Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Welshwabbit · 29/06/2023 22:54

I am the least sporty and least musical member of my comprehensively schooled family and I have grade 4 on one instrument and grade 5 on another and swam for my county. People are just different.

amicissimma · 29/06/2023 22:49

I think it's partly about expectations.

My DC went to a school where all children in year 3 were asked which instrument they would like to learn, not whether or not they would like to learn a musical instrument. The local music shop, which hired instruments, would bring in a selection for the children to try, which led to custom for them. There was a charity that subsidised families who couldn't afford the rental and even lessons, but there were group lessons, in school, which kept the costs down. The school had several orchestras to suit all abilities and any instrument-playing parents were asked to help. It was wonderful to watch young children concentrating so hard in a performance so that they wouldn't get their part wrong.

This was a state primary.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 29/06/2023 22:48

I don't think it really matters what the sport is.

If it's to increase fitness/stamina/skill, help you to learn to win and lose gracefully, work as a team, not give up, help you to think strategically in a high pressure environment etc. then you can get that equally well from lacrosse or football.

babybythesea · 29/06/2023 22:45

I would like to do away with private schools.
Not because I begrudge the children there those opportunities but because I feel really strongly that all kids deserve those opportunities. I’d love to think that not having private school would throw some more opportunities open for all the rest (I know, cloud cuckoo land..)

I hate the fact that we are scrabbling round trying to stick work in with no functioning glue sticks because we can’t afford any, while the school down the road is offering instrument lessons and swimming lessons as standard.
The children in my class don’t deserve the dregs of what is left, they deserve the best. All the more so because some of them have not had a good start.

I don’t hate kids going to private schools as such. I hate that I can’t give the same opportunity to every child because they all deserve it, not just a select few.

Are those at private school better than the children I’ve got? Inherently, no. They aren’t. But with all the extras mine haven’t had? Yes, they probably are now. Because they grew up going to clubs and lessons. Not sitting quietly in a corner of someone else’s house because mum is a cleaner and had no one to leave them with. Or looking after three younger brothers every night. Or not reading because mum can’t read and so can’t help. My children are the bees knees but it’s stacked against them and I really feel the unfairness when I see kids who already have a lot going for them getting far better chances than my lot.

Rant over!

noworklifebalance · 29/06/2023 22:24

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 16:57

I would say having everything handed to you on a platter makes life a bit more bearable than your state school contemporaries. Next you are going to argue that actually your poor children have been discriminated against in Oxbridge applications due to state school applicants been given more leaway on grades🙄

I think a lot of good Art is understanding and experiencing the dichotomies that exist in life- poverty v wealth, segregation v integration, these don't really exist in the private school world. Don't have any studies, don't need any to tell me that!

What about people who go to private school that experience unconscious (or conscious) bias because of the race, sex, sexuality etc in all aspects of life?

Does a white, straight, male from a state school in a middle-class area with engaged and financially comfortable parents from a happy family life have more relevant life experience than a non-white, female, gay student that went to private school?

Some of the generalisation and inverse snobbery on this thread beggars belief.
I went to a state school.

mewkins · 29/06/2023 22:23

blueballoony · 29/06/2023 22:05

They are not sportier or more musically able on entry. What these dc do have though is exposure of arts and sports from birth due to having parents who were also exposed to similar things. And then the cycle continues.

Of course there are fantastic sports people and musicians in state schools too but generally the dc in state schools are from more diverse backgrounds than in a private school so although it appears all the dc are good at private school it's actually because they're from a similar 'pool' of people who want to achieve this stuff before these dc were even born.

I think that's a bit of an assumption. I live round the corner from a prep school - I live in the home counties. I feel pretty confident in saying that I'm not sure there would be much of an exposure to 'the arts' in many of those households😅

PurposefulBear · 29/06/2023 22:22

They don’t do it in school. They do most of it out of school and the school takes the credit.

Comes down to the parents mostly.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 22:20

GodessOfThunder · 29/06/2023 21:53

Well that needs to be stopped. We don’t want to end up like US universities.

Who's going to stop it? You? Bad luck. She's just graduated with a first and gone into the NHS, so you'll probably benefit from the decision somewhere down the line.

TheaBrandt · 29/06/2023 22:16

I didn’t say doing activities is pointless 🙄My own dc do activities they enjoy. Just that they are not a golden ticket to get into university - parents with younger children I have spoken to seem to think this is the case and it’s not.

Barbadossunset · 29/06/2023 22:16

You thing that because a child goes to private school they won’t experience adversity such as physical/emotional/sexual abuse, parental loss, broken families, bullying etc.
Not sure who needs to live in the real work - you or them?
How judgmental you are.

I agree. However, I’ve seen on mumsnet before this idea that if someone is ‘posh’ then they are wholly immune to the adversities that you mention - or that because they’re posh they deserve it.

noworklifebalance · 29/06/2023 22:12

Goldenbear · 29/06/2023 16:22

Adversity that is cushioned by the good fortune of being wealthy is not going to be as challenging. Let's face it having lots of money does not really keep you in touch with the societal and cultural turbulence experienced by the rest of us. You can be wealthy and send your child to state school but you child will not be living in a bubble where they only have friends who are wealthy, where the school experience is only ever calm and a good one. If your classes are being disrupted, if your teachers are being sworn at and threatened then you are immersed in real life, it reflects what is on the outside of the school. If you go to a state school you will inevitably experience those disruptions and friends with difficult lives on a daily basis. Most people who are paying for a private education do so precisely to avoid this experience. When it comes to creativity, where's the source, if all the difficult experiences are airbrushed out.

You thing that because a child goes to private school they won’t experience adversity such as physical/emotional/sexual abuse, parental loss, broken families, bullying etc.
Not sure who needs to live in the real work - you or them?
How judgmental you are.

Ceci03 · 29/06/2023 22:10

I am disappointed in my sons state school that has an excellent reputation. No after school sports?? V disappointing. 1 football team picked from the whole year so I reckon about 350 kids and only 1 team. They have tennis courts but have never seen anyone use them. Am very happy with the school just disappointed in the sports. I guess it comes down to money in the end. Private schools seem to definitely start earlier and end later than the state schools so can fit in more extra curricular stuff. Plus loads more after school sports and clubs

bigageap · 29/06/2023 22:08

OP you keep saying oh but these kids do more outside of school as well. What’s stopping your kids doing more. So if it bothers you then have them doing more at the weekends/after school. My son isn’t in a private school and has access to numerous sports but he was already decent as he had wanted to do loads outside of school on top of that sports start at 7.45 5 days a week then sports every lunch time and every after school in the summer so you have to be motivated plus his school would only except kids at certain grades for the orchestra.

blueballoony · 29/06/2023 22:05

They are not sportier or more musically able on entry. What these dc do have though is exposure of arts and sports from birth due to having parents who were also exposed to similar things. And then the cycle continues.

Of course there are fantastic sports people and musicians in state schools too but generally the dc in state schools are from more diverse backgrounds than in a private school so although it appears all the dc are good at private school it's actually because they're from a similar 'pool' of people who want to achieve this stuff before these dc were even born.

mewkins · 29/06/2023 21:59

Wisenotboring · 29/06/2023 21:48

The comment i was responding to said that sports and music don't matter in the real world and the poster would rather their children learnt useful skills for real life. They are arguably not essential and can certainly be accessed via means other than private school but that is not what the poster said.

I guess being good at them doesn't really matter unless you're one of the tiny number of people who are lucky enough to get a job in those fields. This from someone who learnt clarinet all through school! Music is incredibly important to me but there are lots of ways to appreciate music. Sadly no one gives a shit about my distinction in grade 5 clarinet 😄😄

Barbadossunset · 29/06/2023 21:58

The sports private school kids do well in are largely sports that a) require cash b) no one really cares about

Godess which sports do people care about - apart from football?

VickyEadieofThigh · 29/06/2023 21:56

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:55

@JoWawa is that something they should be looked at in state schools so more enrichment can be offered to close the gap?

Instead of sitting on all those countless millions of pounds that state schools just refuse to spend on state of the art music and sports facilities and additional staff, you mean?

GodessOfThunder · 29/06/2023 21:53

Terryer · 29/06/2023 21:48

Don’t worry - when it comes to university applications they don’t give a shiny shit about your flute or whether you did d of e. Plus many applications for jobs now are school and university blind. Efforts are being made to dilute the privilege money can buy

Dc1 got a lower offer to her uni because she'd been top 20 in her niche posh sport and they excel in it. Sorry.

Well that needs to be stopped. We don’t want to end up like US universities.

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 29/06/2023 21:53

I went to a private secondary and showed zero aptitude for either.

I was desperately unsporty - always last at everything. I did manage the recorder ok but attempting to move onto the guitar betrayed my complete lack of natural talent.

GodessOfThunder · 29/06/2023 21:52

Terryer · 29/06/2023 21:46

*evel in the obvious “posh sports”: rowing, show jumping, polo, yachting, cricket, rugby union etc.

But, let’s face it no one gives a shit about those sports on any real scale.

Are they better at football? Nope.

And state school kids are more dominant in cycling, martial arts*

Yeah, noone gives a shit about rowing, rugby league and cricket. Everyone is thrilled by martial arts. What are you on about?!

theres no real scale of regular interest in the vast majority of sports, yep, including martial arts :) Cricket and rugby noon are followed by a small percentage of the country. The sports private school kids do well in are largely sports that a) require cash b) no one really cares about

Terryer · 29/06/2023 21:48

Don’t worry - when it comes to university applications they don’t give a shiny shit about your flute or whether you did d of e. Plus many applications for jobs now are school and university blind. Efforts are being made to dilute the privilege money can buy

Dc1 got a lower offer to her uni because she'd been top 20 in her niche posh sport and they excel in it. Sorry.

Wisenotboring · 29/06/2023 21:48

mewkins · 29/06/2023 21:45

Absolutely no one is pitting them against real life. We're just acknowledging that formal music tuition particularly is expensive. A lot of us have said that arguably many/most of the best/most interesting popular musicians attended state schools.

The comment i was responding to said that sports and music don't matter in the real world and the poster would rather their children learnt useful skills for real life. They are arguably not essential and can certainly be accessed via means other than private school but that is not what the poster said.

Terryer · 29/06/2023 21:46

*evel in the obvious “posh sports”: rowing, show jumping, polo, yachting, cricket, rugby union etc.

But, let’s face it no one gives a shit about those sports on any real scale.

Are they better at football? Nope.

And state school kids are more dominant in cycling, martial arts*

Yeah, noone gives a shit about rowing, rugby league and cricket. Everyone is thrilled by martial arts. What are you on about?!

Wisenotboring · 29/06/2023 21:45

TheaBrandt · 29/06/2023 12:15

Don’t worry - when it comes to university applications they don’t give a shiny shit about your flute or whether you did d of e. Plus many applications for jobs now are school and university blind. Efforts are being made to dilute the privilege money can buy.

My child doesn't go to private school as some kind of fast pass to university. I value these experiences in their own right. Viewing them as a tick list to get somewhere seems a bit joyless and also a set up for disappointment. There are some very bitter views on this thread.

mewkins · 29/06/2023 21:45

Wisenotboring · 29/06/2023 21:37

Whatever your opinion on private schools, that is such a sad attitude. Sports and music are truly life enhancing experiences that come with loads of benefits. Surely we shouldn't pit these against real life, whatever that means (different people have very different experiences of life on a day to day basis around the world). Shouldn't we want our children to be well equipped to interact and be productive members of society with the rounded experiences that sports, music and the arts offer?

Absolutely no one is pitting them against real life. We're just acknowledging that formal music tuition particularly is expensive. A lot of us have said that arguably many/most of the best/most interesting popular musicians attended state schools.

Swipe left for the next trending thread