess. We wouldn’t have stretched ourselves to an uncomfortable financial position to fund private school. I’m extremely grateful that we can, but it wasn’t a make or break for me, or DH.

gogomoto · 29/06/2023 13:27

It's simply economics, they can afford multiple instrument lessons. Both my DD's play multiple instruments and were state educated (dd1 plays 5 to orchestral standard plus piano and voice at grade 8, it costs a lot of money - I used her dla to pay for them)

Sheselectric77 · 29/06/2023 13:26

It’s obvious really for all the reasons already mentioned.

I used to work in a private school. The teachers are the same as state schools and the dc are the same as any other dc. I used to work in the pre-prep mostly and have also worked in a few state early years settings. The children at that age were the same level in both. However, as they moved up the school the gap widened because the private dc had all the opportunities and the parents had money to pay for extra tuition and activities. We had professional sports coach’s come into the school for sports lessons each day and music lessons were a must. Some parents and dc in private had foul better than you attitudes but not many, the school I worked in would not encourage this and would actively stamp it out. The atmosphere in the private school was very different to state, this was due to class sizes and behaviour. They are better behaved in private because parents are paying so any disruption is not tolerated and they have the resources to swiftly manage disruptive dc. I did see many pros and cons to private but I see this in state schools too.

We are a completely normal family with normal jobs and me and dh were both state educated. I am an active advocate for equality and the rights of the disadvantaged. It’s my whole job basically and I chose it as I’m passionate about that.
My eldest dc was offered a place at a local independent due to academic ability. We explored it as she was having a hard time at her state school. She would probably have been given a scholarship at another private near us. We gave her all the facts and she decided herself to stay in state and go to the local state secondary with her friends as that was important to her. That is fine with me. Her abilities are natural, however, we are fortunate in that we were able to afford to nurture her talents by paying for private lessons 3x per week in music and art. We have the resources to spend time with her studying and are lucky that I have a family member who is a mathematician. One of my parents was educated well (state but a selective one) and her parents were professors who encouraged music and education. When you are surrounded by this it becomes your norm. My younger dc is probably going to go for a sports scholarship soon. She is in the top 10% in her sport. Again it’s a natural talent, I didn’t even know she had I must admit, she was quickly spotted at her extra circular and has since been given opportunities due to that. Again that is because she has a privilege that we can invest in her talents and pay for extra help.
Many dc will be just as talented as mine in all sorts of areas but unfortunately they won’t be given the same push because it’s out of reach for lots of people. It’s totally unfair. I’m not blind to that. We did have to make a decision about what we went without in order to free up funds for the dc’s extras and I have stayed in a job I’m not 100% happy with because of the pay. It’s not been totally plain sailing but I’m aware that it’s still a privilege.

I so wish state education could be even half as good as private but it will never be. All children should be given the opportunity to meet their potential but that will never happen.

I could choose not to send dc2 on the scholarship or pay for either dc extra circulars or lessons but who would honestly do that in the real world? I care about all dc but I naturally want the best for my own. I find it hard to get my head around people who say they wouldn’t pay for private school or extra advantages for their dc even if they had the money. I doubt they would say the same if they actually did.

Screamingabdabz · 29/06/2023 13:25

TheaBrandt · 29/06/2023 12:15

Don’t worry - when it comes to university applications they don’t give a shiny shit about your flute or whether you did d of e. Plus many applications for jobs now are school and university blind. Efforts are being made to dilute the privilege money can buy.

Apart from Oxbridge which is kicking and screaming to admit bare numbers of state school riff raff and only those with freakily bright natural intellect and no other life outside of school. They are the only ones who can match the hot housing of elite private schools.

Whole generations of bright, but poorer kids, whose talents are overlooked for bank balance greasy pole privilege.

So YABU op. No kid is born with superior music and sporting skills just because their mummy and daddy are rich.

GreenhouseGarden · 29/06/2023 13:22

Actively disagree.

Private schools push competitive sport to early for a lot of children and put them off.

Children state schools have more free time for music and sport so can practice more (albeit not in school).

Mumtothreegirlies · 29/06/2023 13:20

In my experience it’s because those types of parents are all about status and competition. Once one child’s done it everyones child has to do it.
fact is private school is not much better then state school and success is all down to the child’s drive and personality not the school they went to. They put them in private school because they don’t want their kids mixing with normal kids and they don’t want their friends thinking they’re poor.
take my colleagues 13 year old daughter, who goes to a very expensive boarding school and was caught vaping in town with a 19 year old lad when she should have been at school. Yes fantastic safe places they are…not.
I could divulge many a dodgy story about private schools but I doubt any of the snobs would care about the truth.

Reugny · 29/06/2023 13:19

TheaBrandt · 29/06/2023 12:41

I’m not “telling myself that” Walrus I am going through the process with dd1 right now. They don’t want to know about any of those things it’s super curricular dedication to your subject that’s relevant. They are also unimpressed by anything that just demonstrates they you have wealthy parents impressed by kid self starting and getting their own job etc .

But then Dh and I are lowly state educated oiks who somehow ended up at Cambridge (Dh only) and City law firms so honestly your school doesn’t make a difference to where you end up even less so now! Agree the sport is def better at private but you can set that up out of school it’s just more effort.

Your school did make a difference.

You both went to state schools were applying to Oxbridge was not actively discouraged.

I went to a school then a college where former students who were studying at a wide range of universities including Oxbridge came back to give us talks about applications.

GnomeDePlume · 29/06/2023 13:16

@Denimrevival have you looked to see what your county music service offers?

Ours offers Saturday morning music and performing arts schools. They take children from early years up to 18 (and beyond if they become volunteers). They have group instrument lessons, choirs, music theory. It's an opportunity for children to try out different branches of music.

Both my DDs went and loved it.

KimberleyClark · 29/06/2023 13:16

Not necessarily. Take Jamie Roberts for example. Wales and British Lions rugby player. Qualified as a doctor. Self taught guitarist, appeared on stage with Manic Street Preachers at a festival. State educated.

ReachForTheMars · 29/06/2023 13:08

This feels beyond obvious.

Because it gets a stronger focus. My siblings kids are private and they are expected to spend most of their Saturdays doing sport. They do more, they get better.

There are also scholarships and bursaries for kids the school think they can show off like prestigious little trophies.

Parents put money in, kids get better resources, kids get better results. Not rocket science.

Plus, if you really want to put the boot in for the poor little state school children compared to their excelling private school peers, perhaps you can even make a nice little link to poverty and obesity and attainment.

randomsabreuse · 29/06/2023 13:08

My children will get more sporting and musical options (and hopefully better ones) by not going to a private school because I will have more money to select teachers and coaches for the sports that suit them.

Club sport is generally better than school sport.

Obviously some parents can afford both private school and sports/music.

It would be good if state schools still had decent playing fields but most sporting success comes from parents seeking out clubs and not through school.

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 13:07

TheaBrandt · 29/06/2023 12:41

I’m not “telling myself that” Walrus I am going through the process with dd1 right now. They don’t want to know about any of those things it’s super curricular dedication to your subject that’s relevant. They are also unimpressed by anything that just demonstrates they you have wealthy parents impressed by kid self starting and getting their own job etc .

But then Dh and I are lowly state educated oiks who somehow ended up at Cambridge (Dh only) and City law firms so honestly your school doesn’t make a difference to where you end up even less so now! Agree the sport is def better at private but you can set that up out of school it’s just more effort.

It's incredibly naive to believe that "your school doesn't make a difference". Of course it does.

It's not about learning the recorder or doing a bit of netball after school, it's the general knowledge, experience, work experience, the confidence and skills you gain.

I see a lot of CV. They are not "blind", you can get a rough idea of the background.

If it wasn't true, why would parents spend so much effort and resources on putting their kids into the best state school they can?

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/06/2023 13:05

whodawhodaeho · 29/06/2023 11:56

They have better access to facilities but better? No. Any child given music lessons from a young age can become a good musician.

This.

Natural aptitude rises to the top regardless of background. Indeed I would imagine some of the best footballers have very humble beginnings. Perhaps they strive harder given that.

queenMab99 · 29/06/2023 13:05

It must be down to breeding and poshness quotient, nothing to do with the cost of lessons or anything.......🙄

Olderandolder · 29/06/2023 13:04

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 12:12

I really disagree with that.

Of course they matter. Being sporty should not be only accessible to the richest ones, or even to the parents who have time and finance to take the children from one club to the other after school.

Physical health, mental health, it all matters. We should push for more sport and opportunities in state school, not accepting the huge difference between the 2 systems.

If you think “We” should include more sport and music,

you are asking for more money to be taken by force from people struggling with the cost of living

and spent on admin and bureaucracy as much as music and sport

Maybe struggling taxpayers want to prioritise their food bills mortgages over bureaucracy, music and sport?

And the impact would be to increase the costs of music and sport for anyone doing it outside the system. Govt would probably regulate it too.

caringcarer · 29/06/2023 13:04

I worked at an independent school in Birmingham. In the summer they had cricket lessons at Edgbaston in the indoor nets. Of course there will be a cost to this. I don't suppose local Birmingham comps can afford the Edgbaston indoor net prices for PE lessons.

AnnaMagnani · 29/06/2023 13:03

God DH and I must be abysmal failures then.

No sport and not an instrument between us.

I finished not even knowing what sport the 'First 11' were playing.

Siriusmuggle · 29/06/2023 13:03

I know about music. My kid was privately educated. All children got individual instrumental lessons from year 3, those with an aptitude carried on. In my local state school there are no instrumental lessons, in some others in the county there are whole class lessons for one term. Mine is now studying music at a conservatoire and it's 100% due to the opportunities from his primary school. A lot of his friends from county youth orchestras were privately educated but there are still plenty from state schools.
Sport is probably similar- he did plenty at school but now does sod all,

strawberrywhisk · 29/06/2023 13:02

State schools are consider factory fodder for the upper classes and earners, just here to serve and do the jobs they don't want to do, why would the government be interested in levelling the playing fields

IAmAnIdiot123 · 29/06/2023 13:00

mumu54 · 29/06/2023 12:17

Same here!

Glad I'm not alone 🤣🤣🤣

skyfalldown · 29/06/2023 12:59

this just in: children with better access to sports facilities and instruments are shockingly more skilled than those without. who would have thought it?

ohfook · 29/06/2023 12:58

Of course they are. I've worked at private and state schools.

Private schools often pay for drama, sports, music specialists to come in and do both lessons and extra-curricular activities. The children will then be competing against children who have experienced similar. The parents will also have the money to support pupils interests outside of school too.

In state primary schools, one teacher teaches everything. I'm a shit musician, can't sing and am crap at sports. Obviously I work hard to overcome these obstacles and provide good lessons but the fact remains that a child taught music by me, who's parents can't afford extra music tuition, is at a serious disadvantage compared to a similar child at a private school.