Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Wisenotboring · 29/06/2023 21:37

Peony654 · 29/06/2023 12:04

But that stuff doesn’t matter in the real world. I’d much rather my kids grow up in the real world and learn some useful life skills

Whatever your opinion on private schools, that is such a sad attitude. Sports and music are truly life enhancing experiences that come with loads of benefits. Surely we shouldn't pit these against real life, whatever that means (different people have very different experiences of life on a day to day basis around the world). Shouldn't we want our children to be well equipped to interact and be productive members of society with the rounded experiences that sports, music and the arts offer?

Appleandoranges · 29/06/2023 21:31

Agree with previous poster. Private school kids are only better at sports which are accessible at private school - cricket, rowing and other sports like that. In sports, which are available at both private school and state school eg football and athletics, state schools do better! Also with music, it's largely to do with funding and parents of private school children better able to fund music lessons. With access to Oxbridge, private schools more likely to be able to support children to do degrees such as classics/medieval languages/russian. That means that they will get more places in Oxbridge too through getting numbers into more obscure courses.

Mortgagewoes1 · 29/06/2023 21:21

Everyone at my private school (secondary) who had been private since young was on the county team for sports I didn't even know existed. They were already decent hockey players before I'd even held a hockey stick.

Money. That's all it is.

My daughter could be amazing at tennis - but we simply can't afford to keep up with the kids who are doing really well. Tournaments weekly are £20, privates weekly are £40. Most decent kids are having 2 or more privates a week, tournaments every week and then travelling on top.

It's 100% due to how much money you've got. The most talented kids are probably on the council estates.

GodessOfThunder · 29/06/2023 21:14

Are private school kids better at sports than state school kids? The numbers show private school kids are disproportionately successful at an elite level in the obvious “posh sports”: rowing, show jumping, polo, yachting, cricket, rugby union etc.

But, let’s face it no one gives a shit about those sports on any real scale.

Are they better at football? Nope.

And state school kids are more dominant in cycling, martial arts.

I wish opportunity was more equitable, but the poshos can keep their clay pigeon shooting and whatnot.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 21:06

GodessOfThunder · 29/06/2023 21:01

What’s wrong with grime? Eski beat is as good as anything required for grade 8, say, clarinet.

You are batshit 🤣🤣🤣

caringcarer · 29/06/2023 21:01

@Denimrevival, my dd got an academic scholarship. Her friend had a music scholarship and both got burseries too. My DD did play the piano but only to grade 5. She had a good singing voice though and got some good parts in school plays and musicals and sang in the school choir. She was in the swimming squad too. She is very outgoing and gets very involved in things. She did Bronze and Silver DoE awards too and was in their Air Cadets too, she did lots of marching drills.

GodessOfThunder · 29/06/2023 21:01

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 20:54

I really hope you've made them all aware that they have destroyed all hope of being creative by attending private school? Also I hope you've rammed their privilege down their throats and your opinion that they don't live in the real world?

What’s wrong with grime? Eski beat is as good as anything required for grade 8, say, clarinet.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 20:56

Goldenbear do you lecture their parents in the iniquities of private school ans you have on this thread - and how their appalling, privileged lives will forever deny them the opportunity to be grime and rap artists?

Snort.

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 20:54

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 18:33

I have been on MN a very long time pretty sure I haven't made up my DC for 16 years!

My nieces and nephews all go to private school. Plus I know loads of extended family on DH's side that went and go to private school. One of DDs friends went for year 7 the stuff she comes out with is disheartening tbh. She is a nice girl b

I really hope you've made them all aware that they have destroyed all hope of being creative by attending private school? Also I hope you've rammed their privilege down their throats and your opinion that they don't live in the real world?

Barbadossunset · 29/06/2023 20:42

I have nieces and nephews at private secondary school so have a very good insight in to that life

Goldenbear do you lecture their parents in the iniquities of private school ans you have on this thread - and how their appalling, privileged lives will forever deny them the opportunity to be grime and rap artists?
I bet they give you a wide berth at family occasions.

dinozzo · 29/06/2023 20:38

My beautiful son, our only child died 3 years ago, he had a brain haemorhage and donated his organs, he gave life to 4 men, our love was 22 years old. We were an Army family, he had three primary schools, and then two secondary schools, when we moved home he excelled and did a Masters Degree in Aeorspace engineering, he was also a brilliant guitarist. He had the most beautiful childhood, we lived in army quarters, not much money, but he had a brilliant education which wasn't private. He would now have a phd in Aerospace engineering, we miss him xo

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 20:26

@Sheselectric77 you are wasting your breath. I'm sure they are a troll just from the ludicrous things they have posted

Sheselectric77 · 29/06/2023 20:19

@Goldenbear you have no idea what life is like for anyone other than the few families you know personally and even then you only know a smidge of their real lives. Regardless of what type of school creates the better musician, you have a bit of a cheek coming here talking about ‘real life’ when you sit in a position of privilege yourself. You have nieces at private school and having a dh who is an architect is someone who has privilege. Living in a disadvantaged community and going to a failing school is real life but so is living in a detached and going to private school. Do you honestly think children who go to private school do not experience abuse, violence, drugs, crime, death, neglect etc because I can tell you with absolute certainty that they do. No one is immune to real life.
Living in poverty, experiencing violence and disruptive behaviour and leaving school with no qualifications does not make you more creative. It makes you traumatised and living in permanent fight or flight. It’s obvious to me you have never experienced any of what you claim goes on in ‘real life’. Do you think these people would pass up an opportunity to get out of this in order to retain their proposed creativity.
If anyone could shield their dc from trauma then you would do it without question. Dc in private school are not always guaranteed this just like state educated dc.

Also not all dc in private school are in the top 7%. Many are there on bursaries or through sen provided places. Some dc in private have just above average earning parents. Just like yourself.

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 20:18

ReachForTheMars · 29/06/2023 13:08

This feels beyond obvious.

Because it gets a stronger focus. My siblings kids are private and they are expected to spend most of their Saturdays doing sport. They do more, they get better.

There are also scholarships and bursaries for kids the school think they can show off like prestigious little trophies.

Parents put money in, kids get better resources, kids get better results. Not rocket science.

Plus, if you really want to put the boot in for the poor little state school children compared to their excelling private school peers, perhaps you can even make a nice little link to poverty and obesity and attainment.

Unfortunately the obese bit is somewhat true.. You don't often see an overweight kid from a private school. Our jr parkrun had lots of kids from the local private, they are all very lithe & very fast. You would think they would take a Sunday off, but they are there rearing to go at 9.30am🤣

OP posts:
Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 20:09

caringcarer · 29/06/2023 12:54

@Denimrevival my DD got a scholarship. I could never afford £6720 per term. That is today's price. It would have been less when she went. I used to struggle to pay the extras stationery, dt materials, activity charges and extortionate uniform cost. I used the second hand uniform shop and it was still extortionate. She did have a very happy childhood/school days though and made some great friends. We used to have her Chinese friend over some half terms because it was too far to fly home for two weeks. I used to have her over for dinner sometimes too. Her Chinese friend has hosted her in China several times and the family insisted on paying for her air fares every time she's been. She is still in contact with her. Also she has a Spanish friend who we hosted one year on an exchange trip and my DD stayed with her in Spain and they still now, go across and stay at each others houses. Both are very good friends now and I was invited to her Spanish friend's wedding too. If she went to the local comp I doubt she would have met those friends. Her Chinese friend/family is fabulously wealthy though and went ott at my DD wedding on her wedding gift.

That sounds amazing & her music really paid off for her? Does she still play? It's a great gift to be able to give a child x

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 29/06/2023 20:08

"Enrichment in state schools could be greatly increased."

Have you been living under a rock, OP?! Paying to attention whatsoever to the teachers' strikes and the reasons for them?

There is a massive crisis in education caused by chronic underfunding. Teachers are leaving the profession in droves."Enrichment", while I value music and sport, is the absolute least of our worries in state education.

Amillionyearsago · 29/06/2023 20:05

As far as music goes, I think it’s because there is a culture where the kids are very much expected to practice every day. I don’t think there’s any specific secret to it - they aren’t suddenly bestowed with musical abilities when they walk through the gates of a private school - but among DDs friends, they would be embarrassed to say that they never practised. (This isn’t any kind of value judgement - I sure as hell never practised when I was a kid!)

DD’s school facilitates music lessons within the school day but the parents have to pay extra for them. I think the rate is pretty similar to the going rate for music lessons with local music teachers in our city. In that sense, the kids’ ability to play instruments is obviously dependent on whether their families can afford it - and that’s really not ok - but they fact that they are at a private school is a bit of a red herring, I think - a state school educated child whose parents had the money for lessons could in theory arrange the same thing, albeit with more running around and inconvenience.

Obviously the wider question is whether schools should be providing more music education generally - and of course they should. I think it’s appalling that kids in deprived areas might get so little. But in our case at least, I do think that it’s about whether or not your parents can afford individual music tuition rather than anything that the school itself is or is not doing as part of the regular school day. The bad guys in this scenario are those who’ve been underfunding state schools such that children from deprived communities don’t get what they should.

BCCoach · 29/06/2023 20:03

SchoolShenanigans · 29/06/2023 18:18

YANBU.

The only adult cyclists I've known (as in proper cyclists with outfits and skinny wheels) are private schooled.

They have an unfair advantage in so many ways, but thats capitalism

I’m a cycling coach and the overwhelming majority of the members of my local club, and all the youth riders I coach, come from very ordinary backgrounds. Yes, we have the local GP and a couple of solicitors, but we also have electricians, nurses, gardeners, tree surgeons, police officers, council workers, teachers, shop workers, SAHMs, artists, farm workers, plumbers, retirees and many others. Oh and quite a few forces veterans.

£25 a year membership (free for youth members). Coaching £3 a session. Yes you need a bike, but once that purchase has been made it’s not a particular expensive sport. I’ve never seen a private school cycling team at a youth race either.

Popsicle42 · 29/06/2023 20:01

Daughter is at private school. Crap at sport and music.

olivehaters · 29/06/2023 19:52

I havent RTFT so just going to answer the OPs question in my experience. My kids go to state school in a nice area. Their cousins go to a private school. There are definitely more music and sports provisions for their cousins. Their parents both work full time and the school sorts everything bar one of their hobbies. I work part time and am run ragged taxying my kids about to after school sports. I couldn't easily do it with a full time job. As a result my kids are all very sporty. So it is possible. I guess there are a few less opportunities for my mine especially music wise. My kids Christmas concert is at the local church. Their cousins at the cathedral. Their sports presentations were at a village hall, their cousins was a full dinner with speakers. We could prob afford private and I wouldn't have to do all the taxying but I prefer for my kids to grow up in a village community.

x2boys · 29/06/2023 19:46

Local.to me*

x2boys · 29/06/2023 19:46

purser25 · 29/06/2023 17:15

Two England football captains went to the same state comprehensive school

The Neville brothers went to a,State school.local.to ,quite a nice area though and there parents were both quite well known locally ,their Dad played cricket for the county,and their mum played netball ,so I guess they had contacts
Jason ,Kenny ,Peter Kay and Paddy Mc guineas all attended.the high school.my son had just left

twistyizzy · 29/06/2023 19:46

Foxesandsquirrels · 29/06/2023 19:29

That's very low! Where in the country are you? It's min £7,500 per term here for mainstream day. DD is moving to a specialist dyslexia school and that's £13,000 per term for a day place. It's insane.

Northern England. 15K per year for Day pupil in Senior school so actually would be 105K for 7 years

OneTwoThreeShake · 29/06/2023 19:38

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 16:34

I'm sorry but in no stretch of the imagination is private school the 'real world'.

If you go to a private school you do no one very clear fact about that person- that their parents are wealthy and that they are in the elite 7% of the population of Britain that go to private school. However, you look at it that is a fact.

This whole thread is full of wild assumptions but yours are beyond ridiculous. You're painting a picture of state schools being akin to a ghetto, and private schools being full of kids who don't experience life.

I lived in social housing. My mum juggled bills so would choose which one to pay late. I earned a full scholarship for private school, with offers from 5 others. There was a fairly diverse mix of kids. Some were incredibly wealthy, some were just children of parents with decent jobs and some were like me.

I went to a state school for a short time because we moved house and I needed somewhere to just finish the school year, and the 2 schools were worlds apart in terms of maturity and conduct. Debate was actively encouraged at private school, and we were challenged to see issues from varying perspectives. And then we had numerous volunteering groups and societies. When I was a teenager I volunteered with asylum seekers, homeless people and the elderly. And it wasn't unusual in my school by any means. Those things didn't exist in my state school.

Sorry, but I think your claims are wildly wrong, smack of inverted snobbery and demonstrate you have very little lived understanding of the setting. It isn't Mallory Towers, and most are nothing like Eton.

musicalmrs · 29/06/2023 19:34

I'm a musician who teaches both both state and privately educated students (and home educated too!). If I were to compare the amount of practice, I'd say on average the private students do more than the state ones per week - I imagine that's down to parents bugging them. However, at the moment I'd say I have several passionate, hard working state educated primary children who are progressing at far faster rates than the private ones are.

So that would suggest it's probably a lot to do with the mindset of parents (and then children) at private schools, making sure practise happens. It's also down to cost, as music tuition is expensive. But I believe that state educated children can excel at both sport and music if they're offered the same opportunities and they are encouraged and pushed (in the best possible way!) by their parents.