Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers strike... what will actually happen in end?!

382 replies

SpringPop · 28/06/2023 18:55

My school is striking again next week with others that have teachers from the particular union.

All that is happening is parents are getting massively angry. Kids are missing out. I've used so much holiday on strike days as I have multiple children. I know my anger should not be directed to school but exactly where can I direct it to? I'm pretty sure my MP wouldn't care. He's completely useless.

The government don't seem to care.

I personally think something needs to change in that profession and funding in my area is shocking! It's probably not attracting the best people to the profession and certainly is driving people away.

However, am I right in thinking rishi and co don't care?! Teachers could do 5, 10, 100 days and it seems they won't budge right?

Parents don't seem to care or get angry enough, short of tweeting about it or writing to MP. It isn't really enough to get this resolved.

How do you think this situation will end?

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 30/06/2023 19:21

Happyfluffball · 30/06/2023 18:31

I don't agree with the teacher strikes. At the end of the day it's the innocent parents and children that suffer rather than the government. When the teachers get a payrise it comes out of existing school funding so the schools will be even more run down and poorly funded.

We're also demanding that the pay rise is funded.

The last offer was overwhelmingly rejected, partly because they were only going to fund 0.5% of it.

The DfE did some research that showed that the offer might have been accepted if it had been funded and then went and did a bunch of webinars with heads trying to tell them that it was actually funded. Heads basically told them they didn't know what they were talking about. The DfE then had to concede that it was actually unaffordable for many schools.

So don't pretend that teachers are demanding money at the expense of their school, we know what the consequences are.

Saywhatevernow · 30/06/2023 19:10

TheSnootiestFox · 30/06/2023 19:02

Oh I absolutely am. 15 years man and boy. But as a card carrying Tory it was like being a square peg in a round hole. Anyone wanting to educate kids and support them in achieving their ambitions in life gets trampled over by the politics and bullying. My lived experience again so please don't tell me I'm wrong 🙄 my opinion is just as valid as anyone else's here. I'd go back tomorrow if I could as I miss the kids but there's redundancies being made at my old school right now, probably to put wriggle room in the budget for whatever pay rise you all demand 🙄 how to shoot yourself in the foot and you're all too busy frothing to realise you're doing it. It'd be hilarious if it wasn't so serious.

One has to ask why you have so much time to post on mumsnet or indeed care so much? Spinning more than a waltzer.

Saywhatevernow · 30/06/2023 19:08

Happyfluffball · 30/06/2023 18:53

I am not happy that there is a shortage but the strikes are making it worse for everyone else and they never lead to any underlying problems being solved anyway.

No they really aren’t. The government are making it worse. For a start, they have no intention of implementing the independent review bodies recommendation.

TheSnootiestFox · 30/06/2023 19:02

Feenie · 30/06/2023 18:21

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣You had me going there, but you properly jumped the shark with that last comment! There’s no way you’re an ex-teacher.

Oh I absolutely am. 15 years man and boy. But as a card carrying Tory it was like being a square peg in a round hole. Anyone wanting to educate kids and support them in achieving their ambitions in life gets trampled over by the politics and bullying. My lived experience again so please don't tell me I'm wrong 🙄 my opinion is just as valid as anyone else's here. I'd go back tomorrow if I could as I miss the kids but there's redundancies being made at my old school right now, probably to put wriggle room in the budget for whatever pay rise you all demand 🙄 how to shoot yourself in the foot and you're all too busy frothing to realise you're doing it. It'd be hilarious if it wasn't so serious.

Fairislefandango · 30/06/2023 18:58

I am not happy that there is a shortage but the strikes are making it worse for everyone else and they never lead to any underlying problems being solved anyway.

Teachers have the right to do what is in their power to change things. You can't guarantee nothing will change as a result. A few days of no school are not 'making it worse for everybody'.

Happyfluffball · 30/06/2023 18:53

Saywhatevernow · 30/06/2023 18:41

However, you are happy that teaching is so poorly paid for the work and qualifications needed- there is a huge teacher shortage. How does that work? Children are suffering already.

I am not happy that there is a shortage but the strikes are making it worse for everyone else and they never lead to any underlying problems being solved anyway.

Saywhatevernow · 30/06/2023 18:41

Happyfluffball · 30/06/2023 18:31

I don't agree with the teacher strikes. At the end of the day it's the innocent parents and children that suffer rather than the government. When the teachers get a payrise it comes out of existing school funding so the schools will be even more run down and poorly funded.

However, you are happy that teaching is so poorly paid for the work and qualifications needed- there is a huge teacher shortage. How does that work? Children are suffering already.

Happyfluffball · 30/06/2023 18:31

I don't agree with the teacher strikes. At the end of the day it's the innocent parents and children that suffer rather than the government. When the teachers get a payrise it comes out of existing school funding so the schools will be even more run down and poorly funded.

avocadotofu · 30/06/2023 18:25

ichundich · 28/06/2023 19:22

I don't know the answer, but agree that it needs to be resolved. It seems like the government and unions aren't even trying to negotiate anymore.

The unions are but the government is refusing to met with them.

Feenie · 30/06/2023 18:21

TheSnootiestFox · 30/06/2023 09:14

Yep, I kept losing out at interview to younger cheaper newly qualified teachers even though I made it clear I was willing to take a cut, I was top of the scale with a big TLR when I left. So I gave up and I'm quite happy in Local Government now. I walked the walk full time for 15 years so please dont try and make out that I have no clue about teaching. It's full to the brim of frothing militant left wing activists that dont give a shny shite about the kids they teach, only their own agendas and this was one of the main reasons I left!

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣You had me going there, but you properly jumped the shark with that last comment! There’s no way you’re an ex-teacher.

Fossie · 30/06/2023 18:06

noblegiraffe · 30/06/2023 11:33

If the system collapses or seizes up, the money will appear.

That’s the thing, and why teachers have been driven to strike action. The system is in crisis and the money is not appearing. Headteachers have been on the news talking about the serious building issues with their schools and how their applications for funding to fix them have been rejected.

The independent pay review body got submissions about how teacher supply and recruitment is in crisis and recommended a pay rise of 6.5% to bring some stability and Rishi is on the news talking about rejecting the recommendation. The Treasury (who are a massive part of the problem here) have been rejecting DfE requests for more funding for years.

You are acting like the government can be expected to act rationally in a crisis, and if they’re not, it can’t be a crisis. But this is not a functioning government, look at state of it after 13 years.

The education system is in crisis, the money is not appearing, there seems to be no political will to do anything about it and that’s why the NEU are striking and the other 3 teaching unions are reballoting.

This pretty much summarises the situation we are in.

lifeissweet · 30/06/2023 12:11

noblegiraffe · 30/06/2023 11:54

What a teacher regards as a crisis and the remedies for it and how others view the state of education and the reasons for any problems are unlikely to coincide

They are increasingly coinciding. Look at the threads on here where parents are complaining that their kid doesn’t have a teacher. It is, probably thanks to the strikes, increasingly being reported in the media. The latest story about unsafe school buildings (which I’ve been posting about for ages) has actually made the news headlines.

If education isn’t a high priority on politicians’ lists, then parents need to get off their arses and put it there.

One benefit of the strikes is that it forces this conversation. Not with Government, clearly, but certainly within forums like this.

I am so baffled, though, by the number of people who STILL aren't getting the problem. It feels wilful at this stage. All the evidence is staring people in the face that education is in crisis and all some can STILL say after ALL this debate is 'but teachers earn plenty'

Some people clearly hate teachers. Fine. But don't pretend it's about anything else - and don't throw your children and the whole next generation under the bus because of it.

JustAsYouSuggestPressedAndDressed · 30/06/2023 12:09

I don't disagree about the importance of teaching. It's the foundation of everything else in society, ultimately. Neither do I disagree about the parlous state of school buildings or the shortage of staff. Things are bad.

But these are not the headlines that dominate. Outside of the Guardian (that's not a slight: the Guardian just happens to be the only news source that covers public sector concerns in any depth) the headlines are about schools not bothering about aggressive and violent pupils (see the numerous threads on here too), unaffordable uniform imposed by schools and teachers promoting fringe social ideology.

Strikes will just create more disillusion with teachers.

noblegiraffe · 30/06/2023 11:54

What a teacher regards as a crisis and the remedies for it and how others view the state of education and the reasons for any problems are unlikely to coincide

They are increasingly coinciding. Look at the threads on here where parents are complaining that their kid doesn’t have a teacher. It is, probably thanks to the strikes, increasingly being reported in the media. The latest story about unsafe school buildings (which I’ve been posting about for ages) has actually made the news headlines.

If education isn’t a high priority on politicians’ lists, then parents need to get off their arses and put it there.

JustAsYouSuggestPressedAndDressed · 30/06/2023 11:48

So long as the NHS, the armed forces, the judicial system, the police, the prison service, immigration and nationality functions and many, many other public sector providers, central and local, seek ever more money, teachers will not be high on the list.

What a teacher regards as a crisis and the remedies for it and how others view the state of education and the reasons for any problems are unlikely to coincide. I'm not saying that's right, but it's a fact of life.

I'm generally very supportive of teachers, but I just do not see how striking will further their cause, just as it didn't in the '80s. In fact I trace the loss of reputation and prestige in teaching back to those strikes. Teachers just became another set of round-the-brazier public workers on strike. And given the opposition of teaching unions to the Blair reforms - i.e. even after the Tories had lost power - it's hard to imagine that any government will satisfy them.

noblegiraffe · 30/06/2023 11:33

If the system collapses or seizes up, the money will appear.

That’s the thing, and why teachers have been driven to strike action. The system is in crisis and the money is not appearing. Headteachers have been on the news talking about the serious building issues with their schools and how their applications for funding to fix them have been rejected.

The independent pay review body got submissions about how teacher supply and recruitment is in crisis and recommended a pay rise of 6.5% to bring some stability and Rishi is on the news talking about rejecting the recommendation. The Treasury (who are a massive part of the problem here) have been rejecting DfE requests for more funding for years.

You are acting like the government can be expected to act rationally in a crisis, and if they’re not, it can’t be a crisis. But this is not a functioning government, look at state of it after 13 years.

The education system is in crisis, the money is not appearing, there seems to be no political will to do anything about it and that’s why the NEU are striking and the other 3 teaching unions are reballoting.

JustAsYouSuggestPressedAndDressed · 30/06/2023 11:20

noblegiraffe · 30/06/2023 11:01

I walked the walk full time for 15 years so please dont try and make out that I have no clue about teaching

When you’re told your experience of schools is out of date and you say you know about pedagogy and assessment techniques, perhaps you should consider that it is not the physical act of teaching that is being referred to, but the state of schools.

The education system is in crisis. Teacher supply is close to collapse, the SEN system is close to collapse, children’s mental health services have basically collapsed, children’s school attendance has dropped dramatically, and behaviour issues have gone up.

Dealing with the impact of all those issues means that the job is now radically different and more stressful in many ways than even a few years ago.

Talking about the reality of teaching today and having someone say ‘I can contribute to this discussion in any meaningful way because I know how to deliver a lesson’ is just so spectacularly missing the point.

But isn't that the real issue? If the system collapses or seizes up, the money will appear. Strikes don't achieve that; they just alienate parents - who will have their own work and employment difficulties - and make the profession look bad.

If you don't like the terms or experience of a job, leave when you can. If you can't leave because the job market and wage levels don't allow it, then you have your answer about what's acceptable pay.

That said, I strongly suspect that in primary and - particularly - secondary education the biggest issue is an inability to teach as well as teachers would like to, because the behaviour of some children and parents is so atrocious.

noblegiraffe · 30/06/2023 11:01

I walked the walk full time for 15 years so please dont try and make out that I have no clue about teaching

When you’re told your experience of schools is out of date and you say you know about pedagogy and assessment techniques, perhaps you should consider that it is not the physical act of teaching that is being referred to, but the state of schools.

The education system is in crisis. Teacher supply is close to collapse, the SEN system is close to collapse, children’s mental health services have basically collapsed, children’s school attendance has dropped dramatically, and behaviour issues have gone up.

Dealing with the impact of all those issues means that the job is now radically different and more stressful in many ways than even a few years ago.

Talking about the reality of teaching today and having someone say ‘I can contribute to this discussion in any meaningful way because I know how to deliver a lesson’ is just so spectacularly missing the point.

Shinyandnew1 · 30/06/2023 09:18

It's full to the brim of frothing militant left wing activists that dont give a shny shite about the kids they teach, only their own agendas and this was one of the main reasons I left!

Really.

TheSnootiestFox · 30/06/2023 09:14

Philandbill · 29/06/2023 21:01

I'd go back now in a heartbeat as financially I'd be much better off plus I actually liked the job, but nobody wants to employ a 50 year old it would appear! @TheSnootiestFox Have you actually tried? Plenty of jobs going in my area and I know several fifty plus year olds who have been snapped up by schools.
I've been teaching for over thirty years and education is on its knees. Recruitment is a huge issue, and there's a reason for that, but there are some experienced teachers who are sticking it out because we believe we have something to offer to pupils. I work sixty hours every week and yes, I am posting on an internet forum now, because having been non-stop all day in school from 7.15 this morning until 7.20 this evening I think some down time is justified. I think your criticism of @noblegiraffe daring to post on an internet forum is appalling. Easy to sound off when you are not now actually walking the walk....

Yep, I kept losing out at interview to younger cheaper newly qualified teachers even though I made it clear I was willing to take a cut, I was top of the scale with a big TLR when I left. So I gave up and I'm quite happy in Local Government now. I walked the walk full time for 15 years so please dont try and make out that I have no clue about teaching. It's full to the brim of frothing militant left wing activists that dont give a shny shite about the kids they teach, only their own agendas and this was one of the main reasons I left!

EnjoyingTheSilence · 30/06/2023 07:15

The sooner we vote this utter shower if shit out the better.

How on earth they’ve managed to stay in power this long is unbelievable, they don’t give a shiny shit about the common people, only what can benefit them. I don’t understand how some people can’t see this.

No party is perfect but the others are not corrupt and morally bankrupt like this lot.

Em2ds1dd · 30/06/2023 06:24

I don’t understand how teachers get 24% pension contribution from their employer.
Wouldn’t it be more easier and fairer to fund say 15% pay rise from the pension Contribution and then employer pay a reduced 8% contribution?

GreenwichOrTwicks · 30/06/2023 05:25

poor pay

GreenwichOrTwicks · 30/06/2023 05:24

You could say the same about most jobs. Interesting that on MN the only group of people who moan incessantly about their job are teachers. You never see packs of carers or call centre workers on here collectively complaining about their poor post and relentless conditions. Went is it just teachers?