Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
PedalStool · 29/06/2023 14:38

For every child who succeeds in these endeavours at private school, there are some who manage not to achieve in sport or music. I am looking at my own kids here ;-) They had no natural talent and we don’t have the drive and push either so they managed to ignore those kinds of opportunities. Did well academically though.

I am always interested when people talk about state school kids having ‘life experience’ and living in the ‘real world’. Private school kids also have life experience and live in a world that is real to them, but just different in some ways to state school kids.

But when I went to university, you couldn’t tell who had been at state or private. It was all a mishmash and did not show in academic or sport or musical achievement.

Wakeywake · 29/06/2023 14:34

It's not about private vs state, it's about money and parental involvement.

DD is in an independent, 12 and piano grade 5, which is by no means outstanding. We pay for her piano lessons in the same way we would if she was in a state school, the only difference is that she can have those lessons on school premises during school hours. But she could have equally achieved the same level if she had lessons at home. DS has no interest in music, he's a grade 4 and rarely practices, and he'd still be the same if he had lessons at home.

Sports are a bit different, as they've been exposed to many sports at school, facilities are excellent and Saturdays are spent at games, so that was all beneficial to them developing a love of sports. That being said, the sport DD loves and does most is unrelated to school.

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 14:32

I was reading comments on a famous FB parenting groups about clubs and after school activities.

You can tell all the difference the parents and their attitude make. It was shocking the number of posters proudly claiming they couldn't be bothered to take their children every day, and a club possibly 2 clubs a week was more than enough. The children could just "relax" at home and have pj days at the weekend.

Meanwhile, the ones who prioritise sport and education and make sacrifice to encourage via private, or physically chauffeur them around to their clubs have an enormous impact.

Money matters a lot, but it's not all. Some school sports or clubs with a small yearly fee are accessible.

ManateeFair · 29/06/2023 14:28

Private school children are not 'sportier'. There are certainly some specific sports that have a high proportion of private school educated athletes (rugby union, cricket, equestrian, rowing) but you won't find many footballers, rugby league players, track and field athletes or boxers who went to private schools.

Private schools are selective, so they can deliberately pick pupils who have already shown ability/interest in things like sport and music as well as being academic. The pupils are tremendously advantaged in terms of the time, money and facilities invested in their education. Take the music example - if your family is wealthy and your school has an orchestra and access to lots of different instruments and music tutors and so on, of course you're more likely to learn to play more instruments and sit more music exams and have more tuition than an equally talented child from a family who can't afford to pay for music lessons beyond 30 minutes after a school once a week playing the recorder. And if you go to a school that has extensive playing fields, a cricket pitch, tennis courts, an indoor pool, a fencing club and the best coaching available, then I don't think it's any surprise that you might be more enthusiastic about sport and have more opportunity to train than a kid whose PE lessons consist of the odd game of rounders an an asphalt playground supervised by a bored sadist.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:28

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:26

But NSEA is u/a level, isn't it?

It's not affiliated, no. Goes up to 1.10.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:26

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 14:23

It is simply not true that private educated equates to 'better musicians' though if it was true, many of the famous musicians would have been privately educated and they have not been. Do private schools encourage children to play a classical instrument yes they do but this a limited view of what a musician is! Equally, all this goes out the window in year 9/10 where if you are not good enough, you are encouraged to drop your violin lessons and concentrate on achieving your 8s and 9s!

I think the USP of a good private school is that they will help you to do both.

It's not unusual for dcs to get all 8s and 9s, play first team sport and play at least one instrument at dds school (not dd unfortunately )

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:26

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:22

NSEA is dominated by private schools.

But NSEA is u/a level, isn't it?

Archeron · 29/06/2023 14:25

It’s about opportunities. Piano lessons cost £30-50 per hour depending on the teacher, plus £2k for an electric piano so DC can practise with headphones on. Sport costs at least £10 per hour and either needs to be facilitated by a private school or by a non-working parent who ferries DC around.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 14:24

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:20

I don't know about across the board of course, but the majority of the kids at our club are at state schools (many are at grammar schools though). Don't get me wrong, the parents have money as you must of course for SJ (😞) but their kids are not at private schools. They train outside of school hours. I don't actually know any secondary schools (even those with horse facilities) who train to a very high level, except for an equestrian college.

No I think the talented riders are more likely to compete individually outside of school teams due to qualifying events etc irrespective of whether they are state or privately educated. DDs school (private) has an equestrian team and they do NSEA but the team members swop and change regularly depending on what they want to qualify for independent of the school. Riders are more likely to want to get on pony club teams than the school team.

Stillcantbebothered · 29/06/2023 14:24

SleeplessinScarbourough · 29/06/2023 12:00

It’s because their parents think they are better than everyone else and they impart that expectation upon their children who by the time they are 11, also think they are better than everyone else - expecting crowds to part for them, expecting traffic to stop for them, celebrating the misfortune of others if it benefits them and pretending the common folk don’t exist.

you sound so bitter lol

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 14:23

It is simply not true that private educated equates to 'better musicians' though if it was true, many of the famous musicians would have been privately educated and they have not been. Do private schools encourage children to play a classical instrument yes they do but this a limited view of what a musician is! Equally, all this goes out the window in year 9/10 where if you are not good enough, you are encouraged to drop your violin lessons and concentrate on achieving your 8s and 9s!

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:22

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:20

I don't know about across the board of course, but the majority of the kids at our club are at state schools (many are at grammar schools though). Don't get me wrong, the parents have money as you must of course for SJ (😞) but their kids are not at private schools. They train outside of school hours. I don't actually know any secondary schools (even those with horse facilities) who train to a very high level, except for an equestrian college.

NSEA is dominated by private schools.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:21

It is partially money, but partially prioritising. Private schools prioritise sport and music. Particularly prep schools.

Also let's not forget football is the highest paid sport in this country and there aren't many privately educated footballers.

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:20

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 14:14

For SJ I wouldn't be surprised at the majority, or at least 50/50 split being state educated. I would be more surprised if you said the same for an evening team!

I don't know about across the board of course, but the majority of the kids at our club are at state schools (many are at grammar schools though). Don't get me wrong, the parents have money as you must of course for SJ (😞) but their kids are not at private schools. They train outside of school hours. I don't actually know any secondary schools (even those with horse facilities) who train to a very high level, except for an equestrian college.

Candleabra · 29/06/2023 14:20

When I was a school the music tuition in the borough was free. It was the default for pretty much every child to at least try a musical instrument from a young age. When I was in the local youth orchestra there were some amazing musicians, some from huge families who could never have afforded private music tuition (plus instruments). With such a large pool, of course the standard was exceptional, with so many more talented children getting the opportunity to excel. Several went on to have careers in music.
Towards the end of my time in the orchestra lesson fees were introduced, albeit heavily subsidised, but a few years later you could see the decline in quality. Funding = opportunity.

JMSA · 29/06/2023 14:19

I've taught in both. The hugest difference is the confidence levels between state and privately educated pupils. The latter are significantly more confident.

MrsAvocet · 29/06/2023 14:17

It's money basically isn't it?
On average (and yes, I know it's not universal) children at independent schools come from more affluent backgrounds than those at state schools, so they can afford more extracurricular activities. These are often provided actually at independent schools who have longer days, often more space/better facilities etc, but if you look at state school pupils who excel in these fields they are also often from better off families- because a lot of sport, music and so on is bloody expensive.
Between lessons, equipment, travel etc a lot of extracurricular activities cost a lot of money. Some youngsters will be identified by talent programmes and attract external funding but unfortunately all too often it comes down to what the bank of Mum and Dad can afford, both in money and time. The more you do something, the better your coaching and your kit, the more likely you are to excel. More privileged children are more likely to get those opportunities.
And this is all assuming you get exposed to these activities in the first That's not just money of course, but it helps. On the whole, children from more affluent backgrounds seem to get introduced to more different hobbies etc. You're never going to become an Olympic skier if you never have ski lessons and a child from a well off family who has regular skiing holidays from an early age is obviously better placed to do that than one from an inner city estate who has never seen a ski slope. You're not likely to take up the violin if you don't ever hear anyone play one or become a great hockey player if your school doesn't have a pitch.
Not that I am saying any of this is right or fair, but it is unfortunately, reality.

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:16

CurlewKate · 29/06/2023 14:11

There are practically no posts on here to which "more money" is not the answer.

I agree with this.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 14:14

XelaM · 29/06/2023 13:56

My daughter's sport is equestrian show jumping, so on paper as elitist as you can get 😂 but you'd be surprised that vast majority of the kids in her team are in state education.

For SJ I wouldn't be surprised at the majority, or at least 50/50 split being state educated. I would be more surprised if you said the same for an evening team!

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:13

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 14:02

Could you be any more patronising! The implication being that somehow private school parents can be 'bothered' and state school parents are apathetic when it comes to their child's best interests. Anyway, I'll repeat the above, how many famously talented musicians went to private school?

But it is possible for state school kids to access sports and music. Most private school kids train outside of school anyway, unless it's a boarding school.

Sheselectric77 · 29/06/2023 14:12

@Guiltridden12345 thats your choice of course but it’s not something I find easy to understand. I don’t see it as selling out.

So if your dc showed natural ability (like lots of dc do) in a certain area you wouldn’t encourage that by paying for extra tuition or whatever if you could easily afford it, because it won’t help others in the state sector or those who can’t afford it? Really? It’s important to care about all dc and important to put effort into closing the gap but it’s also completely natural to want your own dc to do the very best and have the very best you can afford, both through time and money.
You can do both, you can give your own dc a leg up while supporting those who have less opportunities. You can still support state education and send your dc to private. You can still send your dc to extra curricular activities and volunteer at the local free services.
Life is full of unfairness and inequality. I wont believe you if you tell me you never use your resources to make your own life better because it’s not fair on others.

CurlewKate · 29/06/2023 14:11

There are practically no posts on here to which "more money" is not the answer.

Gettingfleeced · 29/06/2023 14:09

Private schools tend to have smaller class sizes. If you have to wait for 30 children to do anything (get books out, queue up for lunch, get changed for PE, take a turn in a game, each read a line, talk about their day, deliver a roleplay skit etc) then more of the school day is lost. If there are only 12 in a class, you can whizz through the syllabus more quickly and then get time for the extracurricular stuff.

If you have more resources at a private school, everyone can play their own violin whereas at state schools with bigger classes, there might be one instrument between 2 or 3 children, so the amount of time you get to have a go is reduced and the amount of time messing around because you are paired with your mates is increased.

redbigbananafeet · 29/06/2023 14:05

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:55

@JoWawa is that something they should be looked at in state schools so more enrichment can be offered to close the gap?

And where does the money go fund that come from?

DramaticBananas · 29/06/2023 14:03

Not to derail the thread but is tennis such an elite sport? My DS is very sporty and at a state school. He loves tennis particularly and I've encouraged him. It is only £40 annual membership for under 18's at our local tennis club. He is there regularly with his Dad or a friend. Is this something that is going to get more difficult and expensive for him to get involved with a higher level?