Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
x2boys · 29/06/2023 16:37

I would say money talks and if you have the money to.send your child to.private school.you probably also m have the money to.spend on expensive hobbies

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 16:34

PedalStool · 29/06/2023 16:00

You should be careful re what you assume about someone you don’t know.

My point is that ‘real world’ has become synonymous with a life of poverty and hardship. Everyone lives in a world that is real for them.

I'm sorry but in no stretch of the imagination is private school the 'real world'.

If you go to a private school you do no one very clear fact about that person- that their parents are wealthy and that they are in the elite 7% of the population of Britain that go to private school. However, you look at it that is a fact.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 16:34

@Goldenbear i think the following privately educated people would argue that they didn't have to experience negative learning environments in order to be creative:

Coldplay, Lily Allen, Jamie T, Jack Peñate, Florence Welch, the Maccabees, Laura Marling and Mumford & Sons, Tom Hiddleston, Hugh Laurie, Damian Lewis, Eddie Redmayne and Dominic West.

Just to name a few!

TheOriginalEmu · 29/06/2023 16:30

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:51

It's a pity state can't follow that model. My children's provisions for music & sport is very limited. I would send them private if I could. My friends kids all seem so fit & sporty in comparison but then that's their family lifestyle outside school too.

it’s a pity that state schools can’t throw a ton of money at a select few kids and Chuck out the ones who aren’t good enough?

Terryer · 29/06/2023 16:29

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 16:28

@Goldenbear why is it a race to the bottom ie only valuing education for children if it involves being disrupted, threatened with knives etc? Because that somehow is to be valued above positive learning environments?
Are you saying that people can only be creative if they are in hostile situations? I would be more inclined to value your opinion if you could show me longitudinal studies which evidence your standpoint.
It is incredibly arrogant to ascert that private children have "all difficult experiences airbrushed out". Does this also include the private SEN schools too?
Of course private school buys privilege but it doesn't get rid of every negative experience/challenges for the DC.

Because its cool to pretend this is a positive thing for your kids.

Usernamen · 29/06/2023 16:28

caringcarer · 29/06/2023 11:59

I think it's about opportunities. At independent schools sports, music and drama are pushed to pupils. Typically Wednesday afternoon is for sports competitions. My DD went to an independent school and school started at 8.30 every morning sharp. It went on until 5.30pm every day except Wednesday when school finished at 12.30 then sports/activities all afternoon until 5.pm then prep go or 45 minutes every night except Wednesday. She had to go to school Saturdays for what was called a half day but it was from 8.30 until 4pm. If you were involved in a sports match then often later finish. She had to attend their chapel service once a month on a Sunday too. Very hard to get out of. She did get 2 week half term though. She did get excellent sports coaching and a lot of girls got into England under 18 hockey team. She also got opportunities to do first aid courses, learn 3 foreign languages plus Latin. She went to Spain for additional Spanish tuition for 6 weeks out of 8 week summer break where they went to a Spanish college every morning and sightseeing relaxing after 1pm. She had a friend on a music scholarship who played two different instruments to grade 8 and another to grade 6. She had to perform for parents quite frequently though. My DD was very popular and outgoing and absolutely loved her school days. She was very into drama and took part in many elaborate productions and the school choir too. I think if all children got these opportunities they could all be good at sports, drama, singing and playing musical instruments.

We don’t have children yet but what you’ve described is exactly what DP and I want for a future DC. Part of the reason we’re holding off having a child just yet is because we want to very comfortably afford top private school fees (ie not just about) so that there’s no risk we can’t send DC and have to go with state!

That being said DP’s family wouldn’t let a grandchild not be privately educated so would step in to help.

I’ve only ever seen the inverted snobbery on MN - everyone we know aspires to send their children to a private school.

I’m glad your daughter had such a great experience!

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 16:28

@Goldenbear why is it a race to the bottom ie only valuing education for children if it involves being disrupted, threatened with knives etc? Because that somehow is to be valued above positive learning environments?
Are you saying that people can only be creative if they are in hostile situations? I would be more inclined to value your opinion if you could show me longitudinal studies which evidence your standpoint.
It is incredibly arrogant to ascert that private children have "all difficult experiences airbrushed out". Does this also include the private SEN schools too?
Of course private school buys privilege but it doesn't get rid of every negative experience/challenges for the DC.

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 16:27

Terryer · 29/06/2023 16:04

I'm willing to stick my neck out and say the majority of modern classical UK composers went to private school. Probably not the rock and pop acts.

Not really sticking your neck out as very highly probable. No, I think you can pretty much guarantee that rock/indie/hip hop/drum and bass and pop have hardly any- so a majority of talented musicians are not privately educated!

EnergyJaguar · 29/06/2023 16:26

You pay for it. The school doesn’t provide it, you pay separately for music lessons (so you could do these out of school). And those that excel at sport do that sport outside of school. Eg they’ll only do netball for a term but it’s the outside club that skills them up.

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 16:25

If your classes are being disrupted, if your teachers are being sworn at and threatened then you are immersed in real life

I hate to break it to you.. but you do realise that not all children in state school have ever experienced this?

You have NO IDEA of state school in the real world, have you 😂

allmyliesaretrue · 29/06/2023 16:24

If you want sports/music opportunities for your children, in most cases you have to create them. They join the local squash/tennis/hockey/swimming club. Same with music. My eldest has grade 6 and grade 7 in two different instruments. 2nd has grade 4 and grade 8 in two instruments. Youngest had the same opportunities but no interest! Got a couple of grade 2s 😊

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 16:22

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 15:50

Because obviously no privately educated child ever encounters any adversity 🙄 Being a state school child doesn't mean you encounter adversity you know ie many wealthy parents choose not to send their kids to private yet still have protection of the magic money tree.
Lazy, boring stereotypes at play here!

Adversity that is cushioned by the good fortune of being wealthy is not going to be as challenging. Let's face it having lots of money does not really keep you in touch with the societal and cultural turbulence experienced by the rest of us. You can be wealthy and send your child to state school but you child will not be living in a bubble where they only have friends who are wealthy, where the school experience is only ever calm and a good one. If your classes are being disrupted, if your teachers are being sworn at and threatened then you are immersed in real life, it reflects what is on the outside of the school. If you go to a state school you will inevitably experience those disruptions and friends with difficult lives on a daily basis. Most people who are paying for a private education do so precisely to avoid this experience. When it comes to creativity, where's the source, if all the difficult experiences are airbrushed out.

Tigertealeaves · 29/06/2023 16:13

For those asking about my school's music programme - it's only in certain schools, not all. Sorry that this wasn't clear. We belong to a charity network that funds this provision (UK based). Provision in other schools varies a lot. I remember the days of free instrument lessons when I was at school via the music service, but often these are paid now... some music hubs will do bursaries though I think.

GodessOfThunder · 29/06/2023 16:10

Parents who send their kids to private school often have very conservative/conventional views of what their kids should be doing in terms of extra curricular stuff. Playing an orchestral instrument to a certain grade level is part and parcel with that. Meantime, the kids that actually come up with innovative musical ideas/styles that become globally popular (eg jungle, drill, grime dubstep, punk) are more likely to have grown up on an estate, have completed no musical grades and gone to a comp.

Foxesandsquirrels · 29/06/2023 16:08

If your children aren't at a private school, it's unlikely you know that many private school kids. Really not all of them are sporty or musical. What is obvious is the amount of opportunities money gives you. This is the case in state schools too. The sporty and musical state school kids will be coming from homes where someone can pay for instruments, music tuition, club fees. They will have parents that are home to supervise instrument practice and can drive them to sports and fixtures.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 16:04

I'm willing to stick my neck out and say the majority of modern classical UK composers went to private school. Probably not the rock and pop acts.

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 29/06/2023 16:03

Goldenbear
the school can't discriminate against people who don't have enough money.

😂ahem, back in the real world...

Your comment alone shows how ignorant you are of this 'real world' as you have no clue about how it works
what an interesting comment, as I said upthread, MY kids are in state school... 😂😂

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 29/06/2023 16:00

My kids are at an independent school. I'd describe them as unsporty but willing in one case; actively avoiding all forms of movement in the case of the older.
They also both play an instrument at Grade 1 level after 3/5 years [incl remote lessons during the pandemic] and ungraded [refuses to sit exams but does play in the junior orchestra. They have a 30 min lesson on site [charged additionally] weekly.
There are kids in the prep that are actively going for scholarships and are Grade 4 by Yr5. They have lessons both in and outside of school and I suspect are actively made to practice. My view is that you either have a passion for music or you don't. The horizon view of whether this is worth it financially is fast approaching for my kids.

I went to a state school and had none of the opportunities they have. Opportunity does not necessarily create talent, drive to succeed and enthusiasm for something. That comes from within and children will be just as talented within the state sector so YABU.

What is the key difference I think is the accessibility. Particularly as a working parent - I can't schlep them to afternoon activities all week. The fact that so many sports, music orchestras and school teams operate around school hours on site makes it very easy for me to say yes.

PedalStool · 29/06/2023 16:00

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 15:08

Even if you go to a comprehensive state school in a 'leafy privileged' area, the school can't discriminate against people who don't have enough money. You do realise that the large radius of intake for oversubscribed schools will inevitably include children in (brace yourself as you may feel queasy hearing the word) living in social housing or sharing a room with their Mum as they live in a bedsit and are in-between rentals, that live with their grandparents as their Dad is in prison and their Mum has left them. The disruption in classes, even in 'leafy privileged' areas has to be tolerated i.e they are not going to be able to expel those children, like they can easily do in private schools. Children fighting and bringing knives in to schools 'even' in 'leafy privileged' areas. Not having enough money to be driven around for sport events, even if they are organised (which is rare), being a latch key kid as your parents both have to work full time to pay their massive mortgage in a 'leafy privileged' area.

Your comment alone shows how ignorant you are of this 'real world' as you have no clue about how it works. There is a baseline of wealth for a child to be able to go to private school so there are 'no money' worries, this is very much not the 'real world' and when you pay for that segregation (which you are, even if you don't admit it), paying for your children to be protected from the realities of the not so attractive lives of others. So no, I don't think living in that bubble is exactly the setting for great self expression that is needed for creating the best musicians!

You should be careful re what you assume about someone you don’t know.

My point is that ‘real world’ has become synonymous with a life of poverty and hardship. Everyone lives in a world that is real for them.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 15:57

@Terryer yes or because they want their DC to develop resilience because obviously the only way you can do this is by attending a state school. Even though odds are that if they can afford to send their kids private but choose not to, that they won't be living in a council flat in inner city London! So chances are that their DC will be mixing in very similar socio-economic groups to those at private school!

Terryer · 29/06/2023 15:53

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 15:50

Because obviously no privately educated child ever encounters any adversity 🙄 Being a state school child doesn't mean you encounter adversity you know ie many wealthy parents choose not to send their kids to private yet still have protection of the magic money tree.
Lazy, boring stereotypes at play here!

The worst trope on here are the parents that insist they can afford private (you haven't said this Goldenbear) yet like to send their kids to the local state to learn empathy, as if it was some sort of poverty zoo.

GasPanic · 29/06/2023 15:52

They put more emphasis on those activities.

In my comp, you had to express an interest in these sorts of activities which were viewed I think in the school as peripheral to the main object of getting everyone out and in a state where they could read and write. Plus playing instruments was also seen as a bit geeky, and in my case it was a pain in the ass because I ended up missing some other lesson that I was really interested in - there was no time outside the academic cirriculum for it.

Whereas in private schools I think it is actively encouraged, if not an actual requirement. That and of course the facilities are better.

Most of the people I knew at university who were at private school seemed to play sport/instruments to a relatively high level compared to people from comps.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 15:50

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 15:45

'cope', you would hope so wouldn't you with the privileges you have afforded them in life and friends yes, you can buy the right kind of friends as well. Personally, I want my children to have developed empathy and a breadth of understanding of different ways of living which you will not get if there is no adversity around you and everyone's life is cushioned by the magic money tree. The creative process needs inspiration where is that from if all around you is the same.

The question is over the assertion of the OP that stated Private schools make 'better musicians', it simply isn't true or even evidenced.

Well I expect if private school kids grow up and feel they've missed out on a particular version of 'real life' they can go and work and volunteer in that area, as lots do. Personally I went to a rough state school back in the 80s and it wasn't a lovely illuminating experience, my best friends lived in council housing though, and I still grew up to send mine privately so go figure. Not sure everyone I went to school with grew up with boundless empathy either, some absolute wrong uns there. My private school educated kids are far more thoughtful and accepting than most of us were back in the day!

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 15:50

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 15:45

'cope', you would hope so wouldn't you with the privileges you have afforded them in life and friends yes, you can buy the right kind of friends as well. Personally, I want my children to have developed empathy and a breadth of understanding of different ways of living which you will not get if there is no adversity around you and everyone's life is cushioned by the magic money tree. The creative process needs inspiration where is that from if all around you is the same.

The question is over the assertion of the OP that stated Private schools make 'better musicians', it simply isn't true or even evidenced.

Because obviously no privately educated child ever encounters any adversity 🙄 Being a state school child doesn't mean you encounter adversity you know ie many wealthy parents choose not to send their kids to private yet still have protection of the magic money tree.
Lazy, boring stereotypes at play here!

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 29/06/2023 15:47

Music is slightly different I think, where a big boost comes from being in a musical family.

I'm thinking of perfect pitch — you can't develop that after about 5 or 6. So you need to either start lessons before that, or have somebody telling you the note names so you learn the mapping. If nobody told you the names of colours you'd never be able to name them, even though you could tell them apart. So without the involvement of somebody musical at a young age, you just won't have perfect pitch.

Swipe left for the next trending thread