Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chrissy Teigen surrogacy

387 replies

HermioneKipper · 29/06/2023 08:35

Just announced a 4th baby via a surrogate.

Its just so breathtakingly entitled to buy a woman’s body - especially when you already have 3 children?!

No regard for the safety of the surrogate’s body or thought for the baby who would be ripped from their mother at birth.

These people sicken me

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Emotionalsupportviper · 29/06/2023 13:24

I think there would be a possible argument in favour of surrogacy, as with prostitution, if full informed consent could be obtained from all parties.

It isn't possible to obtain fully informed consent from a foetus/infant. And that is the most important and vulnerable of all of the parties.

SelfPortraitWithHagstone · 29/06/2023 13:22

I think there would be a possible argument in favour of surrogacy, as with prostitution, if full informed consent could be obtained from all parties. I still think it would be bad for society, for much the same reasons (pertaining to commodification of bodies, etc, particularly women's bodies) and I would oppose it on those grounds alone - however, happy to thrash those issues out once people have found a way to get full, informed consent from the child at the centre of all this, the child who is being taken away from the only person it has ever known and whom some posters do not apparently consider worthy of consideration.

Maybe surrogacy should only be allowed once the child is over 18? [shrug]

CurlewKate · 29/06/2023 13:19

I don't know how surrogacy affects babies. I am viscerally concerned about the impact, but I have no idea whether there is any basis to my concern. My issue with surrogacy is almost entirely based on the exploitation of women. Women's bodies are not there to be bought.

SaltedButty · 29/06/2023 13:15

It’s an imbalance of power.
While I do think the surrogate should also bear some responsibility for basically selling a baby they usually need the money

It's not selling a baby though is it, it's carrying one for someone else

SaltedButty · 29/06/2023 13:14

I am not sure where I stand with surrogacy, however the thought of a new-born baby being taken away from her Mother be difficult to swallow.

I don't think I have the right to have an opinion. That said, I wonder how many of the mumsnetters who are livid about surrogacy stories, also bleat on about pro choice and how a "woman should be able to choose what to do with her body".

I know it goes far deeper than that but that is my thought. As long as a baby has 2 loving parents it shouldn't matter. But of course, it does.

I would be interested to hear from people who were carried by a surrogate and if/how it affected them

Hoppinggreen · 29/06/2023 13:11

OngoingConfidence · 29/06/2023 13:09

Why do the surrogates not get held to the same standard? They are choosing to do this

It’s an imbalance of power.
While I do think the surrogate should also bear some responsibility for basically selling a baby they usually need the money

HarpyValley · 29/06/2023 13:11

Kennykenkencat · 29/06/2023 13:01

What do you mean lesser of 2 evils.

Do you mean because the local authority did such a crap job of raising a child in a care home that you deem that child incapable of ever being a good enough mother to allow them to raise a child on their own. Even if there is nothing to say that would happen

So you are all for ripping a baby away from its mother and taking that child into care for the process to be repeated

I was in care growing up and despite being the latter end of 30s and having a husband and a detached house in a leafy area on the edge of London I had SS at my bedside after I had given birth to both of my children.

I was old enough to know how to get them to back off, say what they wanted to hear. But it was only when I was talking to other mums that I realised that none of the other mums had this. After my 2nd I was ready for them when I saw them approach

Only other person I have ever spoken to who had the same had also spent time in the care system growing up.

Are you saying that as care home kids we should be sterilised to stop us getting pregnant and abusing our children
because we are guaranteed to be an abusive parent because we spent time in the care system.

It’s quite obvious the PP meant in the situations where the child is deemed to be so at risk that removal is the least worst outcome, not that babies should be removed from every formerly looked-after woman as a matter of course. You still have your children with you, I presume, so you are not in the former situation.

I can understand why your experience might make you sensitive about it, but you’re putting words in posters’ mouths.

OngoingConfidence · 29/06/2023 13:09

Why do the surrogates not get held to the same standard? They are choosing to do this

Kennykenkencat · 29/06/2023 13:06

toomuchlaundry

Also in the U.K. surrogacy isn’t a commercial transaction

Intriguedbythis · 29/06/2023 13:04

It is Akin to human trafficking, with the exception of a loved one doing it for another loved one.

ArabeIIaScott · 29/06/2023 13:02

AndrexPuppy · 29/06/2023 08:44

I am ethically opposed to surrogacy, so it’s a YANBU from me.

Same. Babies shouldn't be bought and sold.

Kennykenkencat · 29/06/2023 13:01

What do you mean lesser of 2 evils.

Do you mean because the local authority did such a crap job of raising a child in a care home that you deem that child incapable of ever being a good enough mother to allow them to raise a child on their own. Even if there is nothing to say that would happen

So you are all for ripping a baby away from its mother and taking that child into care for the process to be repeated

I was in care growing up and despite being the latter end of 30s and having a husband and a detached house in a leafy area on the edge of London I had SS at my bedside after I had given birth to both of my children.

I was old enough to know how to get them to back off, say what they wanted to hear. But it was only when I was talking to other mums that I realised that none of the other mums had this. After my 2nd I was ready for them when I saw them approach

Only other person I have ever spoken to who had the same had also spent time in the care system growing up.

Are you saying that as care home kids we should be sterilised to stop us getting pregnant and abusing our children
because we are guaranteed to be an abusive parent because we spent time in the care system.

MsAlder · 29/06/2023 13:00

Oldpalace123 · 29/06/2023 10:12

The birth mother is on the birth certificate in the USA too for goodness sake, the only difference between abroad and here is surrogacy is enforcable in the USA , its not in the UK, so its binding contract to hand over baby and the couple be they two dads, straight couple, two women who can't give birth, are legal adoptive parents.

This isn't the case in all states. In some states you can start the parental recognition (where the woman's partner says he's not the father and the biological father accepts parentage) before the birth and start the adoption proceedings for the intended mother at the same time. The birth certificate will then feature the name of intended parents rather than the surrogates name.
This is why submitting those documents is considered fraud in some countries as they believe the birth mother should be listed on the birth certificate and in those cases, the adoption process can only start after a specific time frame.

Tidsleytiddy · 29/06/2023 12:56

I think surrogacy is fine as long as all parties are fully aware of potential problems.
In this case I see it as a selfish vanity project. The woman is lucky enough to have three children. Talk about money buying you exactly what you want.

Babsexxx · 29/06/2023 12:48

Thanks got to go and have a discussion about induction Monday soo hopefully it goes my way! I explained to my midwife when she asked about movements that it’s nigh on impossible to monitor with never ending attacks making it a dangerous situation she agreed so hopefully have baby in the next couple of weeks!

LaffTaff · 29/06/2023 12:45

Fizbosshoes · 29/06/2023 11:17

Exactly. Lots of celebs are really pro surrogacy...and yet we don't see any of them being the surrogate? (Many have had children previously)
The Kardashians have used surrogates, considering there are several pro surrogacy sisters of child bearing age, none wanted to do it...?

And adoption is usually the least worst option for the child although newborn adoption I believe is fairly rare, and would only happen in very extreme circumstances. You only have to look at long lost families to see that many adopted people do have a yearning to find their birth parents even when they've been brought up by loving and caring families

Baby adoption (under 2) isn't as rare as people think. Babies can (and are) taken into care at birth. Relinquished babies are more rare, but it still happens more often than you'd think.

Long lost families is an entertaintment show (a dreadful one at that imo - a dreadful premise for 'entertainment').
Certainly in my local authority, the overwhelming majority of adopted people DON'T have any desire to trace birth family. Of the minority who do, an unsatisfactory outcome is far more common than long lost families would have you believe.

KimberleyClark · 29/06/2023 12:42

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 29/06/2023 08:53

Adoption is child focused and surrogacy is about what adults want.

Exactly.

MummyJ36 · 29/06/2023 12:42

I know of one acquaintance in the “real world” who has used a surrogate. She has various medical conditions that would make it genuinely dangerous for her to carry a baby (but not less capable of caring or raising the baby once it’s born). That is out of multitudes of friends and acquaintances who have not gone down this path despite gruelling rounds of IVF, miscarriage, infertility etc.

Like it or not, surrogacy is a rich persons game most of the time. And this is seen very clearly now in the celebs that seem to routinely trot out a new baby born via surrogate every 5 minutes.

Surrogacy is a selfless act and one that in the right circumstances for the right reasons I wholeheartedly agree with providing everyone is doing it willingly and understands the implications.

I had absolutely debilitating SPD and pelvic issues in pregnancy. It left me housebound for months before the births and in endless pain. After two kids I have sworn off having any more as I just cannot go through it again. If I was a rich celebrity maybe I’d be sitting here thinking of getting another woman to carry my baby for me so I didn’t have to go through pregnancy again. But would that be morally right? I just don’t think so (in my opinion).

toomuchlaundry · 29/06/2023 12:41

@Kennykenkencat that is where the child comes first, as although not good taking them away from their mother it is felt that is the lesser of two evils as such. And support will hopefully be given to all parties. It is not a commercial transaction

Kennykenkencat · 29/06/2023 12:35

Hazelnuttella · 29/06/2023 08:55

No-one would do it if they could afford not to. Just like prostitution is “a choice”. It’s not really a choice that most women want to have to make.

Strange how we rarely hear stories from surrogates.

If it is because women want to “help”, then why do we never have celebrities growing babies for poor women who can’t afford fertility treatment?

I can assure you this isn’t at all like being forced into prostitution because you need the money (prostitution pays better)and in the U.K. it is basically expenses only. There is no big money to be had.

I know someone who did it for a relative because for her pregnancies were a breeze. She always felt brilliant throughout pregnancies, loved being pregnant. But for her sister she struggled.
I think done properly with the right psychological testing then I don’t see what is wrong with going down this route.

IVF isn’t a safe long term option for some women. And done properly this is far better for everyone concerned.

When people say that the baby is ripped from the “mother” How do you feel about those girls/women who because they have had a bad start in life, been in care and abusive relationships even though they have never had a child before and are on their own SS’s deem them to be a risk to their baby when they are still pregnant and order that the baby is taken into care immediately after birth

EvelynBeatrice · 29/06/2023 12:35

I express no view on the ethics of commercial surrogacy except to say that it is hard to see any distinction between the justifications for it and those that can be put forward to promote the legitimisation of paid for organ donation eg. kidneys . So far as I'm aware there is no country which doesn't regard paid for organ donation as illegal. They only difference I can see between allowing someone to pay for use of a body and placenta and organ donation is that organ donation might be from men as well as women.

LolaSmiles · 29/06/2023 12:27

her choice and she my want to do this for the money..."
This is the problem and immediately shows the 'freewill' argument to be bullshit. Where are the wealthy white surrogates, where is the TV shows covering their altruistic or free choice reasons to be farmed. "
This is ultimately where the "be kind - you do you - but if a woman chooses it then who are we to object" pretend feminism gets us.
It means that actions that oppress women, particularly women who are marginalised and/or have fewer resources and opportunities, are celebrated as empowerment.

Liberal feminism is often DARVO on a large scale where the response to women questioning systemic and institutional oppression are met with but you're the real oppressors, look at you, you don't even want women to make choices (head tilt).

Once you see it, it's there on a lot of topics relating to women being socialised and oppressed on their basis of their biology.

PicnicInthecar · 29/06/2023 12:24

Lwrenagain · 29/06/2023 10:18

The planning was meticulous, I won't lie.
It was discussed before hand with the older DC as he'd experienced the worst one of my pregnancies. (Severity has differed with all.)
We made sure we had all children in fulltime school, plus a good support network to hand.
It's tough, but with DP adjusting hours to suit and help from friends (who all had offered support before we tried) it's been manageable.
I've booked things for DP to do with the younger ones each month, so special visits to places, (Julia Donaldson character theatre shows etc) or my friends have taken them to parties for me. It's been lots of keeping them busy so they don't miss out on day to day stuff, having bigger activities to look forward too.
Older DC has been incredible, (without being asked, ever!) And will wake up early of a weekend and take out his siblings the park and for ice cream or to the local soft play. (Very local, 5 minutes walk away) and its gone quite quickly for them.

All we can do it what feels right for our families and mine has had lots of grief over recent years, this felt right for us. It's not really for anyone else to understand, this is my last time ever doing this and we're all excited for baby to arrive.

Please don’t feel you need to justify yourself @Lwrenagain Flowers

PicnicInthecar · 29/06/2023 12:21

*shame

PicnicInthecar · 29/06/2023 12:21

HermioneKipper · 29/06/2023 10:25

I’m pleased it’s all worked out for you and you sound like you thought about it carefully etc - it’s your life so crack on.

But why don’t you ask your older child in 10/20 years as I imagine their recollection will change by then. You’ve put an awful lot of very adult responsibility on their shoulders because you’re so desperate to have another baby.

Your mates taking them to a party isn’t the same as their mother literally being out of action for up to 9 months.

Anyway, hope all goes well for you

This is really nasty guilting a pregnant woman I’ve her having HG

I have 7 dc and had HG with all was hospitalised with each on and off and really ‘out of action’ for days / weeks at a time. My dc are all fine - absolutely fine. When I was home even if i was in bed I could still sit with them and read to them etc and their dad took over. Plus they had school ! They still had plenty of time with me and it didn’t negatively affect them at all.

some dc are in nursery 8-6 5 days a week from under a year old - spending less time with their parents than my children who only went to pre school at 3 then primary school and factoring in any time I had HG - would you shake those parents too ? Bet you wouldn’t .