Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 15:45

Terryer · 29/06/2023 15:25

I always wonder when I read things like this - how do people think private school kds cope.when they get jobs or go to uni? They seem to do OK in life with plenty of friends etc. Maybe it's not such an issue that they don't know someone who lives in social housing when they are at school?

'cope', you would hope so wouldn't you with the privileges you have afforded them in life and friends yes, you can buy the right kind of friends as well. Personally, I want my children to have developed empathy and a breadth of understanding of different ways of living which you will not get if there is no adversity around you and everyone's life is cushioned by the magic money tree. The creative process needs inspiration where is that from if all around you is the same.

The question is over the assertion of the OP that stated Private schools make 'better musicians', it simply isn't true or even evidenced.

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 15:45

TragicMuse · 29/06/2023 12:22

Depends on the sport and the music.

If you're talking about polo, rugby, equine sports etc. Vs football or classical music Vs grime, rap, EDM.

I'd suggest that it's more to do with the sports available, the time given to properly learn each one, the time and encouragement to practice, the instruments or equipment being available etc.

It's about equality of opportunity across the board.

We had trampolines at my state school. No idea why really, I only ever got to use them twice.

We had tennis courts. Did anyone ever try to teach me even how to stand and hold a racket? No.

Every time a sport was introduced we did it for a week or two and that was it. As a result I'm shit at all of them because I never actually learnt.

You're like me @TragicMuse I hate all sports as I never got the chance at school & my parents had no interest in sports & never exercised themselves, not a slight on them they work very hard.

My dc play sports outside school & do our local jr parkrun (lots of kids from the local privates also do this & are very fast & well prepared in terms of kit, good running shoes & all weather running gear !) My dc wouldn't be a patch on my friends dcs as regards sports but we don't have a very sporty or outdoorsy lifestyle either.

OP posts:
OneTwoThreeShake · 29/06/2023 15:39

Also, we all had to pass exams and an interview to get in, so everybody was of a high level intellectually.

And the days were longer. Our school day was 8am-4pm. Some days we'd have optional sports practice before or after school. We also had to take part in extra curricular activities for half of lunchtime, and had extra lessons during lunch a couple of days a week in exam season. There wasn't much just milling about.

OneTwoThreeShake · 29/06/2023 15:33

I went to private school. It may have changed since my day, but we had a huge focus on not just music and sports, but extra curricular activities generally. So we all played at least a couple of instruments as it was part of our curriculum, and many of us had further lessons too. Our sports department had properly focused teachers who played sports themselves. So our rugby team was coached by rugby players and so on. We played a wide range of sports so it was easy to find something you enjoyed and were good at. Our facilities were top level, and the school brought in external coaches for things like private tennis lessons.

Beyond that, we were encouraged to find something we loved and thrived in within art and design and societies such as debating and volunteering. It's much easier to excel when you have a broad range of things to try and you're supported in your choices. Feeling enriched and fulfilled counts for a great deal too.

MovingBird123 · 29/06/2023 15:26

Of families who can afford to send their children to private school, those who are willing are the types who place value in music education too. Not everyone places education so highly, even if they can afford it.

From someone who will almost certainly never be able to send kids to private school, and am very concerned re state of local secondary...

weebleswobblebuttheydontfalldown · 29/06/2023 15:25

I've had my kids at several state and private schools and think the demographic who send them there in the first place plays a large part of it. The schools themselves charge extra for peripatetic music lessons and these tend to be for at least 30 mins - the longer school days make it easier to slot a music lesson in, even 2 per week in private schools. State schools do this too but often shorter and it becomes hard work for the child who always misses the same parts of school lessons etc. My daughter used to do Singing and Clarinet and her private school have an entire coordinator who ensures they done always miss the same lessons etc. She stopped it all at GCSE tho! They had music lessons just like state schools tho and concerts however the range of music clubs and choirs was greater at private school.

I think music lessons are expensive wherever you have them though so if you are on a lower income it's not easy to do, which is such a shame in my opinion.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 15:25

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 15:08

Even if you go to a comprehensive state school in a 'leafy privileged' area, the school can't discriminate against people who don't have enough money. You do realise that the large radius of intake for oversubscribed schools will inevitably include children in (brace yourself as you may feel queasy hearing the word) living in social housing or sharing a room with their Mum as they live in a bedsit and are in-between rentals, that live with their grandparents as their Dad is in prison and their Mum has left them. The disruption in classes, even in 'leafy privileged' areas has to be tolerated i.e they are not going to be able to expel those children, like they can easily do in private schools. Children fighting and bringing knives in to schools 'even' in 'leafy privileged' areas. Not having enough money to be driven around for sport events, even if they are organised (which is rare), being a latch key kid as your parents both have to work full time to pay their massive mortgage in a 'leafy privileged' area.

Your comment alone shows how ignorant you are of this 'real world' as you have no clue about how it works. There is a baseline of wealth for a child to be able to go to private school so there are 'no money' worries, this is very much not the 'real world' and when you pay for that segregation (which you are, even if you don't admit it), paying for your children to be protected from the realities of the not so attractive lives of others. So no, I don't think living in that bubble is exactly the setting for great self expression that is needed for creating the best musicians!

I always wonder when I read things like this - how do people think private school kds cope.when they get jobs or go to uni? They seem to do OK in life with plenty of friends etc. Maybe it's not such an issue that they don't know someone who lives in social housing when they are at school?

Wilkolampshade · 29/06/2023 15:14

The best, by a country mile, violin teacher my DD had was the council peri at her state primary. Unfortunately we lived in a rural area of very, very high deprivation at the time but he went above and beyond to get her 1-1 tuition at school during the day. She had to audition at the local music service for the privilege and when she got the go ahead the barriers and snarkiness towards her from some other parents and sadly, a couple of staff members, was astonishing. Fed up with battling it, on her teachers advice she auditioned for Chetham's and got in so, off she went. She's now at the Royal College of Music and going up into her final year.
Shortly after she left to go to Chets the local music service was abruptly disbanded and there is now NO music tuition of the kind she received down there. Wealthier parents can of course still access lessons privately but there will be a generation of children with talent that was never nurtured in those schools.
So it's opportunity OP, and sometimes low aspirations amongst not only parents, but those on the council who hold the purse strings. On hearing she was applying to Chets her then Headteacher turned to me and said, "well, she can have a go of course but it's not really 'our' thing, is it?" (For context, she first picked up hrr violin aged 6 and was Grade 8 two years later.)

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 15:08

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 14:47

I am always interested when people talk about state school kids having ‘life experience’ and living in the ‘real world’. Private school kids also have life experience and live in a world that is real to them, but just different in some ways to state school kids.

knowing that "the real world" might just as well be an oversubscribed state school in a leafy privileged neighbourhood, or a struggling multi-cultural school in the worst gang-infected centre of a deprived area, I would ignore any reference to "life experience" 😂

Even if you go to a comprehensive state school in a 'leafy privileged' area, the school can't discriminate against people who don't have enough money. You do realise that the large radius of intake for oversubscribed schools will inevitably include children in (brace yourself as you may feel queasy hearing the word) living in social housing or sharing a room with their Mum as they live in a bedsit and are in-between rentals, that live with their grandparents as their Dad is in prison and their Mum has left them. The disruption in classes, even in 'leafy privileged' areas has to be tolerated i.e they are not going to be able to expel those children, like they can easily do in private schools. Children fighting and bringing knives in to schools 'even' in 'leafy privileged' areas. Not having enough money to be driven around for sport events, even if they are organised (which is rare), being a latch key kid as your parents both have to work full time to pay their massive mortgage in a 'leafy privileged' area.

Your comment alone shows how ignorant you are of this 'real world' as you have no clue about how it works. There is a baseline of wealth for a child to be able to go to private school so there are 'no money' worries, this is very much not the 'real world' and when you pay for that segregation (which you are, even if you don't admit it), paying for your children to be protected from the realities of the not so attractive lives of others. So no, I don't think living in that bubble is exactly the setting for great self expression that is needed for creating the best musicians!

MasterBeth · 29/06/2023 15:03

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:53

@Escapefromhell yes they have had better opportunities but how can state educated kids compete with that come secondary, uni or in the wider world?

They need to be better than private school kids. (See: the state of Britain.)

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/06/2023 15:02

Who gives a shit though? I don’t.

Avondale89 · 29/06/2023 15:00

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 14:52

One or two clubs per week IS enough especially for primary aged kids

if you have the luxury to let the kids play football in the park after school, go on bike rides, go swimming and basically spend energy after school and at weekend, yes possibly.
But it's untrue that 2 clubs are enough when the alternative is to go home and watch tv.

“Enough” for what purpose?

MrsAvocet · 29/06/2023 15:00

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:48

A week's training camp in the school holidays typically costs us £1200 - £1400 by the time you've added fuel and overnight stays on the way there and back

Blimey! What sport is it? Gold leaf origami? And I say that as the mother of a horse rider!

I should have said residential. I don't actually think the costs are at all unreasonable for a week of full board, high quality coaching and evening activities, but it is completely out of reach for most lower income families. Plus they are always at a private school at the opposite end of the country to us which adds a good few hundred pounds to the overall costs. If you live nearby and just go for the day activities I am sure it is a fraction of the cost but there is nothing like that in our region. I'm spending about £300 on a single day's coaching next month, most of which is travel and accommodation. But if you want to progress beyond club/school level round here there's no real alternative.

Avondale89 · 29/06/2023 14:59

PedalStool · 29/06/2023 14:38

For every child who succeeds in these endeavours at private school, there are some who manage not to achieve in sport or music. I am looking at my own kids here ;-) They had no natural talent and we don’t have the drive and push either so they managed to ignore those kinds of opportunities. Did well academically though.

I am always interested when people talk about state school kids having ‘life experience’ and living in the ‘real world’. Private school kids also have life experience and live in a world that is real to them, but just different in some ways to state school kids.

But when I went to university, you couldn’t tell who had been at state or private. It was all a mishmash and did not show in academic or sport or musical achievement.

My god. I don’t know which university you went to, but at mine you could absolutely tell who went to private and who went to state. It was night and day.

My first boyfriend
was privately educated and I went to the local comp. The sports and music facilities he had available to him where absolutely unbelievable, compared to how awful they were in my school. Mind you, the school was much pushier about sport. He was pushed to play many sports for the school because he was good at it. My school had a much more relaxed attitude. He also had parents that paid for private tennis lessons etc.

mewkins · 29/06/2023 14:58

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 14:52

One or two clubs per week IS enough especially for primary aged kids

if you have the luxury to let the kids play football in the park after school, go on bike rides, go swimming and basically spend energy after school and at weekend, yes possibly.
But it's untrue that 2 clubs are enough when the alternative is to go home and watch tv.

We'll have to disagree on this. There are plenty of other options in between, both indoor and outdoor. I don't find them to be bursting with energy after a day at school.

notsallyrooney · 29/06/2023 14:53

Tigertealeaves · 29/06/2023 13:33

Haven't read the entire thread, but state music teacher here. We have additional funding so ALL our students have the chance for free instrument tuition - even 1:1 tutoring for free, if they will commit to attending ensembles. The teachers are professional musicians and are really good. Unfortunately many of the students simply don't appreciate the value of this (because free, or no family culture of valuing music) and practice is not always enforced at home. Or there is no practice space at home and the student refuses to stay after school. Students also drop out of rehearsals and concerts last minute, even lovely kids, and parents let them. Often they are dealing with so much outside school - amd within school. The students/families that do seize all the opportunities achieve up to grade 8... however when something is not being paid for, it appears to be taken less seriously. On the plus side, those who do engage are doing it from genuine love and not because a parent made them.

This is incredible, I wish my children's school offered this. (Or had a music teacher, at the moment... :D)

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 14:52

One or two clubs per week IS enough especially for primary aged kids

if you have the luxury to let the kids play football in the park after school, go on bike rides, go swimming and basically spend energy after school and at weekend, yes possibly.
But it's untrue that 2 clubs are enough when the alternative is to go home and watch tv.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 14:49

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:46

It may not produce 'better' sports people or musicians, but dd's sports day was packed with 17 year old girls still doing sport and running about not caring about being sweaty or bothered by what anyone thinks of them. Some were clearly fantastic athletes but lots were just regular girls who are fit, healthy and happy. That's priceless as far as I'm concerned.

This is actually a really important point. Early teens is prime age for girls to give up sport so I'm happy that DD is at a school that makes multiple sports compulsory and that they have 6 PE sessions per week. I don't care whether she is good at them, just that she enjoys them and is happy running around getting sweaty with a group of friends.

mewkins · 29/06/2023 14:49

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 14:32

I was reading comments on a famous FB parenting groups about clubs and after school activities.

You can tell all the difference the parents and their attitude make. It was shocking the number of posters proudly claiming they couldn't be bothered to take their children every day, and a club possibly 2 clubs a week was more than enough. The children could just "relax" at home and have pj days at the weekend.

Meanwhile, the ones who prioritise sport and education and make sacrifice to encourage via private, or physically chauffeur them around to their clubs have an enormous impact.

Money matters a lot, but it's not all. Some school sports or clubs with a small yearly fee are accessible.

One or two clubs per week IS enough especially for primary aged kids and it is a lot more than many kids are able to access. It's also kind of easier to say that it isn't down to money when it is. Taking children to and from activities is prohibitively expensive for many. Also if you're working long hours it might not be possible or else really exhausting to do this after a full day at work. Mine do a sport pretty much 5 days a week and I work full time. The giving lifts thing is knackering and requires confusing logistics as they mostly train in different locations from each other. I imagine that in many ways it is easier if the majority of extra curricular activities are taking place in school grounds.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:48

A week's training camp in the school holidays typically costs us £1200 - £1400 by the time you've added fuel and overnight stays on the way there and back

Blimey! What sport is it? Gold leaf origami? And I say that as the mother of a horse rider!

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 14:47

I am always interested when people talk about state school kids having ‘life experience’ and living in the ‘real world’. Private school kids also have life experience and live in a world that is real to them, but just different in some ways to state school kids.

knowing that "the real world" might just as well be an oversubscribed state school in a leafy privileged neighbourhood, or a struggling multi-cultural school in the worst gang-infected centre of a deprived area, I would ignore any reference to "life experience" 😂

Terryer · 29/06/2023 14:46

It may not produce 'better' sports people or musicians, but dd's sports day was packed with 17 year old girls still doing sport and running about not caring about being sweaty or bothered by what anyone thinks of them. Some were clearly fantastic athletes but lots were just regular girls who are fit, healthy and happy. That's priceless as far as I'm concerned.

MrsAvocet · 29/06/2023 14:44

XelaM · 29/06/2023 14:13

But it is possible for state school kids to access sports and music. Most private school kids train outside of school anyway, unless it's a boarding school.

It's possible for kids whose parents can afford it to access sports and music. And more parents who can afford independent education can also afford to fund extracurricular activities.
Plus there is a big difference between being able to access something and being able to excel at it. My DS plays a team sport. At grassroots level it is extremely inclusive. By the time you get to national level, at any age, the teams are almost entirely current/former private school pupils, and the relatively few state school pupils tend to be fairly well off too.
My son plays at regional level. The coaching is every week at a venue over 2 hours drive from our home. Matches are all over the country. This weekend we had two, in different cities several hundred miles apart and both 3-4 hours from home. A week's training camp in the school holidays typically costs us £1200 - £1400 by the time you've added fuel and overnight stays on the way there and back. Strangely, though there are some good kids from the nearby council estate who play at out local club, none is participating at regional or even county level. Why might that be I wonder? What mysterious factor could it be that is preventing kids from lower income families progressing? After all, they can access sport, there's no big secret.

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 14:42

My nieces and nephews go to a very good private school, my DH works with loads of people that send their child to private school, not one of them has kept up their instrument in year 9 let alone year10/11, sport yes but not an instrument as they are not to a standard that would be worth the compromise in reducing time spent on studies.

I went to a private school until I was 12 and actually yes, the classic instruments were pushed - I played the Cello and the Piano but we didn't produce anybody who went on to be in famous bands, in Hip Hop or even pop groups, so I am unsure how the OP can argue it produces 'better' musicians. If you are going to be 'good' in those genres, you need to be in an environment that encourages self expression something private schools are not keen on and you need to have experienced a bit of adversity, what do you experience in the bubble wrap of private school, where everyone is of the same wealth and background and where you have paid for that segregation from the rest of us!

GreatBigBoots · 29/06/2023 14:40

My job involves music for children and some of the most talented young musicians I know are at state schools. But having said that I also know that the percentage or privately educated pupils who play instruments is far higher then the percentage of state educated pupils and more of them continue with their instruments at senior school. The primary schools in my local area have next to no music facilities- the most any offer is 20mins a week with a peripatetic teacher with little choice of instrument (and at extra expense) or a choir run by a non-specialist member of staff. Secondary schools have a music department on paper but this is actually one teacher with very few resources. Most state secondary schools here offer less than one music lesson per week for pupils before CGSE options and those lessons are in large classes. None of the local schools have their own band/orchestra. The LEA music team tell me that number of pupils in LEA schools who play instruments has been falling every year since instrument lessons stopped being funded by the LEA.

Friends who send their children to local independent schools tell me that their children have very small classes, individual and group music lessons, a wide variety of instrument lessons available in school and lots of opportunities to try new instruments. The school day is longer to include the instrument lessons, sports and bands/orchestras etc but the parents' view is that this is much easier to manage than having to find music teachers and musical opportunities separately and juggle how to get their DC to them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread