Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
Sheselectric77 · 30/06/2023 09:58

@Goldenbear no one has said that private school pupils are poor unfortunates or disadvantaged. In fact everyone has said the opposite. What they have said is that your assumption that they don’t experience ‘real life’ is wrong. You are wrong simple as that. You are changing peoples words to suit your own argument. If you honestly believe that the only way you can experience real life or be creative, is by fearing you might get stabbed on your way to the local comp then I feel very sorry for you. That is a very blinkered and sad view of the world.
I know a lot about this real life you talk about. More than you actually. It’s no more real life than going to a private school surrounded by countryside. What it is is shite and no one wants to live this life just so they can record a bit of grime and rap about disadvantage.
It is not a race to the bottom, no child should experience adversity in any form, children from every walk of life do unfortunately. Who are you to say that a child being abused but going to private schools experience is less real than one who goes to an inner city comp and uses a food bank. Both are real, both are unacceptable. No one on this planet is saying the private school child doesn’t have an advantage over the other but both are living in the real world.
I find it pretty ridiculous that you feel you are in a position to preach about kids in an inner city comp when you yourself are sat in your pretty comfortable life.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:57

Why don’t the state school parents push? Sometimes they are too busy keeping their own heads above water. As I said, it’s the difference between being able to take your child somewhere to take part in something, and having to take them to work every night while you clean because there’s no one else to look after them

It's not a Netflix show. The vast majority of families at our local state school are perfectly regular 2 income families.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:56

Quite. There are schools out there that don't have Saturday school, so pick one. Also noone is forced to learn an instrument. I'm sure there are non sporty girls at dds school, lots of the very musical ones are not sporty. They all seem very happy so I'm happy.

Barbadossunset · 30/06/2023 09:55

As I said, I’m betting it would change if the PM,s kids went to school where they couldn’t afford a glue stick.
Why don’t the state school parents push? Sometimes they are too busy keeping their own heads above water. As I said, it’s the difference between being able to take your child somewhere to take part in something, and having to take them to work every night while you clean because there’s no one else to look after them.

Babybythesea not all state school parents are too busy keeping their heads above water?
What about all the parents on these threads who say ‘we send our dc to state school because we are decent caring people - even though we could easily afford private school’?
Also, plenty of politicians’ children go to state school - why don’t they do something?
As a pp has said, it’s not easy for parents to make changes in their dcs’ schools. Thinking that private school parents are some sort of ubermensch capable of working miracles is pretty patronising to state school parents.

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 09:54

mewkins · 30/06/2023 09:28

The problem with these threads is that you have people who send their kids to private schools and think that all children who go to private schools are like theirs and that all kids who go to state schools are the opposite. And then you get statements which, while you may not mean them to sound like you believe yourselves to be superior, certainly come across that way. In all walks of life people will do things differently from you. The only thing you have in common with other PS parents is that you've been able to (and chosen to) spend your money at a private school.

In reality there will be children at private schools who dislike Saturday mornings and absolutely hate being made to persist with sports which they have no interest in and they are hopeless at. The same with learning a musical instrument.

Conversely, if you go to my local sports field on a Saturday or Sunday morning you will see a mile of traffic as people get their children (girls and boys) to football, and the pool packed full of parents taking their children to swimming lessons and to swimming club where many will compete at county level. The same at the local hockey club, cricket club, rugby club, etc.

I'm also pretty sure that plenty of PS parents will also be voicing complaints about the discomforts of their children but they'd probably to the school itself as it would go down like a lead balloon if they did it on a public Facebook page, especially in the current climate.

This post is about musical and sporty children though. Obviously not all children are sporty or musical - even with the opportunities, there are plenty of privately educated children who won’t be good at those things, but they’ve had the benefit of being exposed to the opportunities which then picks up those who have a natural talent.

I don’t think we are superior (we are both state educated), but we do what we think is best for our children. On the contrary, the parents who sneer at our choice to send our children to school on a Saturday are the ones with an air of superiority, telling us it’s mean parenting.

I can honestly say that the vast majority of children at our school are happy with Saturdays at school. For the minority who aren’t, perhaps it’s not the right school for them. I don’t know any child who is forced to learn an instrument if they really don’t want to either.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:51

XelaM · 30/06/2023 09:46

I agree with @mewkins . My daughter is one of those kids who would absolutely HATE Saturday school and she specifically rejected private schools that had Saturday school 😆She is also generally sporty, but better at some sports than others. She hates tennis and football for example and would hate to be made to do it, especially on weekends. As I already mentioned, her main sport/obsession she does after school and it has nothing to do with the school.

Well that's fine then isn't it? Dd manages Saturday school, two school sports and riding but you have to be very committed to do that.

Goldenbear · 30/06/2023 09:49

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 09:08

Precisely. I’ve had people comment how awful it is that my children go to school on a Saturday. My children have never once complained and happily go to school 6 days a week with a smile on their face. The same people passing comment on how ridiculous Saturday school is are often the same people who then complain than privately educated children have an unfair advantage. Yes, they have more opportunity, but they also work extremely hard and spend hours more at school a week than their state counterparts.

You only have to read threads on here, and other media reports, to see how many parents complain about their children being slightly uncomfortable having to wear proper shoes, or being a bit warm in their blazers, or being told off by a teacher, or having a whole 2 hours of homework, to realise that there is no way they would be willing to attend school for the hours that private school children often have to, or to put the required amount of effort in. Of course not all parents are like that, but a lot are.

Yes, my children are more sporty and musical than average, partly because they’ve been given that opportunity, but also because they work flipping hard at it.

😳I'm embarrassed for you with those remarks, yes it is clearly the case that your hard working children are innately superior to the riff-raff at the local compo that you drive past in your Land Rover as you ferry your children to and from school; reminding your children that the reason these state educated children are heading for loserville is because they even complain about walking in the rain (oh hang on). Or do you remind your children that being collected by the school bus at 7am is testament to their commitment to their education and hard work as opposed to the riff-raff at the local comp who simply can't be bothered to turn up to school when it isn't open!

It is a good job that you are there to remind them that their struggles are real (heavy is the head that wears the crown of an expensive education) but that ultimately, one day, like you they to will have a misplaced sense of superiority.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:47

mewkins · 30/06/2023 09:45

Yes but you can really only speak about your own 'sporty children' and their specific school. You won't know how any other school, private or otherwise, approach sports and what kids have any say in.

Dd did go to our local state for two years and it was awful. So I sadly have experience of that. I also coach kids in my spare time.

Not sure why everyone except private school parents are allowed to confidently assert what they think about kids and sport.

XelaM · 30/06/2023 09:46

mewkins · 30/06/2023 09:28

The problem with these threads is that you have people who send their kids to private schools and think that all children who go to private schools are like theirs and that all kids who go to state schools are the opposite. And then you get statements which, while you may not mean them to sound like you believe yourselves to be superior, certainly come across that way. In all walks of life people will do things differently from you. The only thing you have in common with other PS parents is that you've been able to (and chosen to) spend your money at a private school.

In reality there will be children at private schools who dislike Saturday mornings and absolutely hate being made to persist with sports which they have no interest in and they are hopeless at. The same with learning a musical instrument.

Conversely, if you go to my local sports field on a Saturday or Sunday morning you will see a mile of traffic as people get their children (girls and boys) to football, and the pool packed full of parents taking their children to swimming lessons and to swimming club where many will compete at county level. The same at the local hockey club, cricket club, rugby club, etc.

I'm also pretty sure that plenty of PS parents will also be voicing complaints about the discomforts of their children but they'd probably to the school itself as it would go down like a lead balloon if they did it on a public Facebook page, especially in the current climate.

I agree with @mewkins . My daughter is one of those kids who would absolutely HATE Saturday school and she specifically rejected private schools that had Saturday school 😆She is also generally sporty, but better at some sports than others. She hates tennis and football for example and would hate to be made to do it, especially on weekends. As I already mentioned, her main sport/obsession she does after school and it has nothing to do with the school.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 09:45

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:37

In reality there will be children at private schools who dislike Saturday mornings and absolutely hate being made to persist with sports which they have no interest in and they are hopeless at. The same with learning a musical instrument

We are talking about sporty children here. And tbf, a good private school wouldn't have a child being made to do a sport they'd hate. They'd find something for them.

Yes but you can really only speak about your own 'sporty children' and their specific school. You won't know how any other school, private or otherwise, approach sports and what kids have any say in.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:40

And I'd be interested to see how many older teen girls are in that crowd of kids in the park. Not many. Maybe at swimming. That was my focus when choosing a school as I think sport, not simply exercise, is really important for girl's mental health. I'm not interested in wasting dds life at a school where there's no decent sport for older girls and the ethos and her peers don't support it.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:37

In reality there will be children at private schools who dislike Saturday mornings and absolutely hate being made to persist with sports which they have no interest in and they are hopeless at. The same with learning a musical instrument

We are talking about sporty children here. And tbf, a good private school wouldn't have a child being made to do a sport they'd hate. They'd find something for them.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 09:28

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 09:08

Precisely. I’ve had people comment how awful it is that my children go to school on a Saturday. My children have never once complained and happily go to school 6 days a week with a smile on their face. The same people passing comment on how ridiculous Saturday school is are often the same people who then complain than privately educated children have an unfair advantage. Yes, they have more opportunity, but they also work extremely hard and spend hours more at school a week than their state counterparts.

You only have to read threads on here, and other media reports, to see how many parents complain about their children being slightly uncomfortable having to wear proper shoes, or being a bit warm in their blazers, or being told off by a teacher, or having a whole 2 hours of homework, to realise that there is no way they would be willing to attend school for the hours that private school children often have to, or to put the required amount of effort in. Of course not all parents are like that, but a lot are.

Yes, my children are more sporty and musical than average, partly because they’ve been given that opportunity, but also because they work flipping hard at it.

The problem with these threads is that you have people who send their kids to private schools and think that all children who go to private schools are like theirs and that all kids who go to state schools are the opposite. And then you get statements which, while you may not mean them to sound like you believe yourselves to be superior, certainly come across that way. In all walks of life people will do things differently from you. The only thing you have in common with other PS parents is that you've been able to (and chosen to) spend your money at a private school.

In reality there will be children at private schools who dislike Saturday mornings and absolutely hate being made to persist with sports which they have no interest in and they are hopeless at. The same with learning a musical instrument.

Conversely, if you go to my local sports field on a Saturday or Sunday morning you will see a mile of traffic as people get their children (girls and boys) to football, and the pool packed full of parents taking their children to swimming lessons and to swimming club where many will compete at county level. The same at the local hockey club, cricket club, rugby club, etc.

I'm also pretty sure that plenty of PS parents will also be voicing complaints about the discomforts of their children but they'd probably to the school itself as it would go down like a lead balloon if they did it on a public Facebook page, especially in the current climate.

Another76543 · 30/06/2023 09:08

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:31

Would never happen sadly as its about ethos as much as money.

Reading some of the comments on my local Facebook page from disgruntled state school parents if their little darlings are expected to walk from one classroom to another when it's raining, there seem to be a huge proportion that just wouldn't cope with Saturday commitments and the rigour of sport for all.

Precisely. I’ve had people comment how awful it is that my children go to school on a Saturday. My children have never once complained and happily go to school 6 days a week with a smile on their face. The same people passing comment on how ridiculous Saturday school is are often the same people who then complain than privately educated children have an unfair advantage. Yes, they have more opportunity, but they also work extremely hard and spend hours more at school a week than their state counterparts.

You only have to read threads on here, and other media reports, to see how many parents complain about their children being slightly uncomfortable having to wear proper shoes, or being a bit warm in their blazers, or being told off by a teacher, or having a whole 2 hours of homework, to realise that there is no way they would be willing to attend school for the hours that private school children often have to, or to put the required amount of effort in. Of course not all parents are like that, but a lot are.

Yes, my children are more sporty and musical than average, partly because they’ve been given that opportunity, but also because they work flipping hard at it.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:34

mewkins · 30/06/2023 08:33

There isn't a way for parents get state schools to magic more money for provisions though. Most already have a parents' association to raise money for extras. Obviously the best way is to vote out this current government.

Oh I agree with you there

mewkins · 30/06/2023 08:33

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:24

This was very neatly demonstrated during lockdown

Lots of mc parents at state school complaining about poor provision from their schools. But despite being educated and middle class, they totally failed to change the ethos of their school.

Not sure why they think that I, as a private school parent, would suddenly get schools to change!

Change your school yourself rather than waiting for the private school overlords to do it for you!

There isn't a way for parents get state schools to magic more money for provisions though. Most already have a parents' association to raise money for extras. Obviously the best way is to vote out this current government.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:31

Would never happen sadly as its about ethos as much as money.

Reading some of the comments on my local Facebook page from disgruntled state school parents if their little darlings are expected to walk from one classroom to another when it's raining, there seem to be a huge proportion that just wouldn't cope with Saturday commitments and the rigour of sport for all.

twistyizzy · 30/06/2023 08:28

@babybythesea yes I think we are agreeing 😊

babybythesea · 30/06/2023 08:27

twistyizzy · 30/06/2023 08:19

@babybythesea but why aren't the parents whose kids are already at state school pushing for better resources etc? Why would it be up to the parents of private school kids to make the difference? The answer is because parents have very little influence so it is naive to say that if private schools we abolished that state schools would improve. You really think that a handful of parents at each secondary school can make any impact on the funding of that school and the way that they do their budgeting? If they can then why don't all state school parents join together NOW to pressure the school rather than waiting for the abolition of private schools?
The answer doesn't lie with getting rid of private schools, the answer lies in voting for a political party who will invest in education and values education for all children. It lies with all parents being invested in their children's behaviour and engagement at school and properly funded SEN provision.

That’s why I said it was cloud cuckoo land. I know ir doesn’t work like that. Doesn’t stop me wishing it did.
As I said, I’m betting it would change if the PM,s kids went to school where they couldn’t afford a glue stick.
Why don’t the state school parents push? Sometimes they are too busy keeping their own heads above water. As I said, it’s the difference between being able to take your child somewhere to take part in something, and having to take them to work every night while you clean because there’s no one else to look after them.

I think we are saying the same thing. Each child deserves all these chances. I would love a world where private schools didn’t need to exist to provide amazing facilities and chances because all kids had the same amazing experience.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:24

twistyizzy · 30/06/2023 08:19

@babybythesea but why aren't the parents whose kids are already at state school pushing for better resources etc? Why would it be up to the parents of private school kids to make the difference? The answer is because parents have very little influence so it is naive to say that if private schools we abolished that state schools would improve. You really think that a handful of parents at each secondary school can make any impact on the funding of that school and the way that they do their budgeting? If they can then why don't all state school parents join together NOW to pressure the school rather than waiting for the abolition of private schools?
The answer doesn't lie with getting rid of private schools, the answer lies in voting for a political party who will invest in education and values education for all children. It lies with all parents being invested in their children's behaviour and engagement at school and properly funded SEN provision.

This was very neatly demonstrated during lockdown

Lots of mc parents at state school complaining about poor provision from their schools. But despite being educated and middle class, they totally failed to change the ethos of their school.

Not sure why they think that I, as a private school parent, would suddenly get schools to change!

Change your school yourself rather than waiting for the private school overlords to do it for you!

twistyizzy · 30/06/2023 08:19

@babybythesea but why aren't the parents whose kids are already at state school pushing for better resources etc? Why would it be up to the parents of private school kids to make the difference? The answer is because parents have very little influence so it is naive to say that if private schools we abolished that state schools would improve. You really think that a handful of parents at each secondary school can make any impact on the funding of that school and the way that they do their budgeting? If they can then why don't all state school parents join together NOW to pressure the school rather than waiting for the abolition of private schools?
The answer doesn't lie with getting rid of private schools, the answer lies in voting for a political party who will invest in education and values education for all children. It lies with all parents being invested in their children's behaviour and engagement at school and properly funded SEN provision.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:09

I think some children ARE inherently better at music or sport but agree, they need the opportunity to show it. Tbf, if a child is really athletic you can identify that at a young age without doing anything other than watching them play sport at primary school. Then park run is free! But you need to be able to get to one. One of the best athletes I ever met used to do park run in a pair of his dad's trainers and his coat. He eneded up getting a full bursary and a scholarship to a - you guessed it - private school.

babybythesea · 30/06/2023 08:01

Barbadossunset · 29/06/2023 23:15

I’d love to think that not having private school would throw some more opportunities open for all the rest (I know, cloud cuckoo land..)

Babybythesea what sort of opportunities would come about if private schools were abolished?

I obviously wasn’t clear - sorry.
Private school children have access to much better facilities eg swimming pools at school so they can have year round lessons, instead of six weeks being shipped by coach for half an hour in the pool. I’d love to think that in the ideal world all kids could have the swimming pool at school thing. In my fantasy world abolishing private schools means that people who value these things don’t pay to send their kids to these places, they push for everyone to have them.
What I was trying to get at is that one set of children are not inherently better at sports and music - what they have is opportunities. I just would love those opportunities for all. Instead my kids barely have the opportunity to have a working glue stick.
If Rishi Sunaks kids were at my school I’m betting he’d be more invested in improving things.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 07:43

State or private, its very hard work being a sporty kid and parent. As a parent you have to be prepared to be taxi, coach, psychologist and cheerleader. Some parents don't have that in them and would prefer their kids had good social lives and wander into town on a Saturday and hang out with their mates rather than get up at 5 and drive miles away which is totally fine of course.

As I've said up thread once they get to uni they often give up or move to something else and everyone's forgotten they won the school swimming cup four years ago.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 07:38
  1. For clarity, Universities do not base offers on extra curricular activities.

Maybe not, but dd was interviewed, personally shown the facilities, then received a very low offer. She went on to represent the university in that sport and did very well. Obviously not many courses interview, but this healthcare based course did,.so it worked very much in her favour. Sport is massive at some universities, with scholarships and grants. Ditto choir. It's not all about getting 3 x As.