Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chrissy Teigen surrogacy

387 replies

HermioneKipper · 29/06/2023 08:35

Just announced a 4th baby via a surrogate.

Its just so breathtakingly entitled to buy a woman’s body - especially when you already have 3 children?!

No regard for the safety of the surrogate’s body or thought for the baby who would be ripped from their mother at birth.

These people sicken me

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 29/06/2023 09:51

x2boys · 29/06/2023 08:41

I'm not sure how i..feel.about surrogacy
But the the surrogate isn't being forced to.carry a child.

When independently wealthy women are doing it for no financial reward then I'll believe this.

ZebraDilemma · 29/06/2023 09:51

Chocolatelover3 · 29/06/2023 08:48

These threads are boring. As soon as a celebrity has a baby via surrogate they start popping up on mumsnet.

First of all the poor woman lost her son Jack so mentally was terrified of getting pregnant again. Loss hurts if you have no children previously or 8 children! Very easy to judge unless you have had a miscarriage or stillbirth.

Whilst I can see negatives to surrogacy - especially when woman need the money and go through it despite not really wanting to. I do not think this is the case for a lot of surrogates. I actually follow a few on TikTok who love doing this for other people, and do not see it as ripping the baby away. I’m sure most celebrities go through a proper process when finding the right surrogate. The baby is going to be loved, not to mention obviously have the best of things as they clearly have money. The surrogate will be happy to do this. What is the problem?

Why is it that people support adoption but hate surrogacy?

First of all the poor woman lost her son Jack so mentally was terrified of getting pregnant again

Chrissy Teigan gave birth to a baby earlier this year, so your argument doesn’t stand up.

Bluebells1970 · 29/06/2023 09:47

I don't understand how a surrogate would think this is OK too when the purchasing parent is already pregnant.... it's beyond weird.

She must have seriously needed that money Sad

MsAlder · 29/06/2023 09:47

SunnyFrost · 29/06/2023 09:43

I would feel that way if you EVER saw a rich woman doing this for a poorer woman. Interesting how many Kardashian sisters have procured babies through surrogacy and not one sister has acted as the surrogate. The massive power imbalance between rich and poor women means that apparent consent is never that clear cut.

One thing that really makes me 🤮 is the obligatory photo of the new mum done up carefully to look tired and wan but still glowing like she has just delivered the baby herself - it’s fucking creepy. The pictures of Khloe Kardashian IN THE HOSPITAL BED ffs, and now Chrissy is (I’m sure purposefully) looking very underdone - wearing sweats and not at all made up in her pics - anything to avoid drawing attention to the fact she has just been handed the baby from the birthing mother. Wouldn’t be a good look to be bright eyed and dressed with a full face of make up, might remind people of the truth.

It’s utterly grim and we will be judged harshly down the line for allowing this abhorrent practice to be legal.

The hospital or midwife would promote skin to skin contact to help bonding after birth.

thecatsthecats · 29/06/2023 09:46

dancinginthesky · 29/06/2023 09:25

Idk I guess I'm gonna wonder about the ethics from this thread

The bit I'm not getting though is some arguments being "they already have X amount of children"

Like if it's actually unethical in people's minds... why after X amount and not 0 children? No magic number of already existing children suddenly tips it from "understandable" to "unethical" surely?

To be clear, I disagree with surrogacy in all of its forms, but I think that it's especially bad when a) the parents/mother are doing it because they KNOW the risks and don't want to bear them themselves and b) when they are not facing childlessness as a consequence of not using a surrogate.

Ethics doesn't have to be a black and white line drawn. I work in an area with a strong degree of ethical choices involved, and it's normal to include these nuances.

ParanoidGynodroid · 29/06/2023 09:46

@RegainingTheWill2023

Two very important points you point that are worth repeating:

Individual women consenting doesn't mean it's ethical

Safeguarding actions / laws do not depend on individual circumstances

Absolutely. As long as surrogacy is allowed to happen there will be exploitation, danger, regret, trauma...
How many "willing" surrogates are truly willing?
As has been said before, you don't see rich/privileged women choosing it as a job option.

BodegaSushi · 29/06/2023 09:45

toodledo · 29/06/2023 08:39

Well, that's a ridiculous presumption. No safety to the surrogate? "Ripped from the mother"? What planet are you on?

You must be new here 🍿

LolaSmiles · 29/06/2023 09:44

I'll feel better about surrogacy when rich white women from the developed world see it as a career choice

This sums it up for me, along with the fact that those who are pro-surrogacy seem to think it's fine to have lower standards separating mother's from their newborns than we have for removing puppies from their mums.

itsserendipity · 29/06/2023 09:43

CurlewKate · 29/06/2023 08:45

I'll feel better about surrogacy when rich white women from the developed world see it as a career choice.

This...

SunnyFrost · 29/06/2023 09:43

Lillyrosemay · 29/06/2023 09:29

This surrogate seems to have done this through choice and personally I respect a woman’s choices. It’s not about whether I disagree or agree. It’s about her right to choose.

I would feel that way if you EVER saw a rich woman doing this for a poorer woman. Interesting how many Kardashian sisters have procured babies through surrogacy and not one sister has acted as the surrogate. The massive power imbalance between rich and poor women means that apparent consent is never that clear cut.

One thing that really makes me 🤮 is the obligatory photo of the new mum done up carefully to look tired and wan but still glowing like she has just delivered the baby herself - it’s fucking creepy. The pictures of Khloe Kardashian IN THE HOSPITAL BED ffs, and now Chrissy is (I’m sure purposefully) looking very underdone - wearing sweats and not at all made up in her pics - anything to avoid drawing attention to the fact she has just been handed the baby from the birthing mother. Wouldn’t be a good look to be bright eyed and dressed with a full face of make up, might remind people of the truth.

It’s utterly grim and we will be judged harshly down the line for allowing this abhorrent practice to be legal.

Bluebells1970 · 29/06/2023 09:42

Her son wasn't stillborn, she had a termination. There is an ocean between the two and she could have made that very clear with her documentation of the event.

I had a late stillbirth myself and the thought of having a professional photographer there to "capture" that event makes me feel sick still.

Babsexxx · 29/06/2023 09:42

I’m not against surrogacy in the correct circumstances, but all these celebs that have birthed there own kids then feel the need to use a surrogate is fucking atrocious and greedy.

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 29/06/2023 09:40

Why is it that people support adoption but hate surrogacy?

If you'd read any of the 'boring' threads that 'pop up' on MN you'd know.

Adoption is about finding a home for a child already in the world who cannot, for whatever reason, be with its biological parents. The needs of the child are paramount. The joy of the new parents is a by-product.

Surrogacy, particularly in its current form, is about creating a child to be removed from the closet physical connection it has, after paying a woman to put herself at significant physical risk, because two (almost always) wealthy adults want to. It's focussed on the joy of the commissioning parents - what is best for the child is a sideline.

One is a step to rectifying a child's existing trauma. One is taking a step to create it. One is helping living children, one is treating women like incubators for the wealthy and selling handing over babies in exchange for money. One is a financial transaction, the other is not.

Think what you will about the morals around surrogacy but it's worlds apart from adoption.

drpet49 · 29/06/2023 09:40

Robotik · 29/06/2023 08:52

She got pregnant quickly after having her stillborn son which was horrific but she wasn’t using a surrogate for the fear of being pregnant again.

Her son wasn’t stillborn. She had Q to have a medical termination as her life was at risk.

RegainingTheWill2023 · 29/06/2023 09:38

Chocolatelover3 · 29/06/2023 09:01

Maybe I need more educating so what is the problem if all parties involved are happy to go through the surrogacy journey? I 1000% agree if the surrogate is doing it out of desperation for money etc I really do not agree with that but I know a couple who had twins via surrogacy their surrogate was so happy to do this for them and says it’s the best gift she’s ever gave anyone and the couple have 2 beautiful babies so why is that a bad thing? Not trying to be funny what I maybe need more educating x

Safeguarding actions / laws do not depend on individual circumstances. They are put in place to protect those who are not "happy" with the situation. In surrogacy those affected beyond the happy surrogate and happy commissioning parents, are the baby, vulnerable women who can be coerced or forced by poverty into surrogacy and society as a whole especially women everywhere!

The process of surrogacy is transactional, even when done without money. Condoning surrogacy in any situation affects how women's bodies and reproductive systems are regarded. As well as ignoring the impact on the babies!

It gives a green light to using women's bodies for someone else's gain. If that's 'OK' in surrogacy what else will be ok in the future?

Individual women consenting doesn't mean it's an ethical.

toomuchlaundry · 29/06/2023 09:37

You don’t see many rich or famous people being surrogates

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 29/06/2023 09:36

Isn't there research that shows that a pregnancy where the surrogate has no genetic connection to the baby is higher risk than one where it's her own egg?

I've been troubled in the past by reading on threads like this that some 'commissioning' parents have attempted to control the decision-making over any problems that may arise during the pregnancy or birth. This means they could be making life-altering decisions for the pregnant/birthing woman because she is not their priority, the baby is. Nobody should make those decisions except the woman herself, and if she's not able to (comatose, for example), it should be her next of kin deciding what to do in conjunction with doctors.

Thesearmsofmine · 29/06/2023 09:35

Yeah it’s grim. I always wanted a big family but medically cannot, it’s sad but it doesn’t give me the right to buy another woman’s body to use.

NameChangeThreeThousand · 29/06/2023 09:34

I'm not against surrogacy per se. But there is something which doesn't sit right with me, that rich people can buy a baby from a poor person and use that person's body to carry a baby for them. If it wasn't about money, and there was no payment involved, I would feel better about it

ParanoidGynodroid · 29/06/2023 09:33

dancinginthesky · 29/06/2023 09:25

Idk I guess I'm gonna wonder about the ethics from this thread

The bit I'm not getting though is some arguments being "they already have X amount of children"

Like if it's actually unethical in people's minds... why after X amount and not 0 children? No magic number of already existing children suddenly tips it from "understandable" to "unethical" surely?

People who are against it are totally against it; there's no "It's ok if you've had a stillbirth/can't have children, but not if you already have 2 or 3"

Granted, some may have pointed out that the sleb in question already has children by way of response to those trying to justify it, but no one has said theres a point at which it switches from acceptable and ethical to the opposite.

It's always wrong, whatever the circumstances.

AngelAurora · 29/06/2023 09:31

HermioneKipper · 29/06/2023 08:35

Just announced a 4th baby via a surrogate.

Its just so breathtakingly entitled to buy a woman’s body - especially when you already have 3 children?!

No regard for the safety of the surrogate’s body or thought for the baby who would be ripped from their mother at birth.

These people sicken me

The Surrogate knows exactly what they are getting. Into, they get paid well for it.

babbscrabbs · 29/06/2023 09:31

dancinginthesky · 29/06/2023 09:25

Idk I guess I'm gonna wonder about the ethics from this thread

The bit I'm not getting though is some arguments being "they already have X amount of children"

Like if it's actually unethical in people's minds... why after X amount and not 0 children? No magic number of already existing children suddenly tips it from "understandable" to "unethical" surely?

I disagree. Say my sister couldn't carry her own children and had none, and I volunteered to be her surrogate willing to take on the associated risks so she could have a child, then I think that's totally different.

MargotBamborough · 29/06/2023 09:30

dancinginthesky · 29/06/2023 09:17

@MargotBamborough the only case I know of personally, the surrogate remains in contact with the parents and is part of the children's life and I guess could be likened to open adoption

I believe the kids are fully aware they grew in the surrogate and she gave birth to them

I don't know how it worked at the time, I didn't know them then but my perception was that she'd have been around them as a baby frequently like she still is now

They all seem really happy 🤷‍♀️

I'm not as black and white about it as some on here.

For me there are two issues. The potential exploitation of the surrogate and the potential trauma for the baby in being removed from his or her birth mother.

On the first issue, I do accept that there are certain situations in which there is no exploitation and little risk, but they are few and far between. Even where it is an altruistic surrogacy and the surrogate mother really, genuinely wants to carry a baby for a couple she really cares about, there are still risks. What if the baby has a life limiting condition and the surrogate and the intended parents don't agree on whether she should terminate the pregnancy? What if the surrogate, having had previous uncomplicated pregnancies, ends up with a life threatening pregnancy complications, severe birth injuries or even dies in childbirth? How would you ever forgive yourself? But in the vast majority of cases I think there is clear exploitation and the surrogacy industry is really problematic. Even in the US where using a surrogate might cost you $250,000, the surrogate only gets around $40,000, which is really not a lot of money for what she is actually doing for the couple. Most of the price tag goes on medical bills and agency fees.

And then once you've normalised the idea that it's OK for a rich couple with €250,000 to spare to use a commercial surrogate because it's all been done properly and the surrogate hasn't been exploited, you normalise the idea that commercial surrogacy is OK among people who haven't got €250,000 to spare but think, "Why should this option only be available to super rich people like Chrissy Teigen and John Legend? I deserve to have a baby as much as they do. More so, actually, since they already had three. I can't afford to do it here but I can afford to go to Ukraine and do it there."

The second issue, about the impact on the baby, is just too unknowable. All we have is speculation really. Obviously I hope that all babies born to surrogates have wonderful childhoods with loving parents who went to extreme measures to have them, but who knows what the impact of being removed from their birth mother really is? It's not like adoption where they are being removed from their birth mother for their own welfare, and where they haven't been conceived for the purpose of being removed from their birth mother and raised by someone else.

Like I said, I'm not completely black and white about it and I would have some sympathy for, say, a woman born without a uterus who was desperate for her own baby and did everything she could to respect the welfare of both the surrogate and the baby. To me that's far less clear cut than celebrities who already have several children using a surrogate to have even more.

toomuchlaundry · 29/06/2023 09:30

@Lillyrosemay but what about the child?

Hazelnuttella · 29/06/2023 09:30

dancinginthesky · 29/06/2023 09:25

Idk I guess I'm gonna wonder about the ethics from this thread

The bit I'm not getting though is some arguments being "they already have X amount of children"

Like if it's actually unethical in people's minds... why after X amount and not 0 children? No magic number of already existing children suddenly tips it from "understandable" to "unethical" surely?

Correct.

But you might expect that a woman who has had children might be even more aware of the dangers and impact of pregnancy and exactly what they are demanding of the surrogate mother. That’s the only context that makes it very slightly worse for me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread