Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Manthide · 02/07/2023 15:24

XelaM · 02/07/2023 12:10

So how many fruit picker's children are at Fortismere or DAO or Latymer?

Well I work in a warehouse as a picker and packer and my 4 dc all went to private secondary schools. Ds was at a public boys school and my 2 elder dds went to Cambridge.

EhrlicheFrau · 02/07/2023 15:07

There are no private schools where I live, yet we have some of the most musical and sporty children and teenagers around! Access to good musical and sporting opportunities is important, and maybe more well off parents have access to the funds which go along with these hobbies when they reach more elite levels perhaps, but that doesn't mean that the child/teenager will necessarily have any more passion than a less well off one!

Xenia · 02/07/2023 12:41

On longer hours in private schools, my children's father is a teacher who has taught at each sector including Saturday school in private sector. The teachers are obliged to do clubs (as indeed they might in state schools of course in some cases). However I have not done an analysis of private schools where teachers must be in before or at 8am and leave at 6pm v state schools where in theory the school day for some might end earlier but there is in all sectors marking and preparation out of hours etc. Also if you run a boarding house you do tend to be pretty much on call a lot of the time too (in boarding schools) although not in school holidays

Lollygaggle · 02/07/2023 12:20

To put the conversation into context https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jul/02/classical-music-cuts-fighting-for-its-life-preserve-of-rich?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other&fbclid=IwAR1RzOthwluF8aaSN-b9NOgy6BoiLRTcZadbB4I2u_XUQFMPlcHXeDKaqhM

hardly surprising when many schools have sold off their school instruments , secondary schools often don't have a single member of staff who can read or play music and the curriculum sees music as a non academic subject.

This is not about elite music or sport , talented individuals will always rise to the top, this is about having the social will to provide every child with exposure and involvement in sports and music.

Hooked on classics? But if you want to learn to play, you’d better be posh | Tomiwa Owolade

My state school taught me the value of Bach and Vivaldi. Today’s pupils aren’t so lucky

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jul/02/classical-music-cuts-fighting-for-its-life-preserve-of-rich?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other&fbclid=IwAR1RzOthwluF8aaSN-b9NOgy6BoiLRTcZadbB4I2u_XUQFMPlcHXeDKaqhM

Foxesandsquirrels · 02/07/2023 12:15

XelaM · 02/07/2023 12:10

So how many fruit picker's children are at Fortismere or DAO or Latymer?

LOL. Fortismere and DAO there may actually be a couple. I worked closely with Fortismere until about 5 years ago and there's a surprising amount of kids from low income households. FSM data is crap at showing this. Most families using food banks don't qualify for FSM.

XelaM · 02/07/2023 12:10

So how many fruit picker's children are at Fortismere or DAO or Latymer?

BCCoach · 02/07/2023 11:38

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 20:58

Even if you live in an expensive area there is social housing and flat that are rented out to a family of 4 for 2 bedrooms. DH designs housing in the most expensive parts of London and the proportion has to be social housing. Outside of London that situation is probably more favourable. If you are referencing primary school, yes, catchments are small but secondary is not the same. I live in a leafy area and my DC go to an oversubscribed state secondary comprehensive, there are many people that are not affluent and they intake is far and wide.

Precisely. Average house price where I live is off the charts (think 600k+ for a two bedroom cottage). Plenty of kids who live in social housing, traveller sites, or in farm mobile home accommodation at school. I really don’t think there are many traveller kids or fruit picker’s children in private schools, even in areas with much cheaper housing.

TheaBrandt · 02/07/2023 09:23

Thought of this thread as saw friends last night whose son is top of his sport and they are in the process of applying to Ivy League colleges in US for scholarships. State school.

Casperroonie · 02/07/2023 09:16

Xenia · 30/06/2023 22:47

Live and let live. I actively chose to pay school fees from 5 - 18 (and university fees) as did my parents - our choice. Other people don't. I am not very sporty but we are quite a musical family and some of the children are keen on sports. It is complicated in the SE as there are also some fairly good state schools too but even in those you tend to find the private schools are better at things like music. It was hammered home to me when my sons' prep school with 3 local state schools teamed up for music outside at some Christmas lights turn on locally. There was a vast difference between the choirs which seemed a bit strange to me as the voice is free of charge and if you are good at it usually just means you have worked very hard on it rather than needing money but it may just be the teachers work shorter hours in state schools

Teachers work less hours in state schools?!?!?!? Omg I've heard it all now.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Correction: there are LESS Teachers, the workload is unmanageable, they're dropping like flies in many schools. In a private school, they can pay for enough teachers to provide top notch education.

Casperroonie · 02/07/2023 09:12

Probably a few factors, the main one being funding and therefore the ability to afford specialist staff. State schools have had their funding cut to the point that they can't afford TAs or resources, teachers are exhausted, let alone be able provide any decent "extra curricular" provision, or specialist teaching in normal hours.

Xenia · 02/07/2023 07:50

I am certainly not lying about the 2.50pm as I time mmy drive to the post office with work things day after day to get down there before then as that is when it gets busier! However I agreetht is one school - a fairly failing one in outer London and we are surrounded by state schools in our area that do very well - QE Barnet (state) eg is not that far away
I agree private schools have longer holidays. They do have to provide their buildings whereas state schools are given them by the stae (or church if C of E) I suppose a comparison might up the state school money a bit to cover that aspect rather than just compare funding per pupil with the school fees.

TooFondOfBooks · 01/07/2023 23:43

In terms of inherent personality traits, of course it’s not true. In terms of the opportunity to develop musical & sporting ability, clearly private schools facilitate that in a way state schools don’t - just as they’ll drag children to vastly higher grades than they’d ever have achieved in even a good state school 🤷‍♀️

sianny87 · 01/07/2023 23:26

I went on a scholarship to a private boarding school for sixth form. It would not have been an option if my parents had to pay all fees. For me, the opportunities that were available to me were greater, the class sizes were smaller. We did longer days - 8.30-4.15 and we had to participate in a extra
curricula activities. I chose netball and choir - but I had my horse at school with me too and this formed part of my lesson timetable. We did prep Monday-Thursday 7-9 and had teachers on rotation for prep duty. This meant I had access to 1-2-1 help with work.
without a doubt I would send my DC if I could afford it/ if they were able to get a scholarship. I don’t think it means better results, but has much better opportunities.

jamdonut · 01/07/2023 23:09

My daughter went to ordinary primary school, where she began learning the flute. She continued through secondary school, where she took Music A level, and gained grade 8 flute exam and went on to a music degree at Uni. She is now a secondary school music teacher. She pretty much has to fight for everything for her department as it is not given the same respect as ‘academic’ subjects… How anybody can say music is not ‘academic’ escapes me… she had to work bloody hard on music theory!!!

rockpoolingtogether · 01/07/2023 21:34

rhow · 29/06/2023 12:32

My children have specialist PE teachers from Reception and games 2 afternoons a week. . There are 4 different options for each year in the week for sport in after school clubs. This term they have had cricket, athletics, tennis and rounders. They can take part in all 4 on 4 different days should they wish. Once they get to year 3, they have sports matches two afternoons a week, and Saturday mornings. As well as having a specific netball, rugby, football, hockey coaches who takes them for PE.

They have music twice a week, with lunch time clubs for piano, violin, choir (all for free). The PTA raised money for 30 violins so all children in year 2 take 2 terms of violin and if they are good or enjoy it, continue for the last term.

Our school cannot compete against the local state schools because it is not an equal match.

You said all for free- is it a state school or a private school but clubs included?

NeonSoda · 01/07/2023 21:17

I work in a private school.

the first thing to note is that the teachers are exceptional. Often university professors rather than career school teachers.

and of course the resources are almost unlimited.

and they study from 8am until 6pm every day. From 3pm in our school it’s all extra-curricular activities.

but the main thing to note is that actually it’s really common for private schools to produce very poor exam results overall because the kids aren’t particularly smart, they’re just wealthy.

Another76543 · 01/07/2023 18:37

electriclight · 01/07/2023 13:05

The hours work out about the same over the year. State school kids have shorter days but longer terms. Just remind them of that.

All schools are different, but our school has around 36 teaching hours a week (including sport, but music lessons and extra curricular activities are on top of that). Our local state school has 25 hours. Even with the extra 5 weeks holiday a year, there is still a vast difference in teaching hours over the course of a year. It’s the equivalent of several weeks extra teaching a year, even taking account of the long holidays.

I know not everyone agrees with longer days and it wouldn’t suit every child.

Cat111 · 01/07/2023 17:11

hoplittlebunnys · 29/06/2023 12:00

I remember watching a documentary ages ago comparing lessons in a public and private school.
It wasn't particularly that the teachers or content of the lessons were better at the private schools, it was that the teachers in the private schools didn't have to spend half the lessons trying to control the class or manage disruptive students who kept walking out of lessons. The students in the private school just sat there quietly ready to learn. The class sizes were smaller too. So I imagine more of the lesson is spent actually learning, which may explain why they are often ahead.
Also musical instruments and lessons can be costly and so that may be more of a barrier for poorer households.

I agree. My son has the same violin teacher at the private school he is now at as at the state primary he was at - by total coincidence as they are geographically quite far apart. The difference is that when I go to concerts at the private school the kids sit still and pay attention. At the state school some could be really disruptive. His class sizes are bigger at the private school too but he says all the kids want to learn and know there will be big trouble if they are disruptive.

singingstones · 01/07/2023 16:16

Kids from wealthy families do better at activity which requires money - hold the front page. And kids at schools with better sports facilities and more sport on offer do better at sports. Honestly, who on earth could have predicted that? 🙄

Manthide · 01/07/2023 15:25

RedToothBrush · 01/07/2023 15:07

Self selected pushy parents

You don't go to private school if your parents don't have certain expectations of you and the school.

Therefore the school have to provide these opportunities that state school doesn't/ can't.

Some of it will be access to equipment as much as anything.

That doesn't mean they are more talented. Far from it. More trained.

I took ds aged 9 to open days at two reasonably local private schools just to see what he thought of them. Ds had had a lot of difficulties with severe speech delay, bilateral sensory processing disorder and he didn't learn to read until he was about 8 because phonics did not work for him. I was worried that he would be bullied at the local upper school. He loved them both and as he was quite behind he agreed to do Bond books everyday starting with the youngest age group going to 11+. It was a lot of work on both our parts but he was determined. He sat the entrance exams to both schools and both offered him full bursaries. I don't think I'm a pushy parent but if they want something I'll help them achieve it. Ds had an amazing time at school and achieved so much - we are on benefits and he cycled 9 miles each way, rain or shine as we couldn't afford the bus fare.

RedToothBrush · 01/07/2023 15:07

Self selected pushy parents

You don't go to private school if your parents don't have certain expectations of you and the school.

Therefore the school have to provide these opportunities that state school doesn't/ can't.

Some of it will be access to equipment as much as anything.

That doesn't mean they are more talented. Far from it. More trained.

Hro01 · 01/07/2023 15:04

Hro01 · 01/07/2023 15:02

Sounds like a very similar experience to mine!
Loved that we had games every week (probably hated it at the time, especially hockey season!) and weekly matches of netball/rounders against other schools.

I’m very fond of my school days and won’t say a bad word about them. I do put that down to the kind of school I went to. I’d love to send my daughter to the same school when the time comes but we’ll see what the finances say!

Oops! Meant to respond to @Manthide with this

Foxesandsquirrels · 01/07/2023 15:04

Terryer · 01/07/2023 14:54

It's tiring but they seem to cope fine. They have long lunch breaks and a tea break. They all seem to have plenty of energy. She has a really short commute though which helps.

Ah yes! The lunch breaks. My DDs friend has 1hr20mins and she manages to swim in that and eat! It's interesting as over the course of the week, DDs friend doesn't have more lessons than DD. It all equals out as they have games all afternoon on Wednesday and no sat school. Not sure how they cover the whole curriculum tbh, their classes are the same or larger than DDs.

Hro01 · 01/07/2023 15:02

Sounds like a very similar experience to mine!
Loved that we had games every week (probably hated it at the time, especially hockey season!) and weekly matches of netball/rounders against other schools.

I’m very fond of my school days and won’t say a bad word about them. I do put that down to the kind of school I went to. I’d love to send my daughter to the same school when the time comes but we’ll see what the finances say!

Terryer · 01/07/2023 14:54

Foxesandsquirrels · 01/07/2023 14:53

I can believe that. She must have incredible stamina. Is it not difficult to return to such long days after so long off? I guess as my DD has profound dyslexia, I can't imagine her managing so long concentrating.

It's tiring but they seem to cope fine. They have long lunch breaks and a tea break. They all seem to have plenty of energy. She has a really short commute though which helps.

Swipe left for the next trending thread