Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
grass321 · 30/06/2023 07:24

I used to find it 😱😱😱 that many private schools don’t offer football but then realised it’s because they don’t win at it competitively because state school kids are better at it, because it doesn’t require £££ to play it.

I think it's probably more of a snobbery thing of rugby v football. Although some parents dislike the physical element of rugby (I think Habs parents recently voted to replace rugby with football).

Schools tend to set their fixtures to play schools of a similar standard. We play Eton and Harrow at cricket and hockey but not at rugby as it would be one-sided (they're far better). The exception would be cup competitions but even those are streamed after the first couple of rounds into main, plate etc.

I went to a state school but I don't think it's about criticising private schools for dominating elite level sport, it's about how to help the state schools provide a better level of sport. Which is hard as it comes down to funding, both for facilities and specialist coaching. And not all parents/teachers want to have their Saturdays taken up by school matches.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 07:22

blueballoony · 30/06/2023 00:14

@mewkins I am one such parent with a dc at a prep in the Home Counties. Our entire cohort are well advanced of the average local parent and the prep parents know exactly what their dc will be doing with regards to learning instruments etc before they even start school. The school also likes to take a lot of credit for outside efforts too. Our dc learn instruments and train for sports outside of school on top of what the school offers. Schools likes to make them the poster dc for their school. This is our second prep. They were both the same in that matter. What you see in the schools PR brochure is more representative of parents efforts generally.

Picking a musical instrument for your unborn child really dies not equate to 'exposure to art before birth' though. Having aspirations for your child isn't the same as being knowledgeable about art and culture.

I also think the OP's assertion about sports is off too. Sport isn't class based. Dressage, rowing etc maybe but sport itself no.

I'm not even going to touch your comment about being 'well ahead of the average local parent'. 🙄

Sycamorethanever · 30/06/2023 07:14

I used to find it 😱😱😱 that many private schools don’t offer football but then realised it’s because they don’t win at it competitively because state school kids are better at it, because it doesn’t require £££ to play it.

Which then makes you think about all other sports and how it is all so skewed in the privileged’s favour and it makes me feel a bit sick.

whatchagonnado · 30/06/2023 06:50

@montysma1 absolutely right.
Talent is innate- and a good musician is born with a good ear. Great athletes are born with physical attributes that set them apart from others i.e. long arms and legs .
All the private schools do is offer facilities, resources, opportunities and encouragement. That's also present in a lot of great state schools. So sorry OP, don't agree that those who go to private school are more talented.

CurlewKate · 30/06/2023 06:46
  1. For clarity, Universities do not base offers on extra curricular activities.
  2. Rich/privileged children are not inherently cleverer/more musical/better at sport than poorer/less privileged ones. They just get more opportunities because they are richer/privileged. It's not rocket surgery!
grass321 · 30/06/2023 06:40

There was an interesting set of statistics produced on this. The least well represented sport is hockey - which makes sense as water based astro pitches are expensive (and take a lot of space).

It can also be a self fulfilling prophecy. Our local state schools are academically excellent. The reason that we chose private is that my kids love sport and the facilities and coaching is excellent. If they weren't keen on sport (or drama/music), I'd have chosen a state school as I'd feel I was 'paying' for something we weren't using.

It's not just the sportiest kids they cater for though. Our school runs A-E teams for rugby, cricket and hockey in the early years of secondary. If the standard is high to make the As, it also encourages kids to practise on their own, go to the gym etc.

But it varies widely among the state schools (as with private schools). Two of our local state schools are strong at rugby, but others don't put out any rugby teams. Ditto for cricket. Not sure about football as our school doesn't play it, I'm guessing this is well represented in state schools as it's a popular sport.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?
Lulu1919 · 30/06/2023 06:37

Parents can afford school fees they can afford music lessons..music lessons as part of curriculum taken by specialised music teachers
More musicians mean bands orchestras are formed in school
Sport....they play sport min an hour a day plus matches all afternoon on Wednesdays and enter competitions against other indie schools....again specialised sorts staff teaching them

So time...money ...

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/06/2023 06:24

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 30/06/2023 00:27

I think family can be just as impactful as school tbh. I went to a state school - played 4 instruments; played sports both inside and outside of school; attended dance classes; and volunteered in the community.
Our friends' DCs are in state school. Both had represented their country (junior teams) in their chosen sports by age 14.

Yes, it is mainly about family, not school.

Some parents will ensure that their kids have opportunities to fulfil their potential. In some cases, the opportunities that private schools offer might be a part of this. In others, the parents might choose to rely on alternative options instead.

The common factors are a) that the parents care enough to make the effort, and b) that the parents have the financial resources necessary to facilitate this.

There are plenty of kids in state schools who excel in music, sport etc, but they do need parental support to help them make the most of their talents.

GodessOfThunder · 30/06/2023 06:08

Terryer · 29/06/2023 22:20

Who's going to stop it? You? Bad luck. She's just graduated with a first and gone into the NHS, so you'll probably benefit from the decision somewhere down the line.

Well, if she was capable of getting a first, she was capable of getting into a decent university without a lower offer due to being good at clay-pigeon shooting, or whatever. So, we’re good to do away with lower grade offers based on one’s ability to, say, get a horse to jump over some stuff.

bumblebee2235 · 30/06/2023 04:12

Nah I think it's the parents in most cases. I'm a musician by trade, starting piano lessons after school age 6, was in an orchestra throughout primary playing flute too, then also had violin lessons. Went state school initially.. it was funded and supported by my parents. Once my school saw it, the state school funded and brought in a teacher on my lunch breaks.

I almost quit many times but my family encouraged it, they wanted my brother and I to have a hobby.

I had a family friend who went to a top private school and he completely flunked. Point blank refused to engage.

You can lead a horse to water but can't make it drink.

Having supportive parents is a deal breaker alongside a child that wants to do it. Not all children will engage themselves, depends where their interest rests.

Plus I find state schools all so different. There is one notorious around where I live for bullying, it's still rife now 30 years on.. but then I've seen some state schools that have a pool and facilities. Likewise with private, there are some amazing ones and some awful ones.

montysma1 · 30/06/2023 01:43

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 29/06/2023 11:54

As above, it's opportunities and privilege. I'm a really good singer and often have people express that they wish they could sing (a talent that is often assumed to be innate).

It's lessons. And practice. Something that private school children get in spades.

Its also inate. I am a prof singer. I sounded like a prof singer long before I had ever had a singing lesson ( to non experts at least). I also teach singing.

Lessons can't give you a voice or musicality they simply refine what you already have.

However with respect to the OP, music and sporting success in school is largely due to opportunity, expectation and quality tuition.
State schools will have the same proportion of kids with potential talent. They just won't have the same opportunities to develop their talent. They might even go through school and nobody ever notices their spark.

Makes me angry really.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 30/06/2023 00:44

The OP did say private school pupils were sportier and more musical. That was exactly their point.

HRTQueen · 30/06/2023 00:39

*talented children in state school

HRTQueen · 30/06/2023 00:38

I don’t think anyone is saying you do not have exceptionally talented In state school

in private school the average child the facilities, small classes, more teachers, schools not having to deal with disruptive pupils that impacts classes allows for children to more likely reach their potential

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 30/06/2023 00:29

Oh and the only professional orchestral musicians I know, also attended state schools.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 30/06/2023 00:27

I think family can be just as impactful as school tbh. I went to a state school - played 4 instruments; played sports both inside and outside of school; attended dance classes; and volunteered in the community.
Our friends' DCs are in state school. Both had represented their country (junior teams) in their chosen sports by age 14.

HRTQueen · 30/06/2023 00:26

More opportunities and often great facilities

then more teachers who just teach those subjects

money can make talent

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 00:24

Sheselectric77 · 29/06/2023 20:19

@Goldenbear you have no idea what life is like for anyone other than the few families you know personally and even then you only know a smidge of their real lives. Regardless of what type of school creates the better musician, you have a bit of a cheek coming here talking about ‘real life’ when you sit in a position of privilege yourself. You have nieces at private school and having a dh who is an architect is someone who has privilege. Living in a disadvantaged community and going to a failing school is real life but so is living in a detached and going to private school. Do you honestly think children who go to private school do not experience abuse, violence, drugs, crime, death, neglect etc because I can tell you with absolute certainty that they do. No one is immune to real life.
Living in poverty, experiencing violence and disruptive behaviour and leaving school with no qualifications does not make you more creative. It makes you traumatised and living in permanent fight or flight. It’s obvious to me you have never experienced any of what you claim goes on in ‘real life’. Do you think these people would pass up an opportunity to get out of this in order to retain their proposed creativity.
If anyone could shield their dc from trauma then you would do it without question. Dc in private school are not always guaranteed this just like state educated dc.

Also not all dc in private school are in the top 7%. Many are there on bursaries or through sen provided places. Some dc in private have just above average earning parents. Just like yourself.

Actually, I'm afraid the 7% figure is the percentage of children in Britain that got to private school so, yes, that include those on Bursaries and as well all know those are handed out like candy and cover all the fees?? So yes, if you got to private school however 'average' your income is, private school is not accessible to or is not accessed by 93% of the country- are a majority of these people loaded but choice not to do the best for their children.

Some of these arguments are laughable, going to great lengths to point out how disadvantaged the poor private school children are. If you go to one of the biggest comprehensives in the country and it is south London, yes, regardless of your middle class credentials, believe me you very much do experience 'real life'. Anyone who can argue that the private pupils are the poor unfortunates and life is going to be more challenging than attendance at a huge London Comp is deluded and has evidently only ever known privilege.

blueballoony · 30/06/2023 00:18

@babybythesea I'm interested how shutting private schools will help those in state schools play instruments or do more sports?

blueballoony · 30/06/2023 00:14

@mewkins I am one such parent with a dc at a prep in the Home Counties. Our entire cohort are well advanced of the average local parent and the prep parents know exactly what their dc will be doing with regards to learning instruments etc before they even start school. The school also likes to take a lot of credit for outside efforts too. Our dc learn instruments and train for sports outside of school on top of what the school offers. Schools likes to make them the poster dc for their school. This is our second prep. They were both the same in that matter. What you see in the schools PR brochure is more representative of parents efforts generally.

Caroparo52 · 29/06/2023 23:59

If the child is totally without talent no amount of tutoring can make them shine no matter how much money you throw at it

Anothermother3 · 29/06/2023 23:34

My dc is at a good level because I am able to send him to lessons and have done since he was 5 because he was very clear from 4 what he wanted to play and very focused. I don’t have money for private school but I am still fortunate that I can send my children to extra activities. I have noticed a lot of the children who are on group courses my ds has attends attend private school. It’s about opportunities and music should be more accessible.

DisneyMillie · 29/06/2023 23:16

Mine aren’t either sporty or particularly musical - but then I’m not either. I do see that there’s a lot more opportunity if you show any hint of skill though - the sports teams travel around the county playing other similar schools every week and there’s all the resources for music.

I know it’s not fair (but, obviously as my children go to one) I don’t think shutting private schools is the answer - bringing state schools up to the same level so there’s no advantage should be the aim. (And yes, I’d happily pay more tax to help with that).

Barbadossunset · 29/06/2023 23:15

I’d love to think that not having private school would throw some more opportunities open for all the rest (I know, cloud cuckoo land..)

Babybythesea what sort of opportunities would come about if private schools were abolished?

Another76543 · 29/06/2023 22:55

I don’t think that privately educated children are necessarily naturally better at sport and music, but they have more opportunity to become good if they have have natural talent. For example, at private primaries children often have specialist music and sports teachers even at pre-school/reception level. Natural talent will be spotted thanks to small class sizes, and parents will often have the resources and drive to encourage that talent.

Private schools, certainly at secondary level, have many more hours per week dedicated to music and sport. Around 8 hours of timetabled sport per week wouldn’t be unusual, including Saturdays. Pupils will often do additional training on top of that. Not everyone at private school will be sporty or musical, but any hint of talent will be encouraged. State schools don’t have as much time or resources, so potentially talented children will go unnoticed.

Private schools often have better sports facilities too which obviously helps.

Swipe left for the next trending thread