Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say private school children are much sportier & better musicians?

633 replies

Denimrevival · 29/06/2023 11:43

Just on the back of comparing with friends & family with dc in private schools. The kids & their families are all naturally sporty & outdoorsy anyways but the school provides a vast range of sports with it's own pool & swim team.
Musically their kids all play 2 or three instruments all at least grade 4 or 5..
How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
XelaM · 14/07/2023 15:10

Anyway, as in many areas of life, hard work beats talent every time if the talented don't work hard. Natural talent alone will not get a kid to succeed in either sport or music.

XelaM · 14/07/2023 14:18

MrsAvocet · 14/07/2023 12:58

It's true that you can't create talent where it doesn't exist, but innate ability alone is unlikely to lead to success in many fields.
Billy Elliot is fiction of course, and whilst there are similar real life stories they are few and far between. The "fairy story" of Billy Elliot is that his potential is recognised and he gets an opportunity that very few children from his background will ever experience. But without that opportunity and the decade or so of high quality training and gruelling practice that the film misses out completely, then child Billy would never have become Swan Billy no matter how much intrinsic talent he had.
To achieve highly in most fields you need some natural ability, some recognition that you have potential, good training and a lot of hard work and practice. If you have parents or someone else willing to facilitate that practice, both financially and logistically, you have a massive advantage over someone who doesn't, even if they have actually got more intrinsic ability. Money can't create talent but it can certainly nuture it. That's where the difference is.

Absolutely. Kids cannot take themselves to or pay for training until they're too old to be able to compete with those who started young (in most sports). Stories where kids from very poor backgrounds made it to elite levels usually either involve state-funded training programs (common in countries like China/Russia) or their talent being noticed by a scout/coach who then is prepared to train them for free. That's very rare unless parents encourage/facilitate it.

MrsAvocet · 14/07/2023 12:58

TheaBrandt · 12/07/2023 21:55

I genuinely don’t think you can force it - it’s innate. Like Billy Elliott!

It's true that you can't create talent where it doesn't exist, but innate ability alone is unlikely to lead to success in many fields.
Billy Elliot is fiction of course, and whilst there are similar real life stories they are few and far between. The "fairy story" of Billy Elliot is that his potential is recognised and he gets an opportunity that very few children from his background will ever experience. But without that opportunity and the decade or so of high quality training and gruelling practice that the film misses out completely, then child Billy would never have become Swan Billy no matter how much intrinsic talent he had.
To achieve highly in most fields you need some natural ability, some recognition that you have potential, good training and a lot of hard work and practice. If you have parents or someone else willing to facilitate that practice, both financially and logistically, you have a massive advantage over someone who doesn't, even if they have actually got more intrinsic ability. Money can't create talent but it can certainly nuture it. That's where the difference is.

mewkins · 14/07/2023 10:08

Daphnis156 · 11/07/2023 20:22

You may think it but the more you go around saying it, the fewer friends you'll have!

Grin
TheaBrandt · 12/07/2023 21:55

I genuinely don’t think you can force it - it’s innate. Like Billy Elliott!

Xenia · 12/07/2023 20:31

Yes, even in the most competitive state grammars and very selective of the private schools you will get those teenagers who are utterly focussed on something - it often comes from within the child (unless it is a Tiger mother type situation).

Daphnis156 · 11/07/2023 20:22

You may think it but the more you go around saying it, the fewer friends you'll have!

LolaSmiles · 11/07/2023 20:14

Dh and I were discussing our friends son who is extremely driven top of his sport trains daily and applying for US scholarships. He is driven Dh was similar but academically. Both state educated.
It’s quite rare but frankly your child is like that or they aren’t. I don’t think a school or parent can force it it has to come from them
I'd agree with this. I've taught at state schools with some pupils who were exceptional in music/drama/sport. They had a talent, their parents were fortunate to have the means to support the training/tuition and they had a good state offer.
I had friends who taught in private and they said that the smaller class sizes made it easier for pupils who required regular absences for their talent to get caught up because if a class of 18 is settled then they could spend a bit extra on the student who has been absent.

Anecdotally the talent seems to be innate to the child and then parents facilitate the talent in the way they believe is best for their children and family.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/07/2023 18:47

I’m a grass roots supporter ( northern city) so are all my friends and family.

We love it.

Wenfy · 11/07/2023 18:33

Xenia · 11/07/2023 18:21

Bit more on Labour's plans https://on.ft.com/3PQn053 - article in today's Financial Times.

Labour’s plans have proved extremely unpopular with grassroots Labour supporters.

xsquared · 03/07/2023 22:34

How do these private schools do the academics, music & sports to such a high standard? Do they also have a very good base if the kids are having sport & music reinforced outside school through their families lifestyles?

It's not so much that they go to a private school, but an obvious factor is money , time spent on practice, as well as discipline and normalising the family lifestyle that lends itself to being good at music and sports, as you have already mentioned.

Having said that our dcs are both state educated; ds plays for a local football club who finished 2nd in the county at the end of this season. He stopped piano at grade 5 though, as it just wasn't his thing but he was disciplined with practice at the time.

Dd on the other hand does so many extra curricular activities as it is. Scouts, 2 types of dance classes, piano, viola. Again, none of these things are cheap.

She is good at lots of things but she cannot be good at everything because of how think spread her time is between them. By the time she comes back from another scout's camp or hike, she barely has time for practice in either instruments. She narrowly missed a merit recently in her grade 6 piano, but her dance grade suffered and she only just passed having missed several lessons because of clashes with other things.

fishingoutofthewater · 03/07/2023 22:01

SleeplessinScarbourough · 29/06/2023 12:00

It’s because their parents think they are better than everyone else and they impart that expectation upon their children who by the time they are 11, also think they are better than everyone else - expecting crowds to part for them, expecting traffic to stop for them, celebrating the misfortune of others if it benefits them and pretending the common folk don’t exist.

We aren't all like that.

fishingoutofthewater · 03/07/2023 21:59

As a private school parent, I can confirm that we are not all like that.

TheaBrandt · 03/07/2023 10:34

Sadly neither of mine are driven to that extent! They work hard at school and do activities but are not that next level driven. It’s quite rare - and I think inspiring to see.

XelaM · 03/07/2023 10:33

TheaBrandt · 02/07/2023 19:36

Thought of this thread eavesdropping in the car on my 14 year old and her mates comparing their sports days - 2 state 2 private. Means nothing to teens what types of school. Their conclusion was the state school (all girls but state) sports day was more fun as involved face paints and mucking about the private one was “too intense” but the state girls loved the idea of the house dinners the private school girls had.

My daughter's private school sports day also had face paint and kids not taking it seriously. In one of the races the girls held hands and ran together so no one came last (my daughter was the only one who broke the chain at the end to win the race as she's super competitive 😂). The other kids were all very chilled. I think my daughter was one of the few kids who took Sports Day seriously and wanted to win all her races.

Xenia · 03/07/2023 10:20

Mant I think you did the right thing. I would not have had some in private and some in state as that is not really very fair on the child.

I also agree with the comment above that some things are innate. One of mine was very keen on sport right through into the sixth form, others not. Same family, similar schools, similar upbringing.

Manthide · 03/07/2023 10:19

Terryer · 02/07/2023 22:30

Funny

Dd is at prestigious private girls school and sports day involved intensity for some and face paints, tutus and mucking about for others. Of course a mix, rather than the one or the other that you get on here.

Sounds like my daughter's private school sports day - a mix of fun and intensity. Her sports day was scheduled for 9am but as it was raining quite heavily it was moved to 11am. Some state schools are flexible like this but I found when mine were at state primary it was often just moved to a different day which was also affected by weather.

Manthide · 03/07/2023 10:13

TheaBrandt · 03/07/2023 07:15

Dh and I were discussing our friends son who is extremely driven top of his sport trains daily and applying for US scholarships. He is driven Dh was similar but academically. Both state educated. It’s quite rare but frankly your child is like that or they aren’t. I don’t think a school or parent can force it it has to come from them.

Some children are like that, dd2 was always quite driven academically and would have done well wherever she went - though she was bullied at her state school for being clever! Dd1, though always pretty good academically was always inclined to do just enough work to be top! She never pushed herself but she was quite competitive.
Ds is ND and was subject to bullying at his middle school which I fear would have got worse at secondary school. At his private school he was given the confidence to be himself. Academically he probably would have come out with all A*s at state school but socially he fared much better in the private sector.
Dd3 would have gone to our local state secondary as I think she'd have done well there. She got 119 and exceeding in her y6 SAT'S overall and being entitled to FSM would have also helped with paying for trios etc. Unfortunately she thought it wasn't fair that her siblings went private at secondary and she didn't so she went private too. I'm still not 100% convinced it was the right decision but she's just finishing y10 and I won't move her now.

TheaBrandt · 03/07/2023 07:15

Dh and I were discussing our friends son who is extremely driven top of his sport trains daily and applying for US scholarships. He is driven Dh was similar but academically. Both state educated. It’s quite rare but frankly your child is like that or they aren’t. I don’t think a school or parent can force it it has to come from them.

graygoose · 03/07/2023 06:04

I went to a private school and it churned out some of the most useless, mediocre and, in some cases, convicted individuals you could hope to meet (and convicted of very nasty things that did harm to vulnerable people). These were all kids who had every opportunity thrown at them, who played instruments, did sports, had the teachers guiding them through every essay and exam and they were still bloody useless as adults. And no, most of them aren't particularly "successful" but they do have bank of mum and dad to support them so it barely matters.

By contrast my DH went to a state school and he is a decent hard working person who is much better adjusted than many of the guys I went to school with. DH was very also sporty and played instruments in school.

What I'm trying to say is, opportunities and ECs during school are great and yes, can lead to brilliant opportunities for the right kid. But I also think the right kid can make the most of opportunities wherever they are. Having seen how so many of my classmates turned out and knowing the opportunities they were given, I am not fussed about sending our kids to private school as long as they get support and encouragement at home.

NeonSoda · 03/07/2023 05:08

Casperroonie · 02/07/2023 09:16

Teachers work less hours in state schools?!?!?!? Omg I've heard it all now.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Correction: there are LESS Teachers, the workload is unmanageable, they're dropping like flies in many schools. In a private school, they can pay for enough teachers to provide top notch education.

So here’s the thing. In the independent boarding school I work at, all teachers work 8-6 every day and every other Saturday morning.

Some teachers also then work evenings and early mornings, and some of those teachers also technically work overnight five-six nights a week.

They do get longer holidays though. But the big thing is that when they’re on holiday they don’t do any work. They often go travelling for a few months or similar.

You've also got to remember that private school teachers often get paid a good amount less than state school teachers because the long holiday is considered to be a perk and they are sometimes offered basic accommodation at a reasonable price (although that accommodation would be in the boarding houses with the children if they were a housemaster/mistress).

Terryer · 02/07/2023 22:30

TheaBrandt · 02/07/2023 19:36

Thought of this thread eavesdropping in the car on my 14 year old and her mates comparing their sports days - 2 state 2 private. Means nothing to teens what types of school. Their conclusion was the state school (all girls but state) sports day was more fun as involved face paints and mucking about the private one was “too intense” but the state girls loved the idea of the house dinners the private school girls had.

Funny

Dd is at prestigious private girls school and sports day involved intensity for some and face paints, tutus and mucking about for others. Of course a mix, rather than the one or the other that you get on here.

TheaBrandt · 02/07/2023 19:36

Thought of this thread eavesdropping in the car on my 14 year old and her mates comparing their sports days - 2 state 2 private. Means nothing to teens what types of school. Their conclusion was the state school (all girls but state) sports day was more fun as involved face paints and mucking about the private one was “too intense” but the state girls loved the idea of the house dinners the private school girls had.

Manthide · 02/07/2023 15:30

Foxesandsquirrels · 02/07/2023 12:15

LOL. Fortismere and DAO there may actually be a couple. I worked closely with Fortismere until about 5 years ago and there's a surprising amount of kids from low income households. FSM data is crap at showing this. Most families using food banks don't qualify for FSM.

Children at private schools are not entitled to FSM though of course they would be included free through bursaries. I had a problem during covid when my dc were obviously not getting school meals but did not qualify for the help given by the government during holidays. In the end I had to get the local councillors involved and they agreed we met the income criteria. Ds's public school was very good at sending me money for the school meals they were missing and dd3's school did send me it after I submitted proof of income but it was very stressful.