Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 14:02

XelaM · 29/06/2023 13:53

If you want your kid to be sporty and musical, sign them up with a sports club and get a music tutor. There's no secret that private school parents know that's not available to state school kids. The parents just have to be willing to dedicate their time to this.

Could you be any more patronising! The implication being that somehow private school parents can be 'bothered' and state school parents are apathetic when it comes to their child's best interests. Anyway, I'll repeat the above, how many famously talented musicians went to private school?

Terryer · 29/06/2023 13:59

XelaM · 29/06/2023 13:56

My daughter's sport is equestrian show jumping, so on paper as elitist as you can get 😂 but you'd be surprised that vast majority of the kids in her team are in state education.

I've just come back from the nsea championships. Not many state school teams there!

greenmarsupial · 29/06/2023 13:59

I think state schools could definitely take on the focus on sports from private schools. From what I've seen, they play one or two winter sports and then the same in summer with a competitive element. In state schools, there isn't the same focus on getting good at a sport.

My children are sporty and play 2-3 musical instruments each. They are on the local competitive swimming team and also play team sports. This is really deliberate though as we can't afford private school so are actively trying to give them the well-roundedness that comes from a private education.

XelaM · 29/06/2023 13:56

My daughter's sport is equestrian show jumping, so on paper as elitist as you can get 😂 but you'd be surprised that vast majority of the kids in her team are in state education.

XelaM · 29/06/2023 13:53

If you want your kid to be sporty and musical, sign them up with a sports club and get a music tutor. There's no secret that private school parents know that's not available to state school kids. The parents just have to be willing to dedicate their time to this.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 13:51

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 29/06/2023 13:46

It's about wealth rather than private education imo. Yes, private schools will do a lot of sports/extracurricular, but state educated kids can access comparable opportunities if their parents can pay to facilitate this.

A lot of the performing arts stuff that my dd was involved in was full of private school kids. Yes, they did stuff in school, but the ones who were really serious about it did it out of school as well. Not cheap though!

Not always. Depends where you live. London maybe. Here the drama, music and sport is far better than any local clubs.

I mean, none of its hugely relevant when they all leave and go to university anyway. The only thing that's really a lot better at our independent school is the encouragement and expectation that girls will do as much sport as the boys if they want to. That was non existent at our state school and the after school clubs constantly cancelled and barely any opportunity to compete for the school. The lunch break was so short that there was no time to do anything.

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 13:50

I don’t think my kids deserve a ‘better’ education than any others.

as you are the only one who has your children best interest at heart and the only one who will push them, you should.

It's hardly selling out to give your own child the best opportunities, nothing stops you from improving the system and volunteering, fundraising and campaigning etc as well.

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 13:48

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 13:45

I don't think talented musicians that went to state school are in the minority, unless you are only referring to classically trained musicians. My son is 16 and plays the guitar and electric guitar to at least grade 6 standard, his friend plays the drums, his other friend plays the guitar. My DD is only 12 but plays piano to grade 4 and writes her own lyrics and compositions. There are many children at DC's state school that play in bands and one of those bands does gigs around the city. My friend's son like his Dad (who was in a band in the 90s) is an incredibly talented guitar player who also is in a band that plays loads of venues. If you think about it how many talented musicians in the public eye went to state school as opposed to private school?

And there is no 'despite' about it, many talented musicians are so because they have life experiences and material to draw upon that you would not have from living in a bubble!

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 13:47

Escapefromhell · 29/06/2023 11:51

Private school kids aren’t more sporty and better musicians. They have simply had all the opportunities.

This is just like saying that the GB Olympic team is better at dressage and sailing than Uganda’s.

but then it literally means they ARE more sporty, and better musician.

It doesn't mean they were born with better abilities, simply they have more practice and opportunities.

If all state school children had 1 or 2 hours of PE every day, state school children would be more sporty. Currently the ones who have parents with time and money go to various clubs after schools, the others go home and watch tv.

People who do more sport are more sporty, it's beyond obvious.

Guiltridden12345 · 29/06/2023 13:47

Sheselectric77 · 29/06/2023 13:26

It’s obvious really for all the reasons already mentioned.

I used to work in a private school. The teachers are the same as state schools and the dc are the same as any other dc. I used to work in the pre-prep mostly and have also worked in a few state early years settings. The children at that age were the same level in both. However, as they moved up the school the gap widened because the private dc had all the opportunities and the parents had money to pay for extra tuition and activities. We had professional sports coach’s come into the school for sports lessons each day and music lessons were a must. Some parents and dc in private had foul better than you attitudes but not many, the school I worked in would not encourage this and would actively stamp it out. The atmosphere in the private school was very different to state, this was due to class sizes and behaviour. They are better behaved in private because parents are paying so any disruption is not tolerated and they have the resources to swiftly manage disruptive dc. I did see many pros and cons to private but I see this in state schools too.

We are a completely normal family with normal jobs and me and dh were both state educated. I am an active advocate for equality and the rights of the disadvantaged. It’s my whole job basically and I chose it as I’m passionate about that.
My eldest dc was offered a place at a local independent due to academic ability. We explored it as she was having a hard time at her state school. She would probably have been given a scholarship at another private near us. We gave her all the facts and she decided herself to stay in state and go to the local state secondary with her friends as that was important to her. That is fine with me. Her abilities are natural, however, we are fortunate in that we were able to afford to nurture her talents by paying for private lessons 3x per week in music and art. We have the resources to spend time with her studying and are lucky that I have a family member who is a mathematician. One of my parents was educated well (state but a selective one) and her parents were professors who encouraged music and education. When you are surrounded by this it becomes your norm. My younger dc is probably going to go for a sports scholarship soon. She is in the top 10% in her sport. Again it’s a natural talent, I didn’t even know she had I must admit, she was quickly spotted at her extra circular and has since been given opportunities due to that. Again that is because she has a privilege that we can invest in her talents and pay for extra help.
Many dc will be just as talented as mine in all sorts of areas but unfortunately they won’t be given the same push because it’s out of reach for lots of people. It’s totally unfair. I’m not blind to that. We did have to make a decision about what we went without in order to free up funds for the dc’s extras and I have stayed in a job I’m not 100% happy with because of the pay. It’s not been totally plain sailing but I’m aware that it’s still a privilege.

I so wish state education could be even half as good as private but it will never be. All children should be given the opportunity to meet their potential but that will never happen.

I could choose not to send dc2 on the scholarship or pay for either dc extra circulars or lessons but who would honestly do that in the real world? I care about all dc but I naturally want the best for my own. I find it hard to get my head around people who say they wouldn’t pay for private school or extra advantages for their dc even if they had the money. I doubt they would say the same if they actually did.

Not true. We have the money, we got the places, but just couldn’t do it. I don’t think my kids deserve a ‘better’ education than any others. Mine are in state, it’s underfunded and nowhere near the advantages and opportunity of private, but it’s real and it’s fair and it’s the right thing to do. We push the school gently for more and better for our kids and, by virtue of that, all kids. We challenge and support. That’s the only way state provision will improve, not by selling out.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 29/06/2023 13:46

It's about wealth rather than private education imo. Yes, private schools will do a lot of sports/extracurricular, but state educated kids can access comparable opportunities if their parents can pay to facilitate this.

A lot of the performing arts stuff that my dd was involved in was full of private school kids. Yes, they did stuff in school, but the ones who were really serious about it did it out of school as well. Not cheap though!

Alyso · 29/06/2023 13:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 13:46

Long days and Saturday school and a school culture where doing something other than academics is normal. Long lunchbreaks with changing facilities and showers so easy to play sport, shower change and eat lunch every day. Good food. Kids coming in from prep schools where they prioritise these things and don't have to follow the curriculum or bother with SATS so have more time to do it. Specialist teachers. Openly proud of the kids who do well in music or sport.

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 13:45

FlyingPandas · 29/06/2023 11:58

In general, though, your DC will by far be the exception, rather than the rule.

Of course there are some hugely talented musical and sporty children in many state schools and yes, some will go on to truly excel 'despite' being state educated. But the fact remains that these DC will be in a minority in the state sector due to lack of opportunity for the majority.

I don't think talented musicians that went to state school are in the minority, unless you are only referring to classically trained musicians. My son is 16 and plays the guitar and electric guitar to at least grade 6 standard, his friend plays the drums, his other friend plays the guitar. My DD is only 12 but plays piano to grade 4 and writes her own lyrics and compositions. There are many children at DC's state school that play in bands and one of those bands does gigs around the city. My friend's son like his Dad (who was in a band in the 90s) is an incredibly talented guitar player who also is in a band that plays loads of venues. If you think about it how many talented musicians in the public eye went to state school as opposed to private school?

StrawberryWater · 29/06/2023 13:44

My primary aged son is privately educated (on a scholarship thingy so we don’t pay a bean) but is neither sporty or musically inclined in any way!

That said, yes he has access to things if he wants to partake in any extra curricular activities. The music tuition instrument list is huge and for sports they have their own swimming pool and gym, a seated cricket ground and football / rugby fields as well as access to the local premier league winning sides training facilities a few times a year (for the upper secondary school aged kids anyway). They also have a very good theatre and clubs and societies, even in the primary phase, are plentiful.

It comes down to resources including private investment with a lot of benefactors etc.

I agree that it’s not fair that state schools don’t receive the same amount of funding and the opportunities aren’t the same but I think the older you get and in terms of job applications etc the less it matters where you went to school, especially as lots of jobs are based on competencies nowadays and if you’re good enough you’re good enough, no matter your background.

ColouringPencils · 29/06/2023 13:41

Sorry not to quote, but the thing about blind shortlisting for jobs assumes that the only benefit you get from performing/playing to a high standard is being able to write about it on your CV. I really disagree with this. There is a huge amount of value to be gained from these activities that will impact on your skills for life, including confidence, resilience, ability to work in a team, strategic thinking, desire to excel etc - never-mind softer skills like self expression, empathy and creativity. Nobody need ever know you played county rugby and grade 8 piano for you to have gained those skills.

(Since we seem to need to say - state school parent who recognises the value of the few amazing opportunities my kids have had, but still envious of those who get a lot more!)

XelaM · 29/06/2023 13:41

Her*

XelaM · 29/06/2023 13:41

My daughter has been in private school since reception and is very sporty, but the sport she competes in she does entirely outside of school. He school offers the sport, but at a beginner level. So her sports achievements are not at all down to the school. Unless a private school specialises in a particular sport, the kids who compete at high level train in clubs outside of school.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 29/06/2023 13:40

@Tigertealeaves Can you please explain the funding for all children. So if my child attends our council-run orchestra (which I am considering for him anyway), will I be able to get free 1:1 tuition for him or am I reading this wrong? Thank you so much!

Dowhatshard · 29/06/2023 13:40

Haven’t read every post. Yes it’s about facilities, specialist teachers and money.

But also, private school kids (ages 4-13) are registering in school at 8.30 am and finish at 5 pm. This includes PE and sports. They also have classes till lunchtime, followed by matches with other schools on Saturday. Senior schools (ages 13-18) have longer days.

The kids privately educated work much harder and longer than state school kids.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 13:40

SleeplessinScarbourough · 29/06/2023 12:00

It’s because their parents think they are better than everyone else and they impart that expectation upon their children who by the time they are 11, also think they are better than everyone else - expecting crowds to part for them, expecting traffic to stop for them, celebrating the misfortune of others if it benefits them and pretending the common folk don’t exist.

Oh bore off!

Guiltridden12345 · 29/06/2023 13:39

Escapefromhell · 29/06/2023 11:51

Private school kids aren’t more sporty and better musicians. They have simply had all the opportunities.

This is just like saying that the GB Olympic team is better at dressage and sailing than Uganda’s.

This!!!!

grass321 · 29/06/2023 13:38

It's time and parental support. My kids have sports sessions every day, often S&C before school at 7.15, also lunchtime and after school training. Plus three scheduled games sessions and school matches. Specialist coaches and facilities (hockey astros, grass wickets through the winter shared with one of the men's county cricket teams).

They do club sport on top but they're probably getting an extra 10 hours a week from school provision. One son played two county sports, the other three plus two at regional level.

They have decent hand-eye coordination and athleticism but they're nothing special, they've just had the benefit of school coaching and facilities. And we've been able/willing to spend both days of the weekend ferrying them around.

mewkins · 29/06/2023 13:37

Tigertealeaves · 29/06/2023 13:33

Haven't read the entire thread, but state music teacher here. We have additional funding so ALL our students have the chance for free instrument tuition - even 1:1 tutoring for free, if they will commit to attending ensembles. The teachers are professional musicians and are really good. Unfortunately many of the students simply don't appreciate the value of this (because free, or no family culture of valuing music) and practice is not always enforced at home. Or there is no practice space at home and the student refuses to stay after school. Students also drop out of rehearsals and concerts last minute, even lovely kids, and parents let them. Often they are dealing with so much outside school - amd within school. The students/families that do seize all the opportunities achieve up to grade 8... however when something is not being paid for, it appears to be taken less seriously. On the plus side, those who do engage are doing it from genuine love and not because a parent made them.

This sounds great. Are you in the UK? Sadly in the county in which I live the music service (run by the local authority) has struggled with years of underfunding.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 29/06/2023 13:35

Check out the proper home ed community. Grade 8s at 11 not uncommon, as are published books, composed symphonies and incredible sports achievements. Nothing to do with private schooling, much more to do with parental support.